Jump to content

Far East: Difference between revisions

Far East (view source)

Revision as of 09:44, 10 April 2017

3 bytes removed ,  7 years ago
update links
VisualWikitext
m (clean up)
(update links)
Line 6:
Has mostly become a [[Discredited Trope]], and split off into individual tropes for [[Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo|Japan]] and [[Land of Dragons|China]].
 
In most console [[Role -Playing Game|RPGs]] set in a [[Medieval European Fantasy]] world, there will be [[Wutai|one country or town]] that pretty much defines this trope (or the related subtropes) for no logical reason. This occurs often even in games ''made in Japan''.
 
Curiously, while many people dislike this sort of mishmash when it comes to Medieval ''East Asian'' Fantasy, hardly anyone seems to object to the ''[[Medieval European Fantasy|European]]'' equivalent, despite it being pretty much the same thing - apparently having [[Dungeons and& Dragons|Celtic druids rubbing shoulders with Odin-worshipping High Medieval Teutonic Knights is fine,]] but an anachronistic samurai will get you [[Fan Dumb|angry letters]].
 
Arguably this has more to do with [[Serious Business|nationalism]] for China and Japan and idea of crazy foreigners [[Did Not Do the Research|getting it wrong]]. See also [[All Asians Are Alike]].
Line 18:
* ''[[Fullmetal Alchemist]]'' has the country known as Xing which is based mostly off of China but has some Japanese included as well such as certain Japanese words and [[Ninja]]. It's the second most important country since an alternate form of alchemy was created there.
* ''[[Seirei no Moribito]]'' is set in a [[Culture Chop Suey]] Far East country based on a weird amalgamation of Goryeo Korea, Heian and Edo Japan, and a bit of Tang China thrown in for a good measure. Though this is clearly the [[Alternate Universe]] and author being a professional culturologist and anthropologist she really [[Shown Their Work|shows her work]] here.
* ''[[The Twelve Kingdoms]]'' also have the similar setting, although this time the Chinese influence is much greater. It too is generally better executed than is the norm.
 
== Literature ==
Line 28:
 
* The ''[[GURPS]]'' fantasy [[RPG]] setting Yrth includes a pseudo-Asian nation called Sahud, which was founded by a random mix of Chinese, Korean and Japanese peasants transported from Earth by the Banestorm. The involuntary settlers attempted to rebuild their social system from their confused memories of what the upper classes ''looked like from afar'', and "modern" visitors will find themselves in a land that seems to be half Gilbert and Sullivan's ''The Mikado'' and half ''[[Monty Python]]'s [[wikipedia:The Tale of Genji|Tale of Genji]]''.
* The ''[[Dungeons and& Dragons]]'' supplement ''Oriental Adventures'' (first edition) portrayed a setting with Japanese [[Role Playing Game Terms|character classes]] and Chinese kung fu styles (along with some Indonesian weaponry). The more recent edition was a bit better and made it relatively clear what elements came from which culture (and tells the reader flat-out that samurai don't belong in China or India—hah), but still threw an entire continent together into one big mish-mash.
** Interestingly when [[Dungeons and& Dragons]] published a ''[[Forgotten Realms]]'' campaign setting for medieval Asian themed fantasy (Kara-Tur) some of the complaints where that it didn't follow this trope ''enough'', choosing dry historcal cultural accuracy at the expense of a less straight, but arguably [[Rule of Cool|more entertaining]] setting. It might not have helped that the states added in Kara-Tur were so [[Fantasy Counterpart Culture]] that in one case, the Tibet-analogue, ''they had forgotten to change the name of the country from Tibet in several parts of the description''. Also, several people complained that, while not making a Far Eastern mish-mash was refreshing, it might have worked better if there had been more Fantasy and less Counterpart in the cultures, and the history of the cultures. Clearly for some this trope [[Tropes Are Not Bad|works.]]
** ''[[Eberron]]'' has fun with its Asia-inspired country, the mysterious land of Riedra. Only this isn't your typical Asian-esque realm: think more North Korea with psychic powers and a dash of [[Cosmic Horror Story]].
* The RPG ''[[Legend of the Five Rings]]'' is all about this. For example, the staple food is rice and sushi. True enough for a clone of medieval Japanese culture, right? Except the Empire itself is modeled after China. As in: huge tracts of ''inland,'' a Great Wall (though on the southern border), and a curiously independent island chain off the eastern coast.
Line 85:
[[Category:Cultural Blending]]
[[Category:Hollywood Atlas]]
[[Category:Far East{{PAGENAME}}]]
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/1493996"
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.
More information