Scream 4/WMG

• Main
• Characters
• Headscratchers
• Quotes
• WMG
• Crowners
  • Awesome
  • Funny
  • Heartwarming
  • Nightmare Fuel
• Wikipedia
• All Subpages
• Create New

Scream 4 had 3 killers, Judy was the 3rd

Think about it, there's NO WAY Jill and Charlie could have done half those kills, they aren't strong enough. There's also a lot of times where it seems like they're both in other places Rebecca, where Jill is in the hospital and Charlie is with Robbie, Olivia, where the cops were pursuing Ghostface while she was being killed, and Kate, Hoss, and Perkins. Where Jill was with Kirby and Charlie was most likely with Robbie. It just doesn't add up! Add the fact that Judy was so incredibly CREEPY and you have a perfect 3rd killer!

• This troper thinks it makes sense, but she was too obvious a suspect, and clearly set up to be a Red Herring, just like the cop in Scream 3 that Patrick Dempsey played. Though maybe the writer will reveal Judy to be the killer in Scream 5, and make her admit to some of the murders in Scream 4.
  • I definitely agree she's too obvious for a regular, it's just that NO ONE else could qualify and it'd be a huge shock to reveal a survivor to be a killer. Think about it, some scenes seem off without 3 killers and she's the only one who could possibly be a killer and alive. Robbie and Kirby may have survived, but their attacks were isolated and done in a way that they could not be killers. Judy is the only one that makes sense.
  • Considering Jill killed off Charlie when he outlived his usefulness, who's to say one of the other killers wasn't a victim who she killed for the same reason?

Kirby and Robbie from Scream 4 survived their knife wounds

This troper is reluctantly adding this WMG because of how prevailant this theory is. So, OK, there is a possibility that both of them, or only one of them survived. It would be nice to have a couple of new recurring characters in future Scream movies besides the usual three.

• I'm in total support of this theory. I'm a huge Kirby and Robbie fan! :P I really wanted them to make it. Besides, Dewey was stabbed way worse in Scream 2 and survived for much longer. It could definitely happen.
• Robbie definitely didn't survive. When The cops get to the house post-bloodbath, Judy feels Robbie's pulse and says "He's gone." Kirby, on the other hand...