Token Minority Couple: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
m (Mass update links)
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{cleanup|The same example from ''South Park'' is listed in both sections. Which one should be removed?}}
[[File:tumblr_m34056s4ZE1r7x4hso1_500_6662tumblr m34056s4ZE1r7x4hso1 500 6662.png|frame|'Cuz blacks belong together.]]
 
 
{{quote|''"Hey there, other black person in the room. Wanna engage in a little... [[Is That What They're Calling It Now?|desegregation?]]"''|'''[[The Nostalgia Chick]],''' [[Lampshade Hanging|pointing this out]] in ''[[Jem and The Holograms]]'' }}
Line 9:
'''Type A:''' The writers attempt to remove the label of tokenism by adding a similar character later, like a black female after a black male. Would be hypothetically successful, except she is usually a [[Distaff Counterpart]] who is quite clearly going to be paired off with the token at some point and will not be fully integrated into the established 'team'.
 
'''Type B:''' Two minority characters are established independently of each other. If they have any interactions at all, it's as friends and nothing more. But then later seasons find them getting...friendlier, even though they have nothing in common beyond their race. It is [[Not a Subversion]] if the lovebirds are different minority races. If everyone else on the show is white except for a black and an Asian, and they fall in love with no subtlety or natural buildup, it's as straight an example as any other. This is because only two races matter in Hollywood: white and not white.
 
Homo/bisexuality is the most common non-racial variant. This can be tricky, since a same-gender love interest must by necessity be sexually compatible, so the key thing to look for is if their relationship develops at a realistic pace and the character is subtly introduced, or if Billy Queer just pops up and is clearly going to get in the token gay's pants. But if the show features two gay/bi characters with no real connection to each other and no reason to start dating, it's another straight example if they get in bed.
 
Another variant happens in the [[World of Funny Animals]], where everybody is a different anthropomorphic animal, but no matter [[Sliding Scale of Anthropomorphism|how anthropomorphic they are]], only those of the same exact species will truly hook up. For example, Bob Kitty is the only cat in the show and has no love interests until Alice the cat shows up. This is less [[Fantastic Racism]] and more to avoid the potential [[Squick]] of an [[Interspecies Romance]].
 
It is unnecessary to list aversions, since that tends to mean rattling off the character's entire dating history.
{{examples}}
==== Type A ====
 
{{examples}}
== [[Comic Books]] ==
==== Type A ====
=== [[Comic Books]] ===
* Chuck and Nancy, Frankie and Maria, and several one-shot couples from [[Archie Comics]].
* [[Lampshade|Lampshaded]]d in an issue of ''The [[New Mutants]]''. Dani tries hooking up Karma with a lesbian they meet at a coffeehouse, and Karma is offended on principle.
 
=== Film ===
* In the ''Twilight'' film this overlaps with [[Pair the Spares]] as some of Bella's friends are given a [[Race Lift]], pairing minorities Eric and Angela (Asian and Hispanic respectively) and white Mike and Jessica.
 
