Night Trap/YMMV

Complaining About Shows You Don't Watch: One of the biggest victims of this trope next to the CD-I system. It received a lot of enemies who had never even played the game (and even admitted to having never played it). They claimed that the game was about kidnapping and raping women, never mind that if a girl died, you got a game over because you were supposed to save the women. As for the scantily clad? The most scantily clad you get are nightgowns... which would be scantily clad to fundamentalist Muslim or Amish people and no one else.
Cult Classic: Its legacy as a legendarily bad FMV game with corny acting has given it a following that continues to the present day, to the point that it is being rereleased for modern platforms.
Narm: A lot of the dialogue, but the ending especially. This was actually invoked, too. The "Violence" in the game was deliberately designed to be so cartoonish and over-the-top that nobody would possibly think to try it in real life. The crew was even laughing on-stage at how ridiculous it was.
Nightmare Retardant: Invoked. And boy, did they succeed.
Overshadowed by Controversy: One of the games that contributed to the ESRB ratings; much like Complaining About Shows You Don't Watch above, one bathroom scene in particular led to intense Senate hearings in the United States, although the game specifically calls you out for failing to spare the woman.
Play the Game, Skip the Story: Odds are, you're too busy looking for Augers to actually care about the story. 25th Anniversary Edition fixes this problem by letting you unlock a mode that lets you watch the story details on their own.
So Bad It's Good - While the gameplay itself is lacking, the movie that plays out during it is pretty damn hilarious. (Sadly, you won't see most of it if you're going for a perfect score.) Click here to watch it. (Don't worry, it's completely work safe.)