Rotoscoping: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
prefix>Import Bot
(Import from TV Tropes TVT:Main.Rotoscoping 2012-07-01, editor history TVTH:Main.Rotoscoping, CC-BY-SA 3.0 Unported license)
 
("commercials"->"advertising")
 
(10 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}
[[File:Waking Life rotoscoping 372.jpg|link=A Scanner Darkly|right]]
<!-- %%Image selected per Image Pickin' thread: http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=1313422281083019700 -->
<!-- %%Please do not change or remove without starting a new thread. -->
{{quote box|[[File:Waking_Life_rotoscoping_372.jpg|link=A Scanner Darkly|right]]}}


Rotoscoping is the process of drawing animation over live-action film.
'''Rotoscoping''' is the process of drawing animation over live-action film.


[[Max and Dave Fleischer]] invented the process in [[The Silent Age of Animation|1915]] to animated Koko the Clown of their ''[[Out of the Inkwell]]'' series, and later used it to animate [[Cab Calloway]]'s dancing in three [[Betty Boop]] shorts, but the most famous Fleischer rotoscoping was done in the studio's [[Superman]] [[Superman Theatrical Cartoons|cartoons.]]
[[Max and Dave Fleischer]] invented the process in [[The Silent Age of Animation|1915]] to animate Koko the Clown of their ''[[Out of the Inkwell]]'' series, and later used it to animate [[Cab Calloway]]'s dancing in three [[Betty Boop]] shorts, but the most famous Fleischer rotoscoping was done in the studio's ''[[Superman]]'' [[Superman Theatrical Cartoons|cartoons.]]


[[Disney]] Studios had used rotoscoping from ''[[Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs (Disney)|Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs]]'' (explaining the slightly different art style of said characters) all the way to ''101 Dalmatians''.
[[Disney]] Studios had used rotoscoping from ''[[Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (Disney film)|Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs]]'' (explaining the slightly different art style of said characters) all the way to ''101 Dalmatians''.


Rotoscoping has been used lightly (to create realistic movements for otherwise stylized characters) and heavily (nearly tracing an entire actor's movements, form, and facial expressions). The downside of heavy rotoscoping is that the animated actors tend to teeter on the edge of the [[Uncanny Valley]].
Rotoscoping has been used lightly (to create realistic movements for otherwise stylized characters) and heavily (nearly tracing an entire actor's movements, form, and facial expressions). The downside of heavy rotoscoping is that the animated actors tend to teeter on the edge of the [[Uncanny Valley]].
Line 14: Line 12:
More recently, computer technology has created new life for rotoscoping as a medium, allowing for much greater detail and smoother movement. Fully computer-generated characters are [[Serkis Folk]], much like fully animated characters give it the [[Roger Rabbit Effect]].
More recently, computer technology has created new life for rotoscoping as a medium, allowing for much greater detail and smoother movement. Fully computer-generated characters are [[Serkis Folk]], much like fully animated characters give it the [[Roger Rabbit Effect]].


However, rotoscoping has gotten a bad reputation among the animation community, including men such as [[Richard Williams]], [[Disneys Nine Old Men|Milt Kahl]] and [[John Kricfalusi]], being percieved as a lifeless, poor substitute for character animation. Even [[Ralph Bakshi]], a frequent user of it in his feature films, admits that he loathed using it and that it was only used due to his low budgets. In fact, Max Fleischer himself came to realize the limitations of the very device he created early on, opting for more creative use of character animation instead ([[Minnie the Moocher|although he did]] [[Max Fleischers Gullivers Travels|make]] [[Superman Theatrical Cartoons|some]] [[Mr. Bug Goes to Town|exceptions]]).
However, rotoscoping has gotten a bad reputation among the animation community, including men such as [[Richard Williams]], [[Disney's Nine Old Men|Milt Kahl]] and [[John Kricfalusi]], being percieved as a lifeless, poor substitute for character animation. Even [[Ralph Bakshi]], a frequent user of it in his feature films, admits that he loathed using it and that it was only used due to his low budgets. In fact, Max Fleischer himself came to realize the limitations of the very device he created early on, opting for more creative use of character animation instead ([[Minnie the Moocher|although he did]] [[Max Fleischer's Gulliver's Travels|make]] [[Superman Theatrical Cartoons|some]] [[Mr. Bug Goes to Town|exceptions]]).


