Topic on User talk:Goo Monster

I see from your recent edits to your user page that you want to add a quote to the wiki...

5
Robkelk (talkcontribs)
Robkelk (talkcontribs)

While I'm at it...

"Zombify the Living is turning the living into undead without killing them first."

How can something be undead if it isn't dead first? We're not TV Tropes - we actually pay attention to the dictionary definitions of words.


"I wanted to add a quote to a sewer gator quote page."

Here you go, as mentioned above.


"I'm a Humanitarian is human eating human."

Not according to the trope as written: "In Speculative Fiction, cannibalism is generally extended to include all sapient or humanoid creatures, even if they aren't technically human."


"I think Meet My Good Friends "Lefty" and "Righty" is fine name (the trope might a case of stock phrases)."

Ah - that's different. If you can find at least three uses of the phrase, feel free to start a Trope Workshop page saying that this about a Stock Phrase.


"Lizard name Liz and Dog named Dog are similar but distinct (although a lumper would disagree)."

Not according to the trope as written: "Usually but not always applied to animals; robots imaginatively named Robot and the like are part of this trope, too."


"Maybe Has a Type should be a case of People Sit on Chairs, but it still has a trope page (I think it being a trope is fine))"

It does not have a trope page here. And everybody has "a type", which is why it's People Sit on Chairs - it's too common to trope.

Goo Monster (talkcontribs)

Zombify the Living is turning the living into undead without killing them first. In some settings it's possible. Vampires and Liches often work that way.

Meet My Good Friends "Lefty" and "Righty": That sounds like work. Especially since I don't want to use the same wording as Tv Tropes.

I'm a Humanitarian is human eating human: fair

Sewer Gator: The quote is already on the wiki somewhere. But I think it would fit better on a Sewer Gator quote page.

Robkelk (talkcontribs)

"That sounds like work." It is work. But nobody else is likely to do it for you.

Goo Monster (talkcontribs)

The issue with Lizard named Liz vs the Dog named Dog isn't about robot vs animal. It's about if a lizard would be named Liz, instead of being named lizard.