Made of Phlebotinum: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{trope}}
{{trope}}


[[File:Mass-Effect-as-Phlebotinum_6452.jpg|link=Awkward Zombie|frame|"How could you [[Hand Wave]] everything like that?"<br />"[[Mass Effect]]."]]
[[File:Mass-Effect-as-Phlebotinum 6452.jpg|link=Awkward Zombie|frame|"How could you [[Hand Wave]] everything like that?" "[[Mass Effect]]."]]


Some [[The Verse|settings]] ''have'' [[Phlebotinum]]. It helps [[Screw the Rules I Have Plot|move along the plot]], [[Hand Wave]] various characters' [[Willing Suspension of Disbelief|improbable]] powers, and conveniently get the [[Heroes]] [[Teleporters and Transporters|from point A to point B quickly]]. It can let you just say [[A Wizard Did It]].
Some [[The Verse|settings]] ''have'' [[Phlebotinum]]. It helps [[New Rules as the Plot Demands|move along the plot]], [[Hand Wave]] various characters' [[Willing Suspension of Disbelief|improbable]] powers, and conveniently get the [[Heroes]] [[Teleporters and Transporters|from point A to point B quickly]]. It can let you just say [[A Wizard Did It]].


But then some settings...are different. They have nothing ''but'' Phlebotinum. That [[City of Adventure]] the heroes are exploring around? It's completely [[Floating Continent|floating]] in the air; not one building is touching the ground. Why? Phlebotinum! In fact, the whole planet is probably bound together with some sort of magical or super-science energy, without which it would simply [[Earthshattering Kaboom|explode]]. Every single thing around requires whatever the local flavor of Phlebotinum is to run in worlds such as these, whether it's [[Functional Magic|magic]], [[Nanomachines]], [[The Force]], or something else similar.
But then some settings...are different. They have nothing ''but'' Phlebotinum. That [[City of Adventure]] the heroes are exploring around? It's completely [[Floating Continent|floating]] in the air; not one building is touching the ground. Why? Phlebotinum! In fact, the whole planet is probably bound together with some sort of magical or super-science energy, without which it would simply [[Earthshattering Kaboom|explode]]. Every single thing around requires whatever the local flavor of Phlebotinum is to run in worlds such as these, whether it's [[Functional Magic|magic]], [[Nanomachines]], [[The Force]], or something else similar.


The main dividing line between a world that simply has a lot of Phlebotinum and one that's [[Made of Phlebotinum|made of the stuff]] is this litmus test: if you took away the Phlebotinum, would your world still exist in any meaningful sense, or would it more or less just [[The End of the World as We Know It|collapse]]? If it would, your world is just plain Made Of Phlebotinum.
The main dividing line between a world that simply has a lot of Phlebotinum and one that's ''made of the stuff'' is this litmus test: if you took away the Phlebotinum, would your world still exist in any meaningful sense, or would it more or less just [[The End of the World as We Know It|collapse]]? If it would, your world is just plain '''Made of Phlebotinum'''.


There is actually a great deal of evidence that ''[[Real Life]]'' is thus: when you develop a potent capability to the point that there are few side effects, you start using it for everything imaginable. When we learned to harness electricity easily, the only things weren't 100% electrical were the things that we used to generate electricity. When computers became advanced enough, we started carrying them around with us. Litmus Test? If you took away computers, it'd '''re-create [[The Great Depression]]'''. If you took away electricity, '''''ninety percent of the world would die within a decade'''''.
There is actually a great deal of evidence that ''[[Real Life]]'' is thus: when you develop a potent capability to the point that there are few side effects, you start using it for everything imaginable. When we learned to harness electricity easily, the only things weren't 100% electrical were the things that we used to generate electricity. When computers became advanced enough, we started carrying them around with us. Litmus Test? If you took away computers, it'd ''re-create [[The Great Depression]]''. If you took away electricity, '''''ninety percent of the world would die within a decade'''''.


If something is literally made of Phlebotinum, see [[Made of Magic]].
If something is literally made of Phlebotinum, see [[Made of Magic]].


