Author Filibuster: Difference between revisions

Content added Content deleted
(split "comics" into "comic books" and "newspaper comics", replace redirect, potholes, standardize sections, split "porn" section among other sections, added example)
(Absurd length never disqualified a segment of text from being a filibuster. Also the least you could do is note the link is NSFW - seems like a basic courtesy even for an "obvious" example, really)
Line 50: Line 50:
* ''[[The Matrix]]'' sequels, ''The Matrix: Reloaded'' and ''The Matrix: Revolutions'' were heavily criticized for being full of lengthy philosophical pontifications by several characters, including Councillor Hamann, The Oracle, The Merovingian (twice), Agent Smith, and Morpheus.
* ''[[The Matrix]]'' sequels, ''The Matrix: Reloaded'' and ''The Matrix: Revolutions'' were heavily criticized for being full of lengthy philosophical pontifications by several characters, including Councillor Hamann, The Oracle, The Merovingian (twice), Agent Smith, and Morpheus.
* Cecil B. DeMille's ''The Greatest Show on Earth'' (1952), which was ostensibly a backstage drama about a season at the Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus, keeps interrupting itself with various segments that have little to nothing to do with the characters, including unself-conscious circus performances (with many, ''many'' in-universe audience reaction shots that tend to undercut the fourth wall) and pure documentary scenes showing what carnival workers do, the latter of which are accompanied by verbose and frankly pompous descriptions by a "voice-of-God" narrator. The movie in general can't seem to decide what it wants to be, making it a fine mess. (Of course, it won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 1953, so it's a little hard to gripe.)
* Cecil B. DeMille's ''The Greatest Show on Earth'' (1952), which was ostensibly a backstage drama about a season at the Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus, keeps interrupting itself with various segments that have little to nothing to do with the characters, including unself-conscious circus performances (with many, ''many'' in-universe audience reaction shots that tend to undercut the fourth wall) and pure documentary scenes showing what carnival workers do, the latter of which are accompanied by verbose and frankly pompous descriptions by a "voice-of-God" narrator. The movie in general can't seem to decide what it wants to be, making it a fine mess. (Of course, it won the Academy Award for Best Picture in 1953, so it's a little hard to gripe.)
* ''[[The Texas Chainsaw Massacre]]''; director/producer [[Tobe Hooper]] is an animal rights activist who initially intended this movie to bring attention to the cruel treatment of animals in the meat packing industry by showing the same methods used on humans. The film has become iconic in regards its genre - possibly helping to start it - but not the genre it was intended for.
* ''[[The Texas Chainsaw Massacre]]'' director/producer [[Tobe Hooper]] is an animal rights activist who initially intended the movie to bring attention to the cruel treatment of animals in the meat packing industry by showing the same methods used on humans. The film has become iconic in regards its genre - possibly helping to start it - but not the genre it was intended for.
** Well, maybe it did. [[Wes Craven]] supposedly claimed that watching this movie made him a vegetarian, so maybe Hooper did have some success.
** Well, maybe it did. [[Wes Craven]] supposedly claimed that watching this movie made him a vegetarian, so maybe Hooper did have some success.
* ''[[The Human Centipede]]'' was originally conceived as a way for the director to express what the proper punishment for child predators should be, and to show what notorious Nazi doctors like Adolph Eichmann would be doing if they were still in business in modern times. When that factor is added in, the message isn't subtle...
* ''[[The Human Centipede]]'' was originally conceived as a way for the director to express what the proper punishment for child predators should be, and to show what notorious Nazi doctors like Adolph Eichmann would be doing if they were still in business in modern times. When that factor is added in, the message isn't subtle...
Line 144: Line 144:
* In Joseph Heller's novel ''Good as Gold'', the narrative stops dead for about forty pages while the author delivers a massive rant about Henry Kissinger, how he's a lying, murdering scumbag and how, worst of all, [[Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking|he isn't even really Jewish]].
