Crying Indian: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
(swapped image and quote)
No edit summary
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
[[File:cryingindian.jpg|frame|People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It.]]
[[File:cryingindian.jpg|frame|People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It.]]


{{quote| ''Somewhere, an Indian is crying.''}}
{{quote|''Somewhere, an Indian is crying.''}}


In 1971, the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_America_Beautiful Keep America Beautiful] organization aired a famous TV commercial of a Native American shedding a [[Single Tear]] at the sight of litter being dropped on the road (in a follow-up ad, the Indian rides with a big smile through towns where people are cleaning up).
In 1971, the [[wikipedia:Keep America Beautiful|Keep America Beautiful]] organization aired a famous TV commercial of a Native American shedding a [[Single Tear]] at the sight of litter being dropped on the road (in a follow-up ad, the Indian rides with a big smile through towns where people are cleaning up).


It's known as the "Crying Indian" ad, although it is called "People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It". At the time this was quite a powerful ad. Not subtle, but of the [[Some Anvils Need to Be Dropped]] variety.
It's known as the "Crying Indian" ad, although it is called "People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It". At the time this was quite a powerful ad. Not subtle, but of the [[Some Anvils Need to Be Dropped]] variety.


But these days, with the overuse of the [[Magical Native American]] trope (not to mention that [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_Eyes_Cody the actor] portraying him was [[Pass Fail|Italian-American]]), this ad has become a [[Stock Parodies|Stock Parody]]. Thus while some still believe in the message, it's hard to resist a good joke from it.
But these days, with the overuse of the [[Magical Native American]] trope (not to mention that [[wikipedia:Iron Eyes Cody|the actor]] portraying him was [[Pass Fail|Italian-American]]), this ad has become a [[Stock Parodies|Stock Parody]]. Thus while some still believe in the message, it's hard to resist a good joke from it.


You can find videos online of course.
You can find videos online of course.
Line 16: Line 16:
* Inverted in Kingpin, where a group of Native Americans drove by Ishmael and threw garbage at Ishmael's feet.
* Inverted in Kingpin, where a group of Native Americans drove by Ishmael and threw garbage at Ishmael's feet.
* In the 2008 [[Knight Rider]] movie, KITT shows this picture when Mike litters in him.
* In the 2008 [[Knight Rider]] movie, KITT shows this picture when Mike litters in him.
* In ''Wayne's World 2'', Jim Morrison's Naked Indian Friend sheds tears on seeing the scattered trash left over from Waynestock. He cheers up, though, when he sees Wayne and Garth picking up the mess.
* In ''[[Wayne's World|Wayne's World 2]]'', Jim Morrison's Naked Indian Friend sheds tears on seeing the scattered trash left over from Waynestock. He cheers up, though, when he sees Wayne and Garth picking up the mess.


== [[Television]] ==
== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
* In one ''[[Friends]]'' episode, the characters are stranded at a rest stop. Chandler throws his empty pack of cigarettes on the ground. When scolded, he replies, "I thought maybe if I littered, that crying Indian might come along and save us."
* In one ''[[Friends]]'' episode, the characters are stranded at a rest stop. Chandler throws his empty pack of cigarettes on the ground. When scolded, he replies, "I thought maybe if I littered, that crying Indian might come along and save us."
* From [[MST3K]]'s infamous take on ''[[Mitchell]]'', there is a scene where Mitchell dumps what seems to be two ashtrays worth of cigarette butts on the ground.
* From [[Mystery Science Theater 3000]]'s infamous take on ''[[Mitchell]]'', there is a scene where Mitchell dumps what seems to be two ashtrays worth of cigarette butts on the ground.
{{quote| '''Servo:''' Somewhere, an Indian is crying.}}
{{quote|'''Servo:''' Somewhere, an Indian is crying.}}
** ''[[Mystery Science Theater 3000]]'' also referenced it during the film ''[[Werewolf (Film)|Werewolf]]''. An Indian contracts lycanthropy, and the early symptoms make him look like he's sobbing more than anything else:
** ''[[Mystery Science Theater 3000]]'' also referenced it during the film ''[[Werewolf (film)|Werewolf]]''. An Indian contracts lycanthropy, and the early symptoms make him look like he's sobbing more than anything else:
{{quote| '''Crow:''' ''[sobs]'' There's just so much litter on the highway!}}
{{quote|'''Crow:''' ''[sobs]'' There's just so much litter on the highway!}}
* The ad was mocked on the recycling episode of [[Penn and Teller Bullshit]]. Penn pointed out that the ad was a terrible form of ethnic stereotyping and compared it to making a commercial encouraging people to save their money that showed a Jew shedding a single tear.
* The ad was mocked on the recycling episode of [[Penn & Teller: Bullshit!]]. Penn pointed out that the ad was a terrible form of ethnic stereotyping and compared it to making a commercial encouraging people to save their money that showed a Jew shedding a single tear.
* Mocked in ''[[Married With Children]]''. Al wants nothing to do with a Keep Chicago Green movement until he realizes that he's been put in a car pool with some beautiful young girls. Now he wants to make sure that keeps up, so he makes Keep Chicago Green commercials. At the end of one, he takes a fake tear out of his pocket and sticks it on his cheek
* Mocked in ''[[Married... with Children]]''. Al wants nothing to do with a Keep Chicago Green movement until he realizes that he's been put in a car pool with some beautiful young girls. Now he wants to make sure that keeps up, so he makes Keep Chicago Green commercials. At the end of one, he takes a fake tear out of his pocket and sticks it on his cheek


