The End of the Beginning: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
prefix>Import Bot
(Import from TV Tropes TVT:Main.TheEndOfTheBeginning 2012-07-01, editor history TVTH:Main.TheEndOfTheBeginning, CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported license)
 
(Replaced redirects)
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
{{quote|''"Now this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning." ''|'''[[Winston Churchill]]''', 1942}}
{{quote|''"Now this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning." ''
|'''[[Winston Churchill]]''', 1942}}


Yeah, what he said.
Yeah, what he said.
Line 10: Line 11:
For some reason, writers just ''love'' to point out this fact wherever possible. Expect a lot of them to mention "the beginning" with some sort of heavy significance.
For some reason, writers just ''love'' to point out this fact wherever possible. Expect a lot of them to mention "the beginning" with some sort of heavy significance.


Oh, and to make it even better--by the same token--sometimes the beginning of the story is referred to as "the end". It can get quite confusing.
Oh, and to make it even better—by the same token—sometimes the beginning of the story is referred to as "the end". It can get quite confusing.


See also: [[My Death Is Just the Beginning]] . Bears only a passing relation to the [[B Movie]] ''[[Beginning of the End]]''.
See also: [[My Death Is Just the Beginning]] . Bears only a passing relation to the [[B-Movie]] ''[[Beginning of the End]]''.


{{endingtrope}}
{{examples|Examples:}}
{{examples}}
== Anime and Manga ==
* ''[[Alien Nine]]''{{'}}s final anime episode was literally titled this trope, and it makes sense considering that, despite the series coming to a close, it reveals little pieces of what could be a possible {{spoiler|intergalactic conspiracy}}.


