Harry Potter/Fanfic Recs/General

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
< Harry Potter‎ | Fanfic Recs
Revision as of 21:27, 1 November 2013 by prefix>Import Bot (Import from TV Tropes TVT:FanficRecs.HarryPotterGeneral 2012-07-01, editor history TVTH:FanficRecs.HarryPotterGeneral, CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported license)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)


These are recommendations made by Tropers for Harry Potter general fanfic, all of which have to be signed to stay on the page. Feel free to add a fanfic of your own to the list, but remember to use the template found here.

You can also add to the current recommendations if you want. Refrain from posting Conversation in The Main Page though; that goes in the discussion page.

Conversion from the "Comments" section to the "Reviews" option is underway. If you are adding a fic, please help us out and use the new template-format on the Fanfic Recommendations Index Page. Please start moving your comments to the reviews sections as we will soon start removing them.

Stories focused on the family and the friendly relationships of the cast. Plot-focused stories or light day-in-the-life stories. Pretty much anything that doesn't fit into one of the other folders.

I'll Fight For you by Hazelmist

  • Recommended by Drjafjaf, Hiraku Joutei
  • Synopsis: Set in the Marauder Era, this fanfic tells the story of Lily and James' 6th year from Lily's point of view.
  • Comments: There are some elements of a typical Marauder Era fic, but this one by far surpasses all others. The writing is excellent and well thought out, the plot revolves around more than just belligerent sexual tension, and the characters are all done justice by the author. In particular, the last section epilogue of the story is one of the most powerful things I have even read, both in published work and fiction.


Harry Potter and the Boy Who Lived by The Santi

  • Recommended by Sweece, User:Magic Kirby
  • Synopsis: Harry Potter loves, and is loved by, his parents, his godfather, and his brother. He isn't mistreated, abused, or neglected. So why is he a Dark Wizard? Non BWL!Harry. Not your typical Harry's brother is the Boy Who Lived story.
  • Comments: An excellent fic with a more intelligent interesting Harry who isn't overpowered or bound by the chains of Destiney (or some such crap).
    • Magic Kirby: The fanfiction link is no longer being updated, the up to date story can be found on Dark Lord Potter Here. About a third of the way down the page of the link is where it picks up from where fanfiction left off. And please for the love of god don't post anything in the story thread.


Thou Shalt Not Suffer by The Wizards Harry

  • Recommended by Liquid-Molasses, mermaidgirl45
  • Synopsis: An emotionally realistic take on the idea of a fundamentalist Christian being invited to Hogwarts.
  • Comments: Still in-progress but interesting so far, and it deals with the issue without being anti-religion.
    • Seconded--a little cautiously--by User:Mthe R. The first couple chapters have a few persistent spelling errors and typos, but nothing distracting. The OC at the center of the story is flawed but likeable, and the representation of Slytherin so far looks to be one of the most balanced and realistic I've seen in a fanfiction. Mostly I'm recommending because it's the first Harry Potter fanfiction in ages to hold my attention past the fifth chapter.
    • For those of you who were put off by the "Christian!" thing, as I was, give this fic a chance. The main character is very likable and the whole thing is great fun. I was expecting a religious rant, but got one of my favorite OC fanfics. Also, calling Lockhart "Captain Vainglory" is made of win.


Apprentice Potter and its sequels, Journeyman Potter and Master Potter (in progress) by Draco664 (All AU)

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, User:Unclouded TJ
  • Synopsis: A Harry Potter Alternate Universe that diverges shortly after the events of Order of the Phoenix. Instead of letting Harry return to Hogwarts for his sixth year, Mad-Eye Moody arranges an apprenticeship for him, with a mysterious and infuriating new master.
  • Comments: Includes Fem!Blaise, Angry!Angry!Really Angry!Harry, and poly shipping.
    • User:Nornagest: Technically competent and usually enjoyable. Unfortunately it makes a few fanficcy structural mistakes -- but my standards are ridiculously high, and I did manage to get through it anyway.


The Most Grievous and Lamentable Tragedy of the Death of Lord Voldemort by rowen_r

  • Recommended by User:Micah, User:Across The Stars, boonerunner, Fenro, Hiraku Joutei
  • Synopsis: Harry Potter meets Jacobean revenge tragedy.
  • Comments: Written pre-Half Blood Prince. Has stage directions like "[In a manner suggestive of profound, puppy-kicking evil]" and "[Makes frightening groaning noises just for the hell of it, the scamp]".
    • It's probably twice as funny for anyone familiar with Renaissance literature, especially Shakespeare and Marlowe, so English majors, theatre majors, and AP Lit students will probably laugh harder than anyone else.
  • Thirded--or is it fourth-ed?--by Ms. Byrd. Note that above troper is spot-on, however.


A Bad Week At The Wizengamot by DisobedienceWriter

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, Comartemis, Ms. Byrd, lanky, Chuckg, User:Dor, User:Riti Troll, User:Seraviel, timeywimey, T7F, The Otaku Ninja, User:Dragon Riding Sorceress
  • Synopsis: After Harry Potter is convicted by the Wizengamot for defending himself against the dementors the summer after his fourth year and goes wandless into exile, Cornelius Fudge is certain all is now well with the world. At least until Harry's revenge begins...
  • Comments: Funny short story set in an Alternate Universe that looks much bleaker than canon... at least at first. Features Cornelius Fudge as the ultimate Pointy-haired Boss.
    • Seconded by User:Comartemis: Best Humiliation Conga I've ever read. Just make sure you aren't drinking anything while you read.
    • Thirded by Ms. Byrd, as she's convinced this fic is undiluted Crowning Moment of Funny. For that matter, she's convinced author DisobedienceWriter is made of Crowning Moment of Awesome.
    • This. This is how you perform a Humiliation Conga.
    • Elenor: I will recommend this as soon as I can stop laughing long enough to type.
    • User:Dor heartily * counts on fingers* sixths this, although he finds the second chapter -- Sirius's efforts to fix the Ministry of Magic -- even more appealing than the Humiliation Conga in the first chapter.
    • User:Riti Troll just wants to repeat that the second chapter is just as awesome in a different way, but the third didn't hold her interest for more than a few paragraphs.
    • T7F 8ths This: BURRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRN!
    • User:The Rich Sheik 9ths This: It is immensely satisfying to see Fudge and wizarding britain get torn apart piece by piece. However the third chapter doesn't live up to the standards set by the first two chapters.
    • 10'th by The Otaku Ninja, as someone who despised how wizarding world treated Harry through the last few books, this was a breath of fresh air to her...
    • Subzero008: I did not like the way it portrayed certain characters; some may find this annoying, like me. But for the most part, loved it.