{{examples}}
{{examples}}
== [[Anime]] and [[Manga]] ==

== [[Anime]] ==
* ''[[Bleach]]''. Everything in the Soul Society is made of [[Phlebotinum|spirit particles]].
* ''[[Bleach]]''. Everything in the Soul Society is made of [[Phlebotinum|spirit particles]].
** So is everything in Hueco Mundo.
** So is everything in Hueco Mundo.
Line 28: Line 27:
* In David Wingrove's [[Chung Kuo]], the world-spanning City is made of "Ice"
* In David Wingrove's [[Chung Kuo]], the world-spanning City is made of "Ice"
* ''[[Discworld]]'' can seem ordinary enough at first glance, until it's pointed out that, without heavy duty magic involved, a flat world on the back of a giant turtle that swims through space should be utterly impossible.
* ''[[Discworld]]'' can seem ordinary enough at first glance, until it's pointed out that, without heavy duty magic involved, a flat world on the back of a giant turtle that swims through space should be utterly impossible.
** The ''Science of Discworld'' books go on to give the Phlebotinum a name: narrativium, which (together with chelonium and elephantigen) in fact makes the formation of flat worlds on board giant turtles and elephants not only natural, but ''inevitable''. Too bad [[Real Life|Roundworld]] lacks these ''perfectly normal elements'' and had to concoct some outlandish alternative involving big rocky balls...
** ''[[The Science of Discworld]]'' books go on to give the Phlebotinum a name: narrativium, which (together with chelonium and elephantigen) in fact makes the formation of flat worlds on board giant turtles and elephants not only natural, but ''inevitable''. Too bad [[Real Life|Roundworld]] lacks these ''perfectly normal elements'' and had to concoct some outlandish alternative involving big rocky balls...
** In ''[[Discworld/The Last Hero|The Last Hero]]'' Discworld comic, Cohen and his Silver Horde have made it their mission to bring fire back to the gods --- via a large explosive. This would suddenly remove magic from the world and cause everything to die.
** In ''[[The Last Hero]]'' Discworld comic, Cohen and his Silver Horde have made it their mission to bring fire back to the gods --- via a large explosive. This would suddenly remove magic from the world and cause everything to die.
* The Roman-based society of ''The [[Codex Alera]]'' is so connected with their Phlebotinum of Furycrafting that the use of certain techniques and technologies, such as quarrying, [[Medieval Stasis|are a lost art.]]
* The Roman-based society of ''The [[Codex Alera]]'' is so connected with their Phlebotinum of Furycrafting that the use of certain techniques and technologies, such as quarrying, [[Medieval Stasis|are a lost art.]]
* ''The [[Chronicles of Thomas Covenant]].'' Then, in the Second Trilogy, {{spoiler|They lose the phlebotinum. This is way more horrific than it sounds.}}
* ''The [[Chronicles of Thomas Covenant]].'' Then, in the Second Trilogy, {{spoiler|They lose the phlebotinum. This is way more horrific than it sounds.}}


== [[Live Action TV]] ==
== [[Live-Action TV]] ==
* Technology in ''[[Doctor Who]]'' is pure phlebotinum: the Sonic Screwdriver that can fix anything ([[Plot-Sensitive Items|unless it's deadlocked or wood]]), Psychic Paper (in the new series), Transmat teleporters, Dalek antigravity, time rings/vortex manipulators that fit on one's wrist, and of course the blue box that's bigger on the inside and travels through time and space. Despite its ostensibly scientific worldview, it's hard to think of a story that uses accurate science.
* Technology in ''[[Doctor Who]]'' is pure phlebotinum: the Sonic Screwdriver that can fix anything ([[Plot-Sensitive Items|unless it's deadlocked or wood]]), Psychic Paper (in the new series), Transmat teleporters, Dalek antigravity, time rings/vortex manipulators that fit on one's wrist, and of course the blue box that's bigger on the inside and travels through time and space. Despite its ostensibly scientific worldview, it's hard to think of a story that uses accurate science.
* ''[[Star Trek]]'' probably is, too. Most tools in the Trekverse don't need to touch what they're working on, just to give one example.
* ''[[Star Trek]]'' probably is, too. Most tools in the Trekverse don't need to touch what they're working on, just to give one example.