== Comic Books ==
* The pilot of ''[[Red Dwarf (TV)|Red Dwarf]]'' said "The End" at the beginning of the episode and "The Beginning" at the end of the episode.
* ''[[Watchmen (comics)|Watchmen]]'': "Nothing ''ends'', {{spoiler|Adrian}}. Nothing ever ends."
* At the end of ''[[Anastasia]]'': "It's a perfect ending!" "No. It's a perfect beginning."
* The final book in the ''[[Animorphs (Literature)|Animorphs]]'' series was titled "The Beginning".
* The final chapter of ''[[Harry Potter (Franchise)/Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire|Harry Potter]]'' was titled "The Beginning"
* After the [[Deathly Hallows]] title was released, the following episode of [[Muggle Cast]] was called "The Beginning Of The End". When they got the release date, Andrew states that it was "the end of the beginning of the end".
* The ''[[Star Trek Expanded Universe (Franchise)|Star Trek Expanded Universe]]'' novel ''Imzadi'' commences with a page reading "The End," then goes through "The End of the Beginning," "Epilogue," "The Beginning," "The Middle," and finally "The Beginning of the End." This comes of a story with a nonlinear narrative that also involves time travel.
* ''[[Star Trek First Contact (Film)|Star Trek First Contact]]'' closes with the first meeting between humanity and the Vulcans, starting a brand new era in human history and marking the beginning of the [[Trek Verse (Franchise)|Trek Verse]].
** ''[[Star Trek Enterprise (TV)|Star Trek Enterprise]]'' ends with a [[Distant Finale]] in which the Enterprise is decomissioned. But the point is made that Archer and his brave crews exploits laid the foundations for the Starfleet (and later ships called ''Enterprise'') to "boldy go where no man has gone before..."
* ''[[Alien Nine (Manga)|Alien Nine]]'s'' final anime episode was literally titled this trope, and it makes sense considering that, despite the series coming to a close, it reveals little pieces of what could be a possible {{spoiler|intergalactic conspiracy}}.
* The first chapter of the first book of [[The First Law]] trilogy is titled ''The End''. The final chapter of the last book is titled ''The Beginning''.
* ''[[Watchmen (Comic Book)|Watchmen]]'': "Nothing ''ends'', {{spoiler|Adrian}}. Nothing ever ends."
* [[Real Life]] example: What Churchill is referring to in the above quote is that the worst part of [[World War II]] appeared to be over at that point; the threat of invasion of the UK by Germany was over, the United States entered the war full bore and a powerful alliance of those nations with the Soviet Union was established to give the Axis what for.
** Also Real Life: Apollo 17 astronaut Gene Cernan frequently invoked this phrase motivationally during training for the final moon landing mission, believing that it should not be thought of as the end of the moon program, but just the "end of the beginning" of such exploration. Technicians would frequently tease him about this ("Hey, Geno, I keep forgetting -- is this the end or the beginning?"), and the phrase was humorously inserted (along with variations and subversions) at strategic points into the checklists Cernan would use on the lunar surface.
* The [[Newspaper Comics|Newspaper Comic]] ''[[Flash Gordon (Comic Strip)|Flash Gordon]]'' kept going for ''decades'' after Ming the Merciless was overthrown, while the characters continued finding new and mostly non-Ming-related adventures to have.
* [[Jerry Lewis]]' ''The Nutty Professor'' ends, after a fake ending, with the words "the beginning", when Professor Kelp and Stella finally got together.
* [[Dissidia Final Fantasy|"This isn't the end. Another dream is waiting to begin."]]
* This was how [[The Last Battle]] ended.
* [[Mass Effect]]: [[Big Bad]] {{spoiler|Sovereign}} is just the vanguard of the coming galactic invasion. Shepard, after being hailed as a hero by the powers that be, vows to find a way to stop the invasion and walks off, continuing his/her quest.
* At the end of ''[[Princess Tutu]]'', the series narrator states that {{spoiler|Fakir}} is writing "a new story full of hope." (However, the title card shown right after this says "the end".)
* In [[Resident Evil]] 2's ending, the main characters exchange this dialog:
{{quote| {{spoiler|'''Leon:''' "It's finally over."}}<br />
{{spoiler|'''Claire:''' "It's not. I've got to my brother."}}<br />
{{spoiler|'''Leon:''' "You're right... ''this'' is just the beginning."}} }}
* Oliver Stone's ''JFK'', ends with "What is past is prologue."
** The phrase is taken from William Shakespeare's [[The Tempest]], and is engraved on the National Archives building in Washington, DC.
* The final chapter of the third book in the [[Star Wars Expanded Universe|Han Solo Trilogy]] features Han sitting in a cantina on some backwater planet and worrying about their financial debt to a crime lord. Chewie walks over to his table and tells him that he may have found the solution to their problems in an old man and a kid who need passage to Alderaan. Where most books say "The End," it says "The Beginning."
** The final line of ''[[Attack of the Clones]]'' is, "Begun, the Clone War has."
* "Shadow thieves" by Anne Ursu, is in four parts" we begin in the middle." " now the beginning" " the end of the beginning" and " the beginning of the end"
* The final panel of ''[[Order of the Stick (Webcomic)|Order of the Stick]]'' [[Prequel]] book ''On the Origins of PCs'' simply says, "The Beginning."
* The final song on Forgive Durden's album [[Razias Shadow (Music)|Razias Shadow]] is titled, "The End and the Beginning" in this fashion.
* The [[Gears of War]] Trilogy has invoked this, They defeated the Locust and the Equally as destructive Lambent Locust. However it's made clear that they are still far off from a happy ending. But for now they have earned their "Tomorrow".
* At the end of Chapter 8 of ''[[The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck]]'', Scrooge was busy shooing off intruders of White Agony Creek, when his arm suddenly gives way of the weight of a big rock he lifts up.
* At the end of Chapter 8 of ''[[The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck]]'', Scrooge was busy shooing off intruders of White Agony Creek, when his arm suddenly gives way of the weight of a big rock he lifts up.
{{quote| '''Scrooge's thoughts:''' Great honk, this rock is ''heavy!'' how could it weigh so much unless...<br />
{{quote|'''Scrooge's thoughts:''' Great honk, this rock is ''heavy!'' how could it weigh so much unless...
'''Scrooge:''' ...Unless it's ''gold!'' Gotta rinse off the mud! A nugget this ''big'' would make me the richest man in the Klondike!<br />
'''Scrooge:''' ...Unless it's ''gold!'' Gotta rinse off the mud! A nugget this ''big'' would make me the richest man in the Klondike!
'''Scrooge's thoughts:''' But if it ''is'' gold, that will mean my quest is finished! I'll be ''rich!'' I'll never be the same again! Will clean air smell any sweeter? Will sunny days be ever brighter? Will starry nights hold any more wonder? Or will I ''lose'' all that? Do I ''really'' want to be... ''rich?''<br />
'''Scrooge's thoughts:''' But if it ''is'' gold, that will mean my quest is finished! I'll be ''rich!'' I'll never be the same again! Will clean air smell any sweeter? Will sunny days be ever brighter? Will starry nights hold any more wonder? Or will I ''lose'' all that? Do I ''really'' want to be... ''rich?''
''([[Beat Panel]]...)''<br />
''([[Beat Panel]]...)''
''(He gains a glint in his eyes...)''<br />
''(He gains a glint in his eyes...)''
'''Scrooge: Yes!!!'''<br />
'''Scrooge: Yes!!!'''
''(He rinses off the mud. The rock is indeed a huge nugget of gold.)''<br />
''(He rinses off the mud. The rock is indeed a huge nugget of gold.)''
'''Scrooge:''' It's ''gold! Solid'' gold! As big as a ''goose egg!'' Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! ''I'm '''{{color|red|R}}'''''<br />
'''Scrooge:''' It's ''gold! Solid'' gold! As big as a ''goose egg!'' Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! ''I'm '''{{color|red|RICH!}}'''''
''(The last word echoes throughout the creek as Scrooge skips about in excitement.)''<br />
''(The last word echoes throughout the creek as Scrooge skips about in excitement.)''
'''Random observing bird:''' ?<br />
'''Random observing bird:''' ?
'''Narration Box:''' The Beginning... }}
'''Narration Box:''' The Beginning... }}

