Pietà Plagiarism: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
VisualWikitext
prefix>Import Bot
(Import from TV Tropes TVT:Main.PietaPlagiarism 2012-07-01, editor history TVTH:Main.PietaPlagiarism, CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported license)
 
(replaced TVT image with the Commons image it was cropped from)
 
(24 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope|wppage=Pietà}}
[[File:pieta.jpg|frame|Accept no substitutes.]]
[[File:Michelangelo's Pieta 5450.jpg|thumb|400px|Accept no substitutes.]]



Michelangelo's sculpture depicting Mary holding the body of the crucified Christ is the best-known example of one of the [[Stock Poses|most popular poses in art]]. There is a whole class of artwork, referred to as "pietàs", that depict Mary (usually seated) holding the dead Jesus, going back to at least the early 14th century. It includes two other pieces by Michelangelo himself - one in the Cathedral Museum in [[Florence]] and known as the Deposition or Florentine Pietà, the other one one in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan and known as the Rondanini Pieta, as well as a third work in the Academia in Florence not generally attributed to Michelangelo today.
Michelangelo's sculpture depicting Mary holding the body of the crucified Christ is the best-known example of one of the [[Stock Poses|most popular poses in art]]. There is a whole class of artwork, referred to as "pietàs", that depict Mary (usually seated) holding the dead Jesus, going back to at least the early 14th century. It includes two other pieces by Michelangelo himself - one in the Cathedral Museum in [[Florence]] and known as the Deposition or Florentine Pietà, the other one one in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan and known as the Rondanini Pieta, as well as a third work in the Academia in Florence not generally attributed to Michelangelo today.
Line 7: Line 6:
This specific pose is often used either following a [[Heroic Sacrifice]] or on a comic book cover, in which case it will likely be accompanied by a [[Tonight Someone Dies]]. It's frequently [[Gender Flip|gender-flipped]] (i.e. the man holding a dead/dying/comatose woman), perhaps because the latter is more dramatic in modern media.
This specific pose is often used either following a [[Heroic Sacrifice]] or on a comic book cover, in which case it will likely be accompanied by a [[Tonight Someone Dies]]. It's frequently [[Gender Flip|gender-flipped]] (i.e. the man holding a dead/dying/comatose woman), perhaps because the latter is more dramatic in modern media.


A subtrope of [[Faux Symbolism]]. May be mixed with [[Touch of the Monster]]. [[Super Trope]] to [[Cradling Your Kill]] and [[Died in Your Arms Tonight]]. See also [[Background Halo]] for related subliminal symbolism. Compare [[Last Supper Steal]] and [[Crucified Hero Shot]] for other examples of frequently homaged Christ-iconography.
A subtrope of [[Faux Symbolism]]. May be mixed with [[Touch of the Monster]]. [[Super-Trope]] to [[Cradling Your Kill]] and [[Died in Your Arms Tonight]]. See also [[Background Halo]] for related subliminal symbolism. Compare [[Last Supper Steal]] and [[Crucified Hero Shot]] for other examples of frequently homaged Christ-iconography.
{{examples|Examples:}}

== Advertising ==
* Kookai used it ([http://www.advertnews.com/pix/kookai_ad_1.jpg here] and [http://www.advertnews.com/pix/kookai_ad_3.jpg here] ),to express a "love at first sight post catatonia".
* Appears in one of the ''[[Compare the Meerkat (Advertising)|Compare the Meerkat]]'' adverts.


