Comedic Sociopathy: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
No edit summary
("comics"->"comic books", "fanfic"->"fan works")
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
{{quote|''"Tragedy is when I cut my finger. [[Crosses the Line Twice|Comedy is when ''you'' fall in an open sewer and die.]]"''|'''[[Mel Brooks]]'''}}
{{quote|''"Tragedy is when I cut my finger. [[Crosses the Line Twice|Comedy is when ''you'' fall in an open sewer and die.]]"''
|'''[[Mel Brooks]]'''}}


[[Comedy]], as has been noted before, ain't pretty.
[[Comedy]], as has been noted before, ain't pretty.
Line 37: Line 38:
* [[Karma Houdini|Mayuri]] [[Mad Scientist|Kurotsuchi]] from ''[[Bleach]]'' in his Hueco Mundo appearance. An awkward case, as the fanbase remains divided as to whether it could be considered ''comedy'' or not. One side of the fence found it all very amusing, while the other found it repulsive. The latter because the [[Butt Monkey]] in that situation was a former enemy and the grandson of one of Kurotsuchi's many [[For Science!]] [[Moral Event Horizon|victims]]. The former because not everyone who reads/watches ''[[Bleach]]'' considers the whole thing [[Serious Business]], and finds Mayuri and his [[Refuge in Audacity|unapologetic]] [[Jerkass|sociopathy]] hilarious.
* [[Karma Houdini|Mayuri]] [[Mad Scientist|Kurotsuchi]] from ''[[Bleach]]'' in his Hueco Mundo appearance. An awkward case, as the fanbase remains divided as to whether it could be considered ''comedy'' or not. One side of the fence found it all very amusing, while the other found it repulsive. The latter because the [[Butt Monkey]] in that situation was a former enemy and the grandson of one of Kurotsuchi's many [[For Science!]] [[Moral Event Horizon|victims]]. The former because not everyone who reads/watches ''[[Bleach]]'' considers the whole thing [[Serious Business]], and finds Mayuri and his [[Refuge in Audacity|unapologetic]] [[Jerkass|sociopathy]] hilarious.
* In ''[[Tona Gura]]'', Yuuji's intrusive, often juvenile pursuit of Kazuki, and his sister Marie's literally armed response to any and all signs of such lewdness. Possibly also Hatsune tying Marie up to stop her punishment of Yuuji, and her ignoring Kazuki's stated desire to stop her extreme efforts at matchmaking.
* In ''[[Tona Gura]]'', Yuuji's intrusive, often juvenile pursuit of Kazuki, and his sister Marie's literally armed response to any and all signs of such lewdness. Possibly also Hatsune tying Marie up to stop her punishment of Yuuji, and her ignoring Kazuki's stated desire to stop her extreme efforts at matchmaking.
* ''[[D.Gray-man|D Gray Man]]'': Cross Marian's abusive treatment of his student Allen Walker is [[Hilariously Abusive Childhood|played for laughs]].
* ''[[D.Gray-man]]'': Cross Marian's abusive treatment of his student Allen Walker is [[Hilariously Abusive Childhood|played for laughs]].
* Combine this with [[Heroic Comedic Sociopath]] and you get Kogurashi from ''[[Kamen no Maid Guy]]''.
* Combine this with [[Heroic Comedic Sociopath]] and you get Kogurashi from ''[[Kamen no Maid Guy]]''.
* Somehow, [[Sayonara, Zetsubou-sensei|Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei]] manages to pull of the feat of playing Comedic Sociopathy for laughs... And, yes, this statement takes into consideration the fact that Comedic Sociopathy is already playing on sociopathy for laughs.
* Somehow, [[Sayonara, Zetsubou-sensei|Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei]] manages to pull of the feat of playing Comedic Sociopathy for laughs... And, yes, this statement takes into consideration the fact that Comedic Sociopathy is already playing on sociopathy for laughs.
Line 60: Line 61:




