Boy Meets T-Girl: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
(Rewriting a bit, removing a few forced/awkward potholes, the fact that Fanservice is YMMV goes without saying and seems written to head off possibly justifiable complaints...)
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope workshop}}
{{tropestub}}
A subtrope and variant of one of the most basic and oldest plots, which originally went: [[Boy Meets Girl]], boy loses girl, boy finds girl again. But with a twist.
 
One of the pair is the inevitably shy and innocent [[Girl Next Door|boy next door]] - a straight stock character. The other is inexplicably gorgeous, intelligent, sympathetic, single and seemingly perfect in every way... but for [[transsexualismTransgender|one minor detail]], which serves as a source of dramatic tension at her expense for most of the story. She was assigned male at birth; her backstory involves a [[Gender Bender|long and difficult transition]], of which the boy who's just been smitten by her has no inkling or idea. Effectively, she's left wondering how he will react [[Unsettling Gender Reveal|once he learns of her past]] - and he will be caught completely off-guard, to the point that that he risks losing the girl if he reacts the wrong way or, (if she's "outed" by someone else). fails to defend her honour.
 
[[The Reveal]] is usually played in one of two ways. If this is being written as porn or erotica, she's transformed into a [[futanari]]-like fetish object that acts as [[Fan Service|"the best of both worlds" sexually]], with all the [[Unfortunate Implications]] that cancarries.<ref>It isn't the "transgender" part that carries the Unfortunate Implications, it's the "fetish object" carrypart.</ref> If this is being written as the sort of teen fiction which turns up in public libraries, she becomes [[An Aesop]] - a [[Public Service Announcement|lesson to bullying teens]] not to judge others on the basis of their sexuality or gender identity.
 
Another variant involves a fellow falling for a transgender woman in some context where he knows (or at least suspects) what's going on, but where his family, friends or colleagues don't know (and react negatively or even violently when they learn the truth).
 
Despite the trope title, '''Boy Meets T-Girl''' could just as easily be played the other way around; there are just as many transsexual[[transgender]] persons transitioning female-to-male as male-to-female. As indicated, the straight boy/trans woman pairing is more common because a woman, transgender womanor otherwise, is a more readily sexualisedsexualized character (see [[Attractive Bent Gender]] and [[Everybody Wants the Hermaphrodite]]), but at the same time, more free to express emotion if the main character allows anyone to hurt her in some way - as [[Men Don't Cry]], but trans women (as they are women) do. And yes, real life is more complicated as there are [[Queer Romance|various possibilities]] to match trans people with other LGBTLGBT2 community members who would be more aware of the issues and the discrimination involved.
 
Not to be confused with [[Something's Different About You Now]], where the lad already knew the lady before transition.
 
See [[Transsexualism]] and [[Transgender]]. See also the older-than-dirt parent trope, [[Boy Meets Girl]].
 
{{examples}}
== [[Advertising]] ==
 
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==
* ''[[Family Compo]]'' plays ping-pong with the trope, as a guy winds up living with a transgender family and is attracted to the "daughter" of the family, who tends to switch between being a "boy" and a "girl" as often as they change clothes, and the story tends to leave what they really are under said clothing up in the air.
 
== [[Comic Books]] ==
 
== [[Fan Works]] ==
 
== [[Film]] ==
* ''[[The Crying Game]]'' has a man unwittingly fall in love with a transwomantrans woman as just one more twist in an already-complex plot.
* ''[[Soldier's Girl]]'' has a soldier fall in love with a transgender showgirl. He's fine with her status, two of his fellow soldiers are not.
* ''Transfixed (2015)'' is an Alon Kol documentary about a pair of Asperger Syndrome patients (Martine Stonehouse and John Gelmon) in a highly unconventional romance. Despite their social limitations (an autism spectrum disorder that makes communication with others extremely difficult), both dream of getting married but straight-identifying John presumably won't tie the knot until Martine is able to complete her sexual reassignment surgery.
* ''XXY (2007 film)'' has a boy fall in love with an intersexualintersex main character, who is living as a teen girl but hiding that she medically has some characteristics of both genders (as XX is the usual genetic code for a lady and XY for a gentleman, XXY is unusual and rare).
 
== [[Literature]] ==
Line 37 ⟶ 29:
 
== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
* ''Transparent'' (Amazon video series): Josh (Jay Duplass) and his crush on Shea (Trace Lysette) in season three. Given that Lysette is a transwoman in real life, it adds a certain extra realism.
 
== [[Music]] ==
 
== [[New Media]] ==
 
== [[Newspaper Comics]] ==
 
== [[Oral Tradition]], Myths and Legends ==
 
== [[Pinball]] ==
 
== [[Podcast]]s ==
 
== [[Professional Wrestling]] ==
 
== [[Puppet Shows]] ==
 
== [[Radio]] ==
 
== [[Recorded and Stand Up Comedy]] ==
 
== [[Tabletop Games]] ==
 
== [[Theatre]] ==
 
== [[Video Games]] ==
 
== [[Visual Novel]]s ==
 
== [[Web Animation]] ==
 
== [[Web Comics]] ==
 
== [[Web Original]] ==
 
== [[Western Animation]] ==
 
== Other Media ==
 
== [[Real Life]] ==
 
 
{{reflist}}