* The sci-fi [[B Movie]] ''[[The Phantom Planet (Film)|The Phantom Planet]]'' ends with the narrator stating that, as humanity continues to explore the cosmos, they'll discover even more amazing wonders. "This is only the beginning!"
== Film ==
* Subverted in ''[[The Reconstruction (Video Game)|The Reconstruction]]''. By the end of the story, {{spoiler|the world is almost completely annihilated and has to be rebuilt practically from scratch}} -- it is ''definitely'' the beginning of a new era. However, it's never actually said anywhere that it's a new beginning -- even the phrase "reconstruction" is never mentioned.
* At the end of ''[[Anastasia (Animation)|Anastasia]]'': "It's a perfect ending!" "No. It's a perfect beginning."
* End of the Beginning is level 1-10 of the Impetus area of ''[[Bit Trip]] RUNNER'', which signals the end of the tutorial levels. This is mirrored by Middle of the Middle and Beginning of the end in Tenacity and Triumph respectively.
* ''[[Star Trek: First Contact]]'' closes with the first meeting between humanity and the Vulcans, starting a brand new era in human history and marking the beginning of the [[Trek Verse]].
* Literally: At the end of the apocalyptic/time-travel sci-fi [[B Movie]] ''Millennium'' (not related to the eponymous TV series), a solemn voice-over proclaims: ''"It is not the end! It is not the beginning of the end! It is the end of the beginning!"''
* [[Jerry Lewis]]' ''[[The Nutty Professor (1963 film)|The Nutty Professor]]'' ends, after a fake ending, with the words "the beginning", when Professor Kelp and Stella finally got together.
* Oliver Stone's ''[[JFK (film)|JFK]]'', ends with "What is past is prologue."
** The phrase is taken from William Shakespeare's ''[[The Tempest]]'', and is engraved on the National Archives building in Washington, DC.
* The final line of ''[[Attack of the Clones]]'' is, "Begun, the Clone War has."
* The sci-fi [[B-Movie]] ''[[The Phantom Planet]]'' ends with the narrator stating that, as humanity continues to explore the cosmos, they'll discover even more amazing wonders. "This is only the beginning!"
* Literally: At the end of the apocalyptic/time-travel sci-fi [[B-Movie]] ''[[Millennium (film)|Millennium]]'' (not related to [[Millennium (TV series)|the TV series of the same name]]), a solemn voice-over proclaims: ''"It is not the end! It is not the beginning of the end! It is the end of the beginning!"''

