Ad Hominem/Quotes: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (revise quote template spacing)
No edit summary
Line 2: Line 2:
{{quote|Let's also stipulate (this happens to be true) that Isaac Newton had bouts of "crazy" behavior later in life -- probably due to his incautious handling of mercury during his experiments.
{{quote|Let's also stipulate (this happens to be true) that Isaac Newton had bouts of "crazy" behavior later in life -- probably due to his incautious handling of mercury during his experiments.
If we thus conclude Isaac Newton was a "kook," does this make it safe to step off the balcony of a high-rise building, confident that Newton's characterization of the laws of gravity don't accurately predict our subsequent tumble to our deaths?
If we thus conclude Isaac Newton was a "kook," does this make it safe to step off the balcony of a high-rise building, confident that Newton's characterization of the laws of gravity don't accurately predict our subsequent tumble to our deaths?
No. The theory of gravity stands [[Pun|or falls]] based on how it explains observable phenomena in the real world, not on whether we approve of Isaac Newton's style of dress, whether he used the correct fork at dinner, or whether he occasionally crawled around on all fours chattering like a badger.|Vin Suprynowicz, ''[http://www.lvrj.com/opinion/tortoise-breeding-endangers-fish--wildlife-jobs-64690162.html Tortoise breeding endangers Fish & Wildlife jobs]''}}
No. The theory of gravity stands [[Pun|or falls]] based on how it explains observable phenomena in the real world, not on whether we approve of Isaac Newton's style of dress, whether he used the correct fork at dinner, or whether he occasionally crawled around on all fours chattering like a badger.
|Vin Suprynowicz, ''[http://www.lvrj.com/opinion/tortoise-breeding-endangers-fish--wildlife-jobs-64690162.html Tortoise breeding endangers Fish & Wildlife jobs]''}}


{{quote|'''Jerry:''' You '''do''' know I'm right!
{{quote|'''Jerry:''' You '''do''' know I'm right!
'''Tom:''' Why?
'''Tom:''' Why?
'''Jerry:''' You've resorted to abuse.
'''Jerry:''' You've resorted to abuse.
'''Tom:''' ...[[Lame Comeback|Shut]] [[I Resemble That Remark|up!]]|''[[The Good Life]]''}}
'''Tom:''' ...[[Lame Comeback|Shut]] [[I Resemble That Remark|up!]]
|''[[The Good Life]]''}}


{{quote|''"When you have no basis for an argument, abuse the plaintiff."''|'''Cicero''}}
{{quote|''"When you have no basis for an argument, abuse the plaintiff."''|'''Cicero''}}
Line 14: Line 16:


{{quote|''"Sure, he's an [[Jerkass|asshole]]. Sure he's dead. Sure, I'm just imagining that he's talking. That doesn't stop the bastard from being absolutely right."''|''Dwight, [[Sin City]]: The Big Fat Kill''}}
{{quote|''"Sure, he's an [[Jerkass|asshole]]. Sure he's dead. Sure, I'm just imagining that he's talking. That doesn't stop the bastard from being absolutely right."''|''Dwight, [[Sin City]]: The Big Fat Kill''}}

{{quote|''"When folks start throwing around terms like "[[Troll|trolls]]" and "harassers" they better back that shit up with some examples.
''What they're almost always talking about are people who don't agree with them."''
|'''Forbin''' on a 2016 [http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/2016-05-06-steams-turned-toxic-and-valve-doesnt-care GamesIndustry.biz article] criticizing [[Steam]]'s community, ''/v/[[Gamergate|GamerGate]] [https://voat.co/v/GamerGate/comments/1026449 thread]'' ([[Voat]])}}


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}

Revision as of 03:38, 13 May 2016


Let's also stipulate (this happens to be true) that Isaac Newton had bouts of "crazy" behavior later in life -- probably due to his incautious handling of mercury during his experiments.
If we thus conclude Isaac Newton was a "kook," does this make it safe to step off the balcony of a high-rise building, confident that Newton's characterization of the laws of gravity don't accurately predict our subsequent tumble to our deaths?
No. The theory of gravity stands or falls based on how it explains observable phenomena in the real world, not on whether we approve of Isaac Newton's style of dress, whether he used the correct fork at dinner, or whether he occasionally crawled around on all fours chattering like a badger.

Jerry: You do know I'm right!
Tom: Why?
Jerry: You've resorted to abuse.
Tom: ...Shut up!

"When you have no basis for an argument, abuse the plaintiff."
—'Cicero
"The thing I love about this is, on the internet, people make a big deal out of the distinction between calling someone names as a way of refuting their arguments, and calling someone names just as a kind of a hobby."
"Sure, he's an asshole. Sure he's dead. Sure, I'm just imagining that he's talking. That doesn't stop the bastard from being absolutely right."
Dwight, Sin City: The Big Fat Kill

"When folks start throwing around terms like "trolls" and "harassers" they better back that shit up with some examples.
What they're almost always talking about are people who don't agree with them."

Forbin on a 2016 GamesIndustry.biz article criticizing Steam's community, /v/GamerGate thread (Voat)