Gideon Ploy

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.

"When I blow the trumpet, I and all who are with me, then blow the trumpets also on every side of all the camp and shout, 'For the LORD and for Gideon.'"

Strength in numbers can be good. Having a vast force at your disposal can be very intimidating to the opposition. It can make you seem like you have great control over the situation and plenty of backup if things get ugly.

But what do you do when you don't have a whole bunch of mooks on your employee roster? If it's just you and some friends or even a solo act?

Well that is where the Gideon Ploy comes in! Through clever acting, disguises, misdirection, decoys, and other such feats, you make the opposition think you have more in your ranks than you actually do.

Compare To Win Without Fighting.

Examples of Gideon Ploy include:

Literature

  • Silver Shadows (a Forgotten Realms novel by Elaine Cunningham) had a moment when Arilyn used shrieker essence to amplify footfalls of centaurs, so that but a handful running at each flank would sound like a big cavalry charge and demoralize a bunch of mercenaries her side fought and make them waste time, while most attackers advanced from a different direction and on foot.

Live-Action TV

  • The main characters of Burn Notice sometimes employ this tactic, especially when they need to fool someone into thinking that Team Westen is actually a large and far-reaching secret agency.

Mythology and Religion

  • Our Trope Namer, of course comes from the Boom of Judges in The Bible, where Gideon leads an army of only 300 Spartan Israelite warriors against the Midianites, who are described as having wall-to-wall camels. Gideon's night-time ambush and making his army seem far bigger than it was, aided by some holy PSYOP support from God, resulted in the Midianites slaughtering each other.

Real Life

  • The battalions of inflatable decoys in World War II served this purpose.
  • Georgy Zhukov in 1946 was about to be punished for his misdeeds (which included looting by entire trains, as well as aiding and abetting looting done by people close to him, including Serov from NKVD, ref>such growing fraternization between commanders of army and secret police in the eyes of Josef Stalin was, of course, a threat that could not be ignored, and was taken into account on a larger scale when NKVD/MGB was restructured and army mostly demobilized after the war</ref>), as well as failures. But the other commanders chided him a little, yet supported, because it was a matter of self-preservation: they remembered how The Purges of 1937-39 have started, and had to worry things may go that far again. This gave those not involved an impression that Zhukov had great support in army and allowed him to contend for power against Nikita Khrushchev. For a while.
    • The bluff was called in 1957, and the very same commanders took turns reciting all Zhukov's failures and denouncing him as an egotistic brute who got too high by being repeatedly Kicked Upstairs, wasted troops for nothing and ordered way too many death sentences. Which, of course, also was self-preservation: it's one thing to make an excessively sadistic commander someone else's problem, and entirely another to let him have more power over oneself. Also, this zigzag of attitudes had a rather ironic epilogue in his near-beatification by propaganda after Khrushchev was overthrown too.