== Literature ==
* The final book in the ''[[Animorphs]]'' series was titled "The Beginning".
* The final chapter of ''[[Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (novel)|Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire]]'' was titled "The Beginning".
* The ''[[Star Trek Expanded Universe]]'' novel ''Imzadi'' commences with a page reading "The End," then goes through "The End of the Beginning," "Epilogue," "The Beginning," "The Middle," and finally "The Beginning of the End." This comes of a story with a nonlinear narrative that also involves time travel.
* The first chapter of the first book of ''[[The First Law]]'' trilogy is titled ''The End''. The final chapter of the last book is titled ''The Beginning''.
* This was how ''[[The Last Battle]]'' -- the final book of the ''[[Chronicles of Narnia]]'' -- ended.
* The final chapter of the third book in the ''[[Star Wars Expanded Universe|Han Solo Trilogy]]'' features Han sitting in a cantina on some backwater planet and worrying about their financial debt to a crime lord. Chewie walks over to his table and tells him that he may have found the solution to their problems in an old man and a kid who need passage to Alderaan. Where most books say "The End," it says "The Beginning."
* ''[[The Shadow Thieves]]'' by Anne Ursu is in four parts: "We begin in the middle", "Now the beginning", "The end of the beginning" and "The beginning of the end".

== Live-Action TV ==
* The pilot of ''[[Red Dwarf]]'' said "The End" at the beginning of the episode and "The Beginning" at the end of the episode.
* ''[[Star Trek: Enterprise]]'' ends with a [[Distant Finale]] in which the Enterprise is decomissioned. But the point is made that Archer and his brave crews exploits laid the foundations for the Starfleet (and later ships called ''Enterprise'') to "boldy go where no man has gone before..."

== Music ==
* The final song on Forgive Durden's album ''[[Razia's Shadow: A Musical]]'' is titled, "The End and the Beginning" in this fashion.

== Newspaper Comics ==
* ''[[Flash Gordon (comic strip)|Flash Gordon]]'' kept going for ''decades'' after Ming the Merciless was overthrown, while the characters continued finding new and mostly non-Ming-related adventures to have.

== Tabletop Games ==
* Subverted in ''[[The Reconstruction]]''. By the end of the story, {{spoiler|the world is almost completely annihilated and has to be rebuilt practically from scratch}} -- it is ''definitely'' the beginning of a new era. However, it's never actually said anywhere that it's a new beginning -- even the phrase "reconstruction" is never mentioned.

== Video Games ==
* ''[[Dissidia Final Fantasy]]'': "This isn't the end. Another dream is waiting to begin."
* ''[[Mass Effect]]'': [[Big Bad]] {{spoiler|Sovereign}} is just the vanguard of the coming galactic invasion. Shepard, after being hailed as a hero by the powers that be, vows to find a way to stop the invasion and walks off, continuing his/her quest.
* At the end of ''[[Princess Tutu]]'', the series narrator states that {{spoiler|Fakir}} is writing "a new story full of hope." (However, the title card shown right after this says "the end".)
* In ''[[Resident Evil 2]]''{{'}}s ending, the main characters exchange this dialog:
{{quote|{{spoiler|'''Leon:''' "It's finally over."}}
{{spoiler|'''Claire:''' "It's not. I've got to my brother."}}
{{spoiler|'''Leon:''' "You're right... ''this'' is just the beginning."}} }}
* The ''[[Gears of War]]'' Trilogy has invoked this. They defeated the Locust and the equally-as-destructive Lambent Locust. However it's made clear that they are still far off from a happy ending. But for now they have earned their "Tomorrow".
* "End of the Beginning" is level 1-10 of the Impetus area of ''[[Bit.Trip|Bit.Trip RUNNER]]'', which signals the end of the tutorial levels. This is mirrored by "Middle of the Middle" and "Beginning of the End" in Tenacity and Triumph respectively.
* This is word-for-word the title of the first BF in the C path of ''[[Blaze Union]]''.
* This is word-for-word the title of the first BF in the C path of ''[[Blaze Union]]''.

== Web Comics ==
* The final panel of ''[[The Order of the Stick]]'' [[Prequel]] book ''On the Origins of PCs'' simply says, "The Beginning."

== Web Originals ==
* After the title of ''[[Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (novel)|Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows]]'' was revealed, the subsequent episode of [[Muggle Cast]] was called "The Beginning Of The End". When they got the release date, Andrew states that it was "the end of the beginning of the end".

