Patton/YMMV: Difference between revisions
< Patton
Content added Content deleted
m (Dai-Guard moved page Patton (Film)/YMMV to Patton/YMMV: Remove TVT Namespaces from title) |
HLIAA14YOG (talk | contribs) (Expanding on YMMV trope to provide context.) |
||
| (2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 4: | Line 4: | ||
* [[Foe Yay]]: The German analyst Steiger has this toward Patton. He's the only one to genuinely sympathize with the son of a bitch. |
* [[Foe Yay]]: The German analyst Steiger has this toward Patton. He's the only one to genuinely sympathize with the son of a bitch. |
||
* [[Magnificent Bastard]]: [[Trope Namer]] in reference to his [[Worthy Opponent]], Erwin Rommel: |
* [[Magnificent Bastard]]: [[Trope Namer]] in reference to his [[Worthy Opponent]], Erwin Rommel: |
||
{{quote| |
{{quote|'''Patton:''' Rommel, you magnificent bastard, I read your BOOK!}} |
||
* [[Memetic Mutation]]: Patton's "You [[Magnificent Bastard]], I read your book!" spawned a new phrase which, among other things, named a trope. |
* [[Memetic Mutation]]: Patton's "You [[Magnificent Bastard]], I read your book!" spawned a new phrase which, among other things, named a trope. |
||
** The scene of Patton before a huge American flag giving the world's [[Rousing Speech|most famous pep talk]] has been homaged and parodied in other films. |
** The scene of Patton before a huge American flag giving the world's [[Rousing Speech|most famous pep talk]] has been homaged and parodied in other films. |
||
* [[Misaimed Fandom]]: The film was a favorite of [[Richard Nixon]]'s, who watched it shortly before ordering an [[The Vietnam War|invasion of Cambodia]]. |
* [[Misaimed Fandom]]: The film was a favorite of [[Richard Nixon]]'s, who watched it shortly before ordering an [[The Vietnam War|invasion of Cambodia]]. To put this into perspective for non-American audiences, Cambodia was not the enemy the USA wanted to defeat, and some historians blame this decision for America's defeat. In other words, it was like if Patton decided to attack Spain while on war with Germany. |
||
* [[Moral Event Horizon]]: Patton nearly sinks into [[Complete Monster]] territory during the Sicily campaign. Upset that Monty is trying to claim all the glory, Patton ignores orders and follows his own way to Palermo, leaving Bradley's Army to suffer heavy losses against dug-in German defenders. Enraged that a mule-cart is blocking a bridge he [[Shoot the Dog|shoots the mule]] in front of the horrified Sicilian farmer. And topping it all is when Patton discovers a victim of shell-shock at a field hospital and goes berserk, slapping the soldier. Patton wins Sicily but the slapping incident nearly destroys his career. |
|||
** Your mileage may indeed vary in many of these cases, as nearly all of them are justified (in at least Patton's mind). To Patton, the Germans in Palermo would have had to have been dealt with sooner or later, and his high-cost tactics averted heavier casualties later on. The mule on the bridge was holding up a column and exposing them to air attack; Patton had personally witnessed several American soldiers killed and wounded by strafing Germans just moments before. Only the last is truly an unprovoked [[Jerkass]] moment, as Patton famously disdained the concept of battle fatigue, and slapped the soldier out of pique. |
|||
** Patton returns to the [[Moral Event Horizon]] at the end of the movie, after the Nazis are finished and the war is over. Eager to keep fighting, Patton itches to take on the [[Dirty Communists|Russian Army]], telling his handler from Eisenhower's office [[False-Flag Operation|he can figure out a way to stage an incident and blame it on the Soviets]]. The second the handler hangs up the phone in disgust, Patton realizes [[What Have I Done|he's just killed his career]]. |
|||
*** Wanting to take down [[Joseph Stalin|the only tyrant left in Europe]] who was arguably ''[[Beyond the Impossible|worse]]'' than Hitler is crossing the line? There were a great many Balts, Poles, and other Eastern Europeans in [[Real Life]] who saw America andf the West's refusal to do so as the REAL [[Moral Event Horizon]]. |
|||
{{reflist}} |
{{reflist}} |
||
Latest revision as of 12:28, 24 February 2023
- Award Snub: Inverted; George C. Scott infamously snubbed his own Academy Award for this film, calling the competition between actors a "meat parade."
- Crowning Music of Awesome: BAHDUHDUH-DahDuhDuh-dahduhduh-dahduhduh...
- Foe Yay: The German analyst Steiger has this toward Patton. He's the only one to genuinely sympathize with the son of a bitch.
- Magnificent Bastard: Trope Namer in reference to his Worthy Opponent, Erwin Rommel:
 |
Patton: Rommel, you magnificent bastard, I read your BOOK! |
 |
- Memetic Mutation: Patton's "You Magnificent Bastard, I read your book!" spawned a new phrase which, among other things, named a trope.
- The scene of Patton before a huge American flag giving the world's most famous pep talk has been homaged and parodied in other films.
- Misaimed Fandom: The film was a favorite of Richard Nixon's, who watched it shortly before ordering an invasion of Cambodia. To put this into perspective for non-American audiences, Cambodia was not the enemy the USA wanted to defeat, and some historians blame this decision for America's defeat. In other words, it was like if Patton decided to attack Spain while on war with Germany.