(cur
prevtopic)
03:15, 14 April 2024. .Pasmorade(talk | contribs)commented on "Is there a trope for..." (Two people unintentionally eating a strand of spaghetti and kissing. Like in Lady and the Tramp, Heartburn, and In the Mood for Love?)
. .+137
(cur
prevtopic)
12:58, 4 April 2024. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for..." (Regarding the first: Not specifically for that, no. It'd pretty obviously be a subtrope of Real Life Relative, but I suspect casting twin...)
. .+1,018
(cur
prevtopic)
21:19, 3 April 2024. .Pasmorade(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for..." (Actual twins who play twins in TV shows (the Olsen twins, the Sprouse twins in Zach and Cody, etc.). Additionally, is there a trope for w...)
. .+331
(cur
prevtopic)
21:28, 16 July 2023. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "New trope: Fee2Pay" (As an example, please see the trope candidate that I put into the Trope Workshop earlier today, Planet Killer. It has what we consider to...)
. .+229
(cur
prevtopic)
21:17, 16 July 2023. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "New trope: Fee2Pay" (You need more than that. You need to recreate the page properly -- it has been deleted for the following reasons: It was created in the m...)
. .+1,232
(cur
prevtopic)
13:29, 6 February 2023. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "How do I launch categories?" (Then we have two entries on the menu, because the second entry on that dropdown, right under Trope Workshop Page, is "index page", which...)
. .+202
(cur
prevtopic)
13:23, 6 February 2023. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "How do I launch categories?" (LT, we corrected that name years ago. See File:Screenshot 2023-02-06 082051.gif if it doesn't show up here.)
. .+167
(cur
prevtopic)
13:15, 6 February 2023. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "How do I launch categories?" (Minor correction: The boilerplate is called "Index page". (Because the system was set up at the very beginning of ATT, and for some reaso...)
. .+358
(cur
prevtopic)
19:18, 5 February 2023. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "How do I launch categories?" (Launching a category is easy - add it to one of the pages that you want listed in the category. That will create a redlink that you can c...)
. .+587
(cur
prevtopic)
21:24, 1 February 2023. .Ilikecomputers(talk | contribs)commented on "How do I launch categories?" (I want to launch "Witch Works", where a witch or witchcraft plays an important role in a work. I know tropes go to the Trope Workshop, bu...)
. .+386
(cur
prevtopic)
15:56, 18 November 2020. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "What can I add here?" (I'm not sure I understand your question. If you don't have anything you want to write about, why do you think you have to make a page? Yo...)
. .+196
(cur
prevtopic)
17:28, 28 December 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" ((blows dust off thread) The rename has been done - Power Trio now means what the rest of the world says it means, and the new page Trio p...)
. .+246
(cur
prevtopic)
21:20, 27 November 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "New Set of Punk" (Another thought: If we're only going to be giving a definition and a list of works, we should create these as categories instead of as tr...)
. .+142
(cur
prevtopic)
18:36, 27 November 2019. .Beta Log 86(talk | contribs)commented on "New Set of Punk" (Well, TVTropes has a page on Cassette Futurism or Formica Punk. Like I said, we ought to go for an original definition though some of the...)
. .+163
(cur
prevtopic)
14:26, 27 November 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "New Set of Punk" (We could copy with attribution the Wikipedia definition of solarpunk as a placeholder until we write our own. Is cassettepunk a thing? Th...)
. .+217
(cur
prevtopic)
04:15, 27 November 2019. .Beta Log 86(talk | contribs)commented on "New Set of Punk" (I was checking and noticed a new fleet of punk sub-genres: solar and cassette for starters. Not, sure how will be for a version here. Of...)
. .+247
(cur
prevtopic)
17:31, 9 October 2019. .Derivative(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (Yeah @Carlb, we do create categories for disambig pages. Also I recommend you follow the wppage advice, as we are heavily interlinked wit...)
. .+196
(cur
prevtopic)
17:24, 9 October 2019. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (You code it like this: {{Useful Notes|wppage=Watershed (broadcasting)}} Don't forget to add the Pages with Working Wikipedia tabs category.)
. .+171
(cur
prevtopic)
17:20, 9 October 2019. .Carlb(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (How do I fix the "Wikipedia" link? The page header for Watershed links to wikipedia:Watershed (a disambig page) when it need to link to w...)
. .+303
(cur
prevtopic)
12:22, 9 October 2019. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (Actually, we do mention that we don't use hatnotes in the third paragraph of All The Tropes:Creating Disambiguation Pages.)
. .+126
(cur
prevtopic)
12:05, 9 October 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (We inherited both articles from TV Tropes, and they were substantially more lax with duplicate articles that we are. Considering that Saf...)
. .+1,329
(cur
prevtopic)
03:44, 9 October 2019. .Carlb(talk | contribs)commented on "Merge Safe Harbor (Useful notes) to Watershed" (Safe Harbor (Useful notes) and Watershed seem to be the same concept - broadcast regulators demanding that over-the-air terrestrial stati...)
. .+1,704
(cur
prevtopic)
14:06, 6 October 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Name change request from Monday Every Day to It's Always Monday" (You left a redirect from the old name to the new name, so none of the wiki links broke. The only thing that didn't move was the Category...)
. .+194
(cur
prevtopic)
21:17, 25 July 2019. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Hugh Mann vs Most Definitely Not a Villain" (Hugh Mann is when a non-human Doppelgänger pretends to be the person he's replaced. Most Definitely Not a Villain is when somebody repeat...)
. .+227
(cur
prevtopic)
20:39, 7 May 2019. .RocketMaster(talk | contribs)commented on "Looking for a game" (I remember reading about a man in a psychiatric ward screaming about a zombie apocalypse, while a baby was crying next door to him. He th...)
. .+235
(cur
prevtopic)
00:19, 14 November 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Beady-Eye Loser Trope" (I'd be more worried about getting into trouble with Bandai - they hold the North American copyright on that particular image - but we've...)
. .+222
(cur
prevtopic)
18:33, 13 November 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Beady-Eye Loser Trope" (Hey, is the Simon image one that ATT won't get in trouble with the Other Trope wiki? Beady-Eyed Loser Just asking, since I was doing some...)
. .+155
(cur
prevtopic)
19:12, 8 November 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Cosmic Forces Trio 2.0" (Hey, I'm just letting anyone know that we're missing the Destroyer page (It currently links to an action/adventure novels) and we don't h...)
. .+206
(cur
prevtopic)
13:53, 19 August 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trivia Question" (Hey, how am I doing with the trivia? I ask mainly about the "Hey, It's That Voice/It's That Guy!", besides grammar mistakes, I heard that...)
