Heartbreaking in Hindsight

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Revision as of 18:15, 12 April 2022 by Looney Toons (talk | contribs) (put italics on work names, fixed CamelCase trope link, fixed redlink, put work name in proper form and added link markup)

An event which is made sadder by a later event. Differs from Harsher in Hindsight in that the events may not necessarily be bad or harsh. The events that are Heartbreaking in Hindsight might be a Heartwarming Moment and it is only until the later event that you see sadder subtext in the first one.

Compare Harsher in Hindsight, Heartwarming in Hindsight, Tear Jerker. Contrast Hilarious in Hindsight.

Examples of Heartbreaking in Hindsight include:
  • In the film Black Panther M'Baku gives a giant smile of relief when T'Challa's family successfully revives him after his Near-Death Experience, showing that he does have a soft side. In Avengers: Infinity War, T'Challa gets dusted by Thanos, along with a good number of the Wakandan forces. All M'Baku can do is stare at the battlefield with an anguished expression.
  • The show Tuca & Bertie has quite a few:
    • In a heartwarming moment between Speckle and Bertie, where Speckle creates a romantic roleplay for Bertie after she admits, following an episode of miscommunication, she wants to add some surprises to their sex routine. They end up reviving the spark between their relationship. In the season one finale, Speckle calls out Bertie for refusing to answer her calls for a week, and was worried that something had happened to her. He says that he can't be the rock in their relationship to constantly provide emotional support or automatically knowing her needs. They do make up, but Bertie admits that she has a lot of work to make up for ghosting Speckle, to be his rock.
    • When a sloshed Speckle witnesses Tuca taking emotional abuse from her aunt, he whispers for her to stand up to the lady. Later, he comforts Tuca that You Did the Right Thing by tearing up the woman's check after her aunt belittles her single mother. In the season finale, Tuca finds out that her aunt is in the hospital from cirrhosis, and their last conversation was a huge fight.