All The Tropes:Example as a Thesis: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
m (removed Category:Just for Fun using HotCat)
m (updated the trope list)
Line 13: Line 13:


{{tropelist|Tropes employing Example as a Thesis include:}}
{{tropelist|Tropes employing Example as a Thesis include:}}
==A-E==
* [[Actually Not a Vampire]]
* [[Actually, That's My Assistant]]
* [[Actually, That's My Assistant]]
* [[Actually Not a Vampire]]
* [[Aesop Amnesia]]
* [[Aesop Amnesia]]
* [[Ah, You Know Him]]
* [["Alone with Prisoner" Ploy]]
* [[America Saves the Day]]
* [[America Saves the Day]]
* [[And Then What?]]
* [[And Then What?]]
Line 22: Line 25:
* [[Bad Mood As an Excuse]]
* [[Bad Mood As an Excuse]]
* [[Bad Powers, Bad People]]
* [[Bad Powers, Bad People]]
* [[Bait the Dog]]
* [[Bait and Switch Boss]]
* [[Bait and Switch Boss]]
* [[Bait the Dog]]
* [[Best Years of Your Life]]
* [[Best Years of Your Life]]
* [[Better to Die Than Be Killed]]
* [[Better to Die Than Be Killed]]
* [[Big First Choice]]
* [[Big First Choice]]
* [[Binary Characterization Assumption]]
* [[Binding Ancient Treaty]]
* [[Binding Ancient Treaty]]
* [[Bottled Heroic Resolve]]
* [[Bottled Heroic Resolve]]
Line 36: Line 40:
* [[Changed My Mind, Kid]]
* [[Changed My Mind, Kid]]
* [[Character Check]]
* [[Character Check]]
* [[Cincinnatus]]
* [[City of Weirdos]]
* [[City of Weirdos]]
* [[Cliché Storm]]
* [[Cliché Storm]]
Line 41: Line 46:
* [[Coincidental Accidental Disguise]]
* [[Coincidental Accidental Disguise]]
* [[Coitus Ensues]]
* [[Coitus Ensues]]
* [[Come Out, Come Out, Wherever You Are]]
* [[The Complainer Is Always Wrong]]
* [[The Complainer Is Always Wrong]]
* [[The Cretaceous Is Always Doomed]]
* [[Conflict Ball]]
* [[Conflict Ball]]
* [[Converse with the Unconscious]]
* [[Converse with the Unconscious]]
* [[Crazy Cultural Comparison]]
* [[Crazy Cultural Comparison]]
* [[The Cretaceous Is Always Doomed]]
* [[Critical Backlash]]
* [[Critical Backlash]]
* [[Crush Parade]]
* [[Crush Parade]]
Line 63: Line 67:
* [[Did You Think I Can't Feel?]]
* [[Did You Think I Can't Feel?]]
* [[Died Standing Up]]
* [[Died Standing Up]]
* [[Disability Immunity]]
* [[Disappears Into Light]]
* [[Disappears Into Light]]
* [[Disability Immunity]]
* [[Do Not Taunt Cthulhu]]
* [[The Dog Bites Back]]
* [[The Dog Bites Back]]
* [[The Dog Was the Mastermind]]
* [[The Dog Was the Mastermind]]
* [[Domino Revelation]]
* [[Domino Revelation]]
* [[Do Not Taunt Cthulhu]]
* [[Don't Shoot the Message]]
* [[Don't Shoot the Message]]
* [[Dungeon Bypass]]
* [[Dungeon Bypass]]
Line 78: Line 82:
* [[Eyes Are Mental]]
* [[Eyes Are Mental]]
* [[The Eyes Have It]]
* [[The Eyes Have It]]