. .+283
(cur
prevtopic)
21:14, 2 August 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Question: Cosmic Forces Trio" (So do we have a trope to describe a character that destroys? In a Cosmic Forces Trio sense, because when I made a Laconic page for this t...)
. .+204
(cur
prevtopic)
14:53, 30 July 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Forgotten Character" (Hey, I was trying to clean this up, so it won't sound like Tv Tropes. So, what do you think? I'm trying to type the article in my own wor...)
. .+218
(cur
prevtopic)
23:19, 25 July 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "My Tweaking" (Hey, I just came back to working on this trope page to clean up my messes. I am adding to it, does it read a little bit better? Trope Wor...)
. .+168
(cur
prevtopic)
18:07, 27 June 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (You're welcome. If you've been creating a completely new page, you can just move it into the main namespace (or into the Trope Workshop n...)
. .+421
(cur
prevtopic)
17:20, 27 June 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (So, when I'm done practicing in the sandbox and fix whatever article that I'm doing, how do I put said article in the trope workshop, mai...)
. .+181
(cur
prevtopic)
12:31, 27 June 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (Well, this is more geared to the fiction writer than to a wiki contributor, but there are some sections that are hard grammar -- my guide...)
. .+252
(cur
prevtopic)
23:42, 26 June 2018. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (This may require I set up a new sub-forum for help with grammar with links to resources and threads for improvement.)
. .+116
(cur
prevtopic)
02:37, 26 June 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (So, I can just post stuff there and fix it. Also, where can someone help me with my grammar and other serious issues, like some idea that...)
. .+173
(cur
prevtopic)
23:59, 24 June 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (Answering the second question first: You can practice your edits in Sandbox. As to what Sandbox is and how you can use it: Sandbox is a s...)
. .+562
(cur
prevtopic)
22:30, 24 June 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Sandbox Question" (So, how does Sandbox work and how can I utilize it. Also were can I practice my edits before I post them anywhere (i.e. Trope Workshop)?)
. .+136
(cur
prevtopic)
01:01, 7 June 2018. .24.151.22.23(talk)commented on "Someone please help" (Sir, please, this is getting incredibly frustrating. I try and try, but I just can't figure out what you mean. My Setting are allowing al...)
. .+477
(cur
prevtopic)
00:42, 7 June 2018. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Someone please help" (http://www.whatarecookies.com/ https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2480401,00.asp See these links for an explanation)
. .+123
(cur
prevtopic)
00:41, 7 June 2018. .24.151.22.23(talk)commented on "Someone please help" (I have tried adding this website to something in my Settings that says "allow Cookies for this site", but still, nothing)
. .+120
(cur
prevtopic)
00:39, 7 June 2018. .24.151.22.23(talk)commented on "Someone please help" (Okay, I'll confess here, I am a N00B when it comes to this sort of thing. I appreciate the help, but your suggestions might as well be in...)
. .+390
(cur
prevtopic)
00:34, 7 June 2018. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Someone please help" (Your account remains in good standing. I personally checked. Also,I have occasionally been logged out of my own account as well, so this...)
. .+838
(cur
prevtopic)
00:17, 7 June 2018. .24.151.22.23(talk)commented on "Someone please help" (Okay, exactly how can I confirm that? Like I said, I cannot log in. Again, my user name is HeneryVII. I don't think I've had any problems...)
. .+192
(cur
prevtopic)
21:54, 6 June 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Someone please help" (Hi HeneryVII, I can't do much from where I am, but I can confirm that your account is in good order here (i.e., there's no tempblock on i...)
. .+180
(cur
prevtopic)
18:45, 6 June 2018. .24.151.22.23(talk)commented on "Someone please help" (I cannot log in! YES, I read the message, YES, I cleaned the cookies, but nothing I do fixes this. Nothing. I'm not very computer savvy,...)
. .+328
(cur
prevtopic)
19:12, 23 May 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: Move all Logical Fallacies from Trope to Useful Notes" (Actually, as it happens they have their own category already, and some do not work as laws/formulas; those that do already are in that ca...)
. .+195
(cur
prevtopic)
19:36, 21 May 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: Move all Logical Fallacies from Trope to Useful Notes" (Okay, then... They live in Useful Notes and are categorized as Laws and Formulas. Anyone against?)
. .+98
(cur
prevtopic)
19:32, 21 May 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: clean up the pages about fan-made videos" (Rob, no one seems to care either way. Go ahead and take care of these as you see fit.)
. .+86
(cur
prevtopic)
04:54, 10 May 2018. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Corner Cover" (Anyone know why Corner Cover isn't listed in Category:Trope Workshop? Makes me wonder what other Trope Workshop type stuff isn't listed.)
. .+141
(cur
prevtopic)
02:27, 28 April 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Help New Trope - Adapted Out" (Okay, I tried fixing some parts of the description and adding examples. Does it read well or must I fix it up some more?)
. .+120
(cur
prevtopic)
12:45, 27 April 2018. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Help New Trope - Adapted Out" (Well, I see you went out of your way to make a "from scratch" version that passes copyright muster, my gratitude for doing so. I cleaned...)
. .+607
(cur
prevtopic)
04:57, 27 April 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Help New Trope - Adapted Out" (Hey, guys, I'm trying to undo some of the red links in some of the work pages that I'm doing. But please use a fine comb to this new trop...)
. .+432
(cur
prevtopic)
19:18, 18 April 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Corner Cover" (Need help with this one, since it needs more examples: https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Corner_Cover)
. .+112
(cur
prevtopic)
20:08, 9 April 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "YKTTW the joke gets the wrong answer? What's it called?" (I think "larger discourse" covers your need sufficiently until we find a better choice.)
. .+87
(cur
prevtopic)
18:00, 9 April 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "YKTTW the joke gets the wrong answer? What's it called?" (That's closer than anything else I can think of - and the description given on Wikipedia doesn't say that only one person makes the state...)
. .+142
(cur
prevtopic)
02:43, 9 April 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "YKTTW the joke gets the wrong answer? What's it called?" (Outside Joke looks to me to be a subtrope of Don't Explain the Joke - not the same thing.)
. .+93
(cur
prevtopic)
20:25, 8 April 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "YKTTW the joke gets the wrong answer? What's it called?" (What's the trope for one character offering a stock joke setup, but another character gives a completely unexpected answer? For example:...)
. .+532
(cur
prevtopic)
06:01, 5 April 2018. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Ironic Death" (I'm having a difficult time understanding this. I did bring it up on it's talk page a while ago, but I'm guessing no one has noticed yet.)
. .+161
(cur
prevtopic)
01:02, 2 April 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (Sorry, I just posted up a new trope that I need help working on. Okay, later on I'll add my thoughts about what I'm linking.)
