Smosh/YMMV

Adorkable: Ian has his moments.
Crowning Moment of Awesome: Defeating Ryan Higa with a dual X slash in Pokémon Theme Song Revenge.
Crowning Moment of Funny:
- "I'm the Teleporting, Teleporting, Teleporting Fat Guy!!!"
- One word: Stranded.

Day 17: "I found an apple in the sand, but it only lasted us a day. We knew that we would have to choose which one of us we would eat first. Robbie and I both chose Jamal, but he called us racist and threatened to eat himself. We told him that wasn't physically possible."
Day 18: "We were wrong. Jamal ate himself."

- Anytime Officer Anous shoots somebody and goes overboard with it.
- In their recent Pokemon parody, the Monkey/Mankey gag.
- This, from the epilogue of the "Anthony is Bald" videos, where Anthony and Ian sing about being best friends:

Guy: "GAAAAAY! Why don't you two fairies go get married already?! UNSUBSCRIBE!!" (gets beaten)

Ear Worm: Milky Milkshake!... Milky Milkshake...
- Cute, furry kittens!
- Charlie! Charlie! The Drunk Guinea Pig!!!
- Teleporting Teleporting Teleporting Fat Guy~!
- Legend of Zelda Rap, specially the chorus.
- "Going to the mountains! Going to the mountains!"
- Even before all of those, we had HARDCORE MAX.
Ensemble Darkhorse: Charlie, the drunk guinea pig, who later got his own weekly series.
Most Annoying Sound: When Smosh Pit Weekly started off with Mari as a hostess, each segment would cutaway with a very annoying "SMOSHU PIT-UH" voiceover. Thankfully, this has since been retired.
- This video, which has Pubertina crying and talking between sobs on an overly long 12 minute loop.
  - In the video above she's a wangst too considering the reception.
Nausea Fuel: A double whammy occurs when an actress pukes after Ian describes a Facebook post about somebody using a toilet which hasn't been flushed and ends up overflowing on him.
Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Mari got a lot of hate when she was first introduced as the new hostess of Smosh Pit Weekly, but after a few episodes passed, people warmed up a lot to her. (The fact that the show got rid of a few annoying elements may have helped as well.)
The Scrappy: "Pubertina" is this for the Shut Up Cartoons lineup, to the point where it's the only show in the lineup to have ratings disabled, due to the episodes being the only videos on any Smosh channel where the dislikes outnumber likes.
Squick: In "What if Holdays Were Real", Ian and Anthony finding out where Easter Eggs really come from.
- Also, the tampon song from episode #3 of Pubertina.
- Pubertina's reaction to seeing a picture of what is presumed to be a penis in episode #4.
  - People's reaction to Pubertina on the whole.
Unfortunate Implications: Pubertina's grossed out reaction to an apparently obscene picture she saw is reasonable enough, but then the cartoonist saw fit to extend the ending when she sneaks onto the PC to gawk at it again with lust in her eyes. Keep in mind that Pubertina just hit puberty.