* In Joseph Heller's novel ''Good as Gold'', the narrative stops dead for about forty pages while the author delivers a massive rant about Henry Kissinger, how he's a lying, murdering scumbag and how, worst of all, [[Arson, Murder, and Jaywalking|he isn't even really Jewish]].
* Joseph Conrad's ''[[Heart of Darkness]]'' (1902) is a psychological thriller masquerading as an African adventure story, but even before the psychological element takes center stage, the novella's protagonist, Charlie Marlowe, veers away from pure narrative at times to talk about his spiritual awakening (or spiritual death, as the case may be) while in the Congo. For several pages at a time, we come upon extensive philosophical treatises that were considered long-winded and dull even in Conrad's time. Partly justified by the fact that Marlowe is actually, in-story, speaking to a group of friends on a boat, and it is an unnamed first-person narrator listening to Marlowe who both opens and concludes the whole thing.
* Joseph Conrad's ''[[Heart of Darkness]]'' (1902) is a psychological thriller masquerading as an African adventure story, but even before the psychological element takes center stage, the novella's protagonist, Charlie Marlowe, veers away from pure narrative at times to talk about his spiritual awakening (or spiritual death, as the case may be) while in the Congo. For several pages at a time, we come upon extensive philosophical treatises that were considered long-winded and dull even in Conrad's time. Partly justified by the fact that Marlowe is actually, in-story, speaking to a group of friends on a boat, and it is an unnamed first-person narrator listening to Marlowe who both opens and concludes the whole thing.
* The Marquis De Sade was quite fond of this trope, intercalating his famously depraved sex scenes with just as many, if less famous, lengthy rhetorics about the pointlessness of morality in a Godless universe and the glories of hedonism. ''The Philosophy in the Bedroom'' is [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin|probably the most blatant example]].
* The [[Marquis De Sade]] was quite fond of this trope, intercalating his famously depraved sex scenes with just as many (if less famous) lengthy rhetorics about the pointlessness of morality in a Godless universe and the glories of hedonism. ''The Philosophy in the Bedroom'' is [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin|probably the most blatant example]].
** Even in ''120 Days of Sodom'', which was allegedly written to be a catalogue of different "passions", he can't help his philosophizing and the first part of the book (the 400 pages that were actually written, as opposed to just notes researchers have found) intertwines "tame" (for de Sade, that means watersports/scat, by the by) non-penetrative sexual scenes with why the four main characters are justified in their future torture and murder of their guests.
** Even in ''120 Days of Sodom'', which was allegedly written to be a catalogue of different "passions", he can't help his philosophizing and the first part of the book (the 400 pages that were actually written, as opposed to just notes researchers have found) intertwines "tame" (for de Sade, that means watersports/scat, by the by) non-penetrative sexual scenes with why the four main characters are justified in their future torture and murder of their guests. This was a [[Stealth Parody]] of the day's aristocracy and those who they share power with.
*** This was [[Stealth Parody]] of the day's aristocracy and those who they share power with, and an example of how an [[Overly Long Gag]] can still be Author Filibuster.
* The book version of ''[[Emanuelle]]'' gets bogged down with these, especially the "Laws of Eros" conversation. The mouthpiece character goes on about how one can't simply replace bad laws with chaotic anomie, then goes on to make the bald assertion that anything man-made is more aesthetically pleasing than anything created by nature.
* The book version of ''[[Emanuelle]]'' gets bogged down with these, especially the "Laws of Eros" conversation. The mouthpiece character goes on about how one can't simply replace bad laws with chaotic anomie, then goes on to make the bald assertion that anything man-made is more aesthetically pleasing than anything created by nature.


== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
* Very common in American TV cartoons and sitcoms during the 1980s and well into the '90s, with the characters (or, sometimes, the actors portraying them) [[Breaking the Fourth Wall]] at the end of the episode to advocate on behalf of a cause with which the episode had fictionally dealt. For more on this phenomenon, see [[And Knowing Is Half the Battle]].
* Very common in American TV cartoons and sitcoms during the 1980s and well into the '90s, with the characters (or, sometimes, the actors portraying them) [[Breaking the Fourth Wall]] at the end of the episode to advocate on behalf of a cause with which the episode had fictionally dealt. For more on this phenomenon, see [[And Knowing Is Half the Battle]].
