Talk:Samurai Jack/YMMV

About this board

Not editable

Doc and Lulzkiller, plz hash out any contention over material like adults plz

6
GethN7 (talkcontribs)

I noticed a bit of revert warring over some edits, and while I don't want to wade into the fray unless I have to, I'd like to ask you two to discuss this whenever you have the time and come to an agreement.

And I want you both to remember this is just a disagreement over content on a crowdsourced wiki, not a life or death argument, so I think this can be hashed out without throwing daggers, be it metaphorical and especially literal

DocColress (talkcontribs)

I don't even mind the idea behind the edit I deleted, but a full writuep for Aku as a CM coming in ahead of the High Priestess and the Dominator, the actual approved examples of the trope, seems ridiculous as even for a YMMV candidate it's hard to ignore that Aku has no agency to be anything other than evil, whereas the High Priestess and Dominator are humans who chose their paths.

Derivative (talkcontribs)

I'm not versed into SJ myself, all I know is is that we're supposed to let people have disagreements on YMMV, indeed that is the whole point of the subpage.

DocColress (talkcontribs)

Well there are times where what gets put on YMMV bypass simple differing view points and interpretations that people might not agree on and become flat out inaccuracies. Aku is a character famous for stuff like reading a bunch of him-based folklore and fairy tales to children who end up annoying him yet he just leaves without harming them in the end. You can only make him seem like a full-fledged Complete Monster if you conveniently leave that stuff out of describing him, in addition to the fact that he has no capacity for not being and doing evil.

Derivative (talkcontribs)

You have to understand that you generally have control of CM, and it looks like yet another example of an IPv6 being autistic and removing something he disagreed with off the wiki for the 1000th time. I was under the impression that reverting someone's mass removal would be wanted (esp. by you) and that's why it stayed for 6 months b4 I got reverted without issue.

Please be a little more noticing next time around, I'm still not confident that it should be removed but CM is your domain.

DocColress (talkcontribs)

Again, I could allow Aku an entry in YMMV but it'd have to come after the entry that's currently there, and probably mention that he could be viewed as an example of the trope despite his nature and Laughably Evil qualities.

There are no older topics