Automoderated users, Autopatrolled users, Bureaucrats, Comment administrators, Confirmed users, Moderators, Rollbackers, Administrators
213,561
edits
All Quiet on the Western Front: Difference between revisions
And I think that's all I the cleanup that can do without having actually read the novel or watched any of the movies.
Looney Toons (talk | contribs) |
(And I think that's all I the cleanup that can do without having actually read the novel or watched any of the movies.) |
||
| (39 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown) | |||
Line 1:
{{work}}
{{Multiple Works Need Separate Pages}}
{{Infobox book
| title = All Quiet on the Western Front
| original title = Im Westen nichts Neues
| image = All_Quiet_on_the_Western_Front_modern_cover.jpg
| caption = Cover of a late-20th or early-21st century printing of the novel
| author = Erich Maria Remarque
| central theme = [[War Is Hell]]
| elevator pitch = The story of a young German man who volunteers to fight in [[WWI]], told from his perspective.
| genre = War novel
| publication date = 29 January 1929
}}
{{quote|''"This book is to be neither an accusation nor a confession. It will try simply to tell of a generation of men who, even though they may have escaped its shells, were destroyed by the war."''}}
'''''All Quiet on the Western Front''''' ('''''Im Westen Nichts Neues''''') is a 1929 anti-war novel, set during [[World War I]], by famous German author and war veteran Erich Maria Remarque. It's considered to be one of the greatest and most important works in the genre. The book was a best-seller when it was first released.
Many of the elements of the narrative correspond to Remarque's own experiences, and the book has strong autobiographic undertones.
''All Quiet on the Western Front'' is narrated by a young soldier, former grammar school student [[The Everyman|Paul Bäumer]]. [[War Is Hell|The horrors of trench warfare are described in a brutally realistic fashion]]. Further themes are [[Band of Brothers|comradeship]] and the soldiers' detachment from civilian life.
The book was a best-seller when it was first released. In 1930, an American film adaptation was made, directed by Lewis Milestone. It won the Best Picture [[Academy Award|Oscar]] and is often considered to be the [[Trope Maker]] of the modern war drama. An equally good TV adaptation was made in 1979, and a new film adaptation is currently in the works. ▼
'''Plot summary:'''
▲''All Quiet on the Western Front'' is narrated by a young soldier, former grammar school student [[The Everyman|Paul Bäumer]]. [[War Is Hell|The horrors of trench warfare are described in a brutally realistic fashion]]. Further themes are [[Band of Brothers|comradeship]] and the soldiers' detachment from civilian life.
Quoting from [[w:All Quiet on the Western Front|Wikipedia]]:
The book centers on Paul Bäumer, a German soldier on the Western Front during [[World War I]]. At the start of the book, Paul lives with his parents and sister in a charming German village. He attends school, where the patriotic speeches of his teacher Kantorek lead the whole class to volunteer for the Imperial German Army shortly after the start of The Great War. At the training camp, where they meet Himmelstoß, his class is scattered over the platoons amongst Frisian fishermen, peasants, and labourers, with whom they soon become friends. Bäumer arrives at the Western Front with his friends and schoolmates (Leer, Müller, Kropp, Kemmerich and a number of other characters). There, they meet Stanislaus Katczinsky, an older soldier nicknamed Kat, who becomes Paul's mentor.
While fighting at the front, Bäumer and his comrades engage in frequent battles and endure the treacherous and filthy conditions of trench warfare. The battles fought here have no names and seem to have little overall significance, except for the impending possibility of injury or death. Only meager pieces of land are gained, which are often lost again later. Remarque often refers to the living soldiers as old and dead, emotionally drained and shaken. "We are not youth any longer. We don't want to take the world by storm. We are fleeing from ourselves, from our life. We were eighteen and had begun to love life and the world; and we had to shoot it to pieces."
Paul visits home, and the contrast with civilian life highlights the cost of the war on his psyche. The town has not changed since he went off to war, but he has: he finds that he does "not belong here anymore, it is a foreign world". He feels disconnected from most of the townspeople. His father asks him "stupid and distressing" questions about his war experiences, not understanding "that a man cannot talk of such things". An old schoolmaster lectures him about strategy and advancing to Paris while insisting that Paul and his friends know only their "own little sector" of the war but nothing of the big picture.
