Well-Intentioned Extremist: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
VisualWikitext
m (categories and general cleanup)
(replaced subpage list with "examples on subpages" template)
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
{{quote|"''The road to hell is paved with good intentions.''"|'''Bernard of Clairvaux'''}}
{{quote|"''The road to hell is paved with good intentions.''"
|'''Bernard of Clairvaux'''}}


{{quote|"''Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim.''"|'''George Santayana'''}}
{{quote|"''Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim.''"
|'''George Santayana'''}}


[[Visionary Villain|A villain who has an overall goal]] which the heroes [[Evil Virtues|can appreciate in principle]], but whose methods of pursuing said goal (such as mass murder) are [[Don't Shoot the Message|problematic]]; despite any sympathy they may have with his cause, the heroes have no choice but to stop him. Taken to extremes, he may fully believe that [[Utopia Justifies the Means]]. Such an idealistic extremist is likely to be either a [[Totalitarian Utilitarian]] or a [[Principles Zealot]], depending on whether he's aiming [[For Happiness]] or [[For Great Justice]]. The most well-written examples of this trope are the kind that the reader/viewer stops just short of agreeing with.
The '''Well-Intentioned Extremist is''' [[Visionary Villain|a type of villain with an overall goal]] which the heroes [[Evil Virtues|can appreciate in principle]], but whose methods of pursuing said goal (such as mass murder) are [[Don't Shoot the Message|problematic to say the least]]; despite any sympathy they may have with their cause, the heroes have no choice but to stop them. Taken to extremes, hethey may fully believe that [[Utopia Justifies the Means]]. Such an idealistic extremist is likely to be either a [[Totalitarian Utilitarian]] or a [[Principles Zealot]], depending on whether he's aiming [[For Happiness]] or [[For Great Justice]]. The most well-written examples of this trope are the kind that the reader or viewer stops just short of agreeing with.


Other times, the villain may be out for simple [[Revenge]] against a person or corporation or other entity that has undeniably wronged him. Again, the heroes may sympathize with his plight, but are obliged to stop him because he cares not who gets in the way of his planned revenge. However, the heroes will often investigate the villain's grievance themselves and will complement stopping the villain with taking down the offending party as well.
Other times, the villain may be out for simple [[Revenge]] against a person or corporation or other entity that has undeniably wronged them. Again, the heroes may sympathize with their plight, but are obliged to stop him because he cares not who gets in the way of their planned revenge. However, the heroes will often investigate the villain's grievance themselves and will complement stopping the villain with taking down the offending party as well.


Either way, it's a common end result of [[Jumping Off the Slippery Slope]]. Their favorite phrase is [[I Did What I Had to Do]] -- unless they are also the [[Tautological Templar]] and believe that what they do is good because a good person like them does only good things. They are not afraid to [[My Death Is Just the Beginning|sacrifice themselves for the cause]].
Either way, it's a common end result of [[Jumping Off the Slippery Slope]]. Their favorite phrase is [[I Did What I Had to Do]]—unless they are also the [[Tautological Templar]] and believe that what they do is good because a good person like them does only good things. They are not afraid to [[My Death Is Just the Beginning|sacrifice themselves for the cause]].

In many ways, this can be among the worst of villains, as unlike the [[Knight Templar]] or [[He Who Fights Monsters]], the Well-Intentioned Extremist ''knows'' their actions are evil, but is willing to do so for a cause he feels is right.


Often a [[Tragic Hero]] that became an [[Anti-Villain]], and sometimes a [[Worthy Opponent]] or even [[Reluctant Warrior]]. The extreme of this is the [[Knight Templar]] who [[Visionary Villain|fully believes that they are in the right]] and the best way to save the world is to [[The Evils of Free Will|remove free will]]. [[Vigilante Man]] is a case where the Well-Intentioned Extremist [[Motive Decay|hasn't (yet) descended]] to the point of not caring who gets hurt. Often ends up in rivalries with the [[Knight in Sour Armor]]. Some of those seeking to bring about a [[One World Order]] to end international strife may count as this.
Often a [[Tragic Hero]] that became an [[Anti-Villain]], and sometimes a [[Worthy Opponent]] or even [[Reluctant Warrior]]. The extreme of this is the [[Knight Templar]] who [[Visionary Villain|fully believes that they are in the right]] and the best way to save the world is to [[The Evils of Free Will|remove free will]]. [[Vigilante Man]] is a case where the Well-Intentioned Extremist [[Motive Decay|hasn't (yet) descended]] to the point of not caring who gets hurt. Often ends up in rivalries with the [[Knight in Sour Armor]]. Some of those seeking to bring about a [[One World Order]] to end international strife may count as this.