== [[Tabletop Games]] ==
== [[Tabletop Games]] ==
* ''[[Eberron]]'''s [[Dungeon Punk]] world comes to mind as an especially obvious example of this trope. Without that magical-flavored [[Phlebotinum]], everything in that world would fall apart ''hard''. It's pretty much [[Made of Phlebotinum]].
* ''[[Eberron]]''{{'}}s [[Dungeon Punk]] world comes to mind as an especially obvious example of this trope. Without that magical-flavored [[Phlebotinum]], everything in that world would fall apart ''hard''. It's pretty much Made of Phlebotinum.
** To a lesser extent, all ''[[Dungeons and Dragons]]'' settings fit this trope. ''[[Planescape]]'' and ''[[Spelljammer]]'' especially, but even a place like ''[[Forgotten Realms]]'' is mildly [[Made of Phlebotinum]].
** To a lesser extent, all ''[[Dungeons & Dragons]]'' settings fit this trope. ''[[Planescape]]'' and ''[[Spelljammer]]'' especially, but even a place like ''[[Forgotten Realms]]'' is mildly Made of Phlebotinum.
** [[Ravenloft]] literally so - it's a series of artifically-created "demiplanes" floating in the misty emptiness of the Ethereal Plane. When a domain's [[Cosmic Keystone]] is destroyed, it may be absorbed by neighboring domains, or it may simply collapse into the Mists.
** [[Ravenloft]] literally so - it's a series of artifically-created "demiplanes" floating in the misty emptiness of the Ethereal Plane. When a domain's [[Cosmic Keystone]] is destroyed, it may be absorbed by neighboring domains, or it may simply collapse into the Mists.
* ''[[Exalted]]'', full stop. Creation itself is the greatest artifact ever built, while [[Odd Job Gods]] exist for individual rice grains and their interactions provide the physics of the universe.
* ''[[Exalted]]'', full stop. Creation itself is the greatest artifact ever built, while [[Odd Job Gods]] exist for individual rice grains and their interactions provide the physics of the universe.
Line 45: Line 44:


== [[Video Games]] ==
== [[Video Games]] ==
* ''[[World of Warcraft]]'' seems more [[Made of Phlebotinum]] than most fantasy worlds, what with all its [[Magitek|magically-powered civilizations]] and such. What's also notable is the multitudes of flavors of [[Phlebotinum]]; The Draeni lean towards magic crystals [[Imported Alien Phlebotinum|given them by the Naaru]], [[Our Elves Are Better|Blood Elves]] throw around Arcane magic like it's going out of style, the [[Our Gnomes Are Weirder|Gnomes]] love their tech, with a healthy dose of Arcane, and the [[Everything's Better with Cows|Tauren]] stick to their [[Nature Hero|hunting, gathering, and communion with nature]].
* ''[[World of Warcraft]]'' seems more Made of Phlebotinum than most fantasy worlds, what with all its [[Magitek|magically-powered civilizations]] and such. What's also notable is the multitudes of flavors of [[Phlebotinum]]; The Draeni lean towards magic crystals [[Imported Alien Phlebotinum|given them by the Naaru]], [[Our Elves Are Better|Blood Elves]] throw around Arcane magic like it's going out of style, the [[Our Gnomes Are Weirder|Gnomes]] love their tech, with a healthy dose of Arcane, and the [[Everything's Better with Cows|Tauren]] stick to their [[Nature Hero|hunting, gathering, and communion with nature]].
** According to [http://www.viddler.com/rooreynolds/videos/26/ this] video, Azeroth is a sphere about 12 kilometers across, with a density around a hundred times that of Earth. This explains why when you drop an item it disappears; due to the gravity it is crushed into an extremely fine powder spread over a wide area.
** According to [http://www.viddler.com/rooreynolds/videos/26/ this]{{broken link}} video, Azeroth is a sphere about 12 kilometers across, with a density around a hundred times that of Earth. This explains why when you drop an item it disappears; due to the gravity it is crushed into an extremely fine powder spread over a wide area.
* In ''[[Chrono Trigger]]'', the magical floating continent of Zeal is this. It completely depends on magical energy to stay aloft and its residents do pretty much everything by magic.
* In ''[[Chrono Trigger]]'', the magical floating continent of Zeal is this. It completely depends on magical energy to stay aloft and its residents do pretty much everything by magic.
* ''[[Touhou]]'' is pretty much supposed to be where, when [[The Magic Goes Away]] on the rest of the Earth because [[Magic Versus Science|the progress of technology leads to a lack of faith in magic]], all the magic is swept up and kept inside Gensokyo so that all the monsters, demons, and Gods can still live their magically supercharged lives. The technology is generally [[Bamboo Technology]] hybrids with [[Magitek]], or simply stolen from "[[This Is Reality|the Real World]]". It is also worth noting that even the [[Muggles]] have ''some'' kind of superpower in Gensokyo, it's just that you only hear about the [[Really Seven Hundred Years Old|world-bendingly powerful little girls.]]
* ''[[Touhou]]'' is pretty much supposed to be where, when [[The Magic Goes Away]] on the rest of the Earth because [[Magic Versus Science|the progress of technology leads to a lack of faith in magic]], all the magic is swept up and kept inside Gensokyo so that all the monsters, demons, and Gods can still live their magically supercharged lives. The technology is generally [[Bamboo Technology]] hybrids with [[Magitek]], or simply stolen from "[[This Is Reality|the Real World]]". It is also worth noting that even the [[Muggles]] have ''some'' kind of superpower in Gensokyo, it's just that you only hear about the [[Really Seven Hundred Years Old|world-bendingly powerful little girls.]]
* ''[[Tales of Symphonia]]'' and ''[[Tales of Phantasia]]'' are like this. The main focus for most of both games is preserving the mana flow and thus preventing the collapse of the world. Without it, magic won't work, crops won't grow, etc.
* ''[[Tales of Symphonia]]'' and ''[[Tales of Phantasia]]'' are like this. The main focus for most of both games is preserving the mana flow and thus preventing the collapse of the world. Without it, magic won't work, crops won't grow, etc.
* [[Mass Effect]] uses this as its ''[[Character Title]] [[Title Drop|Drop]]'', despite being one of the [[Mohs Scale of Science Fiction Hardness|hardest]] [[Space Opera|Space Operas]] to date. How does [[Casual Interstellar Travel|Casual]] [[Faster-Than-Light Travel]] work? [[Applied Phlebotinum|Mass Effect Fields]], generated by [[Unobtainium|Element]] [[Minovsky Physics|Zero]]. How do the [[Flying Car|Flying Cars]] fly? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do [[Differently-Powered Individual|Biotics]] [[Mind Over Matter|move things with their minds]]? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do the guns have [[Bottomless Magazines]]? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do {{spoiler|the Reapers build a space station in the '''[[Black Holes|galactic core?]]}}''' <s>[[His Dark Materials|Subatomic Angels]]</s> '''''[[Overly Long Gag|Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero.]]''''' And of course, without Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero, [[Anthropic Principle|there would be no interstellar civilization]].
* [[Mass Effect]] uses this as its ''[[Character Title]] [[Title Drop|Drop]]'', despite being one of the [[Mohs Scale of Science Fiction Hardness|hardest]] [[Space Opera]]s to date. How does [[Casual Interstellar Travel|Casual]] [[Faster-Than-Light Travel]] work? [[Applied Phlebotinum|Mass Effect Fields]], generated by [[Unobtainium|Element]] [[Minovsky Physics|Zero]]. How do the [[Flying Car]]s fly? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do [[Differently-Powered Individual|Biotics]] [[Mind Over Matter|move things with their minds]]? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do the guns have [[Bottomless Magazines]]? Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero. How do {{spoiler|the Reapers build a space station in the '''[[Black Holes|galactic core?]]'''}} <s>[[His Dark Materials|Subatomic Angels]]</s> '''''[[Overly Long Gag|Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero.]]''''' And of course, without Mass Effect Fields, generated by Element Zero, [[Anthropic Principle|there would be no interstellar civilization]].
** [http://masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Dark_energy It's till pretty hard], [[wikipedia:Dark energy|all things considering]].
** [http://masseffect.wikia.com/wiki/Dark_energy It's till pretty hard], [[wikipedia:Dark energy|all things considering]].