Compare [[Motion Capture]], which is how computers do it these days.
Compare [[Motion Capture]], which is how computers do it these days.


{{examples|Examples}}
{{examples}}
== [[Advertising]] ==
* The [http://www.slate.com/id/2131287/ Talk to Chuck] ads for Charles Schwab, directed by Bob Sabiston, the developer of the Rotoshop software used on ''Waking Life'', ''A Scanner Darkly'', etc.
* A series of bumpers for Nickelodeon that was produced by Buck.


== [[Film]] ==
== [[Film]] ==
* The lightsaber effects in the original ''[[Star Wars]]'' trilogy. Rotoscoping is still the word you would use to describe the prequel trilogy's lightsabers, but it's the modern computer-aided version.
* The lightsaber effects in the original ''[[Star Wars]]'' trilogy. Rotoscoping is still the word you would use to describe the prequel trilogy's lightsabers, but it's the modern computer-aided version.
* ''[[Heavy Metal (Animation)|Heavy Metal]]'' did this with Taarna, the title character of the last major story.
* ''[[Heavy Metal (animation)|Heavy Metal]]'' did this with Taarna, the title character of the last major story.
* [[Ralph Bakshi]] did extensive rotoscoping; ''[[Wizards]]'', ''[[The Lord of the Rings]]'', ''[[American Pop (Animation)|American Pop]]'', and ''[[Fire and Ice (Film)|Fire and Ice]]''. Bakshi went to rotoscoping because 20th Century Fox wouldn't increase his budget for ''[[Wizards]]''.
* [[Ralph Bakshi]] did extensive rotoscoping; ''[[Wizards]]'', ''[[The Lord of the Rings]]'', ''[[American Pop]]'', and ''[[Fire and Ice (animation)|Fire and Ice]]''. Bakshi went to rotoscoping because 20th Century Fox wouldn't increase his budget for ''[[Wizards]]''.
* [[Don Bluth]]'s ''[[Anastasia]]'' and ''[[Titan AE]]'', as well as almost every other movie he's done. Every human appearing in ''[[The Secret of NIMH]]'' and ''[[An American Tail]]'' are rotoscoped, giving them a stark, realistic contrast to the cartoonish mouse characters.
* [[Don Bluth]]'s ''[[Anastasia]]'' and ''[[Titan A.E.]]'', as well as almost every other movie he's done. Every human appearing in ''[[The Secret of NIMH]]'' and ''[[An American Tail]]'' are rotoscoped, giving them a stark, realistic contrast to the cartoonish mouse characters.
* ''[[Waking Life]]'' (digitally, using software called Rotoshop.)
* ''[[Waking Life]]'' (digitally, using software called Rotoshop.)
* ''[[A Scanner Darkly]]'', from the same director and producer as ''[[Waking Life]]'', used this to good effect.
* ''[[A Scanner Darkly]]'', from the same director and producer as ''[[Waking Life]]'', used this to good effect.
Line 33: Line 34:
== [[Music Videos]] ==
== [[Music Videos]] ==
* [[Dire Straits]], "Money for Nothing".
* [[Dire Straits]], "Money for Nothing".
** By extension, [[Weird Al Yankovic]]'s parody "Money For Nothing/[[The Beverly Hillbillies|Beverly Hillbillies]]"
** By extension, [["Weird Al" Yankovic]]'s parody "Money For Nothing/[[The Beverly Hillbillies|Beverly Hillbillies]]"
* [[A-ha]], "Take on Me".
* [[A-ha]], "Take on Me".
* "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEVfHmjKOrM&ob=av2e Shadrach]" by the [[Beastie Boys]] features a heavily stylised example of Rotoscoping.
* "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MEVfHmjKOrM&ob=av2e Shadrach]" by the [[Beastie Boys]] features a heavily stylised example of Rotoscoping.
* Spoon, "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dInnbQrYVhQ Everything Hits At Once]" and Zero 7, "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZncATpZre_w Destiny]", both directed by ''Waking Life'' animators.
* Spoon, "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dInnbQrYVhQ Everything Hits At Once]" and Zero 7, "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZncATpZre_w Destiny]", both directed by ''Waking Life'' animators.
* [[Kanye West]], "Heartless". It's a tribute to ''[[American Pop (Animation)|American Pop]]''.
* [[Kanye West]], "Heartless". It's a tribute to ''[[American Pop]]''.
* The video for "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUbqOcMlD7I&feature=related Electric Surfing Go Go]" by POLYSICS flashes between this and live action.
* The video for "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUbqOcMlD7I&feature=related Electric Surfing Go Go]" by POLYSICS flashes between this and live action.
* [[Kasabian (Music)|Kasabian]], "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C0OEVWKZv0 Shoot the Runner]"
* [[Kasabian]], "[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2C0OEVWKZv0 Shoot the Runner]"


