Jump to content

True Art Is Realistic: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
 
Line 42:
 
== Theater ==
* Inverted by [[Bertolt Brecht]], who -- while subscribing to a [[True Art Sticks It to The Man]] mindset, as is often linked to this trope -- explicitly argued ''against'' theatre (and, by extension, other forms of art) that was too realistic and naturalistic through his theory of the alienation effect; essentially, his argument was that by using theatrical and artistic techniques to create a distance between the performer/audience and the characters and action they were performing/viewing, this meant that both were better equipped to critique the actions of the characters, consider potential alternatives that could be taken and take on the (often political) messages that were being communicated, since they could take a step back from their identification with the characters and consider the wider picture that was being presented to them. Naturalism, however, worked by explicitly presenting the audience with a replication of their day-to-day lives and by giving the audience an image of reality -- however, since the audience operated within those day-to-day lives, they were unlikely to challenge or question them.
 
== Troping ==
* As mentioned in the main article text, this may be the reason (or part of the reason) why [[Deconstruction]] is so popular on this wiki -- [[Sliding Scale of Idealism Versus Cynicism|for a certain measure of "reality", anyway]].
 
== Video Games ==
Line 52:
* Those who don't like video games often use this criticism. Likewise, within gaming communities, this trope comes into play as some games have more "realistic" elements compared with others within their genres. Shooters are particularly prone to this. Pro- and anti-realism rants are just flame bait.
** This was sent up by ''[[The Onion]]'', which made a joke review about how everyone was praising ''[[Call of Duty: Modern Warfare]] 3'' (obviously before it was announced) for its great realism. The player spent hours a day slacking off, doing nothing, waiting for orders, listening to their buddies gab about whether they'd rather sleep with Shakira or Jessica Biel, and repairing HMMWV's for hours on end. Now ''that'' is a realistic depiction of the life of an Army private.
* Suggested by several reviewrs to be the reason behind why ''[[Yoshi's Island]]'' is being treated with less regard than ''[[Donkey Kong Country (video game)|Donkey Kong Country]]'' when doing retrospectives on [[Super Nintendo]] games, as the latter pre-rendered aesthetic was treated more seriously than the former's crayon-like one.
 
== Western Animation ==
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.