. .+124
(cur
prevtopic)
14:26, 1 April 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (And since you haven't started the launch process, six days later... I've started it by posting a similar question on its talk page.)
. .+131
(cur
prevtopic)
03:53, 1 April 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Complicated Possibly-Requited Love" (Need help with this: https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Complicated_Possibly-Requited_Love I tried to wack my brain here.)
. .+132
(cur
prevtopic)
01:59, 29 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (I was thinking about this meme, when I was doing it and thinking of using the old Legend of Zelda pic for it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wi...)
. .+169
(cur
prevtopic)
01:05, 29 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop:Workout Fanservice" (Oh, just in case if there's something better that'll fit the description. I just usually ask this question with new tropes that I put in...)
. .+196
(cur
prevtopic)
01:01, 29 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop:Workout Fanservice" (Why would we change the title? I wish I could come up with trope names that are that good; it's descriptive and entertaining. One thing:...)
. .+291
(cur
prevtopic)
00:33, 29 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop:Workout Fanservice" (Hey, I started this: https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Workout_Fanservice Need a tiny bit of help polishing this (Trying to ca...)
. .+226
(cur
prevtopic)
19:35, 21 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: Move all Logical Fallacies from Trope to Useful Notes" (Agreed that they aren't tropes. I'm thinking they aren't audience reactions, either - like them or hate them, they're still fallacies. La...)
. .+213
(cur
prevtopic)
17:52, 21 March 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: Move all Logical Fallacies from Trope to Useful Notes" (Or maybe their own space entirely. While they can manifest in a trope-like way, they don't really exist in the same metaphorical space, b...)
. .+271
(cur
prevtopic)
13:59, 15 March 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "I could have sworn we had this somewhere..." (The Looney Tunes trope of sticking a finger in a gun to plug it and cause a backfire. If we have it, I can't find it. Can anyone point me...)
. .+159
(cur
prevtopic)
22:09, 13 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: clean up the pages about fan-made videos" (I've just tagged all four of the pages I listed above with a notice about this proposal. if you're here because of the notice, welcome, a...)
. .+230
(cur
prevtopic)
20:43, 13 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (Too bad I couldn't make a better description. I kept on brainstorming on how do I bring that idea over from Tv Tropes without copyright i...)
. .+149
(cur
prevtopic)
03:40, 13 March 2018. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: clean up the pages about fan-made videos" (Having cleaner definitions is always good. I'd set AMV to disambiguation. The links would need sorting, however.)
. .+114
(cur
prevtopic)
21:52, 12 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (Got it. I even put some weird questions in the Trope talk page, even asking if the "Villain Beating Artifact" needs to be rename?)
. .+130
(cur
prevtopic)
20:51, 12 March 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: clean up the pages about fan-made videos" (I think you've summed things us neatly. If I see another related trope as I slowly work my way through the index, I'll post it here.)
. .+133
(cur
prevtopic)
20:50, 12 March 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (I'm still thinking about that one. My initial response when I saw it was, "that's a mcguffin" -- but then I realized it was a functional...)
. .+343
(cur
prevtopic)
19:44, 12 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposal: clean up the pages about fan-made videos" (In an off-wiki discussion with User:Looney Toons, we realized that we have some media pages that don't quite match what a "reasonable bys...)
. .+1,592
(cur
prevtopic)
16:12, 12 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (I was trying to find more examples that would fit, that shock and confuse the audience (and that the creators didn't see that, the reacti...)
. .+166
(cur
prevtopic)
14:21, 12 March 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (I'd like to review Fandom Gank before it gets launched -- last time I looked at it, I thought that a lot of the newer examples were just...)
. .+247
(cur
prevtopic)
12:54, 12 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (If it was up to me, I'd launch Fandom Gank. (I just did a quick sweep through it to fix obvious spelling and grammar errors.) The other t...)
. .+161
(cur
prevtopic)
02:21, 12 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "More Stuff" (Is Fandom Gank ready to go or does it need more work? https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Fandom_Gank These need some more wiki...)
. .+276
(cur
prevtopic)
14:26, 6 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (I have no idea. When I moved "SMURFED" to "Smurfed", I gave an edit reason of "No need to shout". Does that apply here?)
. .+120
(cur
prevtopic)
03:34, 4 March 2018. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (So... I don't mean to be obnoxious, but is this thread going to go anywhere? I know you don't have that big a userbase and you've got oth...)
. .+437
(cur
prevtopic)
17:38, 2 March 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Help" (From a technical point of view, they look good to me (although a quick pass for fixing typos wouldn't hurt). From a troping point of view...)
. .+180
(cur
prevtopic)
17:07, 2 March 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Help" (Need help on these, since I'm not sure if I'm doing these tropes right. https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Cool_Scars https://a...)
. .+209
(cur
prevtopic)
23:34, 15 February 2018. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (I've just noticed SMURFING, where the all-caps seems even more inexplicable and it's not like that at all on TV Tropes (no overridden def...)
. .+158
(cur
prevtopic)
19:24, 14 February 2018. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (Searching for "is", "are" and "be" turned up mostly capital uses. The only lowercase ones I know of are All Women are Doms, All Men are S...)
. .+192
(cur
prevtopic)
17:42, 14 February 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (Style guides and common usage are always tricky - there's always a guide somewhere that matches any given style. I think we'd best take a...)
. .+343
(cur
prevtopic)
17:04, 14 February 2018. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (Really? My understanding was that "to be" is normally capitalized (see e.g. here or here). Also, isn't title case on TV Tropes done by cu...)
. .+1,061
(cur
prevtopic)
14:33, 10 February 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (If the intention is to emphasize the first word, then "HAD to be Sharp" would be correct. If emphasis isn't required or desired, then "Ha...)
. .+526
(cur
prevtopic)
01:12, 10 February 2018. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "HAD to Be Sharp" (I think HAD to Be Sharp should be renamed to Had to Be Sharp. I already did it, but apparently that was wrong (oops). I'm not sure the cu...)
. .+687
(cur
prevtopic)
14:37, 7 February 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we really need..." (Yes, except for things like that bogus animated Anne Frank movie and its million subpages, which I got jumped on for deleting a few years...)
. .+207
(cur
prevtopic)
14:09, 6 February 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we really need..." (Found the only reference to this "work": http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/posts.php?discussion=aaz27la7wplbqf441u101e1w&page=1 So, yeah, this i...)
. .+235
(cur
prevtopic)
19:59, 5 February 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we really need..." (A self-demonstrating page for Word Salad, and a nearly-identically-named page for an imaginary work that makes almost as little sense? Un...)
. .+350
(cur
prevtopic)
23:27, 2 February 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Tongue Suicide" (https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:Tongue_Suicide Guys, don't forget the examples that needs to be added.)