Indeed, the only person he remains connected to is his dying mother, with whom he shares a tender, yet restrained relationship. The night before he is to return from leave, he stays up with her, exchanging small expressions of love and concern for each other. He thinks to himself, "Ah! Mother, Mother! How can it be that I must part from you? Here I sit and there you are dying; we have so much to say, and we shall never say it." In the end, he concludes that he "ought never to have come [home] on leave".
Paul is glad to return and reunite with his comrades. Soon after, he volunteers to go on a patrol and kills a man in hand-to-hand combat for the first time. He watches the man die slowly in agony for hours. He is remorseful and devastated, asking for forgiveness from the man's corpse. He later confesses to Kat and Albert, who try to comfort him and reassure him that it is only part of the war. Afterwards, they are sent on what Paul calls a "good job". They must guard a supply depot in a village that was evacuated due to being shelled too heavily. During this time, the men are able to adequately feed themselves, unlike the near-starvation conditions in the German trenches. In addition, the men enjoy themselves while living off the spoils from the village and officers' luxuries from the supply depot (such as fine cigars). While evacuating the villagers (enemy civilians), Paul and Albert are taken by surprise by artillery fired at the civilian convoy and are wounded by a shell. On the train back home, Albert takes a turn for the worse and cannot complete the journey, and instead is sent off the train to recuperate in a Catholic hospital. By a combination of bartering and manipulation, Paul manages to stay together with Albert. Albert eventually has his leg amputated, while Paul is deemed fit for service and returned to the front.
By now, the war is nearing its end and the German Army is retreating. In despair, Paul watches as his friends fall one by one. Kat's death is the last straw that finally causes Paul to lose his will to live. In the final chapter, he comments that peace is coming soon, but he does not see the future as bright and shining with hope. Paul feels that he has no aims left in life and that their generation will be different and misunderstood.
'''Adaptations:'''
[[File:All_Quiet_on_the_Western_Front_(1930_film)_poster.jpg|thumb|200px|Poster for the 1930 movie]]
▲
* [[All Quiet on the Western Front (1979 film)|An equally good TV-movie adaptation]] was made in 1979.
* [[All Quiet on the Western Front (2022 film)|Another film of the novel]], which won four Oscars, was released in 2022.
{{tropelist}}
* [[An Arm and a Leg]]: Paul's former classmate Albert Kropp has his leg amputated when they're wounded together. This makes him contemplate suicide, but he eventually accepts his fate. Earlier, Franz Kemmerich, another classmate of Paul's has his leg amputated, but he doesn't survive.
* [[Badass]]: Kat. Also, that one guy who was mortally wounded and lived long enough to make sure the enemy fleet was wiped out.
* [[Big Eater]]: Tjaden.
* [[Bread, Eggs, Milk, Squick]]: Paul muses that they didn't learn anything useful at school: "nobody ever taught us how to light a cigarette in a storm of rain, nor how a fire could be made with wet wood - nor that it is best to stick a bayonet in the belly because there it doesn't get jammed, as it does in the ribs."
* [[Bring My Brown Pants]]: A new recruit craps himself in his first fight. The veterans quietly tell him how to deal with it, and ask if he really thinks he's the first soldier ever to get the gun-shits.
* [[But for Me It Was Tuesday]]:
** At the beginning, Paul sits at the bed of his friend, Kemmerich, who had his leg amputated. When he realizes that Kemmerich is dying, he runs for the doctor:
{{quote|'''Paul:''' Come quick, Franz Kemmerich is dying!
Line 23 ⟶ 56:
'''Orderly:''' Bed 26, amputated thigh.
'''Doctor:''' How should I know anything about it? I've amputated five legs today! }}
** {{spoiler|Paul Bäumer}} is killed on a day that was "so quiet and still on the whole front, that the army report confined itself to the single sentence: [[Title Drop|All quiet on the Western Front]]."