== [[Video Games]] ==
== [[Video Games]] ==
* The original ''[[Prince of Persia]]'' and its sequel.
* The original ''[[Prince of Persia]]'' and its sequel.
** And before that, it was in ''[[Karateka]]'', developed by the same guy behind PoP.
** And before that, it was in ''[[Karateka]]'', developed by the same guy behind PoP.
* ''[[Another World (Video Game)|Another World]]''/''Out of This World''
* ''[[Another World (video game)|Another World]]''/''Out of This World''
* ''[[Flashback (Video Game)|Flashback]]''.
* ''[[Flashback (video game)|Flashback]]''.
* Smoking Car Productions's ''[[The Last Express]]'' (by the same developer as ''Prince of Persia'').
* Smoking Car Productions's ''[[The Last Express]]'' (by the same developer as ''Prince of Persia'').
* A few [[SNK]] fighters, most famously ''[[Art of Fighting]] 3''.
* A few [[SNK]] fighters, most famously ''[[Art of Fighting]] 3''.
** SNK is using a similar technical for ''[[King of Fighters]]'' XII and XIII. Instead of live action, the animation is drawn over CG models.
** SNK is using a similar technical for ''[[King of Fighters]]'' XII and XIII. Instead of live action, the animation is drawn over CG models.
*** Arc System used a similar technique for ''[[Blaz Blue]]''.
*** Arc System used a similar technique for ''[[BlazBlue]]''.
* [[Street Fighter|Elena's]] animations look a little different from the rest of the ''[[Street Fighter]] III'' cast, largely because all of her animation was rotoscoped. This was probably done because capoeira may have been too daunting for the artists to hand animate convincingly.
* [[Street Fighter|Elena's]] animations look a little different from the rest of the ''[[Street Fighter]] III'' cast, largely because all of her animation was rotoscoped. This was probably done because capoeira may have been too daunting for the artists to hand animate convincingly.
* ''[[Hotel Dusk]]'' and it's sequel, ''[[Last Window]]''. Actors and actresses are brought in, and they are filmed performing various movements. The most essential "frames" of their movements are then drawn over and spliced together to create the grainy, film-noir novel style.
* ''[[Hotel Dusk: Room 215]]'' and it's sequel, ''[[Last Window]]''. Actors and actresses are brought in, and they are filmed performing various movements. The most essential "frames" of their movements are then drawn over and spliced together to create the grainy, film-noir novel style.
** You can watch the "behind the scenes" [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xv6L26DZYEs video here].
** You can watch the "behind the scenes" [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xv6L26DZYEs video here].
* The ''[[Just Dance]]'' games.
* The ''[[Just Dance]]'' games.
* The kiss scene between Blair and Angel in ''[[Wing Commander (Video Game)|Wing Commander]] II'' was rotoscoped, with series creator Chris Roberts providing the basis for Blair's body.<ref>The female providing the base body for Angel is unknown, however, but probably an Origin staffer at the time.</ref>
* The kiss scene between Blair and Angel in ''[[Wing Commander (video game)|Wing Commander]] II'' was rotoscoped, with series creator Chris Roberts providing the basis for Blair's body.<ref>The female providing the base body for Angel is unknown, however, but probably an Origin staffer at the time.</ref>