== [[Music]] ==
== [[Music]] ==
* Also parodied by VH-1 during an ad for a [[The Seventies|1970's tribute week]] several years ago, with the Indian played by [[Good Times|Jimmie Walker]].
* Also parodied by VH-1 during an ad for a [[The Seventies|1970's tribute week]] several years ago, with the Indian played by [[Good Times|Jimmie Walker]].
* The opening lyrics to the [[Eels]] song ''Mr. E's Beautiful Blues'';
* The opening lyrics to the [[Eels]] song ''Mr. E's Beautiful Blues'';
{{quote| "''The smokestack spitting black soot into the sooty sky/ The load on the road brings a tear to the Indian's eye''"}}
{{quote|"''The smokestack spitting black soot into the sooty sky/ The load on the road brings a tear to the Indian's eye''"}}


== [[Video Games]] ==
== [[Video Games]] ==
Line 36: Line 36:


== [[Web Animation]] ==
== [[Web Animation]] ==
* In ''[[Strong Bads Cool Game for Attractive People (Video Game)|Strong Bads Cool Game for Attractive People]] Episode 3: Baddest of the Bands'', Strong Bad gets to shed a single tear at the sight of a pond full of dead fish. (Of course, this being Strong Bad, he's the perpetrator of the incident.)
* In ''[[Strong Bad's Cool Game for Attractive People|Strong Bads Cool Game for Attractive People]] Episode 3: Baddest of the Bands'', Strong Bad gets to shed a single tear at the sight of a pond full of dead fish. (Of course, this being Strong Bad, he's the perpetrator of the incident.)
** "Oh, [[Sand in My Eyes|must've got bleach in my eye]]."
** "Oh, [[Sand in My Eyes|must've got bleach in my eye]]."
* [[Telltale Games]] have done this before, in ''[[Sam and Max Freelance Police (Video Game)|Sam and Max Freelance Police]]'':
* [[Telltale Games]] have done this before, in ''[[The Adventures of Sam & Max: Freelance Police|Sam and Max Freelance Police]]'':
{{quote| '''Pedro:''' Hey! You can't throw garbage into the time vortex!<br />
{{quote|'''Pedro:''' Hey! You can't throw garbage into the time vortex!
'''Max:''' Yeah, Sam! Somewhere a time travelling Native American is crying! }}
'''Max:''' Yeah, Sam! Somewhere a time travelling Native American is crying! }}


Line 46: Line 46:
** Interestingly enough, [[Word of God]] says the original plan was to have the camera cut back to Megaman after Tomahawk shed the tear, but not explicitly showing his defeat might've created plotholes later.
** Interestingly enough, [[Word of God]] says the original plan was to have the camera cut back to Megaman after Tomahawk shed the tear, but not explicitly showing his defeat might've created plotholes later.
* Used in an [http://thisishistorictimes.com/2010/02/bus-route-of-tears/ editorial cartoon] by Terrence Nowicki Jr., crying at a littered Tea Party flyer with [[Rouge Angles of Satin|"ITS ARE COUNTRY - AN WE WANT IT BACK"]] on it.
* Used in an [http://thisishistorictimes.com/2010/02/bus-route-of-tears/ editorial cartoon] by Terrence Nowicki Jr., crying at a littered Tea Party flyer with [[Rouge Angles of Satin|"ITS ARE COUNTRY - AN WE WANT IT BACK"]] on it.
* Referred to in [http://www.youdamnkid.com/d/20040929.html You Damn Kid].
* Referred to in [https://web.archive.org/web/20090222230922/http://www.youdamnkid.com/d/20040929.html You Damn Kid].
* Shows up in ''[[The Non Adventures of Wonderella]]'' in [http://nonadventures.com/2008/11/15/diamonds-are-whatever/ "Diamonds are WHATEVER"]
* Shows up in ''[[The Non-Adventures of Wonderella]]'' in [http://nonadventures.com/2008/11/15/diamonds-are-whatever/ "Diamonds are WHATEVER"]


