Exactly What I Meant to Say: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (revise quote template spacing)
(quote cleanup)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
{{quote|'''Dialogue coach''': [[Incredibly Lame Pun|Up and ATOM!]]<br />
{{quote|'''Dialogue coach''': [[Incredibly Lame Pun|Up and ATOM!]]
'''Rainer Wolfcastle''': [[Completely Missing the Point|Up and AT THEM!]]|[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3ZoHhvQgjU&feature=related This scene] from ''[[The Simpsons (animation)|The Simpsons]]''}}
'''Rainer Wolfcastle''': [[Completely Missing the Point|Up and AT THEM!]]|[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w3ZoHhvQgjU&feature=related This scene] from ''[[The Simpsons (animation)|The Simpsons]]''}}


Line 20: Line 20:
* Mr. Rumbold from ''[[Are You Being Served?|Are You Being Served]]'' would sometimes get the wrong idea of a word. For example the sales staff had the verb "to knee" meaning "press one's knee in the armhole of a suit to loosen a few threads so as to make it fit the customer better." Thus creating this exchange:
* Mr. Rumbold from ''[[Are You Being Served?|Are You Being Served]]'' would sometimes get the wrong idea of a word. For example the sales staff had the verb "to knee" meaning "press one's knee in the armhole of a suit to loosen a few threads so as to make it fit the customer better." Thus creating this exchange:
{{quote|'''Mr. Lucas:''' You see, it was like this, you see, Sir. Erm, Mr. Humphries kneed the jacket.
{{quote|'''Mr. Lucas:''' You see, it was like this, you see, Sir. Erm, Mr. Humphries kneed the jacket.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Ah! You mean, Mr. Humphries '''needed''' the jacket. [[Grammar Nazi|Let's get our tenses right]].<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Ah! You mean, Mr. Humphries '''needed''' the jacket. [[Grammar Nazi|Let's get our tenses right]].
'''Mr. Humphries:''' No, no, you don't understand, Sir. You see, I kneed the jacket.<br />
'''Mr. Humphries:''' No, no, you don't understand, Sir. You see, I kneed the jacket.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' You need it now?<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' You need it now?
'''Mr. Humphries:''' No, I kneed it then.<br />
'''Mr. Humphries:''' No, I kneed it then.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' You mean, you needed it then.<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' You mean, you needed it then.
'''Captain Peacock:''' If I might clarify the situation, Sir.<br />
'''Captain Peacock:''' If I might clarify the situation, Sir.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Thank you, Captain Peacock. It does seem to have got rather out of hand.<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Thank you, Captain Peacock. It does seem to have got rather out of hand.
'''Captain Peacock:''' Yes. It's a matter of spelling, Sir.<br />
'''Captain Peacock:''' Yes. It's a matter of spelling, Sir.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Spelling?<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Spelling?
'''Captain Peacock:''' Yes Sir. You spelled kneed with an N. Mr. Humphries was using a K.<br />
'''Captain Peacock:''' Yes Sir. You spelled kneed with an N. Mr. Humphries was using a K.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Oh, you mean like kneading dough? Is that it, Mr. Lucas?<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' Oh, you mean like kneading dough? Is that it, Mr. Lucas?
'''Mr. Lucas:''' [[Deadpan Snarker|Yes, that's it]]. I needed the dough, but he didn't want the jacket because it was too tight.<br />
'''Mr. Lucas:''' [[Deadpan Snarker|Yes, that's it]]. I needed the dough, but he didn't want the jacket because it was too tight.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' So you kneaded it to make it more supple, which was why you needed the jacket, you may recall Captain Peacock. That is what I said in the first place.<br />