== [[Western Animation]] ==
== [[Western Animation]] ==
* [[Filmation]] did this to get stock footage for all its animated series: ''[[He Man and The Masters of The Universe]]'', ''[[Blackstar]]'', and ''[[Flash Gordon (Animation)|The New Adventures of Flash Gordon]]''.
* [[Filmation]] did this to get stock footage for all its animated series: ''[[He-Man and the Masters of the Universe]]'', ''[[Blackstar]]'', and ''[[Flash Gordon (animation)|The New Adventures of Flash Gordon]]''.
** Filmation's ''[[Star Trek the Animated Series]]'' used rotoscoping in an interesting way: the footage of the USS Enterprise, used in establishing shots (and the title sequence), was achieved by taking the actual footage used in [[Star Trek the Original Series|the original 1960s live action series]], and then painstakingly recreating it in animation, frame-by-frame. They hold up pretty well.
** Filmation's ''[[Star Trek: The Animated Series]]'' used rotoscoping in an interesting way: the footage of the USS Enterprise, used in establishing shots (and the title sequence), was achieved by taking the actual footage used in [[Star Trek: The Original Series|the original 1960s live action series]], and then painstakingly recreating it in animation, frame-by-frame. They hold up pretty well.
*** Which might explain why a number of fans have noted they felt that the remastered CGI effect version of the Enterprise reminds them of the look of the animated Enterprise.
*** Which might explain why a number of fans have noted they felt that the remastered CGI effect version of the Enterprise reminds them of the look of the animated Enterprise.
* [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46PXaJxzuDE This video] pretty clearly uses rotoscoping, although you may not notice it in the face of [[Ear Worm|Mormon Jeezus]].
* [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46PXaJxzuDE This video] pretty clearly uses rotoscoping, although you may not notice it in the face of [[Ear Worm|Mormon Jeezus]].
Line 64: Line 65:
* ''[[Out of the Inkwell]]'' invented this trope and used it to animate Koko, but it was quickly discarded.
* ''[[Out of the Inkwell]]'' invented this trope and used it to animate Koko, but it was quickly discarded.
* The classic Fleischer [[Superman]] cartoons used ''very good'' rotoscoping for the main characters, thanks to their lavish budget.
* The classic Fleischer [[Superman]] cartoons used ''very good'' rotoscoping for the main characters, thanks to their lavish budget.
* ''[[Max Fleischers Gullivers Travels]]'' (also by Fleischer) used this with the title character.
* ''[[Max Fleischer's Gulliver's Travels]]'' (also by Fleischer) used this with the title character.
* Another Fleischer's feature-length cartoon, ''[[Mr. Bug Goes to Town]]'', does this with ''human'' characters (who, however, appear very ''little'').
* Another Fleischer's feature-length cartoon, ''[[Mr. Bug Goes to Town]]'', does this with ''human'' characters (who, however, appear very ''little'').
* Some [[Looney Tunes]] shorts used this; a few notable examples are in the climax of "Daffy The Commando" the climax scene of Hitler giving his speech, and in "Hollywood Steps Out" with some of the dancing celebrities.
* Some [[Looney Tunes]] shorts used this; a few notable examples are in the climax of "Daffy The Commando" the climax scene of Hitler giving his speech, and in "Hollywood Steps Out" with some of the dancing celebrities.
** In 1967, Warner Bros. had merged with Seven Arts which had acquired the 1931-43 black-and-white Looney Tunes shorts from absorbing Guild Films, who in turn acquired them from Sunset Films (believed to be a W-B dummy distribution firm). At that time, W-B had 75 of those cartoons shipped to Korea to be rotoscoped--redrawn and painted in color. The tight deadlines and low budgets (all done on 6-field cels) rendered these color versions sloppy and unattractive.
** In 1967, Warner Bros. had merged with Seven Arts which had acquired the 1931-43 black-and-white Looney Tunes shorts from absorbing Guild Films, who in turn acquired them from Sunset Films (believed to be a W-B dummy distribution firm). At that time, W-B had 75 of those cartoons shipped to Korea to be rotoscoped—redrawn and painted in color. The tight deadlines and low budgets (all done on 6-field cels) rendered these color versions sloppy and unattractive.
*** King Features had the same thing done in 1986 with the Fleischer BW [[Popeye]] cartoons.
*** King Features had the same thing done in 1986 with the Fleischer BW [[Popeye]] cartoons.
* The little-known, less-seen, and not-entirely-completed masterpiece ''Happy New Year, Planet Earth'' (never released owing to licensing and contractual issues). A Canadian cross between ''Heavy Metal'' and ''Yellow Submarine'' set to music by the band Klaatu, it is mostly rotoscoped.
* The little-known, less-seen, and not-entirely-completed masterpiece ''Happy New Year, Planet Earth'' (never released owing to licensing and contractual issues). A Canadian cross between ''Heavy Metal'' and ''Yellow Submarine'' set to music by the band Klaatu, it is mostly rotoscoped.
* [[Felix the Cat The Movie]] uses this to animate the princess.
* [[Felix the Cat: The Movie]] uses this to animate the princess.
* The animation of [[Josie and The Pussycats]] performing in the opening of their 1970 Hanna-Barbera cartoon was rotoscoped.
* The animation of [[Josie and the Pussy Cats]] performing in the opening of their 1970 Hanna-Barbera cartoon was rotoscoped.
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' uses this on occasion, usually for complex dance sequences (such as the Jitterbug song in one episode)
* ''[[Family Guy]]'' uses this on occasion, usually for complex dance sequences (such as the Jitterbug song in one episode).

