I feel like this could be moved from YMMV status on the basis of not being solely an audience reaction, given that it's employed within the work of a universe many times and isn't limited at all to works with audio - besides that, the presence of a Real Life section despite a warning to the contrary and the fact the linked YMMV subsection just redirects to the main page suggests that both were artifacts from the TVT forking. What do you all think?
Talk:Hell Is That Noise
Open to anyone ofc, but tagging @Robkelk in particular since he's the only one I've seen touch the pages within the last year or so.
Taking the second point first, Real Life examples are certainly possible. We should take that tag off the page.
As for YMMV, some noises are "Hell" to everyone, but others are only annoying to some people - the "Amazing Grace" example under Real Life says as much, for example. Hmmmmm... More opinions from other people, please?
The YMMV status may remain, due to the existence of Misophonia, an actual syndrome where the affected are oversensitive to certain sounds that may be unremarkable to others.
That's a completely fair argument for leaving as is - honestly, that's worth adding to the page no matter which way this falls.
There are no older topics