== Web Original ==
== [[Web Original]] ==
* Parodied by the WCW fansite ''DDT Digest'' - rather then star ratings, bad matches were rated in crying Indians. The later years of the federation saw a lot of crying Indians in the recap.
* Parodied by the [[WCW]] fansite ''DDT Digest'' - rather then star ratings, bad matches were rated in crying Indians. The later years of the federation saw a lot of crying Indians in the recap.
* Somebody in the ''[[Harry Potter]]'' fandom compared the "Harmonians" to [[Unfortunate Implications|the Trail of Tears]], so someone on [[Fandom Wank]] made an icon of the crying Indian looking at Ron/Hermione.
* Somebody in the ''[[Harry Potter]]'' fandom compared the "Harmonians" to [[Unfortunate Implications|the Trail of Tears]], so someone on ''[[Fandom Wank]]'' made an icon of the crying Indian looking at Ron/Hermione.
* The [[Zero Punctuation]] review of [[Fallout]] 3 has a visual sting of a deer crying when he talks about the landscape being littered with gravel.
* The [[Zero Punctuation]] review of ''[[Fallout]] 3'' has a visual sting of a deer crying when he talks about the landscape being littered with gravel.
* The Earth Day special of ''[[Marvel Comics|Marvel Super Heroes]]-What The?!'' has [[Black Panther]] shed a tear after the wind blows a candy wrapper into [[Pet Avengers (Comic Book)|Zabu]]'s face.
* The Earth Day special of ''[[Marvel Comics|Marvel Super Heroes]]-What The?!'' has [[Black Panther]] shed a tear after the wind blows a candy wrapper into [[Pet Avengers|Zabu]]'s face.