==F-J==
* [[Fake Kill Scare]]
* [[Fake Kill Scare]]
* [[Famous-Named Foreigner]]
* [[Famous-Named Foreigner]]
Line 83: Line 89:
* [[Fidelity Test]]
* [[Fidelity Test]]
* [[Finger Muzzle]]
* [[Finger Muzzle]]
* [[For Massive Damage]]
* [[:Category:For Massive Damage|For Massive Damage]]
* [[Game Over]]
* [[Game Over]]
* [[Genocide Backfire]]
* [[Genocide Backfire]]
Line 102: Line 108:
* [[House Inspection]]
* [[House Inspection]]
* [[House Rules]]
* [[House Rules]]
* [[Humanity's Wake]]
* [[I'm Not Hungry]]
* [[I Can Change My Beloved]]
* [[I Can Change My Beloved]]
* [[I Didn't Mean to Turn You On]]
* [[I Didn't Mean to Turn You On]]
* [[I Work Alone]]
* [[Idiosyncratic Cover Art]]
* [[Idiosyncratic Cover Art]]
* [[I'm Not Hungry]]
* [[Improvised Training]]
* [[Improvised Training]]
* [[Incompatible Orientation]]
* [[Incompatible Orientation]]
Line 111: Line 119:
* [[Invisible Streaker]]
* [[Invisible Streaker]]
* [[It Is Not Your Time]]
* [[It Is Not Your Time]]
* [[I Work Alone]]
* [[Jailbird of Panama]]
* [[Jailbird of Panama]]
* [[Jury of the Damned]]
* [[Jury of the Damned]]
* [[Just Hit Him]]
* [[Just Hit Him]]
* [[Justifying Edit]]
* [[Justifying Edit]]

==K-O==
* [[Kaizo Trap]]
* [[Kaizo Trap]]
* [[Kids Prefer Boxes]]
* [[Kids Prefer Boxes]]
Line 129: Line 138:
* [[Like You Would Really Do It]]
* [[Like You Would Really Do It]]
* [[Lost in a Crowd]]
* [[Lost in a Crowd]]
* [[The Love Slap of Epiphany]]
* [[Love Will Lead You Back]]
* [[Lovecraft Lite]]
* [[Lovecraft Lite]]
* [[Lover and Beloved]]
* [[Lover and Beloved]]
* [[The Love Slap of Epiphany]]
* [[Love Will Lead You Back]]
* [[Mainstream Obscurity]]
* [[Mainstream Obscurity]]
* [[The Man Behind the Curtain]]
* [[The Man Behind the Curtain]]
Line 162: Line 171:
* [[No Party Like a Donner Party]]
* [[No Party Like a Donner Party]]
* [[No Sympathy]]
* [[No Sympathy]]
* [[No Zombie Cannibals]]
* [[Not Actually the Ultimate Question]]
* [[Not Actually the Ultimate Question]]
* [[Not Brainwashed]]
* [[Not Brainwashed]]
Line 168: Line 178:
* [[Note to Self:]]
* [[Note to Self:]]
* [[Now Let Me Carry You]]
* [[Now Let Me Carry You]]
* [[No Zombie Cannibals]]
* [[The Obi Wrong]]
* [[Object Tracking Shot]]
* [[Object Tracking Shot]]
* [[Opinion Myopia]]
* [[Opinion Myopia]]
* [[Orgasmically Delicious]]
* [[Orgasmically Delicious]]
* [[Orphean Rescue]]
* [[Our Hero Is Dead]]
* [[Our Hero Is Dead]]
* [[Overt Operative]]
* [[Overt Operative]]