== Real Life ==
* What Churchill is referring to in the above quote is that the worst part of [[World War II]] appeared to be over at that point; the threat of invasion of the UK by Germany was over, the United States entered the war full bore and a powerful alliance of those nations with the Soviet Union was established to give the Axis what for.
* Apollo 17 astronaut Gene Cernan frequently invoked this phrase motivationally during training for the final moon landing mission, believing that it should not be thought of as the end of the moon program, but just the "end of the beginning" of such exploration. Technicians would frequently tease him about this ("Hey, Geno, I keep forgetting -- is this the end or the beginning?"), and the phrase was humorously inserted (along with variations and subversions) at strategic points into the checklists Cernan would use on the lunar surface.


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:Ending Tropes]]
[[Category:Ending Tropes]]
[[Category:The End Of The Beginning]]
[[Category:The End of the Beginning]]
{{DEFAULTSORT:End of the Beginning, The}}
[[Category:Trope]]

Latest revision as of 22:18, 27 August 2023

"Now this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning."

Yeah, what he said.

When a writer tells a story, it usually involves some sort of significant change in the universe of the story, some kind of conflict which finds a resolution. After all, if there's no conflict, there's no story! We like reading about evil emperors getting overthrown and seeing their 100-year reign of oppression come to an end; reading about a peaceful nation with a peaceful king and citizens who are smart enough never to get into any trouble would be just as fun as watching paint dry.

But the story has to end somewhere, usually soon after the big climax and resolution. Thus, we are left to imagine how the world and its characters will live on after the story is over. The end of the story is the beginning of a new era.

For some reason, writers just love to point out this fact wherever possible. Expect a lot of them to mention "the beginning" with some sort of heavy significance.

Oh, and to make it even better—by the same token—sometimes the beginning of the story is referred to as "the end". It can get quite confusing.

See also: My Death Is Just the Beginning . Bears only a passing relation to the B-Movie Beginning of the End.

As an Ending Trope, Spoilers ahead may be unmarked. Beware.

Examples of The End of the Beginning include:

Anime and Manga

  • Alien Nine‍'‍s final anime episode was literally titled this trope, and it makes sense considering that, despite the series coming to a close, it reveals little pieces of what could be a possible intergalactic conspiracy.

Comic Books

  • Watchmen: "Nothing ends, Adrian. Nothing ever ends."
  • At the end of Chapter 8 of The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck, Scrooge was busy shooing off intruders of White Agony Creek, when his arm suddenly gives way of the weight of a big rock he lifts up.

Scrooge's thoughts: Great honk, this rock is heavy! how could it weigh so much unless...
Scrooge: ...Unless it's gold! Gotta rinse off the mud! A nugget this big would make me the richest man in the Klondike!
Scrooge's thoughts: But if it is gold, that will mean my quest is finished! I'll be rich! I'll never be the same again! Will clean air smell any sweeter? Will sunny days be ever brighter? Will starry nights hold any more wonder? Or will I lose all that? Do I really want to be... rich?
(Beat Panel...)
(He gains a glint in his eyes...)
Scrooge: Yes!!!
(He rinses off the mud. The rock is indeed a huge nugget of gold.)
Scrooge: It's gold! Solid gold! As big as a goose egg! Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha! I'm RICH!
(The last word echoes throughout the creek as Scrooge skips about in excitement.)
Random observing bird: ?
Narration Box: The Beginning...

Film

  • At the end of Anastasia: "It's a perfect ending!" "No. It's a perfect beginning."
  • Star Trek: First Contact closes with the first meeting between humanity and the Vulcans, starting a brand new era in human history and marking the beginning of the Trek Verse.
  • Jerry Lewis' The Nutty Professor ends, after a fake ending, with the words "the beginning", when Professor Kelp and Stella finally got together.
  • Oliver Stone's JFK, ends with "What is past is prologue."
    • The phrase is taken from William Shakespeare's The Tempest, and is engraved on the National Archives building in Washington, DC.
  • The final line of Attack of the Clones is, "Begun, the Clone War has."
  • The sci-fi B-Movie The Phantom Planet ends with the narrator stating that, as humanity continues to explore the cosmos, they'll discover even more amazing wonders. "This is only the beginning!"
  • Literally: At the end of the apocalyptic/time-travel sci-fi B-Movie Millennium (not related to the TV series of the same name), a solemn voice-over proclaims: "It is not the end! It is not the beginning of the end! It is the end of the beginning!"