Contrast with [[Necessarily Evil]], where the villain in question has a [[Heel Realization]] and recognizes that he deserves punishment (of course, he may always choose to just [[Ignored Epiphany|Ignore That Epiphany]]). Often [[The Unfettered]]. See also [[A Lighter Shade of Grey]]. A staple trope of the [[Master Computer]] gone mad. If the positive intention is overthrowing an evil government, the Well Intentioned Extremists will be an example of [[The Revolution Will Not Be Civilized]]. If his extremism actually ''succeeds'' in making the world a better place, it's [[The Extremist Was Right]].
Contrast with [[Necessarily Evil]], where the villain in question has a [[Heel Realization]] and recognizes that he deserves punishment (of course, he may always choose to just [[Ignored Epiphany|Ignore That Epiphany]]). Often [[The Unfettered]]. See also [[A Lighter Shade of Grey]]. A staple trope of the [[Master Computer]] gone mad. If the positive intention is overthrowing an evil government, the Well-Intentioned Extremists will be an example of [[The Revolution Will Not Be Civilized]]. If their extremism actually ''succeeds'' in making the world a better place, it's [[The Extremist Was Right]].


As this trope often goes hand-in-hand with the [[Face Heel Turn]], expect spoilers.
As this trope often goes hand-in-hand with the [[Face Heel Turn]], expect spoilers.


{{noreallife|calling real-life people "villains" [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|is a bad idea.]]}}
<!-- %% '''NoRealLifeExamplesPlease''' -->
{{examples}}


{{Examples on subpages}}
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Anime and Manga|Anime and Manga]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Comic Books|Comic Books]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Fanfic|Fanfic]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Film|Film]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Literature|Literature]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Live Action TV|Live Action TV]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Machinima|Machinima]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Music|Music]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Tabletop Games|Tabletop Games]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Theatre|Theatre]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Toys|Toys]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Video Games|Video Games]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Visual Novels|Visual Novels]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Web Animation|Web Animation]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Web Comics|Web Comics]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Web Original|Web Original]]
* [[Well-Intentioned Extremist/Western Animation|Western Animation]]


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:No Real Life Examples Please]]
[[Category:Knight in Shining Tropes]]
[[Category:Knight in Shining Tropes]]
[[Category:Romanticism Versus Enlightenment]]
[[Category:Romanticism Versus Enlightenment]]
Line 49: Line 35:
[[Category:Truth in Television]]
[[Category:Truth in Television]]
[[Category:Villains]]
[[Category:Villains]]
[[Category:index]]
[[Category:Index]]
[[Category:Well-Intentioned Extremist]]
[[Category:No Real Life Examples, Please]]
[[Category:Pages with comment tags]]
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]

Latest revision as of 02:47, 12 March 2021

"The road to hell is paved with good intentions."

—Bernard of Clairvaux

"Fanaticism consists in redoubling your effort when you have forgotten your aim."

—George Santayana

The Well-Intentioned Extremist is a type of villain with an overall goal which the heroes can appreciate in principle, but whose methods of pursuing said goal (such as mass murder) are problematic to say the least; despite any sympathy they may have with their cause, the heroes have no choice but to stop them. Taken to extremes, hethey may fully believe that Utopia Justifies the Means. Such an idealistic extremist is likely to be either a Totalitarian Utilitarian or a Principles Zealot, depending on whether he's aiming For Happiness or For Great Justice. The most well-written examples of this trope are the kind that the reader or viewer stops just short of agreeing with.

Other times, the villain may be out for simple Revenge against a person or corporation or other entity that has undeniably wronged them. Again, the heroes may sympathize with their plight, but are obliged to stop him because he cares not who gets in the way of their planned revenge. However, the heroes will often investigate the villain's grievance themselves and will complement stopping the villain with taking down the offending party as well.

Either way, it's a common end result of Jumping Off the Slippery Slope. Their favorite phrase is I Did What I Had to Do—unless they are also the Tautological Templar and believe that what they do is good because a good person like them does only good things. They are not afraid to sacrifice themselves for the cause.

In many ways, this can be among the worst of villains, as unlike the Knight Templar or He Who Fights Monsters, the Well-Intentioned Extremist knows their actions are evil, but is willing to do so for a cause he feels is right.

Often a Tragic Hero that became an Anti-Villain, and sometimes a Worthy Opponent or even Reluctant Warrior. The extreme of this is the Knight Templar who fully believes that they are in the right and the best way to save the world is to remove free will. Vigilante Man is a case where the Well-Intentioned Extremist hasn't (yet) descended to the point of not caring who gets hurt. Often ends up in rivalries with the Knight in Sour Armor. Some of those seeking to bring about a One World Order to end international strife may count as this.

Contrast with Necessarily Evil, where the villain in question has a Heel Realization and recognizes that he deserves punishment (of course, he may always choose to just Ignore That Epiphany). Often The Unfettered. See also A Lighter Shade of Grey. A staple trope of the Master Computer gone mad. If the positive intention is overthrowing an evil government, the Well-Intentioned Extremists will be an example of The Revolution Will Not Be Civilized. If their extremism actually succeeds in making the world a better place, it's The Extremist Was Right.

As this trope often goes hand-in-hand with the Face Heel Turn, expect spoilers.

No real life examples, please; calling real-life people "villains" is a bad idea.

Examples of Well-Intentioned Extremist are listed on these subpages:
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Well-Intentioned_Extremist?oldid=1872920"