. .+115
(cur
prevtopic)
16:09, 25 January 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "So, About the Trope Pantheon" (So, what's the plans about resurrecting the Trope Pantheon? Since the bot didn't get them (I posted a similar question in the "Long Term"...)
. .+146
(cur
prevtopic)
01:07, 21 January 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "So Where Are The New Trope Pages" (They're in the main namespace -- the "default" area -- just like any other established trope. Which is what is meant by launching them. I...)
. .+520
(cur
prevtopic)
21:37, 20 January 2018. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposed rename of trope: from "Monday Every Day" to "It's Always Monday"" (The current name shows it's distinct from Groundhog Day Loop and Frozen in Time, however.)
. .+97
(cur
prevtopic)
03:23, 20 January 2018. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "So Where Are The New Trope Pages" (I'm wondering after these new tropes come out of the workshop, where can I find them? So, I can add more examples to them and edit out an...)
. .+161
(cur
prevtopic)
22:53, 19 January 2018. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposed rename of trope: from "Monday Every Day" to "It's Always Monday"" (Since "Monday Every Day" and "It's Always Monday" means pretty much the same thing, I'm not opposed to it.)
. .+106
(cur
prevtopic)
21:38, 19 January 2018. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposed rename of trope: from "Monday Every Day" to "It's Always Monday"" (You know, the wiki isn't your personal playground, RocketMaster. Your ridiculously elevated sense of privilege has just wiped out any goo...)
. .+280
(cur
prevtopic)
17:53, 19 January 2018. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposed rename of trope: from "Monday Every Day" to "It's Always Monday"" (Well, that particular "someone" is a full-time admin and I'm a part-time admin, so I can't go yell at him... :) That said, there is a pro...)
. .+391
(cur
prevtopic)
17:48, 19 January 2018. .RocketMaster(talk | contribs)commented on "Proposed rename of trope: from "Monday Every Day" to "It's Always Monday"" (I am the author of the page "Monday Every Day", and I don't like that name. I want it changed to "It's Always Monday". I already renamed...)
. .+230
(cur
prevtopic)
03:44, 20 December 2017. .SimYouLater(talk | contribs)commented on "Trope Workshop: Cool School" (Copied over my only recent trope, Cool School. It's currently in the Trope Workshop languishing because 90% of the links don't link to an...)
. .+227
(cur
prevtopic)
18:45, 30 November 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "the phrase, "this is awesome"." (Sounds like just a Stock Phrase to me. There's no inherent storytelling element embodied in a three-word line of dialogue, so it's not pr...)
. .+157
(cur
prevtopic)
03:04, 13 October 2017. .Keybounce(talk | contribs)commented on "Looking for "Coin Flip Justice"" (I'm looking for a trope that describes things like Twoface flipping a coin, or Terezi's early troll-hood coin flips, or, sadly, if you go...)
. .+237
(cur
prevtopic)
11:17, 6 October 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "True Art Is Realistic" (IIRC, that's on our "Restore" list -- I'll bet you we can safely harvest everything off a copy of the original page from the Wayback Mach...)
. .+195
(cur
prevtopic)
02:39, 6 October 2017. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "True Art Is Realistic" (https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:True_Art_Is_Realistic Hey, ya guys, don't forget to add some really good examples for this t...)
. .+183
(cur
prevtopic)
02:37, 22 September 2017. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Aloof Dark Haired Man" (Hey, I was working a bit on the Trope Workshop. When I was doing some research for the "Aloof Dark Haired Man" and I got the weirdest fee...)
. .+398
(cur
prevtopic)
23:26, 5 September 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on ""Widget Series" - Esoteric Name" (If we rename the page to "Weird Japanese Thing", then we'll need another page for all the non-Japanese examples that are currently there.)
. .+137
(cur
prevtopic)
23:56, 4 September 2017. .Derivative(talk | contribs)commented on ""Widget Series" - Esoteric Name" (Apparently it's just a short hand of Weird Japanese Thing just like Teal Deer can be considered short hand for TL;DR. Either rename it to...)
. .+206
(cur
prevtopic)
23:36, 4 September 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on ""Widget Series" - Esoteric Name" (According to Wikipedia, widget has at least eight different real-world meanings - none of which are remotely connected to the trope curre...)
. .+239
(cur
prevtopic)
23:39, 18 August 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Performance Artist"" (Just to finish it off, I've manually updated the last link that pointed at "Performance Artist" instead of "Into Musical Theatre", and st...)
. .+218
(cur
prevtopic)
20:05, 17 August 2017. .Derivative(talk | contribs)commented on "New top-level template" (I see the potential, Other Sites and whatever the new top-level is will have to be two separate categories, due to IIRC not all of them c...)
. .+219
(cur
prevtopic)
19:03, 17 August 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "New top-level template" (In going page-by-page through the Works category, I've found any number of pages for websites that by themselves are not works in the sen...)
. .+647
(cur
prevtopic)
13:03, 11 August 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Help and Question" (Yes, actually I've been meaning to suggest launching it for a while now. Which I'll do now, just to give people a chance to weigh in first.)
. .+140
(cur
prevtopic)
00:02, 11 August 2017. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Help and Question" (Okay, thanks, LT, for correcting me. So, I just go to the wiki talk and is BoT good to go? https://allthetropes.org/wiki/Trope_Workshop:B...)
. .+163
(cur
prevtopic)
01:00, 10 August 2017. .Jade Shauni(talk | contribs)commented on "Help and Question" (So, how do I find examples for this trope? I can't find a thing on Wayback Machine, except the description of the trope. Link: https://al...)
. .+194
(cur
prevtopic)
13:11, 31 July 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Clock Roaches?" (It's not obvious, yes, but given its scope... the replacement would fit about as well at best, or set the scope too narrow (which would m...)
. .+223
(cur
prevtopic)
21:19, 19 July 2017. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Clock Roaches?" (The name is pretty unintuitive. My suggestions would be "Is Pissed" or "Hates Time Travel" after something like "Time", "The Timeline", o...)
. .+254
(cur
prevtopic)
04:14, 21 May 2017. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "The The Tropes" (Another one that is missing from the list is The McCoy, which to my disappointment, as far as I can tell, has NOTHING to do with the Hatf...)
. .+157
(cur
prevtopic)
15:13, 3 May 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Performance Artist"" (As I just posted on its talk page, there is a far more widely-accepted definition of Performance Artist than "Flamboyant Gay who's into t...)
. .+282
(cur
prevtopic)
21:41, 30 April 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "YKTTW the theme music plays - but it's the wrong music" (YKTTW the theme music plays - but it's the wrong music? What's it called? E.g. http://www.collectedcurios.com/sequentialart.php?s=981)
. .+151
(cur
prevtopic)
14:09, 9 April 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on ""Greater Scope" tropes" (I definitely agree with you on this being a characters-only trope. IMHO, the concepts of good and evil only apply to people who can choos...)