== [[Western Animation]] ==
== [[Western Animation]] ==
* Directly parodied in the 200th episode of ''[[The Simpsons]]'', "Trash of the Titans," in which, as Springfield moves five miles away to a new location, a Duff beer can is discarded at the foot of an Indian. The Indian stares at the litter, then at the camera, and sheds a tear. Another Indian comes up from behind him and warns, "Do yourself a favor: Don't turn around." The camera pans to Springfield's former location, [[Trash of the Titans|now buried with all the trash Homer buried underground.]] The first Indian screams, and the second one lectures, "I ''told'' you not to turn around."
* Directly parodied in the 200th episode of ''[[The Simpsons]]'', "Trash of the Titans," in which, as Springfield moves five miles away to a new location, a Duff beer can is discarded at the foot of an Indian. The Indian stares at the litter, then at the camera, and sheds a tear. Another Indian comes up from behind him and warns, "Do yourself a favor: Don't turn around." The camera pans to Springfield's former location, [[Trash of the Titans|now buried with all the trash Homer buried underground.]] The first Indian screams, and the second one lectures, "I ''told'' you not to turn around."
* [[The Nostalgia Critic (Web Video)|The Nostalgia Critic]] sheds a tear when he watches [[Tom and Jerry (Animation)|Tom and Jerry]] singing and dancing about how they are best friends in [[The Movie]].
* [[The Nostalgia Critic]] sheds a tear when he watches [[Tom and Jerry]] singing and dancing about how they are best friends in [[The Movie]].
* ''[[The Critic]]'': When Duke tries to make "Savvy Indian Chewing Tobacco" a sponsor, complete with an Indian on the set, Jay rips up his contract and throws the pieces at the Indian's feet, making him shed a tear.
* ''[[The Critic]]'': When Duke tries to make "Savvy Indian Chewing Tobacco" a sponsor, complete with an Indian on the set, Jay rips up his contract and throws the pieces at the Indian's feet, making him shed a tear.
* Subverted in ''[[Futurama (Animation)|Futurama]]''. A native Martian sheds a tear at a can of Slurm which was carelessly discarded by [[Fake Ultimate Hero|Zapp Branigan]]. Leela thinks the native Martian is crying over how wasteful Zapp is; turns out he's crying because someone he knew named Cynthia used to drink Slurm.
* Subverted in ''[[Futurama]]''. A native Martian sheds a tear at a can of Slurm which was carelessly discarded by [[Fake Ultimate Hero|Zapp Branigan]]. Leela thinks the native Martian is crying over how wasteful Zapp is; turns out he's crying because someone he knew named Cynthia used to drink Slurm.
* Ceviche from ''[[Chowder]]'' has done this multiple times. While these were most likely not a direct parody, it's still worth mentioning.
* Ceviche from ''[[Chowder]]'' has done this multiple times. While these were most likely not a direct parody, it's still worth mentioning.
* Parodied in ''[[Moral Orel (Animation)|Moral Orel]]'' with the mascot of Diorama Elementary. The mascot is called "The Vanishing American" and is a stereotypical Indian chief with a teardrop painted on his cheek.
* Parodied in ''[[Moral Orel]]'' with the mascot of Diorama Elementary. The mascot is called "The Vanishing American" and is a stereotypical Indian chief with a teardrop painted on his cheek.
* In a [[Flash Back]] to the Arizona episode of ''[[Gargoyles (Animation)|Gargoyles]]'', Elisa's grandfather sheds a single tear when his son (Elisa's father) leaves the tribe to go to New York.
* In a [[Flash Back]] to the Arizona episode of ''[[Gargoyles]]'', Elisa's grandfather sheds a single tear when his son (Elisa's father) leaves the tribe to go to New York.
* [[King of the Hill]]: In "The Arrow Head", Bill cries a single tear when comparing the government taking Hank's land to the government taking the Indians' land.
* [[King of the Hill]]: In "The Arrow Head", Bill cries a single tear when comparing the government taking Hank's land to the government taking the Indians' land.
* Parodied in a [[Harvey Birdman Attorney At Law]] episode by Apache Chief.
* Parodied in a [[Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law]] episode by Apache Chief.
* In the ''[[Phineas and Ferb (Animation)|Phineas and Ferb]]'' episode "Isabella and the Temple of Sap", a hippie guru sheds a single tear as he relates how the maraca-nut trees the Fireside Girls are looking for were harvested to the brink of extinction.
* In the ''[[Phineas and Ferb]]'' episode "Isabella and the Temple of Sap", a hippie guru sheds a single tear as he relates how the maraca-nut trees the Fireside Girls are looking for were harvested to the brink of extinction.
* Parodied in the ''[[Pepper Ann]]'' episode "Dances With Ignorance," in order to show Pepper's [[Stereotype|cluelessness]] about that part of her own heritage.
* Parodied in the ''[[Pepper Ann]]'' episode "Dances With Ignorance," in order to show Pepper's [[Stereotype|cluelessness]] about that part of her own heritage.
* In a [[Pinky and The Brain]] episode where they try to pass themselves off as an endangered species, a propaganda ad is shown with Brain looking over the city of Pittsburgh and shedding a tear.
* In a [[Pinky and The Brain]] episode where they try to pass themselves off as an endangered species, a propaganda ad is shown with Brain looking over the city of Pittsburgh and shedding a tear.
Line 73: Line 73:
[[Category:Tear Tropes]]
[[Category:Tear Tropes]]
[[Category:Crying Indian]]
[[Category:Crying Indian]]
[[Category:Shout-Outs Index]]

Latest revision as of 22:46, 29 March 2022

People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It.

Somewhere, an Indian is crying.

In 1971, the Keep America Beautiful organization aired a famous TV commercial of a Native American shedding a Single Tear at the sight of litter being dropped on the road (in a follow-up ad, the Indian rides with a big smile through towns where people are cleaning up).

It's known as the "Crying Indian" ad, although it is called "People Start Pollution, People Can Stop It". At the time this was quite a powerful ad. Not subtle, but of the Some Anvils Need to Be Dropped variety.

But these days, with the overuse of the Magical Native American trope (not to mention that the actor portraying him was Italian-American), this ad has become a Stock Parody. Thus while some still believe in the message, it's hard to resist a good joke from it.

You can find videos online of course.

Examples of Crying Indian include:

Film

  • Inverted in Kingpin, where a group of Native Americans drove by Ishmael and threw garbage at Ishmael's feet.
  • In the 2008 Knight Rider movie, KITT shows this picture when Mike litters in him.
  • In Wayne's World 2, Jim Morrison's Naked Indian Friend sheds tears on seeing the scattered trash left over from Waynestock. He cheers up, though, when he sees Wayne and Garth picking up the mess.

Live-Action TV

  • In one Friends episode, the characters are stranded at a rest stop. Chandler throws his empty pack of cigarettes on the ground. When scolded, he replies, "I thought maybe if I littered, that crying Indian might come along and save us."
  • From Mystery Science Theater 3000's infamous take on Mitchell, there is a scene where Mitchell dumps what seems to be two ashtrays worth of cigarette butts on the ground.