==P-T==
* [[Parents as People]]
* [[Parents as People]]
* [[Parody Retcon]]
* [[Parody Retcon]]
Line 180: Line 191:
* [[Please Kill Me If It Satisfies You]]
* [[Please Kill Me If It Satisfies You]]
* [[Police Brutality Gambit]]
* [[Police Brutality Gambit]]
* [[Post Script Season]]
* [[Postscript Season]]
* [[The Power of Acting]]
* [[The Power of Acting]]
* [[Premature Aggravation]]
* [[Premature Aggravation]]
Line 189: Line 200:
* [[Rebellious Rebel]]
* [[Rebellious Rebel]]
* [[Refitted for Sequel]]
* [[Refitted for Sequel]]
* [[Retroactive Recognition]]
* [[Revenge by Proxy]]
* [[Revenge by Proxy]]
* [[Reverse Cerebus Syndrome]]
* [[Reverse Cerebus Syndrome]]
* [[Same Content Different Rating]]
* [[Same Content, Different Rating]]
* [[Samus Is a Girl]]
* [[Samus Is a Girl]]
* [[Say Your Prayers]]
* [[Say Your Prayers]]
Line 203: Line 213:
* [[Shrug of God]]
* [[Shrug of God]]
* [[Shut Up and Save Me]]
* [[Shut Up and Save Me]]
* [[Shut UP, Hannibal]]
* [[Silly Rabbit, Idealism Is for Kids]]
* [[Silly Rabbit, Idealism Is for Kids]]
* [[Slept Through the Apocalypse]]
* [[Slept Through the Apocalypse]]
Line 217: Line 226:
* [[Starring Special Effects]]
* [[Starring Special Effects]]
* [[Statistically Speaking]]
* [[Statistically Speaking]]
* [[The Stars Are Going Out]]
* [[The Stinger]]
* [[The Stinger]]
* [[Stop Drowning and Stand Up]]
* [[Stop Drowning and Stand Up]]
Line 222: Line 232:
* [[Such a Phony]]
* [[Such a Phony]]
* [[Sudden Sequel Death Syndrome]]
* [[Sudden Sequel Death Syndrome]]
* [[Super Team]]
* [[Superman Stays Out of Gotham]]
* [[Superman Stays Out of Gotham]]
* [[Superpower Silly Putty]]
* [[Superpower Silly Putty]]
* [[Super Team]]
* [[Surprise Creepy]]
* [[Surprise Creepy]]
* [[Surrounded by Smart People]]
* [[Surrounded by Smart People]]
Line 247: Line 257:
* [[Treachery Cover-Up]]
* [[Treachery Cover-Up]]
* [[Turns Red]]
* [[Turns Red]]

* [[Ugly Guys Hot Daughter|Ugly Guy's Hot Daughter]]
==U-Z==
* [[Unbuilt Trope]]
* [[Unbuilt Trope]]
* [[Unnecessary Time Precision]]
* [[Unnecessary Time Precision]]
Line 257: Line 268:
* [[Weapon Tombstone]]
* [[Weapon Tombstone]]
* [[Why Isn't It Attacking?]]
* [[Why Isn't It Attacking?]]
* [[With or Without You]]
* [[With This Herring]]
* [[With This Herring]]
* [[With or Without You]]
* [[Won't Take Yes for An Answer]]
* [[Won't Take Yes for An Answer]]
* [[Worlds Smallest Violin]]
* [[Working the Same Case]]
* [[Working the Same Case]]
* [[Worlds Smallest Violin]]
* [[The Worm Guy]]
* [[The Worm Guy]]
* [[Would Not Shoot a Good Guy]]
* [[Would Not Shoot a Good Guy]]

Revision as of 01:51, 27 June 2018


Example as a Thesis occurs when a trope is described by giving a generic example of it first.

Instead of trying to tell people what the trope is, it starts out describing a scenario, often written in the third person referring to Alice and Bob. The description takes a while to set up and execute even a few paragraphs. It concludes with a Title Drop before proceeding with a straight description. That straight description is the thesis.

In most cases, the better order of things is to tell the folks what you are going to talk about, then talk about it. Frequently—if the 'thesis' is good and does a good job describing the trope—you can just remove the example completely; after all, there's an entire list of perfectly serviceable examples right below the introduction... a good quote and image also tend to do a lot more than trying to work an example into the introduction text. Alternately, you can try moving the example to the middle of the description rather than the beginning so that readers know what they're supposed to be reading about ahead of time.

This isn't to say that the Example as a Thesis is never acceptable—it's just that 90% of the time, it's a weak way to introduce the trope. So if you're considering starting a description with an example, take a minute to think first about whether you should just cut to the chase instead.

In short, a trope needs a concise definition. A good quote and an image certainly help. Examples are strictly optional and a stylistic feature; an example shouldn't have to define the trope by itself.

If a description is written with an example as the thesis, list it here. This will help tropers who are in the mood to find and fix those tropes where Example as a Thesis is not the best format for the trope.[1]

Tropes employing Example as a Thesis include:

A-E

F-J

K-O

P-T

U-Z

  1. If you fix one, remember to pull it off the list. And thanks for helping out!