. .+219
(cur
prevtopic)
02:18, 9 April 2017. .Series Of Numbers(talk | contribs)commented on ""Greater Scope" tropes" (That makes sense. I'd still recommend have a "Bigger Good" trope, though, for good forces or characters who are important to the setting...)
. .+879
(cur
prevtopic)
00:43, 9 April 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on ""Greater Scope" tropes" (To me, a "greater scope" character is one that appears in multiple otherwise-unconnected stories (for example, many Marvel and DC comic-b...)
. .+259
(cur
prevtopic)
00:35, 9 April 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on ""Greater Scope" tropes" (Eh, I don't see any problem with the current name. It means exactly what it says, goes nicely with the Big Bad trope as is, and while the...)
. .+239
(cur
prevtopic)
02:53, 8 April 2017. .Series Of Numbers(talk | contribs)commented on ""Greater Scope" tropes" (Does anyone here think we should create a "Greater Scope Paragon" page and/or change the name of "Bigger Bad" to "Greater Scope Villain"...)
. .+233
(cur
prevtopic)
07:24, 6 April 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (OK, now we're onto a week here. TBeholder makes a good point. In my view, it's this: If a line is a Non Sequitur, it can have a place in...)
. .+763
(cur
prevtopic)
01:29, 2 April 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Well, we already have pages for both "Narm" and "Bathos", so that wouldn't be a renaming project.)
. .+97
(cur
prevtopic)
20:13, 1 April 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (IMO it's rather descriptive, in that "you see a big-lipped alligator" gives an impression that it's not just a non sequitur somewhere, bu...)
. .+228
(cur
prevtopic)
07:46, 1 April 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Narm" to "Bathos"" (I wasn't kidding. I guess Narm was kind of a big deal in 2005, but it's not like I can find anything relevant on google today outside of...)
. .+6,311
(cur
prevtopic)
07:28, 31 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (I guess I'm just worried that this thread is only a couple of days old. And that while we have essential agreement within the administrat...)
. .+658
(cur
prevtopic)
03:29, 30 March 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Alright, fine. I use AutoWikiBrowser as my bot engine of choice, which is less flexible than your Perl driven bot in some ways, so I'll h...)
. .+398
(cur
prevtopic)
23:49, 29 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Well, uh, a couple objections. First, a philosophical one, which was one of the issues you in that article you just linked to, Geth: that...)
. .+917
(cur
prevtopic)
23:16, 29 March 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Well, if there no objections, the renaming can begin, and when that happen, Gethbot shall make sure the links are all fixed.)
. .+124
(cur
prevtopic)
23:00, 29 March 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Agreed - Labster's proposal is probably the best we'll get, and we can use "Non Sequitur" as the top-level category for the whole shootin...)
. .+145
(cur
prevtopic)
19:56, 29 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (Actually, I never had a dislike for this trope name, despite it being obscure, because it is obviously something that doesn't belong. Tha...)
. .+601
(cur
prevtopic)
16:43, 29 March 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (I'll do my best, but I just realized the new term creates a bit of Accidental Innuendo when it's abbreviated, so I think I might go with...)
. .+230
(cur
prevtopic)
16:40, 29 March 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (I could make a joke about how the trope name is so out of tune with what the trope is about that it goes all the way through and comes ou...)
. .+536
(cur
prevtopic)
13:55, 29 March 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename "Big Lipped Alligator Moment" to "Non Sequitur Scene"" (A point was brought up here about how the term has aged poorly, is based on an obscure reference, and not very descriptive of the actual...)
. .+980
(cur
prevtopic)
09:24, 29 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (And down another 100, to 1020 links. I got rid of all Zero Context Examples, and renamed any example that mentioned The Spock, The Kirk,...)
. .+284
(cur
prevtopic)
09:52, 27 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (OK, ran the first bot. It's reduced the number of links on Power Trio to 1116, which is 250 pages less to check. Well, sort of. While mos...)
. .+449
(cur
prevtopic)
20:13, 26 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Maybe. I guess I can't imagine someone linking to Three by Three on purpose. Wait, I just did it. D'oh! Anyway, I had something of a thou...)
. .+888
(cur
prevtopic)
08:06, 25 March 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (While I understand TBeholder's argument here, I think this has more to do with Trope Decay of the Freudian Trio concept, than it does wit...)
. .+1,137
(cur
prevtopic)
15:53, 20 March 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for overacheivers?" (We don't have "Overacheiver" as a trope, but this is a pretty good example of the trope: http://www.birdandmoon.com/comic/northern-pygmy-...)
. .+162
(cur
prevtopic)
22:50, 24 February 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (In itself, yes. But there are many examples/potholes that don't really fit and dumping them in one place rather than just dropping them m...)
. .+265
(cur
prevtopic)
14:36, 24 February 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (I'm of the opinion that "a category for trio in general" would be a case of People Sit on Chairs, but I'm willing to listed to arguments...)
. .+160
(cur
prevtopic)
14:01, 24 February 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Point is, there needs to be a category for trio in general, Freudian Trio and generic trio trope (or to look it from the other angle, uns...)
. .+211
(cur
prevtopic)
11:54, 24 February 2017. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "The The Tropes" (The Neidermeyer. I'm not sure if Neidermeyer is iconic enough that someone gets what the trope means based on name recognition (I didn't...)
. .+590
(cur
prevtopic)
11:50, 23 February 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (A good part, yes. I still don't see how linking everything to Freudian Trio is a good idea. At a glance, it looks like potholing so ridic...)
. .+236
(cur
prevtopic)
11:07, 23 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (T'was in the original proposal. I tried to add a third word like Triumphant Trio Tropes to form a trilogy but tragically it's not tractab...)
. .+181
(cur
prevtopic)
04:43, 23 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Guys, the current page is a category. It's not a trope, it's an analogue to Category:Duo Tropes. As far as possible I've been trying to r...)
. .+550
(cur
prevtopic)
23:47, 22 February 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Most of what's listed on the current Power trio page has nothing to do with Freud:Blonde, Brunette, Redhead ; Knight, Knave, and Squire ;...)
. .+336
(cur
prevtopic)
23:13, 22 February 2017. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (I agree with this proposed change. If you need a bot, send me the deets on what needs done, and I'll let Gethbot do his thing.)
. .+127
(cur
prevtopic)
13:07, 22 February 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Agreed. I was one of the original voices on TVT saying things like "if there's already a name for it among the professionals, let's use t...)
