Jump to content

Stealth Cigarette Commercial: Difference between revisions

m
clean up
m (update links)
m (clean up)
Line 10:
No, really!
 
Sit down and watch one of these commercials. Now, think back about what you've learned. The classic adage of advertising is, [[No Such Thing as Bad Publicity|"There is no such thing as bad press,"]] so talking about smoking on television -- eventelevision—even in a pejorative context -- [[Do Not Do This Cool Thing|helps their cause]]. It's about as close to a [[Xanatos Gambit]] as anyone has ever come in modern advertising: Whether the viewer smokes after watching it, they still watched it and they're still talking about it.
 
Beyond that, the anti-smoking PSAs produced by tobacco companies are always a little backhanded. The textual message -- donmessage—don't smoke -- issmoke—is coupled with a very different subtext. Studies have actually backed this up, linking exposure to "anti"-smoking PSAs to higher cigarette use. Now there's a series of anti-smoking commercials that no longer talk about the health risks and entirely talk about how evil the tobacco companies are. However, no one ever really thought tobacco companies were that much of a moral standard-bearer beforehand, so the most common reaction to these new revelations concerning their schemes is to marvel at the sheer [[Magnificent Bastard]] genius of them.
 
Ironically, liquor companies have never benefited from any similar trope, since anti-''drinking'' commercials are nowhere near as common and rarely call for the abuser to cease indulging his habit altogether. In fact, they've been more than willing to make commercials of their own calling for their customers to drink "responsibly" (i.e. in moderation) and have a designated driver to get them home safely if they've had too much.
Line 18:
A ''deliberate'' [[Broken Aesop]] that may play on [[Our Product Sucks]] and is probably one of the most extreme versions of [[The Man Is Sticking It to the Man]]. (He's been ''ordered by the court'' to stick it to himself.) See also [[Smoking Is Cool]].
----
=== Real Examples: ===
 
* Stealth PSA motto: "Tobacco is wacko -- if you're a teen."<br />Subtext: "Smoking separates the adults from the mere teenagers."
** This is especially bad, because teenagers spend so much effort trying to be perceived as adults - that's the whole ''point'' of many of them taking up smoking!
** Or, "Don't be the kind of douche who uses [[Totally Radical|'wacko']] unironically - light up!"
* One of the earliest and more memorable anti-smoking PSAs was the "Death of the Marlboro Man" commercial. Aired starting in 1994 and continuing for several years, Charles McLaren, the brother of the late Wayne McLaren (one of many Marlboro men employed during the cigarette brand's "Marlboro Country" ad campaign), implored children not to smoke. The commercial graphically showed the effects of a lifetime of heavy smoking: a picture of the young, vibrant and handsome Wayne McLaren in one of the early Marlboro ads, dressed in a Stetson as if a rugged cowboy, followed by another picture of McLaren lying in a hospital bed, withered due to the effects of lung cancer. The earlier picture of McLaren was taken in the late 1970s, while the latter photo -- tubesphoto—tubes and other machines hooked to his frail body -- wasbody—was taken shortly before his 1993 death. The message to children was obvious ("Please don't smoke") but it was also a stern message against tobacco companies that used advertising campaigns -- suchcampaigns—such as the "Marlboro Country" series -- toseries—to entice children and teenagers to take up the habit.
* Real PSA dialog:
{{quote|'''Voiceover Guy:''' Did you smoke?
Line 40:
** Benson & Hedges pulled its funding for the Symphony of Fire and the Toronto International Film Festival in 2000 when new advertising regulations came into effect. The subtext was that they were only funding them to get their logo displayed, not to support culture.
* PSA: "There is no safe cigarette. Go to our Web site and read more about the health risks of smoking."<br />Subtext: "Hey, look what good corporate citizens we are! ''And go to our Web site! WE HAVE COUPONS!''"
* Outside TV, note the "If you're thinking about quitting smoking..." brochures sometimes attached to cigarette packages. Inside is information on the health benefits of quitting -- informationquitting—information that might reinforce your decision to quit. Of course, as long as the pack is already open...
* There's one in the Netherlands, Canada and the United Kingdom which shows an attractive woman smoking, and then says "Lose The Smoke Keep The Fire". The problem is she still looks sexy smoking, and kind of dorky afterwards. This is a rather indirect version, however, since it's coming from Nicotinell Gum, which doesn't make any money if smokers keep on smoking, but does make money from maintaining a steady consumer base of smokers in need of its product to help them quit. [http://www.nicotinell.nl/index.jsp Here it is].
* Philip Morris has recently released a brochure urging parents to discuss ''all'' tobacco products with their kids: not just normal cigarettes, but also cigars, pipes, smokeless tobacco, Indian cigarettes, and clove cigarettes. At least four of these other product types are types Philip Morris does not make. Not to mention that the explicit message is "tell your kids that the tobacco products Philip Morris doesn't make are just as unhealthy as ones it does...
Line 53:
* Seen on slot machines in Canadian bars: "Before you lose everything, call:" with the number for a gambling addiction hotline.<br />Subtext: Keep gambling until you've lost nearly everything.
* Polish TV saw several suspicious ads: an advertisement of "Bols boat" (the Polish for boat differs in but one letter from "vodka", and Bols is a brand of vodka), "Recreational Equestrian Tourism Soplica" (Polish acronym for that sounds very much like "vodka", and "Soplica" is a brand of vodka), the ad with huge Martini logo and a very small text explaining that Martini is sponsoring some nobody's-heard-of film fest...
* There was an ad that ran in theatres last year that was anti-weed. It featured two badly drawn stick figures--afigures—a man and a dog--talkingdog—talking about weed. The message was basically, "Don't do pot or your dog will be disappointed in you".
{{quote|Text: "Smoking pot is lame, don't do it."
Subtext: "Or not, we don't really care, as can be evidenced by the fact that we refused to come up with something more compelling than this."
Line 64:
** According to some historians, the makers of Vine-Glo (a grape juice concentrate sold during Prohibition) sent demonstrators out to stores to show how easy it was to convert the block into refreshing and legal grape juice. Those demonstrators ''also'' showed exactly what you should not do, lest your grape juice "accidentally" turn into wine.
 
=== Fictional Examples: ===
* In [[The Simpsons]] episode "Lisa the Beauty Queen", Laramie Cigarettes sponsor the Little Miss Springfield Pageant.
{{quote|'''Father''': Wow, president of Laramie Cigarettes, Jack Larson!
10,856

edits

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.