Servo: Somewhere, an Indian is crying.

    • Mystery Science Theater 3000 also referenced it during the film Werewolf. An Indian contracts lycanthropy, and the early symptoms make him look like he's sobbing more than anything else:

Crow: [sobs] There's just so much litter on the highway!

  • The ad was mocked on the recycling episode of Penn & Teller: Bullshit!. Penn pointed out that the ad was a terrible form of ethnic stereotyping and compared it to making a commercial encouraging people to save their money that showed a Jew shedding a single tear.
  • Mocked in Married... with Children. Al wants nothing to do with a Keep Chicago Green movement until he realizes that he's been put in a car pool with some beautiful young girls. Now he wants to make sure that keeps up, so he makes Keep Chicago Green commercials. At the end of one, he takes a fake tear out of his pocket and sticks it on his cheek

Music

  • Also parodied by VH-1 during an ad for a 1970's tribute week several years ago, with the Indian played by Jimmie Walker.
  • The opening lyrics to the Eels song Mr. E's Beautiful Blues;

"The smokestack spitting black soot into the sooty sky/ The load on the road brings a tear to the Indian's eye"

Video Games

  • In World of Warcraft, there's a taunka (imagine an anthropomorphic bison) in a village in the Borean Tundra named Iron Eyes. His quest text includes describing a "single tear" running down his face. The quest he gives? Cleaning up the debris gnomes have left scattered around the geyser fields.

Web Animation

Pedro: Hey! You can't throw garbage into the time vortex!
Max: Yeah, Sam! Somewhere a time travelling Native American is crying!

Web Comics

Web Original

  • Parodied by the WCW fansite DDT Digest - rather then star ratings, bad matches were rated in crying Indians. The later years of the federation saw a lot of crying Indians in the recap.
  • Somebody in the Harry Potter fandom compared the "Harmonians" to the Trail of Tears, so someone on Fandom Wank made an icon of the crying Indian looking at Ron/Hermione.
  • The Zero Punctuation review of Fallout 3 has a visual sting of a deer crying when he talks about the landscape being littered with gravel.
  • The Earth Day special of Marvel Super Heroes-What The?! has Black Panther shed a tear after the wind blows a candy wrapper into Zabu's face.

Western Animation

  • Directly parodied in the 200th episode of The Simpsons, "Trash of the Titans," in which, as Springfield moves five miles away to a new location, a Duff beer can is discarded at the foot of an Indian. The Indian stares at the litter, then at the camera, and sheds a tear. Another Indian comes up from behind him and warns, "Do yourself a favor: Don't turn around." The camera pans to Springfield's former location, now buried with all the trash Homer buried underground. The first Indian screams, and the second one lectures, "I told you not to turn around."
  • The Nostalgia Critic sheds a tear when he watches Tom and Jerry singing and dancing about how they are best friends in The Movie.
  • The Critic: When Duke tries to make "Savvy Indian Chewing Tobacco" a sponsor, complete with an Indian on the set, Jay rips up his contract and throws the pieces at the Indian's feet, making him shed a tear.
  • Subverted in Futurama. A native Martian sheds a tear at a can of Slurm which was carelessly discarded by Zapp Branigan. Leela thinks the native Martian is crying over how wasteful Zapp is; turns out he's crying because someone he knew named Cynthia used to drink Slurm.
  • Ceviche from Chowder has done this multiple times. While these were most likely not a direct parody, it's still worth mentioning.
  • Parodied in Moral Orel with the mascot of Diorama Elementary. The mascot is called "The Vanishing American" and is a stereotypical Indian chief with a teardrop painted on his cheek.
  • In a Flash Back to the Arizona episode of Gargoyles, Elisa's grandfather sheds a single tear when his son (Elisa's father) leaves the tribe to go to New York.
  • King of the Hill: In "The Arrow Head", Bill cries a single tear when comparing the government taking Hank's land to the government taking the Indians' land.
  • Parodied in a Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law episode by Apache Chief.
  • In the Phineas and Ferb episode "Isabella and the Temple of Sap", a hippie guru sheds a single tear as he relates how the maraca-nut trees the Fireside Girls are looking for were harvested to the brink of extinction.
  • Parodied in the Pepper Ann episode "Dances With Ignorance," in order to show Pepper's cluelessness about that part of her own heritage.
  • In a Pinky and The Brain episode where they try to pass themselves off as an endangered species, a propaganda ad is shown with Brain looking over the city of Pittsburgh and shedding a tear.