=== [[Live Action TV]] ===
* Every time ''[[The Love Boat]]'' guest-starred a black female and not a black male, said black female would be after Isaac and/or vice-versa.
** A little more understandable given the time period in which the show was made, but this is done in ''[[Hogan's Heroes]]''. When a black woman turns out to have access to secret Nazi plans, she also turns out to have been the high school girlfriend of Kinchloe (the only black member of the group). They make out at the end of the episode.
* Subverted on ''[[Flash Forward 2009|Flash ForwardFlashForward]]''. Stan Wedeck, who is black, is accused by one of his adversaries of having had an extramarital affair. Later, we meet the woman in question, who is also black. This, along with the friendly way they greet each other when he visits her apartment, implies the accusation is true. But it turns out {{spoiler|the actual affair took place between the woman and the President of the United States, who is white. Stan merely helped cover it up.}}
* Mocked by quite a few watchers and reviewers of ''[[Vampire Diaries]]'' - at the start of Season 2, a hot black guy appears, and everyone immediately goes "Riiight, he's so it looks like Bonnie has a love life as well as the others." Of course, {{spoiler|he died}}.
* ''[[Star Trek]]'':
Line 35:
** And what about Jake's father? His first ''and'' his second wife are black. And most of his love interests. (And not even aliens.)
** Also [[The Next Generation|Geordi LaForge]] once had a black ''[[Rubber Forehead Aliens|alien]]'' love interest. Subverted with his crush in white Leah Brahms, though the writers had intended her to also be black (and a descendent of Dr. Richard Daystrom of ''TOS''), they just neglected to make that clear to the casting department.
** [[Star Trek: Voyager|Tuvok's]] wife also had a rather dark complexion. This could be a result of the show's creators realizing that the notoriously sunny, arid planet Vulcan would favor a darker skin tone - most times you see a Vulcan in Voyager or Enterprise, they at least have a decent tan.
* Happens in [[Stargate Atlantis]] with Teyla. From second season she isn't the only alien or the only non-white of the main characters, but when [[Real Life Writes the Plot|Rachel Luttrell got pregnant]], the [[Ass Pull|character they revealed she was having an offscreen relationship with]] was shown to have a very similar skin tone to hers, despite the fact that her people are shown to be of various races.
* Lampshaded on ''[[Glee]]'' when Kurt tries to set up Mercedes on a date. She notices that he's "One of five black guys in the school" (even though Lima's over a quarter black [[Did Not Do the Research|in real life]]) and is not impressed.
Line 41:
** Played straight with Kurt and Blaine. When we first meet Blaine, even if you weren't following all the online rumors and whatnot, it was clear that he would inevitably end up as Kurt's boyfriend. And when Mercedes hangs out with them, she pictures them both saying "[[Blah Blah Blah|gaygaygaygaylittlepursegay]]", complete with mentions of favorite Vogue magazine covers and discussing Patti LuPone's new book...
*** Although the writing staff tried to give a red herring by saying Kurt was going to get a boyfriend who was a new character but implying that it was ''Sam''. Then his intro episode happened. [[Jossed|Hilarity ensued.]]
* [[Pretty Little Liars]] are more and more clearly following this trope. Every single lesbian that shows up on the show turns into a love interest for Emily, including one who at first bullied Emily and ''held her head under water''. The patterns seems so far to be unaffected by her whether or not she even is single at the moment.
<!-- %%Mike and Tina are listed under Type B. -->
* In ''[[Combat Hospital (TV)|Combat Hospital]]'', Suzy Chao seems to have been introduced only to give Bobby Trang a love interest.
* [[Pretty Little Liars]] are more and more clearly following this trope. Every single lesbian that shows up on the show turns into a love interest for Emily, including one who at first bullied Emily and ''held her head under water''. The patterns seems so far to be unaffected by her whether or not she even is single at the moment.
* In ''[[Combat Hospital (TV)|Combat Hospital]]'', Suzy Chao seems to have been introduced only to give Bobby Trang a love interest.
* Parodied on ''[[Little Britain]]'' where Lou sets up Andy on a date with a disabled woman, believing they will get on wonderfully since they both use wheelchairs. Andy dislikes her, and when Lou leaves them alone, Andy gets up and pushes her wheelchair down a slope.
* In ''[[Seventh7th Heaven]]'' Simon's friend Nigel says that there's a desirable girl in his class who could have picked anyone to be her boyfriend and she picked him. Come to find out that she's black like him.
* Season 8 of ''[[Degrassi]]'' has an episode where Connor, who's black, helps get KC and Clare, who are white, together. In gratitude the writers give him a black girl as admirer. It's like when Liberty (non-token black) is rejected by Sean but in the end she finds out that his black friend likes her.
* ''[[Criminal Minds]]'' seemed to be setting Derek Morgan up with a black woman who was involved in one of the cases, even though they didn't seem to have much chemistry, but she hasn't been seen for a while. It would be nice if the show would stop tiptoeing around things and just set him up with [[Techno Wizard|Garcia]] - they've been flirting pretty much since the show began.
* On ''[[ER]]'', Peter Benton's relationship with fellow surgeon Elizabeth Corday fizzled because actor Eriq [[La Salle]] didn't like what he felt were [[Unfortunate Implications]]--that—that his character had previously had lousy relationships with two other black women, yet now had a functional one with the white Elizabeth. Sure enough, the following season, a black female doctor was brought on to be his love interest, despite them having zero chemistry (but very similar personalities)
 