== [[Web Comics]] ==
== [[Web Comics]] ==
* [[8-Bit Theater]] has recently ''proven'' it's made of Phlebotinum, since, in that world, you can drill for mana.
* [[8-Bit Theater]] has recently{{when}} ''proven'' it's made of Phlebotinum, since, in that world, you can drill for mana.
** No, you can't. That's why attempting to do so is bankrupting Cornelia. Their king is just crazy.
** No, you can't. That's why attempting to do so is bankrupting Cornelia. Their king is just crazy.


Line 60: Line 59:
* In the blog-novel ''[[Flyover City]]!'' – Malphysical Particles create a cosmic loophole which render the laws of physics “malleable”, allowing the story’s superheroes to do all those superhero-y things that are impossible in the real world.
* In the blog-novel ''[[Flyover City]]!'' – Malphysical Particles create a cosmic loophole which render the laws of physics “malleable”, allowing the story’s superheroes to do all those superhero-y things that are impossible in the real world.
* The world of ''[[Tales of MU]]'' is driven by [[Magitek]], the physics are based on [[A Wizard Did It]], and from the point of view of people in other worlds, a knife that was said to be "barely enchanted" is ''[[Made of Magic|made out of magic]]''.
* The world of ''[[Tales of MU]]'' is driven by [[Magitek]], the physics are based on [[A Wizard Did It]], and from the point of view of people in other worlds, a knife that was said to be "barely enchanted" is ''[[Made of Magic|made out of magic]]''.
* [http://elcenia.com/11/251-2-41.shtml Elcenia]:
* [http://elcenia.com/11/251-2-41.shtml Elcenia]{{Dead link}}:
{{quote|"Physical laws? Oh, those things. We don't have them."
{{quote|"Physical laws? Oh, those things. We don't have them."
"But everyone has them. It's a fundamental principle."
"But everyone has them. It's a fundamental principle."
Line 66: Line 65:
"Oh, what then?"
"Oh, what then?"
"Magic. Don't look so alarmed. It's at least as reliable as gravity is." }}
"Magic. Don't look so alarmed. It's at least as reliable as gravity is." }}
* Almost everything off Earth in ''[[Fenspace]]'' is dependent upon the mystery goop known as "Handwavium".


== [[Real Life]] ==
== [[Real Life]] ==
Line 71: Line 71:


{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
[[Category:{{PAGENAME}}]]
[[Category:Applied Phlebotinum]]
[[Category:Applied Phlebotinum]]
[[Category:Made of Index]]
[[Category:Made of Index]]
Line 76: Line 77:
[[Category:Tabletop Game Tropes]]
[[Category:Tabletop Game Tropes]]
[[Category:Magic and Powers]]
[[Category:Magic and Powers]]
[[Category:Made of Phlebotinum]]

Latest revision as of 23:39, 24 February 2024


"How could you Hand Wave everything like that?" "Mass Effect."

Some settings have Phlebotinum. It helps move along the plot, Hand Wave various characters' improbable powers, and conveniently get the Heroes from point A to point B quickly. It can let you just say A Wizard Did It.

But then some settings...are different. They have nothing but Phlebotinum. That City of Adventure the heroes are exploring around? It's completely floating in the air; not one building is touching the ground. Why? Phlebotinum! In fact, the whole planet is probably bound together with some sort of magical or super-science energy, without which it would simply explode. Every single thing around requires whatever the local flavor of Phlebotinum is to run in worlds such as these, whether it's magic, Nanomachines, The Force, or something else similar.

The main dividing line between a world that simply has a lot of Phlebotinum and one that's made of the stuff is this litmus test: if you took away the Phlebotinum, would your world still exist in any meaningful sense, or would it more or less just collapse? If it would, your world is just plain Made of Phlebotinum.

There is actually a great deal of evidence that Real Life is thus: when you develop a potent capability to the point that there are few side effects, you start using it for everything imaginable. When we learned to harness electricity easily, the only things weren't 100% electrical were the things that we used to generate electricity. When computers became advanced enough, we started carrying them around with us. Litmus Test? If you took away computers, it'd re-create The Great Depression. If you took away electricity, ninety percent of the world would die within a decade.