Eternal Return by Silver Pard

  • Recommended by: User:Looney Toons, chimeras, 0Wraith, Fenro
  • Synopsis: Harry finds himself reincarnated as a newborn Tom Marvolo Riddle, decades in the past. Can he do what he needs to in order to ensure that he is born and lives out the life he remembers? Can he bear the cost?
  • Comments: Dark, heartbreaking and ultimately creepy.
    • Definitely seconded, even if you saw it coming, the ending is still chilling.
    • 0Wraith: This is one of the best Harry Potter oneshots I've ever read. Very dark, very devastating. Silver Pard writes brilliant Death Note fics too, if you're into that fandom.


The Book of Dobby: Per Arcana ad Astra by Doghead Thirteen

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, User:Comartemis
  • Synopsis: While obsessively cleaning Colin Creevy's stacks of nerd paraphernalia, Dobby stumbles on a book about The Battle Of Britain and takes a liking to the idea of big metal birds blowing shit up. A few weeks later after Voldemort's return, Harry is trying to think of ways to fight Voldemort and his Death Eaters when Dobby offers a solution involving magic, elves, and World War II air power. "TURNS OUTS THEM LIGHTSES! IS YOUS NOT KNOWING THERE IS BEING A WAR ON?"
  • Comments: One of the most warped and entertaining Potter stories I've ever encountered. Words cannot describe just how twisted and fun this story is -- it must be read to be believed. Completely unlike any other Harry Potter fic in existence. Incomplete, but still being written by an active author.
    • User:Comartemis: A fic that absolutely refuses to take itself seriously, this is gloriously crack-tastic and a joy to read; my only complaint is that there isn't enough of it. Conspicuously avoids Evil!Dumbledore despite invoking the same Fridge Logic that generally leads to that characterization (he's not evil, he's just senile). Also, watch for 40K and Girl Genius shout-outs including a surprise appearance by the Jägers!
    • User:Sinclair: This story is uterly hilarious and Dobby's (and his fellow elves') antics will leave you unable to breathe from sheer laughter many, many times. The best part? For all the crack, it could actually work!


Reclamation by Sam the Storyteller

  • Recommended by Lavanya Six, boonerunner
  • Synopsis: In an alternate universe, one man still struggles with a moral decision made many years before.
  • Comments: My favorite HP one-shot. It explores the life and mind of Tom Riddle in a world where, like a recovering alcoholic, he makes an conscious effort each day to not turn Dark.
    • Seconded by User:Thanos 6. Much like Dexter, this fic explores someone who is essentially a sociopath who is just barely clinging to morality by his fingernails.


Measure for Measure by Grover Cleveland

  • Recomended by Radiofreak
  • Synopsis: Harry Potter's fifth year. Featuring a sarcastic!/slightly independent!/STRAIGHT!Harry Harry/Daphne
  • Comments: One of the best HP fanfics I have had the pleasure of reading, with a very well done first person view of a slightly mad Harry. Features Harry getting paid in virgins outside of a crackfic.


Fair Trade by BajaB

  • Recommended by Ithanyx, User:Unclouded TJ, boonerunner
  • Synopsis: Harry confronts Voldemort after his sixth year at Hogwarts with an alternate reason for some of the Dark's Lord's failures, and offers to help him out, for a price.
  • Comments: A fantastic ret-con fic which shows an interesting idea of what a power that Voldemort knows not could be like.


Bungle in the Jungle and its sequel, Turn Me Loose by jbern

  • Recommended by User:Dor, User:Looney Toons, User:Foo Fighter, Chuckg, lanky, oruma
  • Synopsis: Harry Potter escapes one of Dumbledore's plans to manipulate him by following Bill Weasley on an expedition to South America, where they find far more than they bargained for.
  • Comments: Very few authors use the second person successfully; Bungle in the Jungle is among the best of the exceptions. The story can be a bit intimidating for the first chapter or two, between the point of view and the first chapter being in non-chronological order. Stick with it, and you find a cast of thoroughly-developed original characters, an insightful look into what a cursebreaker actually does, and one of the best climactic battle sequences in fanfiction. Be warned: There's a pretty significant amount of Hermione- and Weasley-bashing, although the sequel redeems them somewhat.
    • User:Looney Toons: I particularly like his take on Luna Lovegood, which makes perfect sense in this setting. Also note that this story does not end conclusively, but its sequel picks up where "Bungle" left off.
    • Comartemis: I'm not sure what to think about this one. On the one hand, Evil!Weasleys and Manipulative!Dumbledore are some of my all-time least favorite cliches, and the fact that Hermione gets similar treatment is another punch in the gut, and her later "redemption" doesn't do much to improve the situation. Setting those things aside, however, it's a damn good fic and probably one of the better Luna/Harry fics I've read.
    • User:Foo Fighter: From reading this and The Lie I've Lived I'm willing to say that jbern writes THE best combat/duel scenes I've seen in any Fanfic.
    • Chuckg: I recommend this fic highly, especially to any Bill Weasley fan or anyone who wants to see jbern's take on what a Curse Breaker really does for a living. Magical Indiana Jones vs. the Zombie Apocalypse of the Ruined City is worth the price of admission all by itself. However, I stopped reading the series after the action got back to England in the sequel, but that's just me.
    • lanky: This is worth the price of admission and the strange second-person perspective JUST for the fact that Ron is not Ron the Death Eater. Despite the fact that the Weasley Clan, Bill and maybe Charlie aside, have been an absolute bunch of manipulative bastards, the first thing he does when he gets the chance to talk to Harry is apologize profusely and try to stand by him. Honestly, I wasn't a fan of the demonization to that point, but it makes sense in context: Dumbledore presents something that might just win the war. Of course the Weasleys, OotP members through and through, would do it, especially when it was a case of making Harry happy. It's a grim, grim reminder of what the Harry Potter series could have been if Dumbledore was just a bit more of a bastard. Hell, it's worth the price of admission just for the Alternate Character Interpretation of Luna Lovegood, who becomes something more than some batshit crazy girl spouting moonspeak.