* When ''[[Brookside]]'' was canceled, the show's creator Phil Redmond had his final say in a rebellious scripted rant about how 'TV and society's not like it was' voiced by its longest-running character.
* When ''[[Brookside]]'' was canceled, the show's creator Phil Redmond had his final say in a rebellious scripted rant about how 'TV and society's not like it was' voiced by its longest-running character.
Line 185: Line 184:
** Not to mention that Kushner is a huge fan of Brecht, and the subtitle of ''Angels In America'' is ''A Gay Fantasia On National Themes''. So really, [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin]].
** Not to mention that Kushner is a huge fan of Brecht, and the subtitle of ''Angels In America'' is ''A Gay Fantasia On National Themes''. So really, [[Exactly What It Says on the Tin]].


== [[Video Games]] ==
== [[Video Games]] ==
* This happens a ''lot'' in the ''[[Metal Gear]]'' series. As a sly apology, more often than not it's the ''villains'' blathering on, and the protagonist greets their speeches with irreverence, frustration or bewilderment as appropriate. Not to mention that you get to ''beat the crap out of them'' once the cutscene's over.
* This happens a ''lot'' in the ''[[Metal Gear]]'' series. As a sly apology, more often than not it's the ''villains'' blathering on, and the protagonist greets their speeches with irreverence, frustration or bewilderment as appropriate. Not to mention that you get to ''beat the crap out of them'' once the cutscene's over.
** That said, in the final cutscene of each game, there's a character that always espouses for Hideo Kojima for a while. In MGS1 it's Naomi Hunter, in MGS2 it's Snake, and in MGS3 it's EVA (sort of, she doesn't nearly break the fourth wall). And you never get the chance to beat any of them up, because it's the final cutscene.
** That said, in the final cutscene of each game, there's a character that always espouses for Hideo Kojima for a while. In MGS1 it's Naomi Hunter, in MGS2 it's Snake, and in MGS3 it's EVA (sort of, she doesn't nearly break the fourth wall). And you never get the chance to beat any of them up, because it's the final cutscene.
*** That's because the Villainous filibusters are actually [[Character Filibuster]]s, with the later Author Filibuster at the end being a disagreement with it. He's generally not wanting you to agree with the villains, which is why their plans fall apart at the end and you get to cream them.
*** That's because the Villainous filibusters are actually [[Character Filibuster]]s, with the later Author Filibuster at the end being a disagreement with it. He's generally not wanting you to agree with the villains, which is why their plans fall apart at the end and you get to cream them.
** As a side-note, Nastasha Romanenko would like you to know that [[Anvilicious|nukes are bad]].
** As a side-note, Nastasha Romanenko would like you to know that [[Anvilicious|nukes are bad]].
* Subverted in ''[[Resident Evil]] 4''. Antagonist Ramon Salazar starts what appears to be a long speech about a rather "special" fate he's got planned for Leon, following a brief quip about terrorism "(being) a popular word these days", but before he can finish his second sentence, Leon [[Shut UP, Hannibal|shuts him up by nailing his hand to a wall with a well-thrown knife.]]
* Subverted in ''[[Resident Evil 4]]''. Antagonist Ramon Salazar starts what appears to be a long speech about a rather "special" fate he's got planned for Leon, following a brief quip about terrorism "(being) a popular word these days", but before he can finish his second sentence, Leon [[Shut UP, Hannibal|shuts him up by nailing his hand to a wall with a well-thrown knife]].
* In ''[[Deus Ex]]'', JC can match wits with a Hong Kong bartender who has a '''lot''' to say about the nature of government and the consent of the governed. The monologue of the NSF leader met in the Statue of Liberty also qualifies.
* In ''[[Deus Ex]]'', JC can match wits with a Hong Kong bartender who has a '''lot''' to say about the nature of government and the consent of the governed. The monologue of the NSF leader met in the Statue of Liberty also qualifies.