If something is literally made of Phlebotinum, see Made of Magic.

Examples of Made of Phlebotinum include:

Anime and Manga

Youtube Commenter: I'm not sure which is weirder, the way the universe in this series works, or the fact that the universe works EXACTLY HOW KAMINA THINKS IT DOES!

Film

Literature

  • In David Wingrove's Chung Kuo, the world-spanning City is made of "Ice"
  • Discworld can seem ordinary enough at first glance, until it's pointed out that, without heavy duty magic involved, a flat world on the back of a giant turtle that swims through space should be utterly impossible.
    • The Science of Discworld books go on to give the Phlebotinum a name: narrativium, which (together with chelonium and elephantigen) in fact makes the formation of flat worlds on board giant turtles and elephants not only natural, but inevitable. Too bad Roundworld lacks these perfectly normal elements and had to concoct some outlandish alternative involving big rocky balls...
    • In The Last Hero Discworld comic, Cohen and his Silver Horde have made it their mission to bring fire back to the gods --- via a large explosive. This would suddenly remove magic from the world and cause everything to die.
  • The Roman-based society of The Codex Alera is so connected with their Phlebotinum of Furycrafting that the use of certain techniques and technologies, such as quarrying, are a lost art.
  • The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant. Then, in the Second Trilogy, They lose the phlebotinum. This is way more horrific than it sounds.

Live-Action TV

  • Technology in Doctor Who is pure phlebotinum: the Sonic Screwdriver that can fix anything (unless it's deadlocked or wood), Psychic Paper (in the new series), Transmat teleporters, Dalek antigravity, time rings/vortex manipulators that fit on one's wrist, and of course the blue box that's bigger on the inside and travels through time and space. Despite its ostensibly scientific worldview, it's hard to think of a story that uses accurate science.
  • Star Trek probably is, too. Most tools in the Trekverse don't need to touch what they're working on, just to give one example.

Tabletop Games

  • Eberron‍'‍s Dungeon Punk world comes to mind as an especially obvious example of this trope. Without that magical-flavored Phlebotinum, everything in that world would fall apart hard. It's pretty much Made of Phlebotinum.
    • To a lesser extent, all Dungeons & Dragons settings fit this trope. Planescape and Spelljammer especially, but even a place like Forgotten Realms is mildly Made of Phlebotinum.
    • Ravenloft literally so - it's a series of artifically-created "demiplanes" floating in the misty emptiness of the Ethereal Plane. When a domain's Cosmic Keystone is destroyed, it may be absorbed by neighboring domains, or it may simply collapse into the Mists.
  • Exalted, full stop. Creation itself is the greatest artifact ever built, while Odd Job Gods exist for individual rice grains and their interactions provide the physics of the universe.
    • The Phlebotinum is named Essence, and it is the essence of everything ever. Even the unshaped raksha are made of it and use it to fuel their eldritch powers. Its name is used in many places where we would use the word "atom".

Video Games

Web Comics

  • 8-Bit Theater has recently[when?] proven it's made of Phlebotinum, since, in that world, you can drill for mana.
    • No, you can't. That's why attempting to do so is bankrupting Cornelia. Their king is just crazy.

Web Original

  • In the blog-novel Flyover City! – Malphysical Particles create a cosmic loophole which render the laws of physics “malleable”, allowing the story’s superheroes to do all those superhero-y things that are impossible in the real world.
  • The world of Tales of MU is driven by Magitek, the physics are based on A Wizard Did It, and from the point of view of people in other worlds, a knife that was said to be "barely enchanted" is made out of magic.
  • Elcenia [dead link]:

"Physical laws? Oh, those things. We don't have them."
"But everyone has them. It's a fundamental principle."
"Not in this world. Everything is taken care of by magic in various forms. What's holding you to your seat isn't gravity, for example."
"Oh, what then?"
"Magic. Don't look so alarmed. It's at least as reliable as gravity is."

  • Almost everything off Earth in Fenspace is dependent upon the mystery goop known as "Handwavium".

Real Life

  • The four fundamental forces of the universe. We know how they work; the why on the other hand would need a theory of everything (Or at least this universe).