. .+430
(cur
prevtopic)
02:07, 22 February 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (Sounds good to me. We're supposedly a wiki about the building blocks of stories; it seems reasonable that we should be able to communicat...)
. .+235
(cur
prevtopic)
00:43, 22 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Rock Trio -> Power Trio -> Freudian Trio" (I hate to be that guy who wants to ruin all of the history of TV Tropes and All The Tropes but... sigh. Power Trio is currently a list al...)
. .+1,592
(cur
prevtopic)
13:36, 13 February 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Last Call in the Trope Workshop for..." (A merge I can handle. And yeah, Anonymous Gladiator. (yes, complete with inexplicable period at the end of the name) has some potential,...)
. .+841
(cur
prevtopic)
11:30, 13 February 2017. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Last Call in the Trope Workshop for..." (Afterlife Search And Rescue is an obvious duplicate that needs to be merged with redirect, per talk page. Anonymous Gladiator kind of has...)
. .+269
(cur
prevtopic)
09:11, 13 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Last Call in the Trope Workshop for..." (OK, so I really like Trope Workshop:Trimurti Trio. I learned about a new concept from the page, which is always cool. It's got a great wr...)
. .+426
(cur
prevtopic)
02:17, 12 February 2017. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Last Call in the Trope Workshop for..." (It looks to me like the only thing keeping "Binary Characterization Assumption" from launching is a lack of examples - and I don't see Ir...)
. .+239
(cur
prevtopic)
21:05, 10 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for..." (Yeah, I'm not seeing a trope. Though I seem to recall it happening in Bullwinkle. Mighty Roar comes closest.)
. .+114
(cur
prevtopic)
16:10, 10 February 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for..." (... the moment when a hero walks up to a monster, and it roars into his face, possibly blowing his hair back with the force of the roar,...)
. .+178
(cur
prevtopic)
09:39, 1 February 2017. .Labster(talk | contribs)commented on "The The Tropes" (I want to necro this thread because I'm a bit worried about The Apprentice. I'm not really happy with (trope) being part of the page name...)
. .+961
(cur
prevtopic)
02:19, 13 January 2017. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Clearing Out Trope Workshop" (Well, I've got it down to six candidates, two of which just need a little more work to polish them up, several of which just need some ex...)
. .+253
(cur
prevtopic)
17:26, 25 November 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Written by the Winners vs. Historical X Upgrade vs. Politically-Correct History" (I thought they were already distinct. Written by the winners is where the winner of a conflict decides who was righteous and who was not...)
. .+880
(cur
prevtopic)
13:09, 25 November 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Written by the Winners vs. Historical X Upgrade vs. Politically-Correct History" (I'm sure we can come up with a consistent difference between the three. Let's use Custer's Last Stand as an example. Written by the Winne...)
. .+655
(cur
prevtopic)
03:42, 25 November 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Written by the Winners vs. Historical X Upgrade vs. Politically-Correct History" (Noticeably decayed and overlapping, so needs better definitions (at least Written by the Winners) and sorting for the less vague criteria...)
. .+453
(cur
prevtopic)
00:59, 8 November 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "What trope is in use here?" (A line by stand-up comic Dave Broadfoot: "Oklahoma! The only state named after a musical! (beat) Les Miz." (Actually, I wouldn't be surpr...)
. .+225
(cur
prevtopic)
15:12, 9 October 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Clearing Out Trope Workshop" (Six months to launch or die was just what I was coming into the forums now to suggest. There's no point in letting this stuff just sit he...)
. .+307
(cur
prevtopic)
17:46, 8 October 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Clearing Out Trope Workshop" (Probably because most of those are left from before the transfer to new host. Then the workshop wasn't working correctly for a while, so...)
. .+184
(cur
prevtopic)
15:23, 8 October 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Clearing Out Trope Workshop" (The alerting part is probably a good jobfor a bot - tag anything that hasn't been updated in six months (or whatever number we choose) wi...)
. .+250
(cur
prevtopic)
02:28, 8 October 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Clearing Out Trope Workshop" (We really need to do something with the workshop -- we have stuff in there that's been sitting untouched for a year or more. I'm going th...)
. .+362
(cur
prevtopic)
01:51, 18 September 2016. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Bribing Your Way to Victory" (I think pay-to-win might be a more common term outside of troper groups. I am proposing a rename or at the very least a redirect page. I...)
. .+265
(cur
prevtopic)
10:53, 10 September 2016. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on " N-Word Privileges" (Is this an inversion?: {{Quote|Jeff, you and Hitler have a lot in common: micropenis, you're bad at your art, and no one cared about you...)
. .+278
(cur
prevtopic)
23:42, 6 September 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Which trope is being discussed here?" (http://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=6856 It isn't Precision F-Strike - there's too many of them, but nowhere near enough for a Cluster F-Bomb...)
. .+255
(cur
prevtopic)
14:50, 2 September 2016. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Identifying trope" ((Nice Stephen Colbert clip) I would say Most Definitely Not a Villain. Johnny Cowboy (a ridiculous name for any American) uses False Reas...)
. .+522
(cur
prevtopic)
07:18, 2 September 2016. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Identifying trope" (https://youtu.be/4qG2Eylvwxg?t=1m13s What is this? Most Definitely Not a Villain? Paper-Thin Disguise? Hugh Mann? Clark Kenting?)
. .+145
(cur
prevtopic)
12:55, 23 August 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Big Screwed up Family" (I don't see anything in Big Screwed-Up Family indicating a family size, although there is an implication that larger families have more w...)
. .+172
(cur
prevtopic)
04:42, 22 August 2016. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Big Screwed up Family" (Is the "many traditions" or the size of the family important? I'm trying to find a trope that fits what the fifth diary user from Mirai N...)
. .+411
(cur
prevtopic)
12:12, 15 August 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on ""Reactionary Fantasy"" (In many ways: Nobody is complaining about shows. It's about reactionary works, not right-wing works. "Reactionary" means "going back to t...)
. .+381
(cur
prevtopic)
11:13, 10 August 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Title-guessing game: "I Can't Use These Things Together"" (Talking to Yourself redirects to another page with a Non-Indicative Title, as well. So much for that fix.)
. .+109
(cur
prevtopic)
15:39, 9 August 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Title-guessing game: "I Can't Use These Things Together"" (See the right answer at I Can't Use These Things Together. We have a strong contender for The Non-Indicative Title of the Year contest here.)
. .+144
(cur
prevtopic)
21:19, 8 July 2016. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "President Pages" (The Useful Notes template doesn't handle all the subpages properly, and practically every President has been referenced in some form of m...)
. .+427
(cur
prevtopic)
01:09, 25 May 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "What is the difference between "New Media" and "Web Original"?" (Oooh, good question. "Interactive" usually means back-and-forth between viewers and creators; when the work offers the chance for "viewer...)
