Little House on the Prairie/YMMV

These things about Little House on the Prairie are subjective - not everyone will agree with all of them.

TV Series

Adaptation Displacement (Little House on the Prairie is the catchall name for the franchise these days, despite it being only one of many books with different titles.)
- The pilot for the series was a more-or-less straightforward adaptation of the book Little House on the Prairie. The series itself began with the setting and stories of On the Banks of Plum Creek.
Foe Yay (Laura and Nellie, whose rivalry defined much of their youth. In a later ep, when mellowed, married Nellie visits (and deals with her clone Nancy, see below), Nellie jokes with Laura about getting into a fistfight.)
- In a musical version, Nellie sings mournfully about her life 'Without An Enemy' once Laura leaves to teach.
Nightmare Fuel: For a show supposedly purporting wholesome family values, this one had a lot of it. Dead children and babies, fires, rapists, gunfire, drug addiction and withdrawl, disease...they spared the audience nothing about the harshness of life back then.
Narm
Narm Charm (To many modern viewers, one of the only reasons to watch. The other being Michael Landon's perm.)
The Scrappy: Albert. There's a reason he was listed as the reason the show Jumped the Shark in the official "Jump the Shark" book.
Tear Jerker (Ooh boy howdy yeah. The moment when Mary's vision goes completely is probably the nadir, though. Her father holding her as she wails inconsolably at the moment they'd been dreading all this time...)
Values Dissonance: The Aesop veers back and forth between modern values and prairie values being heralded as superior.
The Woobie: Mary. And Sylvia.

Book series

Harsher in Hindsight: The end of These Happy Golden Years can become this, after reading The First Four Years. The Wilders are initially quite optimistic about their future, but the first years of their marriage turn out to be one almost-unmitigated disaster. Drought causes their crops to continually fail, they both come down with diphtheria (which gives Almanzo a stroke, leaving him dependent on a cane for the rest of his life), their infant son dies, and then their house burns down and they subsequently lose both claims. If it weren't based on real events, it would be a complete Shoot the Shaggy Dog story.
Hollywood Homely: Laura's rather critical of and dissatisfied with her own appearance; she envies Nellie Oleson her blonde hair and tall, willowy figure, as she herself is quite short and brunette. In reality, she was a very pretty girl.
Ho Yay: Almanzo and Cap, for some.
Narm: In-universe example. Miss Wilder's little speeches to her students have Laura and the rest reacting this way.
Purity Stu: Almanzo's father James Wilder. When not being shown, we are repeatedly and explicitly told in Farmer Boy that he is the best farmer and the smartest, shrewdest, most important and respected man in his community, not to say a kind, fair, understanding, all-round great dad. Mitigated somewhat in that the story is told from the POV of his hero-worshipping small son, presumably also as filtered through the much older Almanzo's nostalgic memories.
Tear Jerker: The death of Laura's son, especially so close after her and Almanzo's diphtheria, which was followed by Almanzo having a stroke. Modern medical theory is that the baby was conceived too soon after the diphtheria and died as a result.
- Comes up again in the The Rose Years, when the Wilders attend the funeral of their hired man's infant son. Both Almanzo and Laura are wracked with grief, Laura admitting that what struck the the hardest was hearing the preacher read the baby's name--the Wilders' son died before they gave him one.
- The end of Little House on the Prairie, when Charles Ingalls muses on "how much fun the rabbits will have eating the garden" which they planted but have been forced to leave behind, along with their house and at least a years' work on their homestead.
- The death of Jack the bulldog.
Values Dissonance: Laura's youth at the beginning of her and Almanzo's courtship wasn't at all unusual in the 1880's (she was 15 and he 25, which would garner a visit from Chris Hansen in today's world, but back then many, many women were married before the age of 20; if you were still single at 25 odds are people called you a spinster). Fridge Logic can hit that with a potential case of Surprise Creepy, though, when you consider he first met her when she was thirteen, and wonder just how much of a conscious Jailbait Wait went on there. Laura failed her spot check when he first started courting her, but Ma definitely wasn't happy about it, precisely because Laura was only fifteen. Fortunately for Almanzo, Pa didn't seem to have any problem with it, but read from an adult 21st century perspective (especially a parental perspective), it can seem unintentionally creepy.
- The blackface minstrel show -- complete with jaunty assurance that "These darkies can't be beat!" -- in Little Town on the Prairie, in which Pa takes part. Not precisely intentional; while the real Laura's experience with actual people of colour was severely limited, it seems to have been amicable. Back in that era, one didn't need to be overtly racist to find that kind of thing hilarious. The Unfortunate Implications and Dude, Not Funny didn't show up until several decades after the books were written.
- On a lighter note, the parenting styles on display in both the Ingalls and Wilder families, with their extreme emphasis on self-discipline and frequent reference to whippings, are liable to strike modern readers as serious overkill. Laura is reminded constantly that adults -- 'ladies' especially -- do not allow their emotions to show in public. And when little Almanzo gets too close to a hole during ice-cutting and nearly drowns, he is told immediately post-rescue that he deserves severe punishment for his carelessness, though the punishment does not follow. Pa also whips a 5-year-old Laura as punishment.
  - See particularly both Ma and Pa's response to Laura's kerfuffle with Eliza Jane Wilder during Miss Wilder's stint as Laura's schoolteacher in Little Town on the Prairie. Miss Wilder's treatment of Laura, and especially her harassment of Laura's little sister Carrie, is unprofessional, patently unfair, and in Carrie's case borderline abusive; nevertheless, both parents chastise Laura for acting out in protest, and Ma tells Laura point-blank that she should never criticize her teacher.
- See also the Wilder parents' horror when Royal decides he's sick of the whole 'get up at 5am and work until sundown' gig and wants to become a storekeeper, instead of a 'free and independent' farmer.
- The eponymous Little House on the Prairie was built in the middle of Injun Country: Pa basically found a spot he liked and started building his house. The Native Americans whose land this was are less than pleased, and feel they have a right to come in and take anything they want. This is shown as being a terrible thing to have happened -- not wholly unreasonably at the time, since the Ingalls have put a lot of work into their claim but in modern hindsight, that Pa is squatting on their land is a lot more evocative.
- Pa's obsession with moving in general. At the beginning of Little House on the Prairie, the reason given for the move from the Big Woods is that it's gotten too crowded -- the definition of "too crowded" being that the Ingallses sometimes, without trying, encounter people they are not related to. After multiple moves and much traveling, Pa's attitude doesn't change, and Laura clearly demonstrates that it's hereditary. The only thing keeping them in place once they hit De Smet is that Charles long ago promised Caroline that he'd ensure their kids got a proper education.

Back to Little House on the Prairie