== Anime & Manga ==
* The first opening sequence of ''[[Death Note (Manga)|Death Note]]'' features {{media-|misora_pieta_plagiarism_7367.jpg| Naomi Misora}} cradling (apparently {{spoiler|recently killed}}) fiancee Raye Penber about halfway through as just one of countless biblical references.
** Also, Light Yagami holds {{spoiler|L's dead body in this position, while grinning evilly after L [[Died in Your Arms Tonight|dies in his arms.]] }}
* ''[[Final Fantasy VII]] [[The Movie|Advent Children]]'' used this in promotional artworks, most notably for the front cover of the OST. It shows [http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B000CBNIJW.01-A2ZG40UZTGC4WR._SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg Cloud and Kadaj].
* CC in the first ''[[Code Geass]]'' OP. It's self-conscious, given that she seems to be in a church.
** Suzaku pulls this off absolutely straight with {{spoiler|Euphemia}}...
** CLAMP have drawn an illustration of Suzaku holding {{spoiler|Lelouch}}.
* ''[[Mazinger Z (Anime)|Mazinger Z]]'': Several times in the manga and in the anime series Kouji held Sayaka -or vice versa- in that position, usually when one of them lay unconscious on the ground. Actually the cover of one of the volumes features a grim-looking Kouji holding a fainted Sayaka.
** ''[[UFO Robo Grendizer (Anime)|UFO Robo Grendizer]]'': It happened near from the end, when {{spoiler|Rubina got murdered}} and Duke held her as she died.
* ''[[Sailor Moon]] R'' does this near the end, when {{spoiler|Prince Dirmando carries his brother Safiiru's lifeless body away of the battlefield, after he's killed by Wiseman.}} This is repeated in the S season, {{spoiler|after Super Sailor Moon rescues Sailor Saturn from her last fight with Pharaoh 90 and takes her back to Earth, now as a newborn baby, in her arms.}}
* The [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/B000G73URC/ref=dp_image_text_0?ie=UTF8&n=130&s=dvd DVD cover] for ''[[Wolfs Rain|Anime Legends: Wolf's Rain Complete Collection II]]'' depicts (among other things) Kiba holding Cheza in his arms. Which should be ''impossible'', because (in case there's anyone who isn't aware of the show's basic concept) {{spoiler|Kiba is actually a wolf and is only projecting the illusion of being human - he doesn't really ''have'' arms, and couldn't possibly hold this pose in wolf form - it would look pretty silly too}}.
** Turns out this ''is'' an actual scene from the show. {{spoiler|Presumably he's actually carrying her on his back.}}
** In addition, it isn't as though weight would be an issue, seeing as how Cheza {{spoiler|is literally a flower.}} Within the context of the show, it seems significant that she's the only one able to be carried like that {{spoiler|by the wolves.}}
* Quite unsurprisingly given the title, the [[Girls Love]] manga ''[[Pieta]]'' uses this pose at a climactic moment, with one of the protagonists holding the other after the latter's suicide attempt.
* Used on the spoileriffic [http://www.nanoha.com/archive3/goods/dvd6.html Vol. 6 cover] of ''[[Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha]] StrikerS''' Japanese DVD, which has Subaru cradling the {{spoiler|seemingly dead body of her sister Ginga}}.
* Daram holds his girlfriend Harulu like this [[After the End]] of ''[[Space Runaway Ideon]]''. It is especially poignant since ''both'' characters are [[Kill Em All|dead at that time]] and appear as spirits. [[Mind Screw|Don't ask]].
* ''[[Ranma One Half|Ranma 1/2]]'' several times, but at least twice in a definite parallel: first, a chapter-cover illustration with Ryoga thus cradling an unconscious Akane during an [[Martial Arts and Crafts|ice-skating battle]]; second, at the end of the series when {{spoiler|Ranma thinks Akane has died}}.
* One chapter of ''[[Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro]]'' ends with X holding Yako like this. An image of the scupture is behind them, except Mary and Jesus are wearing bondage masks.
* The cover art for the latest release of the remastered Platinum Collection of ''[[Neon Genesis Evangelion]]'' features [http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/images/B001GTFP1I/ref=dp_image_z_0?ie=UTF8&n=130&s=dvd Shinji holding Rei in this fashion]. Of course, [[Faux Symbolism|given everything else in the series]]...
** IIRC, there's art of the original series with Misato holding Shinji similarly.
* In ''[[One Piece]]'', Usopp holds Sanji like this when he thinks he's dead. {{spoiler|Turned out he was just checking the wrong side of his chest for a heartbeat.}}
* In the ''[[Fullmetal Alchemist]]'' manga, Armstrong holds a dead child like this [http://www.onemanga.com/Full_Metal_Alchemist/60/12/ as seen here].
** Also seen in the ''Brotherhood'' anime, when {{spoiler|Riza Hawkeye is dying from having her throat slit. Roy Mustang}} cradles her Pieta-style, urging her to stay with him, until {{spoiler|May Cheng performs the alkahestry ritual that saves her life. Once he realizes she's going to live, Mustang scoops her up again the same way, this time pressing his face into her hair.}}
* The cover art for Volume 13 of ''[[Berserk]]'' has a bloody Guts, minus a hand and an eye, holding a naked and unconscious Casca like this, {{spoiler|in what is presumably the aftermath of Casca being raped by Femto}}.
* In ''[[Gundam Seed Destiny]]'', after {{spoiler|Meer Campbell}} dies in the arms of {{spoiler|Lacus Clyne}}, her friend and unrequited crush {{spoiler|Athrun}} briefly carried around her dead body as well.
** And some time before that, {{spoiler|Shinn Asuka}} carried {{spoiler|Stellar Louissier}}'s body after she perished in his arms.
* In ''[[Yu Yu Hakusho]]'', after Toguro kills Genkai, Yusuku holds her in his arms, telling her not to die.
** And {{spoiler|Itsuki}} holds {{spoiler|his lover and leader Sensui}}'s body after he dies.
* In the ''[[Inuyasha]]'' manga and ''Final Act'' anime, {{spoiler|Kikyo dies in Inuyasha's arms}} in this manner.
* ''[[Yu-Gi-Oh]]!''. Yami pulls this with Yugi after defeating the latter in a duel, the price of which was at least [[Sadistic Choice|one of their souls]], in the episode ''Self Destruction (Showdown! The Two Yugis)''.
* In ''[[Pokémon Special]]'', Red holds an unconscious Yellow in this fashion, and to drive the point home, {{spoiler|they're both frozen in stone in this position for presumably some time.}}
** Wallace also briefly holds {{spoiler|Steven's dead body}} in this manner.
* At the near-end of the series of ''[[Tokyo Mew Mew]]'', used twice with Tart and Pudding and Kish and Ichigo. The former being the dead one in both cases.
* [[Darker Than Black|Hei]] does this at the end of the second season with {{spoiler|Yin's body}}.
* ''[[Saint Seiya]]'': When Seiya saves Saori from crows and then [http://www.deathms5.altervista.org/athena1/ath138.jpg catches her before landing]
** In the anime, this is also pulled by {{spoiler|Hyoga}}, who carries {{spoiler|Shun}} in his arms after the other {{spoiler|almost sacrifices himself for him, holding Hyoga in his own arms and then burning his Cosmo to its limits to ''[[Human Popsicle|literally]]'' de-freeze him.}}
* There is official art of Heero from ''[[Gundam Wing]]'' holding Relena this way.
** Link please? And anyway, she returns the favor in ''Endless Waltz'', when Heero collapses out of exhaustation when it's all said and done and Relena catches him mid-fall, then cradles him gently to her.
* The second opening of [[Soul Eater]] shows Soul holding Maka in this fashion, [http://i55.tinypic.com/aoq0iu.png like this]. Never happens in the series, though.
* Tetsuya emerges from a burning building carrying Luna this way in ''[[Casshern Sins]]''. Cue music, then the single-handed [[Crowning Moment of Awesome|Curb Stomping of an entire robot army]].
* Happens in the ''[[Bleach]]'' [[Adaptation Expansion|anime]], with {{spoiler|Hitsugaya}} [http://i55.tinypic.com/315mn3b.png holding a seriously injured] {{spoiler|Hinamori}} this way... {{spoiler|after ''he'' wounded her, under Aizen's hypnotism.}}
* A slightly more frightening example appears in ''[[Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle]]'' in the arc that delves into Kurogane's past. During this part, the character, [[Unstoppable Rage|in a bloody, senseless rage]], ends up being shown, his entire face, except for his eyes, totally shadowed, holding {{spoiler|his mother's bloody corpse.}} This goes on for quite some time, with the only other feature being shown being the occasional appearance of his mouth, usually open in a shout or growl. Then finally, {{spoiler|the character Tsukiyomi stops him and, in an attempt to calm him, closes his dead mother's eyes, telling him that she should rest.}} During this whole time, he never once {{spoiler|dropped his mother's body.}} [http://www.mangareader.net/338-23949-19/tsubasa-reservoir-chronicles/chapter-96.html here it is]
* In ''[[Eureka Seven]]'' episode 13, Renton carried the unconscious Eureka this way when Nirvash started to move on its own.
* The last we see of Hei in the final episode of ''[[Darker Than Black]]'' Ryuusei no Gemini was him carrying Yin this way. Yin's fate is left unknown.
* In [[G Gundam]], this is done with Gundams ''twice''. The first is when the old Shuffle Alliance [http://i41.tinypic.com/nec8qb.jpg heal their successors] {{spoiler|through a [[Heroic Sacrifice]]}}. The second is after {{spoiler|the Shining Gundam is destroyed, seen [http://i39.tinypic.com/bi87kg.jpg here].}}