. .+207
(cur
prevtopic)
13:38, 24 May 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "What is the difference between "New Media" and "Web Original"?" (Okay, there's some value to having both, in that one can be used for interactive works. Is something like Fenspace (which invites new aut...)
. .+228
(cur
prevtopic)
12:37, 24 May 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "What is the difference between "New Media" and "Web Original"?" (Mm. Yes. RWBY would be "Web Original" but since it doesn't involve any kind of viewer feedback (at least no more than more traditionally...)
. .+318
(cur
prevtopic)
09:21, 24 May 2016. .Uladox(talk | contribs)commented on "What is the difference between "New Media" and "Web Original"?" (I we have to choose one I would vote for "Web Original" since it is clear what it is. I hope I don't sound too out of the loop when I say...)
. .+810
(cur
prevtopic)
21:42, 23 May 2016. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Shana Clone" (The original version has more details in the trope's description and corrects some typos. Otherwise, they're the same. The sandbox versio...)
. .+161
(cur
prevtopic)
17:36, 23 May 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Shana Clone" (We have two versions of this page -- one at Shana Clone and another at Shana Clone/Sandbox. There are small but noticeable differences be...)
. .+336
(cur
prevtopic)
13:26, 18 May 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Need a Hand - or A Handjob?" (I think that's something different from what we're discussing here. (And it isn't paratext, either.) Certainly "the old bait and switch"...)
. .+260
(cur
prevtopic)
23:40, 15 May 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Need a Hand - or A Handjob?" (By way of Missing Supertrope. Show a teaser portraying the normally upright hero acting in an evil and despicable manner, causing the aud...)
. .+651
(cur
prevtopic)
23:06, 15 May 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Need a Hand - or A Handjob?" (How so? An innuendo is made, and it backfires - the trope name looks descriptive to me.)
. .+88
(cur
prevtopic)
14:40, 5 May 2016. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Lolicon - Restore pre-censorship version?" (I concur, please do what you can to rescue the page before the censors went after it, at least in regards to making it more informative a...)
. .+164
(cur
prevtopic)
04:07, 5 May 2016. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Lolicon - Restore pre-censorship version?" (Yes, a thousand times yes. The original version is way more informational and isn't something dumb like "Lolicon = Pedophile". If anythin...)
. .+205
(cur
prevtopic)
02:15, 5 May 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Lolicon - Restore pre-censorship version?" (Lolicon came up on my radar tonight as a page with comment tags; when I went in I found a rather large amount of TVT justification for a...)
. .+853
(cur
prevtopic)
23:00, 2 May 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Need a Hand - or A Handjob?" (Well, not all the examples are subtle enough to be innuendo, but I think it's a good suggestion.)
. .+96
(cur
prevtopic)
19:38, 2 May 2016. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Need a Hand - or A Handjob?" (The trope, formerly named "Solicitation Mistaken For Help", is about someone's Double Entendre being misinterpreted as literal by another...)
. .+282
(cur
prevtopic)
17:28, 22 March 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Death Penalty By Extradition" (In a crime/legal drama set in a location without the death penalty, almost always Big Applesauce, the drama of the death penalty is reint...)
. .+787
(cur
prevtopic)
18:51, 20 March 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (What we have de facto is: the trope as named, simple and limited, closely related to Monochrome Casting. AND/OR the version re-spun to in...)
. .+621
(cur
prevtopic)
18:32, 20 March 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (If we include the word "white", then we continue having the problem that the trope name doesn't cover Bollywood or Anime. The best altern...)
. .+230
(cur
prevtopic)
09:11, 20 March 2016. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (I think the trope name itself being too wide is the problem. The current description does narrow it down, but the fact that we're even ha...)
. .+221
(cur
prevtopic)
04:12, 20 March 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (Even if not, it probably will. So, needs a clear description. And maybe supertrope/subtrope split (cough, Anime, cough).)
. .+121
(cur
prevtopic)
00:13, 20 March 2016. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (I wonder if after the original trope creation the trope description had been edited to exclude silliness like those complaints about Harr...)
. .+227
(cur
prevtopic)
14:52, 19 March 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (But the description says it has nothing to do with whiteness. It also is genre specific but has no indicator in the title.)
. .+123
(cur
prevtopic)
00:27, 19 March 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "What is the difference between "New Media" and "Web Original"?" (According to their descriptions, Category:New Media is for "works that can be found originally on the internet", and Category:Web Origina...)
. .+242
(cur
prevtopic)
14:47, 15 March 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "What's this trope?" (YKTTW somebody starts a phrase that you expect to finish in a particular way, but finishes it in a completely different way? An example,...)
. .+250
(cur
prevtopic)
14:45, 15 March 2016. .Robkelk(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (If the work is historical, certainly. If the work is SF, then one would need to explain why the demographics are skewed away from humanit...)
. .+183
(cur
prevtopic)
22:17, 14 March 2016. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (How about All Demographics Are American? This is a subtrope of Creator Provincialism/Audience Provincialism and is a supertrope to Politi...)
. .+345
(cur
prevtopic)
01:50, 13 March 2016. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (Well, it can have a legitimate use, as a story in which only white humans are depicted when there is no cultural or plot based reason why...)
. .+524
(cur
prevtopic)
19:45, 12 March 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Rework Humans Are White" (Humans Are White seems like Complaining About Casts You Don't Think are Diverse Enough. The description suggests it is supposed to be a c...)
. .+241
(cur
prevtopic)
14:41, 12 March 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Manipulative Bastard and Chessmaster" (It's in the first paragraph of Manipulative Bastard, but basically, the difference is the Chessmaster is wholesale, and the Manipulative...)
. .+334
(cur
prevtopic)
21:25, 17 February 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Bokukko" (If the term does not exist in Japanese, go with the one that does. However, the "double K" does exist in some other romanizations. "Chibi...)
. .+265
(cur
prevtopic)
21:08, 17 February 2016. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Bokukko" (I support this if the current title is wrong like it apparently is. My Japanese is terrible, but I think it's important to treat such thi...)
. .+202
(cur
prevtopic)
19:04, 17 February 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename Bokukko" (I'm pretty sure Bokukko was titled by someone who didn't really understand the Japanese language and just made something up. The Japanese...)
. .+750
(cur
prevtopic)
18:08, 11 February 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "The Dragon: The most sacred of all sacred cows" (How about using "Lieutenant" somewhere in the name? English vernacular already has it mean a second in command that does the the dirty wo...)
. .+199
(cur
prevtopic)
17:39, 11 February 2016. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Suspiciously High Security?" (Characters realize something isn't what it looks like because there is way too much security for its cover. A bakery shouldn't have the l...)
