Narrowed It Down to the Guy I Recognize/Quotes

Daniel: Watch it, Jack. He killed Mozart!

Slater: In a movie?

Daniel: Amadeus! It won eight Oscars!

—Last Action Hero, after a meeting with John Practice (F. Murray Abraham)

Ray: That's the guy who did it.

Fraser: How do you know?

Ray: He looks like, um... that actor.

Fraser: What actor?

Ray: Well, you know how on Barnaby Jones, you can always tell the bad guy because he's played by that actor that you see a lot?

Fraser: Yes?

Ray: He looks like that actor. Trust me. They haven't been able to fool me once.

—Due South, "They Eat Horses, Don't They?"

You mean the recognizable character actor with one brief scene before this was the bad guy? What a surprise!

—Film Brain, Bad Movie Beatdown of The Riddle