== Art ==
* The ''[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pietà Pietà]'' was already a long-established representation of the sorrowful Virgin Mary by the time Michelangelo started work on his first one. It first arose in Germany, where the form is known as ''Vesperbild'' ("vespers image", because it portrays a moment after the crucifixion, around the time of evening prayers on Good Friday), and spread to Italy from there. The oldest surviving Pietàs date back to the early 1300s, over 150 years before Michelangelo was born.
** Some ancient sculptures and paintings depicting scenes from pre-Christian mythology also have Pietà-like configuration, e. g. Niobe holding the body of one of her children, Eos (Dawn) with that of her son Memnon etc.
* While it lacks the Mary figure, David's ''Death of Marat'' has the subject mimicking Jesus' pose.
** Although that portrait supposedly was taken from life, er death.
* An even closer version is [http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:G._W._Fasel_-_Charles_G._Crehen_-_Nagel_%26_Weingaertner_-_Martyrdom_of_Joseph_and_Hiram_Smith_in_Carthage_jail,_June_27th,_1844.jpg this image of the death of Joseph Smith], founder of the Mormon Church, from ''[[Older Than They Think|1851]]''.
* [http://themetapicture.com/lego-tragedy/ Lego Tragedy]
* [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v4PjMuIhwdA Even Robert Downey Jr. partakes in a little plagiarism.]


== Comic Books ==
* Many, many comic books. The examples below are just a brief overview. As citing the numerous examples would take up ''way'' too much of this page, here's a nice big [http://www.comics101.com/guestlecturer//?mode=project&action=view&project=Guest%20Lecturer&chapter=17 list] for ya.
** The cover of ''[[Crisis On Infinite Earths]]'' #7, showing Superman carrying Supergirl's dead body, is one of the best known examples in comic books, and is frequently referenced and/or parodied, effectively making the origin of the trope [[Older Than They Think]].
*** The final page of ''[[Final Crisis]]'' #6 has Supes doing it again, this time with {{spoiler|Batman}}'s corpse. This has got to be a throwback.
**** And a drawing by Arthur Suydam of DC zombies has it too, with everyone but Supergirl a zombie, and her with an apple in her mouth.
*** ''[[Tom Strong (Comic Book)|Tom Strong]]'' #22.
*** A [http://machsabre.deviantart.com/art/Guardians-issue-51-colors-34543555 cover] done for a ''[[Guardians of the Galaxy]]'' storyline that [[What Could Have Been|never actually came to be]].
** The {{media-|398px-X-Men_Vol_1_136.jpg| cover}} of ''[[X-Men (Comic Book)|Uncanny X-Men]]'' #136 (Cyclops holding Dark Phoenix) is equally well known; ironically, it wasn't until the ''next'' issue that Phoenix died.
*** This cover came about five years earlier than the Crisis cover mentioned above, so it's at least passably likely that the Crisis cover was an homage to THIS one.
*** Two more X-Men examples, both all-female: The cover of ''Uncanny X-Men'' #255 shows Mystique kneeling, holding the body of her leman Destiny in a pietà pose, and that of ''X-Men Annual" #1 (2006) shows Mystique sitting on the ground holding her injured daughter Rogue.
*** Subverted slightly in X-Treme X-Men #2, where the villain arranges a dead (at the time) Psylocke and bloody-and-broken Beast in a reversal of the Pietà. Might be calling back to the Dark Phoenix cover, as a good portion of the fandom indulges in Shipping where these two are concerned.
** Likewise, the cover of {{spoiler|''The Death of Captain Marvel''}} is very explicitly based on the Michelangelo work.
** One of the most ''notorious'' examples is from the cover of one of the ''[[Teen Titans (Comic Book)|Teen Titans]]'' '[[Very Special Episode|Drug Awareness issues]]', with Speedy holding an unnamed child.
** Another very famous one comes from [[Batman|A Death in the Family]], with Batman holding {{spoiler|Jason Todd as Robin's body. [http://mindlessones.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/jason_todd_robin.jpg This picture.]}}
** ''[[Captain Atom]]'' probably deserves mention for doing it twice, first on the cover of #8, with Plastique [[Foe Yay|cradling]] a badly wounded Cap, with bonus points for Cap having a very visible wound in his side, and then inverting that image on the cover of issue #44, with Cap now cradling an unconscious Plastique.
** It's a fictional comic book, but [http://www.popimage.com/content/images/rage-lg.jpg the cover of issue 1] of ''Rage: Gay Crusader'' from the US version of [[Queer As Folk]].
** The last issue of the fictional Bluntman and Chronic, from [[Kevin Smith]]'s ''[[Chasing Amy]]'', references the Batman example with "the inevitable death of Chronic!".
** ''[[Dark Reign (Comic Book)|Dark Reign]]'' had [http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/herocomplex/2009/02/exclusive-cover.html one of these] in a promo poster.
** ''[[Witchblade (Comic Book)|Witchblade]]'' #128's cover.
* Issue 217 of ''[[Hellblazer (Comic Book)|Hellblazer]]'' [http://www.insanerantings.com/hell/gallery/hb217.html literally copied the statue].
* Two-Face holds a drugged and bleeding Batman like this in ''Batman: Jekyll and Hyde''.
* One of the earliest ''[[Star Trek the Next Generation]]'' comics had Data cradling Geordi's dead body this way. {{spoiler|Then Q resurrects him.}}
** This cover was a double whammy: Data's not only holding Geordi's dead body, he's also in ''tears''.
* The [[The Avengers (Comic Book)|Avengers]]: [http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y84/tsukinofaerii/temp/redzone5cover.jpg Red Zone Part 5 cover] features this with Iron Man holding a very dead Captain America. Note that Tony's angst is so great that even the [[Ho Yay (Comic Books)|armor is emoting]].
* The "Death of Captain America" plotline has Steve Rogers {{spoiler|taking a bullet and collapsing outside the court}}, only for him to be cradled by Sharon Carter and a federal agent '''''[http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0/40/955433-marvel_comics_captain_ameri.jpg.jpeg (spoilers)]'''''.
* Marjane in ''[[Persepolis]]'' recounts how she got into the Iranian art school; in the entrance exam, she drew a copy of Pietà, with Mary replaced by a veiled Iranian woman, and [[Jesus]] replaced by a martyr.
* [[Spider-Man]] holds Gwen Stacy in this way, in the last panel of {{spoiler|''The Night Gwen Stacy Died''}}.
* For the Marvel reprints of [[Elf Quest]], a new series of covers was made. [http://www.elfquest.com/gallery/images/marvel24.jpg Issue 24] also used this pose for Clearbrook and One-Eye.
* A cover of Batman and Son has [http://dc.wikia.com/wiki/File:Zur_En_Arrh_001.jpg Batman do this to the Joker]
* In ''[[All Fall Down (Comic Book)|All Fall Down]]'', the Ghoul holds {{spoiler|Portia}} this way after rescuing her.