Taking Control and Free Life, by "fake a smile"

  • Recommended by Chuckg, User:Unclouded TJ
  • Synopsis: Sirius' ghost hangs around after OoTP to help Harry get over his death and train him, leading to a Harry who enters year 6 with an iron determination to grow up and take his fate in his own hands and fight the war against Voldemort on his own terms. Meanwhile, the "Golden Trio" splits apart when Harry won't let them in on his new plans, leaving Ginny (and later Remus) as his only confidants. Independent!Harry and Genuinely-Well-Meaning-But-Stiflingly-Manipulative!Dumbledore. Taking Control is complete; its sequel Free Life is incomplete but in progress.
  • Pairings: Harry/Ginny
  • Comments: Although the main focus of the story is not the romance, this still has one of the best-developed Harry/Ginny romances ever. The pacing is delightfully appropriate, the author has a fine grasp of subtlety, and the plot is interesting and without obvious holes. Unlike most other Manipulative!Dumbledore fics, the Dumbledore in this one is neither using inappropriate methods or has evil intentions, he's just idealistically misguided. And while Harry's more kickarse than canon, this isn't remotely near a Super!Harry fic. Indeed, the only possible negative note is that Ron and Hermione do not come off well in this fic -- its hardly Ron the Death Eater territory, but Ron gets to be the clueless git again, and Hermione has her bossy know-it-all tendencies taken to positively Flanderized levels. So, Ron and Hermione fans have been warned.
    • Not so sure that it's not a bit of a Super!Harry fic, what with the dual animagus forms and the superfast learning cool stuff over the summer. The mandatory shopping splurge can't be avoided but it's a nice enough read apart from that.


The Innocence of Guilt by ENSIGN

  • Recommended by User:Unclouded TJ
  • Synopsis: Harry Potter was sentenced to Azkaban prison. However he never went there. Who is this James Pathertrory who's running around the world causing problems for the Death Eaters?


Make A Wish by Rorschach's Blot

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, Chuckg, Elenor, UnseenVoice, lanky
  • Synopsis: After learning the prophecy, Harry comes to the conclusion there's no way he can win against Voldemort. And if that's the case, he decides he has to get in as much living as he can before he must return to the conflict. But in the process of the whirlwind round-the-world tour he takes under an assumed name as result of that decision, he inadvertently creates a mythic figure of such proportions that even Voldemort begins to fear him.
  • Comments: An enjoyable, funny story despite the author's primitive grasp of the technical rudiments of writing and the somewhat anticlimactic ending. Watching how the Wizarding World creates the myth of "Mr. Black" by misunderstanding or selectively re-interpreting the information and stories left in Harry's wake is worth the occasional frustration with Blot's style, as is the scale to which the myth eventually grows -- and how Harry reacts when he finally learns what his "last vacation before dying" has wrought. (Be warned, though, that Make A Wish starts slowly -- although the lead-up has some good if low-key humor, the funniest stuff really doesn't start to kick in until the end of chapter 10.) Anyway, don't take this story seriously -- just sit back and enjoy it. It has a sequel, The Hunt for Harry Potter, which isn't quite as good in my opinion, but is still fun to read.
    • The writing is amateurish, but the plot is original and engaging, the OCs interesting, and the humor spot-on.
    • lanky adds: The more the story goes on, the less entertaining it gets, I found. It's an interesting read, but Harry quickly becomes a Boring Invincible Hero when he stops being mistaken for a huge, powerful badass and actually becomes one. Especially after the story abandons humor to take the serious route. Honestly, the story could have been a lot better had it just stuck to the premise. It's still worth a read, however.


Warrior's Heir by Osireia (AU)

  • Recommended by User:Unclouded TJ, abcd_z
  • Synopsis: Harry is thrown into a world where purebloods are discriminated against, Tom Riddle is the Boy Who Lived, and the Dark Lord...is someone he'd never suspect. Will his emerging abilities be enough? Should he support Riddle -- or the Dark Lord?


The Alexandra Quick series by Inverarity: the Thorn Circle, the Lands Below, and the Deathly Regiment and the Stars Above (Very completely AU)

  • Recommended by FrankRonaldOrion, User:Unclouded TJ, Chaosjunction
  • Synopsis: This story has next to nothing to do with the characters in the Harry Potter series; it has everything to do with the Harry Potter world. Set in the United States, where the Confederation, a government in political turmoil, has problems with revolutionaries and warring cultures. It focuses on Alexandra Quick, a Muggle-born girl who goes to Charmbridge Academy and discovers a lot about not only magic and the wizarding world, but about herself as well.
  • Comments: If you liked Hogwarts Houses Divided by the same author you will most definitely like this one. The setting feels natural and sucks you in, and the characters are memorable and detailed. The first two stories are complete, but a third is on the way. I really hope he goes on to finish the entire series with seven stories total; Alexandra Quick is a lot more than fanfiction. In fact, it's closer to the Star Wars novels set in earlier eras with less Lucas guidance than it is to fanfiction. Got me teary eyed near the end of the second one, too.
    • White Hat: It is good to know I am not the only one who got teary eyed. An excellent version of Wizarding America, though definitely not how I would have done it.
    • User:Shay Guy: I just read the first one, and I'm not seeing any AU. But I would like to note that in HP canon, transfiguring people into animals alters their minds considerably, and I'm not entirely sure the Fidelius Charm works that way. Nevertheless, the fact that I blazed through it in one night when I should've either been sleeping or doing homework says a lot about it.
    • Blufox: I fell in love with the series from the first chapter of Thorn Circle. It's riveting, and I have yet to see any proof that any of the characters are Mary Sues, a sign of a great story, especially since every character is original. Inverarity has started on the third book of the series, Deathly Regiment, which really focuses on Alex's reaction to Max's death. Personally, I vote on Alex having her own trope page.
    • Khajmer: I love Inverarity's style. It's very reminiscent to me of J.K. in the delivery, but in terms of the content it's much more thought provoking. There is no clear black or white, plenty of wash of gray. The way The Lands Below ended had me in tears, and the Deathly Regiment had some serious philosophical implications that set me to thinking. Beyond that, I particularly love the way Inverarity takes similar character developing situations to Harry Potter and shows how Alexandra, an entirely different character, goes through them (for example, her insistence in Deathly Regiment on finding a way to bring Max back versus Harry's steady acceptance of Sirius dying) All in all I give it a big thumbs up and second Blufox's motion for her own page.
    • Qwerfvtgb here and GOD, I loved this series. I read it straight through in one day because it was just that awesome. You can tell it's the same world as Harry Potter's, but if you took out the little connections and replaced them with something else, like removing house elves and using the Clockwork Golems entirely, it could be published as an actual book. Heck, it can be published as an actual book now. It should at least. TROPE PAGE.
    • Handfoc: due to the rising HSQ of recent Stars Above chapters, I have gone ahead and stared an Alexandra Quick trope page. Let's get to work people!