=== [[Western Animation]] ===
* Bumblebee from the ''[[Teen Titans (Animationanimation)|Teen Titans]]'' cartoon basically flirts with Cyborg in every episode she's in, despite the fact that the two never shared a romance in the comics.
** To be fair, Cyborg didn't have any other love interest. He had Jinx, but she went with Kid Flash.
** Also, they never technically have any "real" romance, though there's enough subtext to make it a [[Fan Preferred Pairing]]. Also, I think I read somewhere that she winds up with her usual love interest, Herald, in the ''[[Teen Titans Go (Comic Book)!|Teen Titans Go]]!'' comics. (Of course, ''he's'' black too...)
** Notably subverted in ''[[Teen Titans Go (Comic Book)!|Teen Titans Go]]!'' where Cyborg has a steady girlfriend, Sarah Simms, who was Caucasian. Yet, Bumblebee and Herald are implied to be going out later on as a nod toward their being married in mainstream DC comics.
* ''[[Jem and The Holograms]]'' had a bad one when Shana met a black guy at a party. No sooner did the gang see him, that the other girls basically shoved Shana into his path. They of course became the only permanent recurring couple of the show.
* ''[[Winx Club (Animation)|Winx Club]]'''s Layla and her [[Ambiguously Brown]] fiancé Nabu. Layla was introduced in season two and Nabu late in season three, and it was established at their first meeting that they had a lot in common. But while Layla was an obvious fit into The Winx Club, Nabu didn't fit as easily into the boys' group, especially since he was the only non-Specialist. He wasn't even seen hanging out with them until season four, where he became {{spoiler|the first main character of the series to die for real}}.
* On ''[[Total Drama]],'' [[Latin Lover|Alejandro]] (Hispanic) and [[Alpha Bitch|Heather]] (Asian) have a strong case of [[Belligerent Sexual Tension]]. (Despite being different races, it counts best as Type A--Alejandro was introduced after Heather and is repeatedly played up as her [[Distaff Counterpart|Spear Counterpart]].)
* ''[[South Park]]'' [[Parodied|parodies]] [[Decon Recon Switch|and then reconstructs]] this trope--atrope—a black girl named Nicole moves to town, and racist Cartman immediately decides that she has to get together with [[Token Minority|Token]], previously the only black kid in school. At first Token won't even speak with her to avoid this trope, but eventually Cartman manipulates them to get together, only for Nicole to break up with Token when she misinterprets evidence of Cartman's plan to mean that Token was invoking this trope. Eventually Cartman manages to manipulate them ''back'' together, and the two decide that not dating over their shared race was just as bad as dating only because of their race.
 
==== Type B: ====
=== [[Comic Books]] ===
 
* The infamous pairing of [[X-Men (Comic Book)|Storm]] and the [[Black Panther]]. Hell, it's been outright stated by the writer of BP at the time that he married them because they were the "two most prominent black characters in Marvel." Granted, her [[Pimped-Out Dress|wedding dress]] was gorgeous.
== [[Comic Books]] ==
* The infamous pairing of [[X-Men (Comic Book)|Storm]] and the [[Black Panther]]. Hell, it's been outright stated by the writer of BP at the time that he married them because they were the "two most prominent black characters in Marvel." Granted, her [[Pimped-Out Dress|wedding dress]] was gorgeous.
* Storm and Bishop have never been more than just friends, but this has not stopped fanfiction pairings of the two.
** Storm broke up with Forge (a Cheyenne) not that long after Bishop joined the team, prompting speculation that Storm would become involved with Bishop.
Line 69 ⟶ 67:
* Lampshaded in an issue of ''[[Justice League of America]]'', where Congorilla tries to pair his friend Starman up with Tasmanian Devil. He later admits that as far as he knows, the two men have absolutely nothing in common other than both being gay.
* The [[Young Avengers]]' Hulkling and Wiccan might be immensely popular, especially among GLBT readers, but there's no shortage of fans of any persuasion who would like to know ''how'' they fell in love, instead of taking for granted that the two gay boys on the team would automatically get it on.
* The situation in Silver Age superhero teams with just one female member was often somewhat comparable, although here at least the token female had a choice. But what really were the odds that e. g. [[X-Men|Cyclops]] would fall in love with Marvel Girl, who was not only the only female X-Man, but also the only woman with whom he had any social contact at all due to the [[Married to Thethe Job|responsibilities of being the team leader]]?
* In ''[[X -Force|X-Statix]]'', the writers of the X-Statix movie felt it was more "appropriate" for the Anarchist to get together with Venus Dee Milo in the movie. While this is mainly so they can hold the [[Conflict Ball]] with her boyfriend the Orphan, it's implied that they got pushed together by [[Executive Meddling]] because they're both black.
 