== Fan Works ==
* In ''[[With Strings Attached (Fanfic)|With Strings Attached]]'', immediately after the Heart of Evil has been destroyed, the Hunter comes walking through a curtain of rain carrying Paul's naked body (though he isn't dead, and he didn't perform a [[Heroic Sacrifice]]; he got drained by wraiths that he overconfidently attacked).
* In [http://www.fanfiction.net/s/6019679/1/A_Captive_Light A Captive Light] a Digimon fanfiction, {{spoiler|Kari}} cradles {{spoiler|TK}}'s body after Ken's monsters attack, with the intent of actually ''killing'' his hostage. The holding and sobbing last for a good chapter and a half, and reduced more than one reviewer to tears.


== Film - Animated ==
* Nearing the end of ''[[The Nightmare Before Christmas]]'', {{spoiler|Jack lies defeated}} in the arms of a graveyard statue of an angel.
* {{spoiler|Meg's death}} in ''[[Hercules (Disney)|Hercules]]''. {{spoiler|And it's not just Hercules cradling her in his arms as a powered mortal, but he also holds her spirit once he is restored to godhood as well.}}
* In ''[[Tangled]]'', {{spoiler|Rapunzel is holding Eugene/Flynn}} after his [[Heroic Sacrifice]].
* At the very beginning of ''[[The Hunchback of Notre Dame (Disney)|The Hunchback of Notre Dame]]'', the Archdeacon actually does this to Quasimodo's mother after she has been trampled to death by [[Complete Monster|Frollo]] for being a Gypsy and is about to drown baby Quasimodo by dropping him into a well because of his hideous appearance.