A Place For Warriors by owlsaway

  • Recommended by User:Sharysa, Fenro
  • Synopsis: A fifteen-chapter Bottle Episode begins as Dumbledore locks Harry and Snape in the Room of Requirement for a week, and as the focus on Snape and Harry's interaction is very tight even after they manage to get out, the cast is still less than ten people. The author mentions that it is not, nor will it ever be, slash. Work-in-progress.
  • Comments: The explosive mesh of "screwed-up-teenager" plus "screwed-up-adult" strikes a very weird but audible chord, and Dumbledore is presented as a flawed human rather than an emotionless chessmaster. The interactions between Snape and Harry are excrutiatingly powerful once they realize their similarities, and this is twenty-five chapters of Talking Heads that you will not resist reading out loud. And that friend you rope into reading with you won't mind, either.
    • User:Shay Guy: Excellent characterization indeed, but be warned that it falls into the common fanfic trap of overdoing the Dursleys' abuse. (I mean, really, Harry considering suicide at age seven?)


The Dagger of Foreboding by Lord Drash

  • Recommended by The Omegod
  • Synopsis: A supposed AU of the Harry Potter series with the characters searching for the above-mentioned, Dagger of Foreboding.
  • Comments: Honestly this is nearly impossible to describe. It is probably one of, if not the most hilarious fanfic ever made for several reasons. First, it's written in an awkward style rife with inconsistencies and contradictions and can be a biting parody of Harry Potter fanfiction as a whole. Oh, and it has the best similes ever.


The Brave New World, by 'bellerophon30'

  • Recommended by Chuckg
  • Premise: After year 5, Harry Potter hits the limit of his frustration and flees to Magical America to continue his schooling. Interweaves Slice of Life as Harry and a cast of OCs become friends and come of age at the Great Lakes Magical Institute, and wartime and espionage drama as events in England conspire to draw Harry back into the war against Voldemort.
  • Pairing: Harry/OC
  • Comments: This fic has one of the best portrayals of Rufus Scrimgeour as a competent, intelligent, politically adept and thoroughly ruthless Minister of Magic I've seen in Harry Potter fic. The cast of OCs is well-detailed and developed, and Harry's OC girlfriend avoids the obvious pitfalls. Although Ron Hermione have the hardest time adjusting to Harry's sudden absence, no character gets Ron the Death Eater treatment -- not even Manipulative!Dumbledore, who is built up over the fic into an antagonist figure second only to Voldemort in Harry's view, only to have a shocking twist ending to his saga. At over 865,000 words, the author spends a tremendous amount of effort detailing his version of Magical America, the events of the war against Voldemort, and the political machinations surrounding Harry Potter, Scrimgeour, Dumbledore, and the Wizengamot. Contains everything from romantic comedy to technothriller espionage drama. Ends on its own personal 'in the far future' epilogue/happy ending. Goes heavily AU in some elements, most notably in the split between Voldemort and Greyback, the lack of horcruxes, the Alternate Character Interpretation of Dumbledore, and a significantly more intelligent and dangerous Peter Pettigrew. Highly recommended.
    • mvdwege: Tentatively recommended. The Harry vs. the Order of the Phoenix dynamic is interesting, and fairly well written. Unfortunately the fic is marred by some bad writing that can be really jarring at times: expository asides that read more like private notes from the author to themselves, stilted dialogue, awkward paragraph breaks, and a romantic subplot that really does not develop at all, but is just stated to happen in about one chapter's worth of prose.


Unequivocally Unusual, by Quantum Cat

  • Recommended by User:Comartemis
  • Synopsis: Fate kicks Harry in the teeth in his second year when Ron and Hermione are both petrified by the basilisk. With the rest of the school villifying him worse than ever and nobody left to turn to, Harry begins to break down... until coincidince throws him a bone. A rather loony bone.
  • Comments: Now here's something you don't see every day; a Harry/Luna friendship fic. No soul bonds, no "twu wuv!", and no use of Obfuscating Stupidity to turn Luna into a Possession Sue. A very engaging take on what it would take for these two to hit it off and what happens when you mix Lovegood-brand insanity into Harry's usual adventures. Highly recommended, but it seems to be dead; it's been on hiatus since April of '09.


Poison Pen, by Genkai Fan

  • Recommended By User:Mandrke, User:Unclouded TJ, User:Looney Toons
  • Synopsis: "Harry has had enough of seeing his reputation shredded in the Daily Prophet and decides to do something about it. Only he decides to embrace his Slytherin side to rectify matters." As quoted from the author's page.
  • Comments: It has its ups and downs but the overall story has enough twists and turns to keep you interested. The plot revolves around the wizarding world's reaction to the writings of one "Oliver Twist" during the summer between the 4th and 5th book and goes on from there. It brings up some good points about how stupid the wizarding world can be, especially during wartime. It's also a finished work with the author ruling out sequels or side stories, so what you see is all you'll get.