=== Film ===
* In ''[[The Matrix]]'' films, there's a lot of this. Neo (white) ends up with Trinity (white), while Morpheus (black) only has one strongly implied relationship- Niobe (black), whose implied former love interest was Jason Locke (black). Link (black) is married to a black woman too, and Dozer's (black) widow is also black. Switch (white) with Apoch (white) in the first film too, and Mouse's (white) attraction attraction to his own fictional "ideal woman", the Woman in Red (white).
* Subverted in the 2000 adaptation of ''[[LovesLove's LaboursLabour's Lost]]''. While Maria and Dumaine are both played by black actors, they instead fall in love with Longaville and Katherine respectively (as the play has it), both of whom are played by white actors.
* [[Lampshaded]] by Danny Glover and Alfre Woodard's characters in ''[[Grand Canyon]]'' after Kevin Kline acts as matchmaker for both of them. On their first date they realize that they're probably the only two black people he knows and laugh about it.
 
=== [[Live Action TV]] ===
* Played for laughs on ''[[Glee]]'' when Puck and Rachel very randomly start dating for no reason other then that they're both Jewish. The two have [[No Accounting for Taste|very little in common]] and end up breaking up by the end of the episode. Rachel also has a [[Stalker Withwith a Crush]] named Jacob Ben Israel. It should be noted that Puck and Rachel's [[Official Couple|actual love interests]] are the Christian Quinn and Finn.
 
** The fandom also has a tendency to ship Matt/Mercedes (the two black characters on the show) before Matt was [[Put Onon a Bus]], and Tina/Mike (the two Asians).
* Played for laughs on ''[[Glee]]'' when Puck and Rachel very randomly start dating for no reason other then that they're both Jewish. The two have [[No Accounting for Taste|very little in common]] and end up breaking up by the end of the episode. Rachel also has a [[Stalker With a Crush]] named Jacob Ben Israel. It should be noted that Puck and Rachel's [[Official Couple|actual love interests]] are the Christian Quinn and Finn.
** The fandom also has a tendency to ship Matt/Mercedes (the two black characters on the show) before Matt was [[Put On a Bus]], and Tina/Mike (the two Asians).
*** Tina/Artie begin as this, shipping the two "disabled" members of the Glee Club together. In fact, Artie is explicitly attracted to Tina for her disability (stuttering), thinking they had a shared empathy. Subverted when she reveals she had been faking the stutter all along.
** In the second season, Tina officially dumped Artie for Mike over the summer when they both worked at "Asian Camp". This was the beginning of both characters going from their race being incidental to [[Flanderization|it being all they ever talk about]].
* [[Degrassi the Next Generation|Jimmy and Hazel]]. It doesn't help much that Hazel really doesn't do anything.
* Mickey and Martha in ''[[Doctor Who (TV)|Doctor Who]]'' were revealed out of nowhere to have gotten married in their final appearance. While their personalities do in fact make a good match for each other, the facts that they had a neglible amount of screentime together, both of them are black, and Martha dumped her white fiancé Tom offscreen make it look like this trope. Unintended, [[Unfortunate Implications]].
** That Mickey was Rose's boyfriend, but she chose the Doctor over him, and Martha pined after the Doctor, who didn't notice and was hung up on Rose, makes this [[Pair the Spares]], while Rose and the Doctor being white adds to the unintended, [[Unfortunate Implications]].
* ''[[Castle]]'': Lanie and Esposito are shown in bed together in a cold open. Seeing as how everyone else is in some sort of relationship at the time (until Castle re-breaks up with his ex-wife at the end of it), it's also a case of [[Pair the Spares]].
Line 94 ⟶ 91:
* [[Sesame Street|Luis and Maria]].
 