== Film - Live Action ==
* The live-action [[Chop Sockey]] movie ''The Protector'' ends with {{spoiler|the hero and the lead villain falling through a skylight onto the mounted skeleton of the elephant he was supposed to be protecting from poachers; his body ends up cradled in the elephant's tusks.}}
* The last scene of Dead Ringers.
* The film version of ''[[Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street (Film)|Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street]]'' has this. The twist is, {{spoiler|they're both dead}}.
** [[Johnny Depp]] does it again in ''[[Dark Shadows]]''. The twist is, {{spoiler|they're both ''undead''}}.
* The Jane Howell film of ''[[Shakespeare|Richard III]]'' ends with a ''reversed'' Pietà pose: {{spoiler|Margaret holding Richard's body with its head cradled in her left arm, laughing.}}
* ''Superbad'', when Seth carries a drunk Evan out of the party.
* Happens in ''[[The Rocky Horror Picture Show]]'', with {{spoiler|Rocky holding Frank-n-Furter}}. [[Isn't It Ironic|Considering the nature of the movie/play...]]
* Used blatantly, and intentionally, in the Argentinian film ''Hombre Mirando al Sudeste'' (''Man Looking Southeast''), because one of its many, many [[Epileptic Trees|possible interpretations]] is that the character Rantes is what he says he is, [[The Messiah]] (or rather, ''a'' messiah).
* The first example of this in film is, predictably enough, ''[[The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (Film)|The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari]]'', as Cesare kidnaps Jane
* At the very end of ''[[Dogma]]'', Silent Bob and Bethany mimic this, with Bethany playing the role of Christ. Don't worry, she's not dead.
** Well, [[Sorting Algorithm of Deadness|not very, anyway]].
** And it's incredibly appropriate, considering she's the last living relative of Christ.
* Another Kevin Smith example: the last "Bluntman and Chronic" in-universe comic shows Bluntman cradling Chronic in a similar way.
* Used intentionally in ''[[Children of Men]]'', with a refugee mother holding her dead (or at least severely wounded) son. The commentary reveals this was a reference both to Michelangelo's sculpture and a real-life photograph.
* Parodied at the end of ''[[Waynes World]]'' when Wayne stumbles out of the burning house cradling the dead Garth and shouting "Why, God?! Why?!"
* Used blatantly and purposely in Mel Gibson's ''[[The Passion of the Christ]]'', when the dead Christ is removed from the cross. Mary cradles him in Michaelangelo's pose while the camera slowly pulls away.
* In ''[[The Silence of the Lambs|Hannibal]]'', the title character carries {{spoiler|Clarice}} this way towards the end.
* Inverted In [[Tom Yum Goong]] ([[The Protector]]).
* Parodied in the ''[[Strangers With Candy]]'' movie when Noblet attacks Jerri over the science fair and then collapses backward into the arms of the other students.
* ''[[Starman (Film)|Starman]]'' carrying Jenny away from an explosion. [[Unexplained Recovery|She gets better]].
* Parodied in ''[[Mr. Bean]]'s Holiday'' - Bean attempts to earn some money by dancing to music from a CD stall, then the music switches to an opera piece, prompting Bean to stage his own improvised opera, with himself and his new friend in the roles of Mary and Jesus. It's [[Better Than It Sounds]].
* [http://www.reverseshot.com/files/images/issue21/idaho4.jpg Scott cradles Mike] in My Own Private Idaho - more than once. However he's only sleeping. He suffers from narcolepsy and it's up to Scott to look after him, and yes, carry him about when he's asleep.
* In the Australian film Animal Kingdom, Pope carries Nicole out of the house like this. {{spoiler|he just killed her by smothering and proceeds to dump her body under a bridge}}
* In [[We Were Soldiers]], an American helicopter returns to base carrying dead and wounded from an intense ongoing battle during the early stages of the [[Vietnam War]]. A [[Big Scary Black Man|large black soldier]] picks up a dead white soldier and carries him away while weeping. [[Truth in Television]], as the authors of the book the movie was based on indicate that it actually happened.
* In ''[[The Fugitive (Film)|The Fugitive]]'', Richard Kimble holds his dead (or dying) wife in his arms this way.
* In ''[[Don Juan Demarco]]'', the pose is enacted when {{spoiler|John's father is fatally wounded in a sword duel, and dies in the arms of John's mother.}}
* [[The Incredible Hulk (Film)|The Incredible Hulk]] carries Betty away from the battle on the college campus.
* In ''[[Robo Cop]] 3'', the titular character carries the dying {{spoiler|Anne Lewis}} into a church in this fashion, and sets them down on the altar before {{spoiler|she finally succumbs to her gunshot wound}}.
* Used in ''[[Robot Monster]]'', as immortalized on the [http://www.cultreviews.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/RM-poster.jpg poster].
* Scotty carrying his dead nephew Ensign Prescott onto the bridge in ''[[Star Trek|The Wrath of Khan]]''
* In ''[[Harry Potter (Film)|Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2]]'', {{spoiler|Severus Snape cradles Lily Potter's body after finding her dead.}}
* Used in ''[[Transformers Dark of the Moon]]'' when Optimus holds Sentinel's body, which has been on the moon since [[The Sixties]] and is locked in stasis due to lack of Energon.
* {{spoiler|Erik}} cradles a wounded {{spoiler|Charles}} on the beach in ''[[X Men (Film)|X-Men: First Class]].''
* The last shot of ''The Roaring Twenties'' leaves {{spoiler|Eddie}} dead in Panama's arms after his [[Heroic Sacrifice]].
* The spectacular shot of Sam cradling Frodo on the slopes of Mount Doom in ''[[Lord of the Rings|The Return of the King]]''.
* In ''[[Sherlock Holmes (Film)|Sherlock Holmes: A Game of Shadows]]'', Sim does this to {{spoiler|her brother}} after they collapsed from {{spoiler|a poisoned dart}}.


== Literature ==
* Rare non-visual example: in [[Justina Robson]] 's [[Living Next Door To The God Of Love]], the Stuffies' Cathedral has a stained-glass window showing Francine with a "sexy dark chick" in her lap: it's Cadenza Fortitude, the titular God's [[Gender Bender|female version]].
* ''[[The Executioner]]''. On the cover of "Day of Mourning" in which {{spoiler|Mack Bolan's long-term [[Love Interest]] April Rose is killed, Bolan}} is shown cradling the latter's dead body. [[Empathic Environment|And it's raining]].