To Fight The Coming Darkness by jbern

  • Recommended by lanky
  • Synopsis: Susan Bones was with Amelia Bones when Voldemort came to kill her. Unfortunately for him, Harry was there to stop him. Essentially, the story diverges rapidly after the events of the fifth book, with Harry managing to catch Voldemort off of his guard and injuring him. This enrages Harry's powerful foe into taking him completely seriously, causing reality to ensue.
  • Comments: This story rapidly gets darker and darker as it progresses, with both Harry and Voldemort not pulling their punches. While jbern's work is always leaning towards cynicism on the sliding scale, this work takes Anyone Can Die to new levels and develops some characters into quite believable monsters. This is a world where Voldemort becomes very Dangerously Genre Savvy, forcing Harry to ditch being The Messiah in order to examine exactly how far he's willing to go to beat Voldemort and to discover the simple truth that Good Is Not Nice. Brilliantly written, as always, and it gets bonus points for lots and lots of Character Development, not all of which is good for the characters involved.
    • Unseen Voice: Really good story with a believable real-world-approach to the Wizards War. There are no true heroes in this story, just survivors who are ready to do anything it takes to win, leading to an egregious amount of What the Hell Hero moments. I disliked the Bittersweet Ending with hints of a sequel, but that's just my preference of reading stories with a definite closure. A good read.


My Immortal Refined by Evilkritter of Youtube


The Potions Master's Nephew

  • Recommended By: Kittastrophe
  • Synopsis: An accident occurs and Professor Snape finds himself trapped in his fifteen-year-old body. Enrolled into Harry Potter's fifth year, he is forced to hide his true identity. Girls, drama and teenage angst do not bode well with Severus.
  • Comments: Probably my favourite "Fountain of Youth" fic. The writing is beautifully done and the plot development is excellent. It eventually contains some Draco/Ginny (well-written, I add). It looked like a deadfic for a while, but when the author eventually finished it, the edited version was put up all at once. Anyway, excellent characterization, and who doesn't want to read youthified!Snape? It's fun!


The Serpent of Lord Voldemort by Angie Astravic

  • Recommended by User:Leradny
  • Synopsis: Harry can turn into a snake. This power saves him when Voldemort turns up at Privet Drive and blows up the (empty) Dursley's house -- instead of killing Harry on sight, Voldemort just thinks he's a real snake who can recognize Harry Potter, and takes him prisoner.
  • Comments: Voldemort has some of the oddest yet most in-character Pet The Snake moments EVER.
    • This fic is the fourth in a series of fics: An Unwelcome Visitor, Under the Rose Bush, The Serpent
    • Aryllia: There are some vague part in the plots that the author cover by including a Q&A session in the end of each chapter. I can't say that I in any way see why the author couldn't just as well have enforced these part in-story, as well as why spoilers seem to be given out there.


Realizations by Wishweaver.

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, User:Seraviel, User:Dor
  • Synopsis: A Harry Potter fic set in the summer after Goblet of Fire -- Harry comes back from Hogwarts to discover the Dursleys have packed up and moved to Australia without telling him, and he must find a way to survive the summer without unnecessarily alarming anyone.
  • Comments: Incomplete, but not a Dead Fic despite the long period between chapters -- the latest chapter was posted (after a two-year hiatus) in November, 2010.
    • What's especially notable about this fic is that the Fridge Logic employed is never condescending to Canon and that nobody is villified- even the way that Harry's abuse escaped the notice of the Order and the Ministry is covered in an amazingly believable way (One Ministry social worker mistakes Petunia's violent reaction against Magic as protectiveness and shielding Harry from potential Death Eaters!), and once I got over Figg being a full witch and not a squib, my suspension of disbelief has never wavered.


Magical Moments by Pittsburghmuggle. Sexual imagery and discussion, but no actual sex by or between the characters. Erotic issues at the very least, though. Set between Goblet of Fire and Order of the Phoenix, which is when it was written.

  • Pairings: None. No romance ahead.
  • Synopsis: Following some information given to him by his brothers, Ron Weasley takes Harry Potter to sneak into a store in Diagon Alley catering to adult wizard clientele. A friend joins them at the last moment, and there is a thrilling escape involved when the owners arrive to open the store for the day.


The Founder's Pendants, by Spiral Digger

  • Recommended by Oracle Seven, Fenro
  • Synopsis: The spirit of Salazar Slytherin has been released into an unwilling Snape and as the charismatic Founder takes charge of his body, Severus discovers the only way to regain control is through his own Slytherin cunning.
  • Comments: A definite AU that diverges rather forcefully from the main plot of the books in the first chapter. Salazar comes across as a Magnificent Bastard right from the beginning, and it only gets better as the story continues.
    • There are so few well-written Founder Fics out there. It is good to see one that is enjoyable.


Dimension Hopping For Beginners, by nonjon

  • Recommended by User:Khym Chanur
  • Synopsis: After defeating Voldemort, Harry travels to other universes and helps them with their Voldemort problems.
  • Comments: Several of the universes are serious, but most of them are comedic. Contains bashing of Draco, Snape, and Harry/Draco.


Renegade Cause by Silens Cursor

  • Recommended by User:USA Bobcat, Vazeron1
  • Synopsis: At the start of Order of the Phoenix, the Ministry comes to take Harry into custody for using a Patronus charm in front of a Muggle. Harry, warned by Dumbledore to not let them destroy his wand, defends himself. Things change.
  • Comments: An in-depth look at the darker arts of Magic, the darker forms of politics, and the darker morals. And not just Voldemort or Fudge, for once.. Harry makes difficult decisions, Voldemort delves in Spell Creation, and it is very violent.


Sounds Like a Breakfast Cereal by Ara Kane

  • Recommended by User:Mthe R
  • Synopsis: In his fifth year, Harry finally gets to take a vacation. Join Hex Holmstrom as he dodges arrest from the Ministry, gets the girl, beats the bad guy, and turns Hufflepuff House upside down! This story was written prior to the release of "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix."
  • Comments: I like this one because it takes the badfic staple of "American witch/wizard comes to Hogwarts," and keeps the core idea (let's follow someone new and different and see all their wacky fun adventures!) but sorts the OC into Hufflepuff, a house which sorely needs some wacky fun adventures. It's probably not for everyone, though.


Happy Birthday Mr. Dark Lord by After the Rain

  • Recommended by Valjean, User:Shadow AI, Mazz
  • Synopsis: Lord Voldemort announces that he's going to celebrate his birthday with Sugar Quills, Pin-the-Beak-on-the-Hippogriff, and Death Eaters in hula skirts. Has he finally lost his mind, or is somebody crazy like a fox?
  • Comments: Achieves what all short pieces should strive for -- packing a lot of meaning into a few paragraphs. Starts out sounding like a hilarious, highly random crackfic, twists into what seems to be a great light-hearted humor piece, and finally whiplashes at the end into one of the most horrifically bleak, dark, gut-wrenching, tragic slaps in the face this troper has ever read. The simple, two-word line "They won't." hurts like punch in the stomach.