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' So you kneaded it to make it more supple, which was why you needed the jacket, you may recall Captain Peacock. That is what I said in the first place.
'''Captain Peacock:''' Nearly right, Sir, yes. But what they're trying to explain, Sir, is that, erm... and coming from Hardware, you would not be aware of this, but there is a method used, and I disapprove of it myself, Sir. There is a method used to enlarge the arm holes of jackets, and the method used is to knee the jacket... with a K.<br />
'''Captain Peacock:''' Nearly right, Sir, yes. But what they're trying to explain, Sir, is that, erm... and coming from Hardware, you would not be aware of this, but there is a method used, and I disapprove of it myself, Sir. There is a method used to enlarge the arm holes of jackets, and the method used is to knee the jacket... with a K.
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' [[Completely Missing the Point|I am aware of how you spell jacket]], Captain Peacock. }}
'''Mr. Rumbold:''' [[Completely Missing the Point|I am aware of how you spell jacket]], Captain Peacock. }}
* There is a ''[[Monty Python's Flying Circus]]'' sketch invoving a man who cannot pronounce the letter 'C' (his 'C's coming out as 'B's) that includes this exchange:
* There is a ''[[Monty Python's Flying Circus]]'' sketch invoving a man who cannot pronounce the letter 'C' (his 'C's coming out as 'B's) that includes this exchange:
Line 49: Line 49:
{{quote|Norm: Cliffy had himself the "Ton O' T-Bone". For less than four bucks you get 24 ounces of USDA Choice bef.
{{quote|Norm: Cliffy had himself the "Ton O' T-Bone". For less than four bucks you get 24 ounces of USDA Choice bef.
Cliff: Bef? No, you mean beef.
Cliff: Bef? No, you mean beef.
Norm: Beef? Don't be ridiculous, Cliffy. That stuff is bef. You see it's a Hungry Heifer trademark for [[Lite Creme|a processed, synthetic, meat-like substance]].<br />
Norm: Beef? Don't be ridiculous, Cliffy. That stuff is bef. You see it's a Hungry Heifer trademark for [[Lite Creme|a processed, synthetic, meat-like substance]].
Cliff: Ah, no.<br />
Cliff: Ah, no.
Norm: What do you expect for four bucks? You see me complainin' about the loobster? }}
Norm: What do you expect for four bucks? You see me complainin' about the loobster? }}
* In ''[[Green Acres]]'' ("It's Human to Be Humane"), [[Cloudcuckoolander|Lisa]] asks Oliver to play "Scribble, Cabbage, or Monotony", and he assumes it's one of her [[Malapropisms]]. Later, Mr. Drucker [[Strange Minds Think Alike|tries to sell him those same games]], which apparently do exist in [[Cloudcuckooland|Hooterville]].
* In ''[[Green Acres]]'' ("It's Human to Be Humane"), [[Cloudcuckoolander|Lisa]] asks Oliver to play "Scribble, Cabbage, or Monotony", and he assumes it's one of her [[Malapropisms]]. Later, Mr. Drucker [[Strange Minds Think Alike|tries to sell him those same games]], which apparently do exist in [[Cloudcuckooland|Hooterville]].
Line 60: Line 60:
== Web Comics ==
== Web Comics ==
* [http://xkcd.com/496/ This] issue of ''[[Xkcd]]'' comics, when someone "pleads the third."
* [http://xkcd.com/496/ This] issue of ''[[Xkcd]]'' comics, when someone "pleads the third."
{{quote|'''Interrogator:''' You mean [[Stock Legal Phrases|the fifth]]?<br />
{{quote|'''Interrogator:''' You mean [[Stock Legal Phrases|the fifth]]?
'''[[Cloudcuckoolander|Black Hat Guy]]:''' No, the third.<br />
'''[[Cloudcuckoolander|Black Hat Guy]]:''' No, the third.
'''Interrogator:''' You refuse to quarter troops in your house? }}
'''Interrogator:''' You refuse to quarter troops in your house? }}
* In ''[[The Order of the Stick|Order of the Stick]]'', during Roy's duel with Thog in the arena:
* In ''[[The Order of the Stick|Order of the Stick]]'', during Roy's duel with Thog in the arena:

Revision as of 15:22, 15 October 2015

Dialogue coach: Up and ATOM!
Rainer Wolfcastle: Up and AT THEM!

The verbal equivalent of Exactly What I Aimed At, this is when a character deliberately says one thing, and is mistaken for having meant to say another thing. Cue another character wrongfully "correcting" them.

A sub-variety of this is things that are mistaken for misspellings or mispronounciations, but these aren't the only cases.

Examples of Exactly What I Meant to Say include:


Comic Books

  • In Batman: Legends Of The Dark Knight #128 (collected in The Ring, the Arrow and the Bat), the Goo-Goo Godlike religious leader of a Fictional Country tells a treacherous general that he will be "safed". The general corrects his pronounciation of "saved", but the boy insists that's what he meant. Five minutes later, the general is hit by a falling safe.


Literature

  • In the novel Freaky Friday, Annabel's friend Boris has problems breathing through his nose, and when he offers to "bake a beetloaf" for dinner, she assumes he means "make a meatloaf". He doesn't. (Also, his name is actually Morris, but that's a case of Annabel failing to correct for his pronunciation.)


Live Action TV

  • Mr. Rumbold from Are You Being Served would sometimes get the wrong idea of a word. For example the sales staff had the verb "to knee" meaning "press one's knee in the armhole of a suit to loosen a few threads so as to make it fit the customer better." Thus creating this exchange:

Mr. Lucas: You see, it was like this, you see, Sir. Erm, Mr. Humphries kneed the jacket.
Mr. Rumbold: Ah! You mean, Mr. Humphries needed the jacket. Let's get our tenses right.
Mr. Humphries: No, no, you don't understand, Sir. You see, I kneed the jacket.
Mr. Rumbold: You need it now?
Mr. Humphries: No, I kneed it then.
Mr. Rumbold: You mean, you needed it then.
Captain Peacock: If I might clarify the situation, Sir.
Mr. Rumbold: Thank you, Captain Peacock. It does seem to have got rather out of hand.
Captain Peacock: Yes. It's a matter of spelling, Sir.
Mr. Rumbold: Spelling?
Captain Peacock: Yes Sir. You spelled kneed with an N. Mr. Humphries was using a K.
Mr. Rumbold: Oh, you mean like kneading dough? Is that it, Mr. Lucas?
Mr. Lucas: Yes, that's it. I needed the dough, but he didn't want the jacket because it was too tight.
Mr. Rumbold: So you kneaded it to make it more supple, which was why you needed the jacket, you may recall Captain Peacock. That is what I said in the first place.
Captain Peacock: Nearly right, Sir, yes. But what they're trying to explain, Sir, is that, erm... and coming from Hardware, you would not be aware of this, but there is a method used, and I disapprove of it myself, Sir. There is a method used to enlarge the arm holes of jackets, and the method used is to knee the jacket... with a K.
Mr. Rumbold: I am aware of how you spell jacket, Captain Peacock.

  • There is a Monty Python's Flying Circus sketch invoving a man who cannot pronounce the letter 'C' (his 'C's coming out as 'B's) that includes this exchange:

Tourist: Yes I'm sorry I can't say the letter 'B'
Bounder: C?
Tourist: Yes that's right. It's all due to a trauma I suffered when I was a spoolboy. I was attacked by a bat.
Bounder: A cat?
Tourist: No, a bat.

    • Another Monty Python example is a sketch about a person who sometimes ends his sentences with the wrong fusebox.

Burrows: It's so embarrassing when my wife and I go to an orgy.
Thripshaw: A party?
Burrows: No, an orgy. We live in Esher.
Thripshaw: Quite.

Norm: Cliffy had himself the "Ton O' T-Bone". For less than four bucks you get 24 ounces of USDA Choice bef.
Cliff: Bef? No, you mean beef.
Norm: Beef? Don't be ridiculous, Cliffy. That stuff is bef. You see it's a Hungry Heifer trademark for a processed, synthetic, meat-like substance.
Cliff: Ah, no.
Norm: What do you expect for four bucks? You see me complainin' about the loobster?


Video Games

  • When you talk about the "magick" in the game Eternal Darkness people who aren't familiar with it will often attempt to correct you, or edit you.

Web Comics

  • This issue of Xkcd comics, when someone "pleads the third."

Interrogator: You mean the fifth?
Black Hat Guy: No, the third.
Interrogator: You refuse to quarter troops in your house?

Roy: I don't care how strong you are, thug.
Thog: thog's name is thog.
Roy: I didn't misspeak.


Western Animation

  • Another Simpsons one:

Bart: I'd be happy to do this one pro-boner.
Skinner: You mean, "pro bono".
Bart: I know what I said.

    • Another yet:

Homer: Nucular. It's pronounced nucular.

Colonel K: Danger Mouse! Wales is being devastated by a giant fire-breathing dragon!
Penfold: No, no, Colonel, it's "whales are being devastated."


Real Life

  • Real life: Tell someone that an anime was macekered and sometimes they'll say, "Don't you mean massacred?"
  • Stage critic George Jean Nathan belittled Tallulah Bankhead for her playing in what he called Queen of the Nil: "no e, please, Mr. Printer; don't make something out of nothing."