=== [[Professional Wrestling]] ===
* Nothing to do with [[Shipping]], but this principle also appears in [[Professional Wrestling]]: there is a maxim that, if a promotion features two black wrestlers, they will always either be in a tag team together or feuding against one another. Even in 2008, the (black) Shelton Benjamin was the man chosen to feud against the debuting (and so black he ''rapped'' his way to the ring) R-Truth.
** Granted, Shelton's own tag partner is white. Same with the Dudley Boyz/Team 3D
** However, it goes right smackdab into [[Unfortunate Implications]] territory when a plain-speaking black guy feuds with a [[Jive Turkey]] and/or [[Uncle Tomfoolery]] incarnate where the former is '''ALWAYS''' the heel because [[Sarcasm Mode|educated black men aren't keeping it real.]]
 
=== [[Real Life]] ===
* Some [[Fag Hag|Fag Hags]]s have an annoying habit of playing matchmaker to their gay friends ("You're gay? My cousin's gay, you guys should hang out!"), giving no regard to their personalities, interests, or physical tastes. Such attempts ''can'' work for the would-be couple, but are usually awkward at best and offensive at worst.
** Wasn't that also an episode of ''[[Sex and Thethe City]]''?
** The same happens with Bisexuals, who are just paired up with anyone since they will do "Anything". Also happens with people in certain groups (Goths, Bikers, Gamers, Anime fans, ext.), which could be about friends or pairings, in which people don't seem to realize that not all, say, Goths get along with each other. Having similar interests, taste in music and/or clothing are not the only thing that attracts people to each other.
** It happens with race too. If there are two people of the same race in a group of friends (especially if they're the only ones of that race in the group) and they are the opposite gender, guess how often people on the outside looking in will assume that they're dating each other, and not someone else in the group who's a different race and/or the same sex. If it comes out that they aren't dating, guess how many people will start Shipping them anyway.
* Averted in Chris Rock's case when he went to grade school in a white neighborhood where he was the only black boy in his grade and there three black girls but he "wasn't cute to them." Rock: "You would think, 'Hey! It's just me! Come on ladies!'"
 
=== [[Web Comics]] ===
 
* Parodied in ''[[Kid Radd]]''. The [[Token Minority]] is a black man who in his original game was a shopkeeper, and since he was always behind the shop counter, the lower half of his body was never animated--heanimated—he levitates instead. He's paired not with another black, but with a nurse who's similarly half-nonexistent. (And yes, there is a joke about the [[Mermaid Problem|physical disadvantages]] of this pairing.)
== [[Web Comics]] ==
* Parodied in ''[[Kid Radd]]''. The [[Token Minority]] is a black man who in his original game was a shopkeeper, and since he was always behind the shop counter, the lower half of his body was never animated--he levitates instead. He's paired not with another black, but with a nurse who's similarly half-nonexistent. (And yes, there is a joke about the [[Mermaid Problem|physical disadvantages]] of this pairing.)
** IIRC, they actually showed that their lower halves (or rather, any part of their body that goes below their waists) are simply ''invisible'' (or possibly in [[Hammerspace]]), [[Power Perversion Potential|which only raises further questions]].
* Subverted outright in ''[[Girls Withwith Slingshots]]'', when the two known lesbians in the cast meet each other, find that they have nothing in common, try to make it work anyway, and it turns into a giant disaster when everyone finds out {{spoiler|1=Angel doesn't consider Thea her girlfriend, is cheating on her, and isn't taking precautions against STDs with either partner}}.
 
