(cur
prevtopic)
01:03, 31 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Take it to https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Blog:A_post_on_a_recent_bit_of_drama_involving_Comple_Monster_pages_and_moderator_infighting)
. .+133
(cur
prevtopic)
00:42, 31 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I have no idea what Robkelk is even saying anymore. I would have to veto such things because that would be blatant misuse of the trope. P...)
. .+206
(cur
prevtopic)
19:18, 30 August 2019. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I have posted a blog linked in the site header to centralize all discussions on this topic, please refer to that and comment as appropriate.)
. .+140
(cur
prevtopic)
19:10, 30 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (You misunderstand. There is no reason for you to have a veto. At all. On any Complete Monster page.)
. .+104
(cur
prevtopic)
17:27, 30 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (In that case, there is no reason for you to have a veto. Uh, I'm not vetoing Innominat as an example - he stays. But on the Tales (series...)
. .+200
(cur
prevtopic)
01:38, 30 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Anyone who is only reading this thread, please also read this thread and this thread.)
. .+195
(cur
prevtopic)
01:19, 30 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I don't want to control what gets posted as an example. In that case, there is no reason for you to have a veto.)
. .+116
(cur
prevtopic)
00:32, 30 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Complete Monster is a subjective character-based trope. Those types of tropes aren't handled the same way as many other tropes on the wik...)
. .+1,858
(cur
prevtopic)
23:59, 29 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Do I ... want to take away your admin rights? Not without a discussion amongst all of the bureaucrats. But if one of the other bureaucrat...)
. .+180
(cur
prevtopic)
23:49, 29 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" ("Lump multiple examples across a series" is how Complete Monster has always been done. Like, since the trope's beginning on this wiki. Wh...)
. .+2,449
(cur
prevtopic)
23:14, 29 August 2019. .Derivative(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I feel like if the 'foe' feature is going to cause that much bother, what's the point in keeping it? I don't have much perspective to con...)
. .+440
(cur
prevtopic)
22:13, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I will make time if I have to. Honestly, I did not think that one-example pages were a thing. I'd assumed that even pages still under con...)
. .+182
(cur
prevtopic)
22:11, 29 August 2019. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (In the unlikely event that you win, Doc, you have just volunteered to "fix" every other one-example page on the wiki. Because if it becom...)
. .+256
(cur
prevtopic)
22:09, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I still vote for 4, but even 2 or 3 would be better than 1. To put it simply, a trope page that has only 1 entry on it is pure cringe and...)
. .+168
(cur
prevtopic)
21:44, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" ("Lump multiple examples across a series" is how Complete Monster has always been done. Like, since the trope's beginning on this wiki. It...)
. .+2,701
(cur
prevtopic)
19:26, 29 August 2019. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (MOD HAT ON: Fine, since you want an opinion, here is mine. If we have to choose between a dedicated page for just one specific example or...)
. .+1,169
(cur
prevtopic)
17:18, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I cannot recall when splitting up pages like that was a thing for tropes like Complete Monster. What works for things like Awesome, Funny...)
. .+299
(cur
prevtopic)
17:16, 29 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (We have been splitting up pages that cover multiple works for years now. We even have a category for them that is permanently linked from...)
. .+222
(cur
prevtopic)
17:07, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (@Looney Tunes: I did not delete under the reasoning of "spam" this time. @Robkelk: I want GethN7 to weigh in on this. Because, to be blun...)
. .+1,134
(cur
prevtopic)
16:44, 29 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (And I think we need to formally define the policy on how many entries are required for a subpage. I vote for "1". @Labster @GethN7 @Loone...)
. .+306
(cur
prevtopic)
16:36, 29 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (And it looks to me like we have a project - take all those one-offs listed on pages about multiple works and split them out into pages fo...)
. .+305
(cur
prevtopic)
15:46, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (For reference, it's the second to last entry on this page, see? https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Complete_Monster/Tales_(series))
. .+126
(cur
prevtopic)
15:36, 29 August 2019. .DocColress(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (I hadn't seen the notification asking me for vetoing it or not. I veto it now because we already have a Complete Monster page for example...)
. .+441
(cur
prevtopic)
21:46, 28 August 2019. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Thirded. I'd rather we keep the page and eliminate repeats on other pages as opposed to removing it.)
. .+100
(cur
prevtopic)
17:39, 28 August 2019. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (Seconded. We have plenty of pages with only one entry on them. That is not at de factor definition of spam.)
. .+117
(cur
prevtopic)
16:49, 28 August 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Why did you delete Complete Monster/Tales of Berseria?" (You had two days to veto that page move at Talk:Complete Monster before the page move was made. I have restored the page. And if a page w...)
. .+588