Winter's Debt by La Guera.

  • Recommended by Eoppen.
  • Synopsis: Draco Malfoy tells the story of the little sister he found he had, and why she had to be hidden from the world.
  • Comments: Warning: This one is serious Tear Jerker material. If you don't start crying at some point in the story, you have no soul.


Marshmallows by Glockgal

  • Recommended by Wookiee
  • Synopsis: Summer with the Weasleys. Harry and friends go camping, and bring some muggle marshmallows along. Set in the summer after fourth year, written before Order of the Phoenix came out.
  • Comments: Possibly the most beautiful piece of fanfiction this troper has read in her life, in any fandom. The powerful but understated characterization, the surprising drops of darkness and angst mixed with the strong, homey, familial tone, and the simple, childlike emotions were enough to bring tears to her eyes. The style is brief, but too descriptive to truly be called sparse. The various events are full of unanalyzed meaning that are addressed by the characters' reactions and never explained by an omniscient author, giving it the feeling of poetry and lingering in the reader's mind long after the story is finished.


In Blood Only by E.M. Snape

  • Recommended by Fenro, lanky
  • Synopsis: Snape is Harry's father. No one is happy to hear it. R due to colorful language, dark themes, and nongraphic violence.
  • Comments: This is one of the best Severitus Challenge fics out there. This story is complete. See Severitus for challenge details.
    • lanky adds: This is one of those stories that seems too silly to truly enjoy, and then it turns around and surprises you. Though the author pulls no punches and makes sure that we all know people suck, he adds in some truly poignant scenes which help to characterize the growing relationship between Harry and Snape. It's all topped by the fact that there's truly wonderful writing going on with this story, and again, the author pulls no punches: The duo hate one another even after the revelation, and it takes chapters and chapters before they even begin to stand one another, let alone begin to bond in any way.


Fire Burns by Purple Banana/Parnopius

  • Recommended by skysong8, Aerin Alanna
  • Synopsis: Set in Marauder time, seventh year, but centered around the Slytherins. Second in the trilogy (Carpe Diem, Fallen Angel). Currently being revised. Revolves around Katherine Riddle (Voldemort's daughter), her friend Remus, and her fellow Slytherins during their seventh year at Hogwarts. Not your traditional OC.
  • Comments: Marauder time -- start of 7th year at Hogwarts. Great characterization. Complex, occasionally dark, often hilarious.
    • Aerin Alanna adds: Snarky, silly, dangerous, enigmatic...it's brilliantly written and extremely believable. There are other fics that go along with it, all of which are on the author's sites at ff.net and Chamber of Secrets.


Ananke by Eunike

  • Recommended by FatRat, User:Tender Lumpling, Fenro
  • Pairings: Severus Snape/Lily Evans
  • Synopsis: An accident sends the nineteen-year-old Lily Evans eighteen years into the future, and a coincidence leads her to her former best friend, Severus Snape. Lost in a terrible world she no longer recognizes, Lily is torn between doing what she is supposed to do, and doing what she thinks is right. Can Lily change her fate, or must she succumb to what was meant to be? Meanwhile, Severus can't believe his own luck when he realizes that he's given another chance to save Lily, and to finally tell her how he really feels -– but is he brave enough to take that chance?
  • Comments: sort of AU but fits very well with canon in the Authors own words "time-travel. Tad confusing. Severus is mostly depressed, Lily has an odd sense of humour. Multichaptered and kind of long. Angst! Angst! Glorious angst!"
    • Very well-done, especially Lily's reaction to finding herself seventeen years in the future, and her complete shock at how things have unfolded. Still in-progress, but the next chapters will be worth waiting for.
    • This is among the best LE/SS fics out there.


The Lies That Bind

  • Recommended by User:Willyolio
  • Synopsis: Takes place mid-HBP and Harry gets captured and tortured for months. Quite a few twists for such a short fic, but it features a Dark!Harry and a good interpretation of the prophecy (marked as an equal and power he knows not). Also has a satisfying, but unhappy, ending.


The Third Wizarding War: The Story of Miles Brand by McJunker

  • Recommended by McJunker
  • Synopsis: An ex-Auror, a Pureblood supremacist, and a Muggle-born criminal are on the run during the Dark Lord's second acension. At least one Moral Event Horizon once per story arc.
  • Comments: Darkfic. Lots of swearing and violence had by all. Basically, what would happen if a trio of villains instead of heroes were on the run during Deathly Hallows?


The Wall by brenners

  • Recommended by mermaidgirl45
  • Synopsis: What if, in Hogwarts, there was a wall in the girls bathroom where there was a list of all the guys in the school, rated from 1 - 10?
  • Comments: This is a great fic. It's really interesting, and funny, and it's sticks with the characters. It comes highly recommended.


Man-eaters of Kumaon by ignipes

  • Recommended by Goodwrench
  • Synopsis: April, 1982. Remus Lupin travels to India to track a creature that has been devouring villagers in the Himalayan foothills.
  • Comments: A Lost Years fic. The author does an amazing job of portraying the local color, and this is an excellent action/adventure story as well.


Carnival Of Dark And Dangerous Creatures by DragonDi

  • Recommended by Goodwrench
  • Synopsis: Four years ago, Remus Lupin lost his friends to death and betrayal. Now he finds himself betrayed once more, and in a place where death may very well be preferred.
  • Comments: Great adventure story. The author's written several other fine works as well.


Ashes by killing_rose

  • Recommended by User:Those Dancing Days
  • Synopsis: Rose is your surrender. You will not, cannot, be a Muggle now. You are not going to get another chance to escape.
  • Comments: Chilling and memorable; this one will haunt me for years. The POV allows some of the story bits to resonate on a personal level that's achingly disturbing.