== Live-Action TV ==
* ''[[Veronica Mars]]'' began and ended its second season with the Pietà; in the first case, Veronica tends to Logan, and in the second, it's reversed.
* The Season 7 finale of ''[[Smallville]]'' had {{spoiler|Lex Luthor cradling a (Weakened? Paralyzed? Don't really know.) Clark Kent in a similar fashion as the Fortress of Solitude crumbled around them.}} It's further enforced by the former repeatedly apologizing to him and apparently seeing this event {{spoiler|of killing his former-best friend}} as a great personal sacrifice.
* Used at least once in ''[[Buffy the Vampire Slayer]]'', after Drusilla is restored to health and Spike is injured, she holds him in this manner.
** Also used in the episode The Puppet Show, when Buffy cradles {{spoiler|the [[Demon Slaying]] puppet}} after his death.
* ''[[Heroes (TV)|Heroes]]'' used this twice in season 3 in paintings of the future. One of {{spoiler|Matt holding a burned Daphne in a possible-future where Sylar goes nuclear}} and {{spoiler|Noah holding an injured Claire, foreshadowing the eclipse during which the powered people lose their abilities.}}
* The last episode of the first season of ''[[Merlin (TV)|Merlin]]'' plays it straight with {{spoiler|Uther holding Arthur. It's ok though, he gets better.}}
** Also in the [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIbESjbH2wI season four trailer], {{spoiler|Percival was seen carrying an unconscious Merlin in his arms.}}
* Used in, of all places, the first season of ''[[The OC]]'', with Ryan and Marissa, who had just taken a painkiller overdose washed down with a lot of alcohol in Tijuana.
** And in a deliberate parallel to the above scene, {{spoiler|he carries her the same way in the Season 3 finale, "The Graduates", following a car accident. She's suffered head trauma and he has to carry her away from the burning car. She dies in his arms, and the final shot is him huddled over her body}}.
* Spoofed in an episode of ''Upright Citizens Brigade'' in the Camp Kalterman sketch.
* Done a few times in ''[[Hercules: The Legendary Journeys]]'', usually whenever Iolaus dies. (Yes, it happened more than once.) In a commentary, Michael Hurst got his Michelangelo sculptures mixed up and compared it to ''David''.
* Worf carrying Data during the ''[[Star Trek the Next Generation]]'' episode "Brothers". Data was only deactivated at the time, though.
* In [[Doctor Who (TV)|Doctor Who]], the Doctor holds {{spoiler|the Master}} in this way in the Series 3 Finale. Somewhat ruined by his odd squatting pose on the floor, although that was only as narmy as the odd position of his legs while dramatically floating.
** He did it again {{spoiler|with Jenny}} in 'The Doctor's Daughter,' complete with that little hug-rocking motion. Once again, a secondary character {{spoiler|shot the closest thing to family he had left out of almost nowhere;}} it was a bit of a callback.
*** Given the way {{spoiler|the Doctor}} tends to feel responsible when people die around him, this almost plays as [[Cradling Your Kill]].
** The scene in "Smith & Jones" where the Doctor carries Martha after she passes out from the lack of oxygen could be seen this way, especially since there was no particular reason she couldn't have stayed where she was besides drama.
* In the ''[[Dark Angel]]'' episode "Pollo Loco," Max holds her "brother" Ben in this manner after {{spoiler|he asks her to kill him and she complies.}}
* [[Seinfeld]] - Jerry has a bad dream where he ends up in this pose after getting illegal cable and the Cable Police gun him down. Kramer cradles him crying "What have you done to my little ''CABLE BOY???''"
* ''[[Power Rangers in Space]]'': Andros holds the body of {{spoiler|Karone}} after Zordon's [[Heroic Sacrifice]] to stop the attack on the world. {{spoiler|She is revived by Andros' love for her.}}


== Tabletop Games ==
* A picture on the page explaining the rules for Resonance (that's the accumulation of the wrath of the undead creators of the world to you and me...) in the ''[[Exalted]]'' 2nd ed Abyssals book. Something of an inversion, however- the character doing the cradling is presumably an Abyssal, and has probably just invited the anger of the Neverborn by attempting to do some good in the world- renegade Abyssals can quite easily hit [[The Messiah|Messianic]] status, [[Dark Messiah|Dark]] or otherwise.


== Theater ==
* The script of the play for [[Little Shop of Horrors]] mentions Pieta a few times when discussing how to act {{spoiler|Audrey's death and subsequent feeding to the plant}}.
* [[Shakespeare]] example: [[King Lear]] carrying Cordelia's body at the end of the play. Well, near the end.
* The very last pose in [[Elisabeth]]. See that show's trope page for an illustration.
* [[Miss Saigon]], after {{spoiler|Kim shoots her cousin Thuy (she was protecting her son from him), then at the end, after she shoots herself.}}


