Complete Monster: Played with for laughs, but Johnny thinks Elliot is a sociopath after the Heavy Rain Let's Play, ranging from Elliot ditching Lauren in the car, to picking the saw to remove Ethan's finger.
From the Sonic CD review, he makes fun of Sonic's notorious Broken Base: "SONIC HAS GRAY EYES?! RUINEDFOREVER!!
One town mission in Sonic '06 has Silver save a girl named Roberta from exploding red barrels. When the mission ends, Roberta still dies due to the explosion, abruptly ending the mission with no rank. Johnny laments this for a few seconds, then resumes playing.
Matt enters the bubble right at the end of World 8-1 in New Super Mario Bros. Wii, abruptly sending everyone back to the checkpoint. Johnny and Elliot absolutely explode with fury and disbelief.
Johnny shows off one of Sonic's ways to go to the "moon" (going off the map) by using a Gem to continuously levitate a box to the point where the sky graphics end. On the way back down, Sonic's fall is interrupted at the end with a loud SPLAT.
Ending Fatigue: The Back to the Future: The Game LP, where the last few parts contain noticeably worse and more irritated commentary, especially on the part of Johnny, in addition to the already anti-climactic ending of the game.
Fan Dumb: Wars and debates get so bad, Johnny sometimes has to block comments on his review channel.
Back when Matt first officially joined the LP channel, there were some people who did not want this to happen, as to them "it was not the Super Gaming Bros with Matt involved".