* A summary of ''[[The Last Resurrection]]'' would read like this: "Dear Christians, fuck you cunts. Hate, Sean".
* A summary of ''[[The Last Resurrection]]'' would read like this: "Dear Christians, fuck you cunts. Hate, Sean".
Line 215: Line 214:
* ''[[Sonichu]]'', especially during the troll-influenced issues, usually have the eponymous character or the [[Author Avatar]] complaining about stuff the author hates, mostly trolls and homosexuality. Issue 10 is the worst of the bunch, with at least three filibusters and, at one point, Sonichu even tells Chris to stop and get on with the story!
* ''[[Sonichu]]'', especially during the troll-influenced issues, usually have the eponymous character or the [[Author Avatar]] complaining about stuff the author hates, mostly trolls and homosexuality. Issue 10 is the worst of the bunch, with at least three filibusters and, at one point, Sonichu even tells Chris to stop and get on with the story!


== [[Web Original]] ==
== [[Web Original]] ==
* The ''[[Camp Camp]] Holiday Special - A Camp Camp Christmas, or Whatever'' ends with the characters breaking the fourth wall and lecturing the audience. It's not exactly clear how compelling someone that thought climate change was a hoax would be swayed by this, and any viewers that believed it's a hoax could very well feel insulted (and thus admitting being wrong could feel like it comes with the extra baggage of validating the insults. And thus be counter productive to the Rooster Teeth's intent). Mercifully, this was at the very end of the episode, so it didn't grind the plot to a screeching halt as the plot was already wrapped up.
* The ''[[Camp Camp]] Holiday Special - A Camp Camp Christmas, or Whatever'' ends with the characters breaking the fourth wall and lecturing the audience. It's not exactly clear how compelling someone that thought climate change was a hoax would be swayed by this, and any viewers that believed it's a hoax could very well feel insulted (and thus admitting being wrong could feel like it comes with the extra baggage of validating the insults. And thus be counter productive to the Rooster Teeth's intent). Mercifully, this was at the very end of the episode, so it didn't grind the plot to a screeching halt as the plot was already wrapped up.
* A mild example occurs in ''[[Sailor Nothing]]'', when at one point Shin bursts into a long rant about DVD regional lockout and copy protection. This is actually pretty much exactly in character for her, given the situation, but it's a little jarring and has nothing to do with the plot whatsoever.
* A mild example occurs in ''[[Sailor Nothing]]'', when at one point Shin bursts into a long rant about DVD regional lockout and copy protection. This is actually pretty much exactly in character for her, given the situation, but it's a little jarring and has nothing to do with the plot whatsoever.
Line 224: Line 223:
* [[Moviebob]] has a ''really'' long extended rant on [[Megan Fox]] in ''[[Jennifer's Body]]''- it isn't until the two-minute mark that he starts talking about the actual film because he feels he has to get off his chest his annoyance at how overrated she is as either an actress ''or'' a sex symbol.
* [[Moviebob]] has a ''really'' long extended rant on [[Megan Fox]] in ''[[Jennifer's Body]]''- it isn't until the two-minute mark that he starts talking about the actual film because he feels he has to get off his chest his annoyance at how overrated she is as either an actress ''or'' a sex symbol.
** His ''[[Star Trek (film)|Star Trek]]'' review also included a long rant against the Tyler Perry cameo.
** His ''[[Star Trek (film)|Star Trek]]'' review also included a long rant against the Tyler Perry cameo.
** Bob recently{{when}} got a column at the ''[[Escapist]]''. He gleefully announced in his first video that the new series would just be his personal soapbox.
** Bob got a column at the ''[[Escapist]]'', and gleefully announced in his first video that the new series would just be his personal soapbox.{{fact}}
* [[Atop the Fourth Wall|Linkara]] has a tendency of interrupting his comic reviews to remind us of how very much he hates ''[[One More Day]]'', and at one point adds a caption saying he will not be getting over it any time soon. He has the decency to make it funny.