== Video Games ==
* A pretty clever example occurs in ''[[Assassin's Creed]] Brotherhood''. In one particular story mission, you are tasked with preventing someone's assassination in the middle of a play, where said person is playing Jesus. Let's just say things take a turn for the bad, so they cut him off the cross, and Ezio picks him up and carries him off. Perfect Pieta pose included.
* When ''[[Shin Megami Tensei II]]'' was remade for the Playstation, its original poster featured {{media-|[[SMT 2]].jpg| the protagonist being held by the angel Gabriel in this postition.}}
* In the fifth case of the original Ace Attorney game, Lana Skye holds her unconscious younger sister Ema in this manner after {{spoiler|Ema is attacked by a serial killer.}}
* Kefka of ''[[Final Fantasy VI]]'' mimics this as one of his [[One Winged Angel|final forms]], with himself replacing Christ.
** Notably, in the Japanese version, the female torso and head floating behind Kefka was named "Maria", as in "Mary", as opposed to the western translations in which she was named "Girl" or "Lady" depending on the console version. (Quite obviously to avoid pushing any [[Berserk Button|berserk buttons]].)
* Tellah of ''[[Final Fantasy IV]]'' takes both sides of this trope in the DS remake, holding {{spoiler|his daughter Anna as she's just been shot full of Baronian arrows}}, and then being picked up by Cid after {{spoiler|[[Cast From Hit Points|sacrificing his own life]] to power his uber-doom Meteor spell against Golbez.}}
* The standing Pietà could be found on the box art of ''[[Shadow Hearts]]'' with Yuri carrying Alice. The sequel ''Shadow Hearts: From the New World'' mimics this with Johnny and Shania, except that Johnny is not strong enough to lift Shania. The art effectively looks more like the picture above (''Lamentation'') as Johnny is kneeling. Ruined, at least for this troper, as Shania's neck is straight up; she is clearly supporting it herself.
** You can see the sculpture itself in Apoina Tower in ''Covenant''.
* ''[[Mega Man X]] 4'', during the infamous [[Narm|"WHAT AM I FIGHTING FOOOOOOOOOOR"]] scene, where Zero carries the {{spoiler|dead Iris}}.
** Another one in ''X8'', with X carrying {{spoiler|a comatose Axl}} before and during their {{spoiler|journey back to Earth}}.
** And again in ''[[Mega Man Zero]]'', where Zero saves [[Distressed Damsel|a falling Ciel]] this way.
* Done twice in ''[[The Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess]].'' Link holds Colin in this manner after rescuing him from abduction by the Bulblins. Later, when Midna uses the power of the Fused Shadow for the first time and it renders her unconscious, she likewise is [http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=cgn_brYu594 held in Link's arms until she wakes].
* An interesting variation from ''[[Final Fantasy VIII]]'': Rinoa does this with Squall after she finds him unconscious in the desert after Time Compression, but it's mostly shown from the ''back'' - most likely to highlight the wings on the back of her outfit.
** Also averted in ''[[Final Fantasy VIII]]''. Squall carries the unconscious {{spoiler|Rinoa}} piggyback style.
* A statue in Chorrol in ''[[Oblivion]]'' resembles this.
* {{spoiler|Snake holding Big Mama}} in ''[[Metal Gear Solid]] 4'' is an [[Inverted Trope|interesting twist]], because all the [[What Do You Mean Its Not Symbolic|symbolism]] up until that point was that {{spoiler|Snake was the self-sacrificial, messianic one and Mama was his mother (she even blatantly described Snake's birth as an 'immaculate conception').}}
* in the ''.hack'' series, Kite holds the {{spoiler|dying Mia}} in this manner.
** In G.U., Haseo does this when {{spoiler|1=Alkaid is PKed}}.
* ...And now someone's gone and made a [[Real Life]] statue of [[Super Mario Bros|Peach holding Mario in that pose]]. From styrofoam. It's titled [http://www.designboom.com/weblog/cat/10/view/9567/michelangelo-nintendo-remix.html "Game Over"].
* In ''[[Umineko no Naku Koro Ni (Visual Novel)|Umineko no Naku Koro Ni]]'''s PS3 remake, Battler is holding Beatrice like this on the cover.
* In ''[[Dragon Age 2]]'' Hawke does this with his/her mother {{spoiler|when he/she is too late to save their mother from an insane blood mage who sought to [[Body Horror|'reassemble']] his late wife.}}
** Later in Act 2, Viscount Dumar does this {{spoiler|with his son Seamus after the latter is murdered by Petrice in her attempt to incite war with the Qunari.}}
* In ''[[Fable III (Video Game)|Fable III]]'', The Hero does this as {{spoiler|Walter dies in his/her arms after the final battle}}.
* In ''[[Batman Arkham City|Batman: Arkham City]]'', done by Batman during the ending after {{spoiler|the Joker dies from TITAN poisoning}}.
** Made somewhat hilarious by the fact that {{spoiler|he seems to have left Talia lying in a pool of her own blood without a second thought.}}<ref>Ehh, she'll get better, wot with the Lazarus Pit and all...</ref>
** This is also an [[Ironic Echo]] to the first image we see in the ''Catwoman'' opening - [[Cain and Abel|Cain]] doing the exact same pose with Abel.
* Despite being the furthest thing from a messiah imaginable, Alex Mercer in ''[[Prototype (Video Game)|Prototype]]'' cradles [[Morality Pet|his sister's]] unconscious body this way when he rescues her from a kidnapping, before he lifts her [[Super Strength|effortlessly]] and tears out of the building to find medical care.


== Webcomics ==
* ''[[Kevin and Kell]]'', normally a very gag-based comic, had one [http://www.kevinandkell.com/2003/kk0922.html here], following the death of {{spoiler|Danielle}}.
* Parson pulls one of these in ''[[Erfworld]]''.
* There's at least one in the [[Walkyverse]].
** At least one? If a major character dies and leaves a body, there's a greater chance that this will happen as the series goes on. In Shortpacked, it was used for unconscious character''s'', considering how [[Death Is Cheap|Death wasn't so cheap]] there.
* ''[[Breakfast of the Gods]]'' gives us (spoiler warning) ''[http://www.webcomicsnation.com/poyorick/botgpromo/series.php this]''. And yes, that ''is'' {{spoiler|Tony the Tiger cradling the lifeless body of Cap'n Crunch}}.
** [http://www.webcomicsnation.com/poyorick/botg3/series.php?view=archive&chapter=40085 Later on] the inversion, [[Cradling Your Kill]] is used: the Pietà pose is of an enemy holding his victim.
* Occurs [http://www.garanos.com/pages/page-165 near the end of the first volume] of fantasy comic ''[[Garanos]]''.
* Pastiched by [[Dasien (Webcomic)|Dasien]] and Mindmistress on [http://www.drunkduck.com/Crossoverlord/index.php?p=598517 this] cover in ''[[The Crossoverlord (Webcomic)|The Crossoverlord]]''.
* In one of two pages being added to the [http://www.girlgeniusonline.com/comic.php?date=20061216 second printing] of ''[[Girl Genius (Webcomic)|Girl Genius]]'' Volume 6 to fix a layout issue, {{spoiler|Agatha tends to a freshly dead Lars}}.
* Done with the accidentally slaughtered Raccoon #1 in ''[http://www.intrepidgirlbot.com/2009/04/27/pieta/ The Intrepid Girlbot]''.
* Rumble Bee of Super Stupor strikes this pose with her mentor when he ceases to exist during the Cataclysm in [http://www.superstupor.com/sust12242007.shtml this] strip.
* Seen in [[Juathuur]] [http://oneway.juathuur.com/1/?strip_id=278 here], with inverted genders.
* [[Dominic Deegan (Webcomic)|Dominic Deegan]] shows this trope during a flashback to {{spoiler|the slaughter of a group of students by a sadistic Infernomancer.}}
* ''[[El Goonish Shive (Webcomic)|El Goonish Shive]]''. Grace is shown doing it in [http://egscomics.com/?date=2011-05-19 this comic], right after knocking the guy out with a sleeper hold.
* ''[[Weapon Brown]]'': {{spoiler|[http://www.whatisdeepfried.com/2011/07/25/weapon-brown-245/ ME GOYLE!!]}}
* In ''[[Blue Yonder]]'', [http://www.blueyondercomic.net/comics/1086929/blue-yonder-prologue-page-15-finale/ Jared is carried in like that after the injuries he suffered.]
* [[Karate Bears]] need [http://www.karatebears.com/2012/01/pita.html a mop.]
* ''[[Homestuck (Webcomic)|Homestuck]]'' manages to pull it off both seriously and mockingly ''[[Crosses the Line Twice|at the same time]]'' thanks to Sburb's [http://mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=005284 kiss-revival system.]


