Sherlok Holms/YMMV
- Crowning Moment of Funny: The Slender Man arc.
- Ben's Evil Twin is apparently Jadusable. Oh, and he took out Ben's batteries. The sheer WTF-ery crosses over into hilarity.
- Designated Hero: Ben. This is intentional.
- Ensemble Darkhorse: This comic probably would have ended about 5 comics in if it weren't for Ben.
- Genius Bonus: A few lines are a lot funnier if you've read the creepypasta in question.
- Nightmare Face: Ben.
- Nightmare Fuel: Some of the end-of-panel faces Sherlok makes.
- Nightmare Retardant: It's hard to be scared of Slender Man when he's a villain in a horrible webcomic, right? According to Word of God, this trope is the entire purpose of the comic.
- So Bad It's Good: Completely intentional.
- Uncanny Valley: Almost all of Sherlok's end-of-panel faces.