With Malice Aforethought and And Malice Towards None by SPSmith

  • Recomended by Shinji117
  • Synopsis: An alternate 6th year. But surprisingly believable. Avoids Ron, Albus or Ginny The Death Eaters. A very possible what-could-have-been. Harry takes the death of Sirius rather badly, and decides to take things seriously (but realistically. No time-turner training, insta-god-mode from Founder inheritance etc) in 6th year.
  • Pairings: Start of fic- Ron/Hermione, Harry/Ginny, end of WMA- Harry/Hermione, Ron/Luna.
  • Comments: This is actually very good. Normally alternate year stories have Harry somehow gain power overnight (be it via time travel, inheritance or divine intervention). This story avoids that, and gives Harry a realistic power increase in proportion to the work he is putting in. This story has no moments that truly are canon-breaking (well, Crabbe and Goyle are a tad Leather Pantsified as unbelievable as that sounds). Voldermort is a tad passive at the start, but that does change later on. Even those who normally hate H/Hr probably won't mind as it comes off believably after all the main characters undergo quite a lot of well-written development. No-one really acts out of character other than Crabbe, Goyle and Dawlish. Now if only SPSmith would continue the sequel...


A Second Chance at Life by Miranda Flairgold

  • Recommended by rheasilviadiroma
  • Pairings: M/M, M/F
  • Synopsis: A Second Chance at Life and its sequels, Changes in a Time of War and A Magical World is a realistic take on the overdone 'Harry gets into a new school' cliche. It's a complete AU of Deathly Hallows, and features a much more diverse magical world, new forms of magic (which are fully explained by the story instead of Applied Phlebotinum). Unfortunately A Magical World hasn't been updated for over a year now, and leaves a lot of plot points hanging. Her older works aren't that stellar either.


In Her Hands She Held The Whole World by Sirenny

  • Recommended by Thanatos13713
  • Synopsis: Three years after the defeat of Voldemort, Hermione Granger looks back on the events that destroyed her world. Heart-rending, beautifully written, and utterly chilling. A masterpiece.


Not Go Gentle by Cloneserpents.

  • Recommended by MrMous
  • Synopsis: Harry goes on a Horcrux hunt, but is captured patheticly easily. Meanwhile, Hermione and Ron are having relationship problems... as yet unfinished, but enjoyable; HOWEVER, to quote the author,
  • "WARNING: this work contains depictions of sex (heterosexual, lesbian, bi-sexual, and group acts with both consensual and nonconsensual sex scenes), graphic violence (including but not limited to torture, murder, mutilation, rape, and more). These actions will happen TO and be performed BY major canon characters (both protagonists and antagonists). This is a horror story so readers should expect evil activity from canon characters." I have read this, and if you are faint hearted or under, say, twelve (or even over), DO. NOT. READ.


Yes, Minister by Taure

  • Recommended by User:Rabid Cookie, Mazz, Fenro
  • Synopsis: A new Muggle Prime Minister has been elected, and it's time for him to meet the Minister for Magic. Only, things don't go quite as smoothly as normal...
  • Comments: Possibly my favorite HP fanfic ever. just read it and watch out for the ending. its a dozy...
    • User:Slade JT: Seconded. Completely baffled at the new Prime Minister's name not ringing any bells, but then again...


As Long As You Know That, Potter by owlsaway

  • Recommended by dezba, Mazz, Marlee Cross, Fenro
  • Synopsis: A different take on Harry's first Occlumency lesson with Snape. A very short, one-page fanfic that is nevertheless powerful, building up to a surprise ending.
  • Comments: For a "one-shot", it's surprisingly compelling. Keeps Snape in-character, complete with snide and unnecessary remarks, but actually helping Harry in a roundabout way, and showing he cares in the only way he can.


Recnac Transfaerso by Celebony

  • Recommended by Animaluver
  • Synopsis: In a rash act of self-sacrifice, Harry saves a dying Muggle by magically transfering the man's cancer to himself. Now, going through his fifth year with a terrible secret, he begins to realize just what he's given up.
  • Pairings: Harry/Ginny, Ron/Hermione
  • Comments: Like the synopsis says, there is abuse, but this story is so heartrendingly sad, yet so inspirational, it's difficult to stop reading. The characters are well-written, keeping in canon even as they grow in their own way.


A Better Man by Valandar

  • Recommended by GeorgeUK
  • Synopsis: Vernon changed in the beginning to be a better man, thanks to a wish. How will this affect Harry, and the entire Wizarding World? Now complete!
  • Pairings: Harry/Ginny, Ron/Hermione, Remus/Tonks
  • Comments: The idea of Good!Dursleys is a novel one, and the author manages to make it work, due to Vernon getting a chance at redemption when he ends up in Hell after his death. Glosses over the first four books, with a few changes Peter is arrested instead of Sirius because Lily told Petunia about the switch but takes a MASSIVE diversion from Canon after A Dumbledore-led raid on the graveyard sees the Prophet report Voldemort's return. Well worth reading.


My Nephew Harry by Lucillia

  • Recommended by Marlee Cross
  • Synopsis: During the two months she had watched her eight year-old nephews, Marge Dursley discovered that Petunia was a pathological liar, Vernon had somehow been brainwashed by that no good b***h, Dudley was the spawn of Satan, and Harry was actually a good kid.
  • Comments: It's obviously not a new concept by any stretch for Harry to be removed from the Dursley's custody in some way, however, the fact that Aunt Marge of all people is the one who instigates it, and quite believably I might add, is what makes this fic notable. The chapters may be short, but are still quite well written. Also of note is the very interesting Alternate Character Interpretation of certain characters, Vernon in particular.


Future Imperfect by Lady Azar de Tameran

  • Recommended by Mazz, Fenro
  • Synopsis: One Shot. AU. A world in which Voldemort wins. And honestly wishes he hadn't. Time travel. Could be interpreted as slash, but only if you are looking for it. Ignores Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows but incorporates some of their elements.


The Reign of Theodore Nott by Amadea

  • Recommended by AwayLaughing
  • Synopsis: Oneshot. Draco Malfoy never noticed Theodore Nott at all until sixth year when his task starts to weigh heavily on his mind along with death and all things surrounding it. Very much a character driven work, Draco/Pansy is there and some slash if your goggles are on, but that is very much not the point of this work.