== Web Original ==
* ''[[Dr. Horribles Sing Along Blog]]'' has one heralding its finale in Act III: {{spoiler|Billy carries the lifeless body of Penny to a stretcher}} as he sings "Everything You Ever" and {{spoiler|makes his final transformation to Dr. Horrible}}.
* Invoked at the end of Brad Neely's [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wv8xazDzACg ''China, IL.'']
* [[Atop the Fourth Wall (Web Video)|Linkara]] does this with [[Marz Gurl]] in ''[[Kickassia]]'' when she's knocked down by an explosion. [[Played for Laughs]], since the entire time he's doing it, she's protesting that she's fine.
* ''[[Chaos Fighters]]: Chemical Warriors-RAKSA'' has this near the end, but subverted that the one being hugged {{spoiler|was alive and woke up}}.


== Western Animation ==
* ''[[Avatar: The Last Airbender (Animation)|Avatar: The Last Airbender]]'': {{media-|avatar.jpg| This scene}} from the second season finale is one example that doesn't follow a [[Heroic Sacrifice]], but a [[Hope Spot|poorly timed mistake]].
* ''[[Ben 10 Alien Force (Animation)|Ben 10 Alien Force]]'' actually has a shot like this in "What Little Girls Are Made Of", with Kevin holding Ben after he is knocked down in a (brief) conflict with a woman who turns out to be his grandmother. The scene is not dramatic and Ben isn't even unconsious, but he stays in Kevin's arms like that for a good five seconds.
* ''[[Superjail (Animation)|Superjail]]'': When {{spoiler|the [[Littlest Cancer Patient]] dies,}} one of the prisoners holds her like this.
* ''[[Transformers Animated]]'', Endgame Part 2: {{spoiler|Jazz carries Prowl's body after the third Lugnut Supreme blows up.}}
* Spoofed in the ''[[Dexters Laboratory|Dexter's Laboratory]]'' accompanying short, ''The Justice Friends'', in which Major Glory holds Valhallen in his arms after Valhallen injures himself in an attempt to get a bee out of their apartment. When Valhallen states that he is fine, Major Glory casually tosses him aside.
* In ''[[Lilo and Stitch]] 2'', where {{spoiler|Stitch has died, Lilo}} holds him in this fashion. It's okay though, he gets better.
* The end of the ''[[Looney Tunes]]'' cartoon "What's Opera Doc?"
* ''[[The Simpsons]]'': The famous "Death of Superman" comic is parodied with [http://simpsonswiki.net/wiki/The_Death_of_Sad_Sack Sad Sack].


== Real Life ==
* Mortally wounded Sen. [http://www.monroegallery.com/photographers/detail/id/420 Robert F. Kennedy] and busboy Juan Romero. Ambassador Hotel, Los Angeles, California, June 5, 1968.
* World Press Photo [http://lightbox.time.com/2012/02/10/the-2012-world-press-photo-of-the-year/ picture of the year], 2011.


{{examples on subpages}}
{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Stock Poses]]
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Alliterative Trope Titles]]
[[Category:Art Imitates Art]]
[[Category:Art Subjects]]
[[Category:Art Tropes]]
[[Category:Art Tropes]]
[[Category:Sherlock Holmes (Film)]]
[[Category:Cover Tropes]]
[[Category:Cover Tropes]]
[[Category:Pieta Plagiarism]]
[[Category:Pages with working Wikipedia tabs]]
[[Category:Trope]]
[[Category:Shout-Outs Index]]
[[Category:Stock Poses]]

Latest revision as of 01:06, 5 April 2022

Accept no substitutes.

Michelangelo's sculpture depicting Mary holding the body of the crucified Christ is the best-known example of one of the most popular poses in art. There is a whole class of artwork, referred to as "pietàs", that depict Mary (usually seated) holding the dead Jesus, going back to at least the early 14th century. It includes two other pieces by Michelangelo himself - one in the Cathedral Museum in Florence and known as the Deposition or Florentine Pietà, the other one one in the Castello Sforzesco in Milan and known as the Rondanini Pieta, as well as a third work in the Academia in Florence not generally attributed to Michelangelo today.

This specific pose is often used either following a Heroic Sacrifice or on a comic book cover, in which case it will likely be accompanied by a Tonight Someone Dies. It's frequently gender-flipped (i.e. the man holding a dead/dying/comatose woman), perhaps because the latter is more dramatic in modern media.

A subtrope of Faux Symbolism. May be mixed with Touch of the Monster. Super-Trope to Cradling Your Kill and Died in Your Arms Tonight. See also Background Halo for related subliminal symbolism. Compare Last Supper Steal and Crucified Hero Shot for other examples of frequently homaged Christ-iconography.

Examples of Pietà Plagiarism are listed on these subpages:
Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Pietà_Plagiarism?oldid=1961543"