Star Trek: Titan/YMMV: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 11: Line 11:
** One of the characters behaves towards one of the others in a way that's ''blatant'' sexual harassment... but seems brushed off due to [[Values Dissonance]]. This is happening ''during'' Riker bemoaning his race's barbarism, so apparently it's only wrong when white humans treat someone else like sexual meat.
** One of the characters behaves towards one of the others in a way that's ''blatant'' sexual harassment... but seems brushed off due to [[Values Dissonance]]. This is happening ''during'' Riker bemoaning his race's barbarism, so apparently it's only wrong when white humans treat someone else like sexual meat.
* [[The Woobie]]: Troi, Jaza, Vale, Tuvok, Riker, Keru, Ra-Havreii, Ree, screw it ''[[Dysfunction Junction|THE ENTIRE CREW]]''.
* [[The Woobie]]: Troi, Jaza, Vale, Tuvok, Riker, Keru, Ra-Havreii, Ree, screw it ''[[Dysfunction Junction|THE ENTIRE CREW]]''.
** The problem with this is that it effectively neuters them as protagonists in what is still theoretically an adventure series. It's [[Character Derailment|especially bad with Riker]], who goes from being the strong, confident man of action he was in the series to a mewling, cringing wimp who spends a lot of time brooding in his ready room.
* [[Wangst]]: And we're talking ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer|Buffy]]'' levels of it, here.
* [[Wangst]]: And we're talking ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer|Buffy]]'' levels of it, here.
** To expound: Everyone's either mourning a dead lover, trying to hook up with a new one and miserable because they're failing, Riker and Troi's marriage has distinctly unhappy (read ''absolutely miserable'') overtones, most of the crew's backstory is full of pain and angst and ostracism. It seems the series believes [[True Art Is Angsty]]... but it's so [[Anvilicious|unsubtle]] and [[Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy|all-consuming]] that it's [[Narm|impossible to take seriously]].
** To expound: Everyone's either mourning a dead lover, trying to hook up with a new one and miserable because they're failing, Riker and Troi's marriage has distinctly unhappy (read ''absolutely miserable'') overtones, most of the crew's backstory is full of pain and angst and ostracism. It seems the series believes [[True Art Is Angsty]]... but it's so [[Anvilicious|unsubtle]] and [[Darkness-Induced Audience Apathy|all-consuming]] that it's [[Narm|impossible to take seriously]].

Revision as of 18:49, 13 November 2014


"I always knew I'd be killed by nature!"

  • Crowning Moment of Heartwarming: The ending of Over a Torrent Sea.
    • Plus the end of Synthesis, when Second-Gen White-Blue returns, declaring his intention to join the team for good:

" I don't know what to say".
"Say yes"

  • Ensemble Darkhorse: Minor character Torvig Bu-kar-nguv has become rather popular, and his role in the series expanded significantly. The author who created him has expressed his pleasant surprise.
  • Unfortunate Implications: The novels can sometimes come off as an extended exercise in white guilt, extended to white male guilt, taken to an extreme with white male human guilt. Riker spends almost an entire chapter bemoaning that he comes from "a culture built on rape and conquest"... ignoring that this could describe practically every culture on Earth. Even assuming that's what he meant, as opposed to just white Americans, it ignores that most other Star Trek cultures have similarly warlike pasts, despite the airs they put on, and a lot of the rest of his current ship's crew have practices that are just as immoral to an outside observer as rape and conquest would be.
    • One of the characters behaves towards one of the others in a way that's blatant sexual harassment... but seems brushed off due to Values Dissonance. This is happening during Riker bemoaning his race's barbarism, so apparently it's only wrong when white humans treat someone else like sexual meat.
  • The Woobie: Troi, Jaza, Vale, Tuvok, Riker, Keru, Ra-Havreii, Ree, screw it THE ENTIRE CREW.
    • The problem with this is that it effectively neuters them as protagonists in what is still theoretically an adventure series. It's especially bad with Riker, who goes from being the strong, confident man of action he was in the series to a mewling, cringing wimp who spends a lot of time brooding in his ready room.
  • Wangst: And we're talking Buffy levels of it, here.
    • To expound: Everyone's either mourning a dead lover, trying to hook up with a new one and miserable because they're failing, Riker and Troi's marriage has distinctly unhappy (read absolutely miserable) overtones, most of the crew's backstory is full of pain and angst and ostracism. It seems the series believes True Art Is Angsty... but it's so unsubtle and all-consuming that it's impossible to take seriously.
  • White Man's Burden: Whether Riker is an actual example of it as the white human captain of an almost totally non-human/non-humanoid crew is debatable. The fact that he spends most of his time in the novels wringing his hands worrying that people will think this of him isn't.