== Commercials ==
* The [http://www.slate.com/id/2131287/ Talk to Chuck] ads for Charles Schwab, directed by Bob Sabiston, the developer of the Rotoshop software used on ''Waking Life'', ''A Scanner Darkly'', etc.
* A series of bumpers for Nickelodeon that was produced by Buck.


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
Line 82: Line 79:
[[Category:Eastern Animation Tropes]]
[[Category:Eastern Animation Tropes]]
[[Category:Rotoscoping]]
[[Category:Rotoscoping]]
[[Category:Trope]]

Latest revision as of 14:54, 14 May 2021

Rotoscoping is the process of drawing animation over live-action film.

Max and Dave Fleischer invented the process in 1915 to animate Koko the Clown of their Out of the Inkwell series, and later used it to animate Cab Calloway's dancing in three Betty Boop shorts, but the most famous Fleischer rotoscoping was done in the studio's Superman cartoons.

Disney Studios had used rotoscoping from Snow White and The Seven Dwarfs (explaining the slightly different art style of said characters) all the way to 101 Dalmatians.

Rotoscoping has been used lightly (to create realistic movements for otherwise stylized characters) and heavily (nearly tracing an entire actor's movements, form, and facial expressions). The downside of heavy rotoscoping is that the animated actors tend to teeter on the edge of the Uncanny Valley.

More recently, computer technology has created new life for rotoscoping as a medium, allowing for much greater detail and smoother movement. Fully computer-generated characters are Serkis Folk, much like fully animated characters give it the Roger Rabbit Effect.

However, rotoscoping has gotten a bad reputation among the animation community, including men such as Richard Williams, Milt Kahl and John Kricfalusi, being percieved as a lifeless, poor substitute for character animation. Even Ralph Bakshi, a frequent user of it in his feature films, admits that he loathed using it and that it was only used due to his low budgets. In fact, Max Fleischer himself came to realize the limitations of the very device he created early on, opting for more creative use of character animation instead (although he did make some exceptions).

Compare Motion Capture, which is how computers do it these days.