Reunion by movinggirl

  • Recommended by Aromli, Mazz
  • Synopsis: James and Lily Potter have had to learn everything about their son through people who have died and come Above. But after 100 long years on Earth, Harry's finally at the Gate. Now James and Lily will get to meet their son, for the very first time.
  • Comments: Character death is a lot more heartwarming from the eternal side of the Gate. Also, it's fun to see James and Lily learn about Harry second-hand. As James says, "Coolest. Son. EVER."


I'll Shoot the Shot, Bang by wandlorean

  • Recommended by Str 8 Shoot
  • Synopsis: Harry travels back in time to shape the future into a happier one, but will he listen to Hermione's warning? (Snape/Harry, oneshot, not slash)
    • Comments: This, ladies and gentlemen, is a wonderfully original take on time travel. I recently stumbled upon this little gem and am very thankful I discovered it. It is extremely well-written and the characterizations are spot-on. Time travel has become an overused plot in Harry Potter fanfiction but, here, the author takes the idea and turns it into something unique and chilling. With fics like this one, you have a character going back in time to change certain things about the future, but what would happen if information about the future was given to someone like Severus Snape; a young, proud, active Death Eater very much capable of committing evil acts? Just when you think you know where things are headed, the author spins everything around, smacking you across the face with a horrifying, tragic, and absolutely delicious twist at the end. A haunting, bleak, and original story with solid writing. It will leave you speechless and feeling like you've been punched in the gut. Really, there are no words. I highly recommend it.


Never Alone Never Again by Bored Beyond Belief

  • Recommended by Zephyr7
  • Synopsis: Harry's holiday reaches its lowest point. Will Harry finally be able to have the kind of love everyone else seems to take for granted?
  • Comments: This was a well-executed fic with strong characterization and amazing development and layers to the characters. Harry's suffering (combined from the Dursleys' abuse, the worsening nightmares and the emotional and physical pain that came with Voldemort's return) was just gutwrenching for Harry's loved ones and for the readers to see. There are some parts in the story that can be quite dark and it seems like Harry won't be getting better. But there are some light-hearted moments and some heartwarming and Tear Jerker moments to balance it out, leading up to a Bittersweet Ending. The one-shot sequel Make a Joyful Noise couldn't have ended the story any better.


The Riddle Chronicles Little Differences by Theta Serpentis

  • Recommended by Shebali
  • Synopsis: They say the road to hell is paved with good intentions. From a few hours before his birth, to the end of his eleventh birthday, this is the life Tom Marvolo Riddle.
  • Comments: A most wonderful story which tells us of the origins of Voldemort. Can be rather dark at times, but that's to be expected, really. Incredible writing style, well-developed characters and all historical research you could wish for. It's a WIP, recently updated. Go ahead, take a look. And be sure to check LJ version for fact finders. They make the experience even better.


My Renewal, My Immortal by esbmusic42

  • Recommended by Melody H. Grace
  • Synopsis: Ebony Way is normal. Even if the rapidly-growing canines and love of blood say otherwise.
  • Comments: It's basically the author's attempt to give My Immortal's Ebony D'arkness Dementia Raven Way a real personality (and a normal name). There's not much up yet, but Ebony's character is pretty good and, more to the point, the Canon characters (Draco, Hermione, etc.) are pretty close to their Canon counterparts as well. It's not that long yet, but it's definitely worth the read.

Dudley Dursley and the Quest for Truth by books101

  • Recommended by: Tropical Snow
  • Synopsis: When Dudley Dursley and his parents are forced to spend a year with witches and wizards, Dudley decides this is the opportunity for him to learn more about his apparently famous cousin. With Potterwatch,tall tales and magic thrown into the mix, it's bound to be an interesting journey!
  • Comments: This story is well-written and truly is an interesting and entertaining read. It also gives Dudley, Petunia and several minor characters some well-needed Character Development along the way.


Against the Moon by Stoplight Delight

  • Recommended by Mismoree
  • Synopsis: The odds were stacked against him: a child from a blended home with no friends, no social skills to speak of, and a terrible secret. Yet slowly Remus Lupin began to realize there was a place for him in the world, if he could find the courage to claim it.
  • Comments: I can't even begin to describe how amazing this story is. It has incredible imagery, realistic dialogue, character development, and some serious suspense; it's good enough to be considered canon. Updates are near daily and are several thousand words long.


Session Transcripts by lastcrazyhorn

  • Recommended by templar627, Salnax1
  • Synopsis: What happens when a brain damaged Harry and a transgender Hermione both get sorted into Slytherin? Snape's not sure, but he thinks it's likely to be an interesting term. This story follows various first years through the trials of their first year.
  • Comments: This story is just amazing. The characters seem to really just jump off the page, all of them have their pro and cons. They seem to be truly more than just one dimensional, from Malfoy to Crabbe. Also, the transgender Hermoine isn't as bad as it seems. He/she just really seems to be a guy stuck in a girls body and acts accordingly. Also, the brain damaged harry just seems to finish off the fic giving huge amounts of WAFF and genrally empathazing with everyone even a troll


Business by esama

  • Recommended by User:Looney Toons, User:Unclouded TJ, The Forgotten One
  • Synopsis: So the Dursleys have painted Harry as a freak and a criminal in the years before he gets his Hogwarts letter? Well, when Harry decides to find out what those words really mean, the well-intentioned intervention of a librarian results in Harry finding a role model -- and the Wizarding World will never be the same. As the author puts it, the "mildest of fusions with Sherlock Holmes". And no, it's not Holmes who becomes Harry's inspiration.
  • Comments: A complete short story. While it's a little hard to imagine an 11-year-old making some of the plans that Harry does here, it's still a gripping read, right to the end moments.


Shapechangers and Espionage by User:Mc Junker

  • Recommended by User:Mc Junker
  • Synopsis: A one shot the First War, a pair of Death Eater sympathizers try to infiltrate the Order using Polyjuice.
  • Comments: An exercise in world-building, plot, and characterization. Features two OCs vs. the Marauders


Reach the Open Space by Tinn Tam

  • Recommended by User:Magic Kirby
  • Synopsis: After defeating Voldemort, Harry Potter was about to become the most adulated wizard in the History of Wizardkind. But he ruined it all. And he's damn proud of it. Mild violence.
  • Comments: A oneshot that I keep going back and reading. Takes a canon Harry and turns him into the person he was always meant to be.


Retrieved from "https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Harry_Potter/Fanfic_Recs/General?oldid=91701"