. .+790
(cur
prevtopic)
03:42, 9 February 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Do we have a trope for..." (...how SF writers have a tendency to incorporate the latest theory, development or gizmo into their new stories as a major plot point? So...)
. .+801
(cur
prevtopic)
03:36, 9 February 2016. .Msq(talk | contribs)commented on "Weird sentences on TVT" (I'd agree. Though in the case of TVT, at least in the more frequented/frequently edited pages there tends to be a more predominant group...)
. .+162
(cur
prevtopic)
03:34, 9 February 2016. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Weird sentences on TVT" (It's hard to say, but I'd wager it's just the cumulative effect of thousands of different people editing the articles over the years. Las...)
. .+455
(cur
prevtopic)
19:08, 7 February 2016. .RocketMaster(talk | contribs)commented on "Weird sentences on TVT" (Why does TV Tropes (and this wiki) have weird sentences like "Unusually uncommon" and others like that? I don't understand, and i'm sorry...)
. .+169
(cur
prevtopic)
23:17, 4 January 2016. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "guess the trope: "Old Friend"." (That's descriptive, but can we come up with a shorter or snappier version? "An Old Friend Appears", or something.)
. .+113
(cur
prevtopic)
08:19, 3 January 2016. .Uladox(talk | contribs)commented on "Hello, world!" (Hello, my name is Uladox and I am new to the world of All the Tropes. I decided to join since it looked fun, plus cc by-sa is now GPL com...)
. .+693
(cur
prevtopic)
21:09, 20 December 2015. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Guess the trope: "Big Lipped Alligator Moment"" (Hmm... Naming it Blam! Moment or Episode makes it sound like someone gets shot in the moment. Such a shocking moment would bring it back...)
. .+435
(cur
prevtopic)
20:06, 20 December 2015. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Guess the trope: "Big Lipped Alligator Moment"" (It was an acronym? I was thinking (because even though I had read the trope description, my brain has shown incredible resistance to the...)
. .+726
(cur
prevtopic)
19:38, 20 December 2015. .SelfCloak(talk | contribs)commented on "Guess the trope: "Big Lipped Alligator Moment"" (You have a good point, but naming it BLAM Moment would be redundant (Big Lipped Alligator Moment Moment) I don't have good names at the m...)
. .+183
(cur
prevtopic)
18:14, 20 December 2015. .Nerdanel(talk | contribs)commented on "Guess the trope: "Big Lipped Alligator Moment"" (I had bumped into this trope several times and eventually started to remember it by how I could never remember what it was. So go ahead a...)
. .+597
(cur
prevtopic)
21:39, 17 November 2015. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Free Food for big eater?" (These might be related: Mountain of Food and Improbable Food Budget. If we still need a trope for this, go ahead and create one in the Tr...)
. .+169
(cur
prevtopic)
19:29, 17 November 2015. .2dgirlfan(talk | contribs)commented on "Free Food for big eater?" (Is there an existing trope for Big Eater being offered an unqualified amount of free food and characters making referencing to how this w...)
. .+262
(cur
prevtopic)
01:06, 9 May 2015. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "Fourth Wall Myopia vs. Viewer Myopia" (While obviously distinct, may need some cross-references more eloquent than "not to be confused with X". And yes, Needs More Wick Love.)
. .+151
(cur
prevtopic)
01:29, 3 May 2015. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Magnetic Plot Device vs. Plot Generator" (The former seems to be the instigator for plots revolving around a common premise or theme for a work, where the latter is merely a sprin...)
. .+266
(cur
prevtopic)
07:33, 31 March 2015. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "We should rename "Jossed" to something more intuitive." (What do you mean "What do you mean"? Is it a term that's actually used anywhere? Or do you propose to change an actually used (if obscure...)
. .+344
(cur
prevtopic)
02:42, 31 March 2015. .Tau Ceti(talk)commented on "We should rename "Jossed" to something more intuitive." (Creator's Dismissal? I know it sounds rather ambiguous, needs to be better.)
. .+75
(cur
prevtopic)
02:39, 31 March 2015. .Tau Ceti(talk)commented on "Stuff that doesn't make sense?" (In any work, to any category, please note what you want to say does not make sense. Maybe once this is finished we will move such discuss...)
. .+179
(cur
prevtopic)
07:37, 16 March 2015. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Complete Monster YMMV" (This post by GethN7 was moved on 2015-03-16. You can find it at Thread:Forum:Trope Talk/Complete Monster YMMV.)
. .+125
(cur
prevtopic)
09:54, 7 February 2015. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rape tropes name restoration" (At the time I proposed this, I was only thinking of the ones that currently start with "Double Standard Rape". But other pages were renam...)
. .+206
(cur
prevtopic)
15:41, 6 February 2015. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "Rename: Help Help Trapped in Title Factory" (I was about to rename Help Help Trapped in Title Factory to add punctuation, but in thinking about it, I felt it needed a bit more of a r...)
. .+323
(cur
prevtopic)
16:50, 5 February 2015. .GethN7(talk | contribs)commented on "Rape tropes name restoration" (Not entirely sure that's wise, but I do see your point about some of the names being really clunky.)
. .+99
(cur
prevtopic)
08:55, 5 February 2015. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Rape tropes name restoration" (I was thinking we should restore the name of the tropes that had their name changed as a result of The Second Google Incident back to the...)
. .+185
(cur
prevtopic)
11:53, 1 February 2015. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "Grimmification rename" (I find Grimmification a poor name for the trope. My understanding is the Brothers Grimm bowdlerized what they published. Sure they left t...)
. .+314
(cur
prevtopic)
22:56, 27 January 2015. .Goo Monster(talk | contribs)commented on "He Who Must Not Be Named redirect" (I'm not that familiar with Harry Potter, but I am pretty certain He Who Must Not Be Named in Harry Potter is an example of The Scottish T...)
. .+399
(cur
prevtopic)
14:45, 27 January 2015. .Looney Toons(talk | contribs)commented on "He Who Must Not Be Named redirect" (Ooooh, that's a hard one. Speak of the Devil is a lot like what made the Trope Namer the Trope Namer, but The Scottish Trope is closer to...)
. .+227
(cur
prevtopic)
22:47, 8 January 2015. .Flyingcat(talk | contribs)commented on "Change the title of "Improbably Female Cast"?" (Couldn't we just have created Improbably Male Cast (or even merge both concepts into Improbably Gender-biased Cast or something)? Both ca...)
. .+451
(cur
prevtopic)
08:59, 8 January 2015. .TBeholder(talk | contribs)commented on "We should rename "Jossed" to something more intuitive." (It's not limited to Buffy fandom, though not omnipresent either. In the end, if there's no comparable (as either widespread or clear and...)
. .+184