* [[Atop the Fourth Wall|Linkara]] has a tendency of interrupting his comic reviews to remind us of how very much he hates ''[[One More Day]]'', and at one point adds a caption saying he will not be getting over it any time soon. He has the decency to make it funny.
** Justified in that ''[[One More Day]]'' ''is'' a comic, so at least he's still doing his job as a reviewer. Come for one review, get another one free!
** Justified in that ''[[One More Day]]'' ''is'' a comic, so at least he's still doing his job as a reviewer. Come for one review, get another one free!
Line 232: Line 231:
* Animated web series ''[[Broken Saints]]'', steeped as it is in political and religious themes, comes dangerously close to this several times.
* Animated web series ''[[Broken Saints]]'', steeped as it is in political and religious themes, comes dangerously close to this several times.
* Alpharius from ''[[PRIMARCHS]]'' spends an entire chapter doing this at the end of the 2nd arc. Not only is this lampshaded by the stage directions ('''Alpharius'''...'''Alpharius again'''...'''Alpharius still isn't shutting up''') but the chapter itself is titled "[[Invoked Trope|I Think This Qualifies As An Author Filibuster]]".
* Alpharius from ''[[PRIMARCHS]]'' spends an entire chapter doing this at the end of the 2nd arc. Not only is this lampshaded by the stage directions ('''Alpharius'''...'''Alpharius again'''...'''Alpharius still isn't shutting up''') but the chapter itself is titled "[[Invoked Trope|I Think This Qualifies As An Author Filibuster]]".
* Search around the [https://web.archive.org/web/20100908060930/http://www.asstr.org/ Alt Sex Stories Text Repository] (very heavily [[NSFW]]) long enough, and you'll see plenty of ASSTR writers are guilty of making their stories nothing more than glorified morality plays. It's very annoying when these stories target specific audiences with [[Reactionary Fantasy|thinly veiled contempt towards their fetishes]], and (as with much online erotica) often becomes all the more striking the more [[Squick|objectionable]] the story's subject matter is.
* ''Relatively'' brief, but frequent, bouts of this appear to be a [[Signature Style]] of the work of [https://web.archive.org/web/20100822135108/http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/SD40ka/ "SD40ka".] Marvel at how Gary proves to a black guy that [https://web.archive.org/web/20100611202715/http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/SD40ka/The%20Singer%20Meets%20Her%20Man.txt racism does not exist.] Marvel again at how in ''another'' story Carol proves that [https://web.archive.org/web/20090507183851/http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/SD40ka/Greg%20and%20Carol.txt those liberals are all just hypocritical closet racists.]
** For example, ''relatively'' brief-but-frequent bouts of this appear to be a [[Signature Style]] of the work of [https://web.archive.org/web/20100611195852/http://www.asstr.org:80/files/Authors/SD40ka/ "SD40ka".] Marvel at how Gary proves to a black guy that [https://web.archive.org/web/20100611202715/http://www.asstr.org/files/Authors/SD40ka/The%20Singer%20Meets%20Her%20Man.txt racism does not exist.] Marvel again at how in ''another'' story Carol proves that [https://web.archive.org/web/20090507183851/http://www.asstr.org:80/files/Authors/SD40ka/Greg%20and%20Carol.txt those liberals are all just hypocritical closet racists.]
** SD40ka isn't the only culprit. Search around [http://asstr.org asstr] long enough, and you'll see plenty of asstr writers are guilty of making their stories nothing more than glorified morality plays. It's very annoying when these stories target specific audiences with [[Reactionary Fantasy|thinly veiled contempt towards their fetishes.]]