=== [[Western Animation]] ===
* Wade + Monique in the ''[[Kim Possible]]'' episode "The Cupid Effect," though it was played entirely for laughs. They were, at the time, sixteen and eleven, but it was a [[Precocious Crush|one-sided schoolboy crush]] on an older woman. Wade picks up a girl-of-the-week his own age at the end of the episode, who's white.
* Some episodes of ''[[Hey Arnold!]]!'' had the title character's [[Black Best Friend]], Gerald, paired off with another major minority character Phoebe, who's half-Japanese and half-white. Then again, it ''is'' a multiracial pairing so it could be something of a subversion...
** They're best friend shipping, also supposed to show EASY it should be, as opposed to the song and dance of Arnold and Helga.
* Like ''Hey Arnold,'' on ''[[Phineas and Ferb]]'' Candace's Asian friend Stacy is paired with Jeremy's [[Black Best Friend]] Coltrane. He later turns out to be a [[Boy Of The Week]], but then her ''next'' [[Love Interest]] is also black...
** Likewise [[Bollywood Nerd|Baljeet]] (Indian) has had romantic interests in the form of his old childhood friend [[All Grown Up!|Mishti]] (also Indian) and [[Scout Out|Ginger]] (unspecified Asian}). He also seems to have a crush on Isabella, who is [[Informed Judaism|Jewish]] ''[[Twofer Token Minority|and]]'' Hispanic ([[But Not Too Foreign|not that you can tell either very easily]]). Apparently averted with Wendy, his love interest in the Christmas special, who seems to just be white. (And yes, he's quite the [[Kidanova]], isn't he?)
* Wheeler and Linka, the only white Planeteers on ''[[Captain Planet]]''.
** This pairing was incredibly subversive, but not for racial reasons. Linka came from the Soviet Union, Wheeler from the United States, and the show started a little before the end of the Cold War...
Line 123 ⟶ 119:
** Possibly also keeping with the intentional [[Positive Discrimination]] both were stuck in being nearly the only black people in Lawndale. It's not much of a stretch to consider that while they genuinely like each other, their PD cred would be gone and become labeled as sellouts if either dated interracially.
* [[Green Lantern]] (John Stewart) and Vixen in ''[[Justice League]] Unlimited'' might have counted, had Stewart not already been involved with, then had a mutual breakup with, Hawkgirl. (Which doubled as an [[Interspecies Romance]].)
* In ''[[Braceface]]'', Brock (black) and Maria ([[Twofer Token Minority|half Asian, half Italian]]) hooks up in the second season.
* ''[[Young Justice (Animationanimation)|Young Justice]]'' has a subtle, sci-fi example when [[Superboy]] and [[Green-Skinned Space Babe|Miss Martian]], the two alien team members, hook up.
** In season two they've had an [[Off -Screen Breakup]], and now M'Gann is together with Lagoon Boy. Possibly unintentional, but they're both green non-humans. (If ''they'' break up, who wants to bet she hooks up with Beast Boy?)
*** M'Gann and Garfield certainly seem very close, but they seem to view each other as siblings. Wouldn't it be awkward if they suddenly started dating?
** For a whole season, no one was attracted to Aqualad. Then Rocket shows up...
*** Though prior to this, Aqualad had dated Tula, who was white. She ended up with Garth, Aqualad's white best friend, creating much angst.
* Ramone (Latino) and Flo (black) from ''[[Cars]]''.
* Jacobo (Hispanic) and Tasumi (Asian) on ''[[The Replacements (Animationanimation)|The Replacements]]''.
* Parodied in ''[[South Park]]'' when Cartman tries to pair up Nicole, the new black student, with Token, the only other black kid in the entire school. He then becomes upset when Nicole displays an attraction to Kyle, a white Jewish student.
* Numbuh 4 (Austrailian) and Numbuh 3 (Japanese) on ''[[Codename: Kids Next Door]].''
** Then again, Sector V is a [[Five -Token Band]], so this may not really count.
 
{{reflist}}
Line 139 ⟶ 135:
[[Category:Token Index]]
[[Category:Race Tropes]]
[[Category:Token Minority Couple{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Trope]][[Category:Pages with comment tags]]