Literature

  • The final book in the Animorphs series was titled "The Beginning".
  • The final chapter of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire was titled "The Beginning".
  • The Star Trek Expanded Universe novel Imzadi commences with a page reading "The End," then goes through "The End of the Beginning," "Epilogue," "The Beginning," "The Middle," and finally "The Beginning of the End." This comes of a story with a nonlinear narrative that also involves time travel.
  • The first chapter of the first book of The First Law trilogy is titled The End. The final chapter of the last book is titled The Beginning.
  • This was how The Last Battle -- the final book of the Chronicles of Narnia -- ended.
  • The final chapter of the third book in the Han Solo Trilogy features Han sitting in a cantina on some backwater planet and worrying about their financial debt to a crime lord. Chewie walks over to his table and tells him that he may have found the solution to their problems in an old man and a kid who need passage to Alderaan. Where most books say "The End," it says "The Beginning."
  • The Shadow Thieves by Anne Ursu is in four parts: "We begin in the middle", "Now the beginning", "The end of the beginning" and "The beginning of the end".

Live-Action TV

  • The pilot of Red Dwarf said "The End" at the beginning of the episode and "The Beginning" at the end of the episode.
  • Star Trek: Enterprise ends with a Distant Finale in which the Enterprise is decomissioned. But the point is made that Archer and his brave crews exploits laid the foundations for the Starfleet (and later ships called Enterprise) to "boldy go where no man has gone before..."

Music

Newspaper Comics

  • Flash Gordon kept going for decades after Ming the Merciless was overthrown, while the characters continued finding new and mostly non-Ming-related adventures to have.

Tabletop Games

  • Subverted in The Reconstruction. By the end of the story, the world is almost completely annihilated and has to be rebuilt practically from scratch -- it is definitely the beginning of a new era. However, it's never actually said anywhere that it's a new beginning -- even the phrase "reconstruction" is never mentioned.

Video Games

  • Dissidia Final Fantasy: "This isn't the end. Another dream is waiting to begin."
  • Mass Effect: Big Bad Sovereign is just the vanguard of the coming galactic invasion. Shepard, after being hailed as a hero by the powers that be, vows to find a way to stop the invasion and walks off, continuing his/her quest.
  • At the end of Princess Tutu, the series narrator states that Fakir is writing "a new story full of hope." (However, the title card shown right after this says "the end".)
  • In Resident Evil 2‍'‍s ending, the main characters exchange this dialog:

Leon: "It's finally over."
Claire: "It's not. I've got to my brother."
Leon: "You're right... this is just the beginning."

  • The Gears of War Trilogy has invoked this. They defeated the Locust and the equally-as-destructive Lambent Locust. However it's made clear that they are still far off from a happy ending. But for now they have earned their "Tomorrow".
  • "End of the Beginning" is level 1-10 of the Impetus area of Bit.Trip RUNNER, which signals the end of the tutorial levels. This is mirrored by "Middle of the Middle" and "Beginning of the End" in Tenacity and Triumph respectively.
  • This is word-for-word the title of the first BF in the C path of Blaze Union.

Web Comics

Web Originals

  • After the title of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows was revealed, the subsequent episode of Muggle Cast was called "The Beginning Of The End". When they got the release date, Andrew states that it was "the end of the beginning of the end".

Real Life

  • What Churchill is referring to in the above quote is that the worst part of World War II appeared to be over at that point; the threat of invasion of the UK by Germany was over, the United States entered the war full bore and a powerful alliance of those nations with the Soviet Union was established to give the Axis what for.
  • Apollo 17 astronaut Gene Cernan frequently invoked this phrase motivationally during training for the final moon landing mission, believing that it should not be thought of as the end of the moon program, but just the "end of the beginning" of such exploration. Technicians would frequently tease him about this ("Hey, Geno, I keep forgetting -- is this the end or the beginning?"), and the phrase was humorously inserted (along with variations and subversions) at strategic points into the checklists Cernan would use on the lunar surface.