* [[Butterfly of Death and Rebirth]]: In the movie, when Paul goes home he sees his sister's butterfly collection. In the final scene {{spoiler|Paul is shot and killed while reaching for a butterfly}}.
* [[Cloudcuckoolander]]: This is one of the few works
* [[Cool Old Guy]]: Kat. He's 40, but still counts, as he's old compared to the people around him.
* [[Dead Hand Shot]]: The 1930 film depicts {{spoiler|Paul's death}} like that.▼
* [[Despair Event Horizon]]: Paul has crossed it by the end of the book. He describes his feelings like this: "Let the months and years come, they can take nothing from me, they can take nothing more. I am so alone, and so without hope that I can confront them without fear."
* [[Dies Wide Open]]: The French soldier that Bäumer stabs dies like this.
* [[Distracted From Death]]: {{spoiler|Kat dies while being carried to the hospital, and Paul doesn't notice until a medic at the hospital points it out.}}
* [[Does That Sound Like Fun to You?]]: In the 1930 film, when on leave, Paul goes back to his old classroom to see Kantorek using the same speech he told his class on another group of young innocent students. Excited to see one of his former students drop in, Kantorek encourages Paul to tell them how grand being in the front lines are. To his credit, Paul was really uncomfortable and insisted he had nothing to say, but caved to his teacher's demands... and flat out told the students that [[War Is Hell]] and [[Take That|that their teacher was going to send them to their deaths like his class before them]].▼
* [[Drill Sergeant Nasty]]: Corporal Himmelstoss, who trained Paul and his friends. Himmelstoss does a [[Heel Face Turn]] after having been forced to actually serve in the trenches.
* [[Dwindling Party]]: Starts off slow, but picks up the pace near the end.
* [[Fatal Family Photo]]: After Paul kills a French soldier, he finds pictures of his wife and daughter (which makes him feel even more guilty).
* [[Get a Hold of Yourself, Man!]]: A newbie in the trenches is getting hysterical to the point of trying to leave the bomb shelter. Everybody else in the shelter beats him up until he doesn't try to leave any more. Paul tells us that it's not pleasant, but it's the only thing that helps.
* [[Getting Crap Past the Radar]]: Tjaden is occasionally described as "delivering the most famous quote from ''[[
* [[
* [[Heroic BSOD]] : Paul has a very memorable one {{spoiler|after stabbing the French soldier trapped with him in a crater to death and then listening to him slowly die during the entire sleepless night. [[Must Make Amends|After he examines the dead soldier's personal belongings, he repentantly promises to secretly support his family once the war ends]]. [[Tear Jerker|Then he realizes he can't, because they'd eventually find out who's the mysterious donor and realize he's the one who killed their relative]].}}
* [[Humiliation Conga]]: Himmelstoss gets this early on in the book as revenge for his harsh boot camp rituals.
* [[If You Die, I Call Your Stuff]]: A pair of good boots are passed around among the soldiers.
* [[In Medias Res]]: The story starts with the characters already in the trenches. Paul later reminiscences about their training.
* [[Insert Cameo]]: In the 1930 film, {{spoiler|Paul's death scene shows his hand reaching for a butterfly; then a shot is heard, and the hand goes limp in death.}} The hand in the scene belonged to director Lewis Milestone.▼
* [[Instant Death Bullet]]: Averted; a character is shot shot point-blank in the stomach with a flare gun, and he is dying for half an hour "quite conscious and in terrible pain".
* {{spoiler|[[Kill'Em All]]:}} [[An Aesop|Just to drive the point home]] that [[Finagle's Law|war is absurd, unpredictable]]... and with NO real [[War Is Glorious|glory]] in store for anyone...
* [[Last-Name Basis]]
* [[New Meat]]: Paul says that the new recruits are almost useless, because they have no knowledge about trench warfare; "A man would like to spank them, they are so stupid, and to take them by the arm and lead them away from here where they have no business to be."
* [[Not Even Bothering with the Accent]]: In the film, the German characters are played by American actors, who speak with American accents. This, however, is intentional [[Translation Convention]], in order to show American movie-goers [[Not So Different|just how much like us the German protagonists really are]].▼
* [[Old Soldier]]: Kat.