== Comics ==
== Comic Books ==
* ''[[Knights of the Dinner Table]]'' lives off of this trope, especially with how the players and [[Game Master|Hackmasters]] relate to each other. [[Justified]], as it's an outgrowth of the [[Killer Game Master]] philosophy that dominated [[Tabletop RPG|roleplaying games]] the time period the comic parodies—Hackmasters were expected to show players no mercy and players were expected to twist the knife if they got even a smidgen of an advantage. This, however, only applies within the game... it's considered in very poor taste between the characters to invoke this trope in [[Real Life]]. [[Jerkass]]es like [[Small Name, Big Ego|Stevil]] and [[The Real Man|Bob]] still pull it, but they're much more likely to get called on it.
* ''[[Knights of the Dinner Table]]'' lives off of this trope, especially with how the players and [[Game Master|Hackmasters]] relate to each other. [[Justified]], as it's an outgrowth of the [[Killer Game Master]] philosophy that dominated [[Tabletop RPG|roleplaying games]] the time period the comic parodies—Hackmasters were expected to show players no mercy and players were expected to twist the knife if they got even a smidgen of an advantage. This, however, only applies within the game... it's considered in very poor taste between the characters to invoke this trope in [[Real Life]]. [[Jerkass]]es like [[Small Name, Big Ego|Stevil]] and [[The Real Man|Bob]] still pull it, but they're much more likely to get called on it.
* [[The Joker]] is a very literal comedic sociopath. Some of his best moments are as hilarious as they are evil.
* [[The Joker]] is a very literal comedic sociopath. Some of his best moments are as hilarious as they are evil.
{{quote|'''Robin:''' I have to admit, the barracuda down the pants was funny.
{{quote|'''Robin:''' I have to admit, the barracuda down the pants was funny.
'''Batman:''' [[The Comically Serious|No, it wasn't.]] }}
'''Batman:''' [[The Comically Serious|No, it wasn't.]] }}
* In ''[[Sam & Max: Freelance Police|Sam and Max Freelance Police]]'', Max's most common solution when he's given the reins may as well be "give the problem the coolest death possible."
* In ''[[Sam & Max: Freelance Police]]'', Max's most common solution when he's given the reins may as well be "give the problem the coolest death possible."
* ''[[Fun With Milk and Cheese]]'' lives on this trope. The only reason the comic gets away with beating up senior citizens, stabbing bystanders, and incinerating furries is because it's too comedic to take seriously.
* ''[[Fun With Milk and Cheese]]'' lives on this trope. The only reason the comic gets away with beating up senior citizens, stabbing bystanders, and incinerating furries is because it's too comedic to take seriously.
* Bad guy Schlich from one [[Wilhelm Busch]] story is made of this. [[Running Gag|Several times]], he comments "That's fatal - heh, heh, but not for me!"
* Bad guy Schlich from one [[Wilhelm Busch]] story is made of this. [[Running Gag|Several times]], he comments "That's fatal - heh, heh, but not for me!"
* Calamity James of ''[[The Beano]]'' is the world's unluckiest boy, and gets chewed up by life in every strip; sometimes the punishment comes from his pet lemming or even his mother. This trope makes it funny, though the poor boy wouldn't see it that way.
* Calamity James of ''[[The Beano]]'' is the world's unluckiest boy, and gets chewed up by life in every strip; sometimes the punishment comes from his pet lemming or even his mother. This trope makes it funny, though the poor boy wouldn't see it that way.
* [[Johnny the Homicidal Maniac]], in spades.
* ''[[Johnny the Homicidal Maniac]]'', in spades.




== Fanfic ==
== Fan Works ==
* Meta-example: Characters that fit this trope are often the subject of bashing by authors who like to file off the "comedic" part of the trope and turn up the "sociopathy" aspect by treating their behavior seriously. Does a girl smack around a guy for [[Accidental Pervert|catching her coming out of a bath]] or for being just kind of a [[Idiot Hero|goofball]]? Treat her as if she's dangerously unhinged or make the slapstick violence cause real injuries. In some fandoms, treatment of this trope as [[Dude, Not Funny]] is more common than playing it straight.
* Meta-example: Characters that fit this trope are often the subject of bashing by authors who like to file off the "comedic" part of the trope and turn up the "sociopathy" aspect by treating their behavior seriously. Does a girl smack around a guy for [[Accidental Pervert|catching her coming out of a bath]] or for being just kind of a [[Idiot Hero|goofball]]? Treat her as if she's dangerously unhinged or make the slapstick violence cause real injuries. In some fandoms, treatment of this trope as [[Dude, Not Funny]] is more common than playing it straight.