Examples of Rotoscoping include:

Advertising

  • The Talk to Chuck ads for Charles Schwab, directed by Bob Sabiston, the developer of the Rotoshop software used on Waking Life, A Scanner Darkly, etc.
  • A series of bumpers for Nickelodeon that was produced by Buck.

Film

Music Videos

Video Games

  • The original Prince of Persia and its sequel.
    • And before that, it was in Karateka, developed by the same guy behind PoP.
  • Another World/Out of This World
  • Flashback.
  • Smoking Car Productions's The Last Express (by the same developer as Prince of Persia).
  • A few SNK fighters, most famously Art of Fighting 3.
    • SNK is using a similar technical for King of Fighters XII and XIII. Instead of live action, the animation is drawn over CG models.
      • Arc System used a similar technique for BlazBlue.
  • Elena's animations look a little different from the rest of the Street Fighter III cast, largely because all of her animation was rotoscoped. This was probably done because capoeira may have been too daunting for the artists to hand animate convincingly.
  • Hotel Dusk: Room 215 and it's sequel, Last Window. Actors and actresses are brought in, and they are filmed performing various movements. The most essential "frames" of their movements are then drawn over and spliced together to create the grainy, film-noir novel style.
  • The Just Dance games.
  • The kiss scene between Blair and Angel in Wing Commander II was rotoscoped, with series creator Chris Roberts providing the basis for Blair's body.[1]

Western Animation

  • Filmation did this to get stock footage for all its animated series: He-Man and the Masters of the Universe, Blackstar, and The New Adventures of Flash Gordon.
    • Filmation's Star Trek: The Animated Series used rotoscoping in an interesting way: the footage of the USS Enterprise, used in establishing shots (and the title sequence), was achieved by taking the actual footage used in the original 1960s live action series, and then painstakingly recreating it in animation, frame-by-frame. They hold up pretty well.
      • Which might explain why a number of fans have noted they felt that the remastered CGI effect version of the Enterprise reminds them of the look of the animated Enterprise.
  • This video pretty clearly uses rotoscoping, although you may not notice it in the face of Mormon Jeezus.
  • Disney used rotoscoping in the Goofy cartoon "Baggage Buster", making him look way more earthbound than his usual loose, lanky self.
  • Out of the Inkwell invented this trope and used it to animate Koko, but it was quickly discarded.
  • The classic Fleischer Superman cartoons used very good rotoscoping for the main characters, thanks to their lavish budget.
  • Max Fleischer's Gulliver's Travels (also by Fleischer) used this with the title character.
  • Another Fleischer's feature-length cartoon, Mr. Bug Goes to Town, does this with human characters (who, however, appear very little).
  • Some Looney Tunes shorts used this; a few notable examples are in the climax of "Daffy The Commando" the climax scene of Hitler giving his speech, and in "Hollywood Steps Out" with some of the dancing celebrities.
    • In 1967, Warner Bros. had merged with Seven Arts which had acquired the 1931-43 black-and-white Looney Tunes shorts from absorbing Guild Films, who in turn acquired them from Sunset Films (believed to be a W-B dummy distribution firm). At that time, W-B had 75 of those cartoons shipped to Korea to be rotoscoped—redrawn and painted in color. The tight deadlines and low budgets (all done on 6-field cels) rendered these color versions sloppy and unattractive.
      • King Features had the same thing done in 1986 with the Fleischer BW Popeye cartoons.
  • The little-known, less-seen, and not-entirely-completed masterpiece Happy New Year, Planet Earth (never released owing to licensing and contractual issues). A Canadian cross between Heavy Metal and Yellow Submarine set to music by the band Klaatu, it is mostly rotoscoped.
  • Felix the Cat: The Movie uses this to animate the princess.
  • The animation of Josie and the Pussy Cats performing in the opening of their 1970 Hanna-Barbera cartoon was rotoscoped.
  • Family Guy uses this on occasion, usually for complex dance sequences (such as the Jitterbug song in one episode).
  1. The female providing the base body for Angel is unknown, however, but probably an Origin staffer at the time.