* [[Only a Flesh Wound]]: Averted ''hard''. A character dies from a leg injury, another is hit by a shrapnel on his hip, and quickly bleeds to death.
* [[Only Electric Sheep Are Cheap]] : An interesting non-sci-fi example. One of the soldiers in the story is overjoyed when he discovers ''an actual cherry tree in bloom'' during a march across the countryside to a new position. Since he (and the others) have spent entire weeks at the frontline, this is hardly surprising - the frontline being [[Mordor|a lifeless war-torn muddy wasteland]] and all.
* [[Peaceful in Death]]: When
* [[Politically-Motivated Teacher]]: Kantorek, who encourages his students to join the army, greatly romanticizing it as [[War Is Glorious|something glorious.]] [[Foregone Conclusion|Of course, he couldn't be farther from the truth.]]
* [[Popcultural Osmosis]]: The famous "butterfly" scene from the film is parodied by people who may well have never heard of the film, let alone the book.▼
* [[Precision F-Strike]]: in the (unabridged) English translation, the word "fuck" appears only once. Other profanities are not terribly common (with "shit" being used sparingly).
* [[Redshirt Army]]: As the protagonist explains it, the training of the time didn't really prepare soldiers for the war, so newbies got mowed down by the score. A few survived by blind luck long enough to learn proper survival strategies, and they formed a core constantly supplemented with [[New Meat]].
* [[Serrated Blade of Pain]]: The narrator mentions that veterans on the front take away from new soldiers any sawtooth bayonets they find on them, as anyone captured with them is killed outright rather than taken prisoner.
* [[Shell-Shocked Veteran]]: All characters became such people.
* [[Shovel Strike]]: The experienced soldiers sharpen their shovels into bladed weapons (a bit like a [[wikipedia:
* [[Soldiers
* [[Stranger in a Familiar Land]]: Paul feels like this, when he visits home.
* [[Title Drop]]: On the last page. A cable from the High Command stating this is sent, at the end of the war
* [[War Is Hell]]: The original title is literally "Nothing New in the West". Now think about what happened, the setting, and ''why'' there's nothing new.
* [[Wide-Eyed Idealist]]: One [[Mauve Shirt]] character.
{{tropelist|page=All Quiet on the Western Front (1930 film)}}
▲* [[Does That Sound Like Fun to You?]]: In the 1930 film, when on leave, Paul goes back to his old classroom to see Kantorek using the same speech he told his class on another group of young innocent students. Excited to see one of his former students drop in, Kantorek encourages Paul to tell them how grand being in the front lines are. To his credit, Paul was really uncomfortable and insisted he had nothing to say, but caved to his teacher's demands... and flat out told the students that [[War Is Hell]] and [[Take That|that their teacher was going to send them to their deaths like his class before them]].
▲* [[Insert Cameo]]: In the 1930 film, {{spoiler|Paul's death scene shows his hand reaching for a butterfly; then a shot is heard, and the hand goes limp in death.}} The hand in the scene belonged to director Lewis Milestone.
▲* [[Not Even Bothering with the Accent]]: In the film, the German characters are played by American actors, who speak with American accents. This, however, is intentional [[Translation Convention]], in order to show American movie-goers [[Not So Different|just how much like us the German protagonists really are]].
▲* [[
{{reflist}}
<!-- MOD: Literature templates and categories are listed below; be sure to move them to the novel's works page once "All Quiet on the Western Front {novel)" is written -->
{{The Big Read}}
[[Category:Lit Fic]]
[[Category:
[[Category:
[[Category:Films of the 1930s]]▼
[[Category:Academy Award]]▼
▲[[Category:Epic Movie]]
[[Category:School Study Media]]
[[Category:
[[Category:
<!-- MOD: Film templates and categories are listed below; be sure to move them to any or all of the films' works pages once those pages are written -->
{{Academy Award Best Picture}}
[[Category:Films Based on Novels]]
[[Category:Films With Recuts]]
▲[[Category:Films of the 1930s]]
[[Category:National Film Registry]]
[[Category:Films of the 1970s]]
[[Category:Films of the 2020s]]
[[Category:Military and Warfare Films]]
| |||