Topic on User talk:Horrorshow

Line 1: Line 1:
{{FlowMention|Horrorshow}}: Because you seem to be lacking a bit in the common sense, I'll spell it for you:
{{FlowMention|Horrorshow}}: Because you seem to have a lapse of common sense, I'll spell it for you:

While not specified in the rules (and in retrospective it should be), the unspoken politics is that whenever there is an single version of the work,, or a particular version is the better known version (like this case seems to be),, or if the different adaptations are either extremely loyal versions of the original work or close enough to that having different page repeating the same tropes for each adaptation is redundant, there should be a single article without extra parenthesis, if only to serve as a main hub of the franchise. For what I see, you have repeatedly recreated the same page while adding a parenthesis that doesn't actually require. I can get why are you doing it, if you came from TV Tropes and their heavyset namespaces politics,, but unless you are creating pages not only for the light novel but also one for each adaptation that parenthetical tacking isn't actually necessary.
While not specified in the rules (and in retrospective it should be), the unspoken politics is that whenever there is an single version of the work, or a particular version is the better known version (like this case seems to be), or if the different adaptations are either extremely loyal versions of the original work or close enough that having different pages repeating the same tropes for each adaptation can be redundant, there should be a single article without extra parenthesis, if only to serve as a main hub of the franchise. For what I see, you have repeatedly recreated the same page while adding a parenthesis that doesn't actually require. I can get why are you doing it, if you came from TV Tropes and their heavyset namespaces politics, but unless you are creating pages not only for the light novel but also one for each adaptation that parenthetical tacking isn't actually necessary.


C.C. {{FlowMention|Looney Toons}} @[[User:Labster|Labster]], @[[User:GethN7|GethN7]], @[[User:Robkelk|Robkelk]], @[[User:QuestionableSanity|QuestionableSanity]], @[[User:DocColress|DocColress]], @[[User:LulzKiller|LulzKiller]], @[[User:SelfCloak|SelfCloak]]
C.C. {{FlowMention|Looney Toons}} @[[User:Labster|Labster]], @[[User:GethN7|GethN7]], @[[User:Robkelk|Robkelk]], @[[User:QuestionableSanity|QuestionableSanity]], @[[User:DocColress|DocColress]], @[[User:LulzKiller|LulzKiller]], @[[User:SelfCloak|SelfCloak]]