Topic on Talk:Main Page

This is a permanent link to the first version of this post. You can view later versions on the post history page.

I like this new section.

Personally I would add merge some new ideas into this section:

Yes, we have YMMV pages. Yes, YMMV pages are subjective, but 99% of YMMV tropes aren't related to the quality of something. The usage of the tropes that are regarding reception, like Sacred Cow, is tightly controlled. Under All The Tropes:Not a Trope, both Complaining About Shows You Don't Like and Gushing About Shows You Like aren't tropes.
(Elaborating "While we do have Audience Reactions pages, they are not the focus of this wiki") Yes, we have other pages that are quite opinionated, like So Bad It's Horrible and Gushing About Shows You Like, but those aren't the focus of the wiki. While our users can choose to go there, the majority of them don't, and chooses to focus on troping instead.

This should clear up confusion users have when they go "wait a minute, this page is about the reception of something".