== [[Western Animation]] ==
== [[Western Animation]] ==
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' has done a lot of this in its post-revival episodes to express the writers' generally left-wing views, usually without any self-parody. There is one example of a parodical usage in the episode "Boys Do Cry", however. The message itself is completely sincere, but the way it's delivered is comedically heavy-handed, infused with [[Reality Subtext]]:
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' has done a lot of this in its post-revival episodes to express the writers' generally left-wing views, usually without any self-parody. There is one example in the episode "Boys Do Cry", however, where the message itself is completely sincere, but the way it's delivered is [[Clueless Aesop|hilariously heavy-handed]], infused with [[Reality Subtext]]:
{{quote|"Like, for instance, if you're watching a TV show and you decide to take your values from that... you're an idiot. Maybe you should take responsibility for what values your kids are getting. Maybe you shouldn't be letting your kids watch certain shows in the first place if you have such a big problem with them, instead of blaming the shows themselves. [long pause] Yeah."}}
{{quote|"Like, for instance, if you're watching a TV show and you decide to take your values from that... you're an idiot. Maybe you should take responsibility for what values your kids are getting. Maybe you shouldn't be letting your kids watch certain shows in the first place if you have such a big problem with them, instead of blaming the shows themselves. [long pause] Yeah."}}
:* One particularly egregious example has an entire episode defending OJ Simpson and in the closing scenes there's an explanation about how it's wrong to judge others - and it ended with [[Shaggy Dog Story|OJ stabbing three people and running]]. The [[Broken Aesop]] infuriated many viewers who felt that they had just had a half hour of time stolen from them.
** That is subtle [[Lampshade Hanging]] of Author Filibuster in ''[[Family Guy]]''. [[Clueless Aesop|If the line was intended to have a go at people taking morals from TV without irony]] then...
*** One particularly egregious example has an entire episode defending OJ Simpson and in the closing scenes there's an explanation about how it's wrong to judge others and it end with OJ stabbing three people. The [[Broken Aesop]] infuriated many viewers who felt that they had just had a half hour of time stolen from them.
:* A particularly horrifying example of a literal filibuster came from the same episode where they used up 5 minutes of their show playing... a Conway Twitty music video. The DVD commentary for that episode announces gleefully that they put it in for its whole ~5min run because people would assume that Fox was just not playing [[Family Guy]], and literally put the whole thing in to piss them off.
:* Parodied in ''The Road To Germany'' when Stewie mocks Brian after he said an obvious [[Take That]] towards the war in Iraq.
** A particularly horrifying example of a literal filibuster came from the same episode where they used up 5 minutes of their show playing... a Conway Twitty music video.
*** The DVD commentary for that episode announces gleefully that they put it in for its whole ~5min run because people would assume that Fox was just not playing [[Family Guy]]. They know how it is inappropriate for the show, and literally put the whole thing in to piss off the people who watch.
** Parodied in ''The Road To Germany'' when Stewie mocks Brian after he said an obvious [[Take That]] towards the war in Iraq.
* ''[[South Park]]''. Although sometimes with mocking, many episodes are about what Trey Parker and Matt Stone find wrong in the world.
* ''[[South Park]]''. Although sometimes with mocking, many episodes are about what Trey Parker and Matt Stone find wrong in the world.
** This has become increasingly apparent in recent seasons. In a scene from "Whale Whores", the in-universe Larry King breaks character and diverts attention from the scene just to talk about how much he (that is, Matt and Trey) hates the host of ''Whale Wars''. A previous episode had a scene that made fun of ''Ghost Hunters'' [[Overly Long Gag|by repeating the same joke over and over again, that did not contribute anything to the plot of the episode and was basically a throwaway gag for something like five whole minutes]]. In other words, [[South Park]]'s instances of author filibuster have not only become more jarring and (even) less subtle, have become increasingly-focused upon more minor topics (such as currently-popular TV shows or trends).
** This has become increasingly apparent in recent seasons. In a scene from "Whale Whores", the in-universe Larry King breaks character and diverts attention from the scene just to talk about how much he (that is, Matt and Trey) hates the host of ''Whale Wars''. A previous episode had a scene that made fun of ''Ghost Hunters'' [[Overly Long Gag|by repeating the same joke over and over again, that did not contribute anything to the plot of the episode and was basically a throwaway gag for something like five whole minutes]]. In other words, [[South Park]]'s instances of author filibuster have not only become more jarring and (even) less subtle, have become increasingly-focused upon more minor topics (such as currently-popular TV shows or trends).