X Marks the Hero

Probably the most iconic and distinctive form of Good Scar, this scar consists of two clean, intersecting cuts that form a cross or X on the hero's face. Generally, it serves to imply that the hero has been through quite a few skirmishes while making them look Badass.

How the hero got such a scar is usually not explained. Part of our brain tells us that getting such a scar in battle is highly unlikely, if not impossible (unless they're deliberately inflicted, such as in torture). Nobody listens to this part of their brain for more than ten seconds.

Examples of X Marks the Hero include:

Anime and Manga

The poster child of this trope is Kenshin Himura of Rurouni Kenshin fame. The cross-shaped scar is associated with him so utterly that characters with this scar are regularly accused to ripping the idea from him, even if they predate him by years. Unlike many examples, Kenshin's scar proves to be from two separate incidents. In the anime, the second one was deliberately inflicted so as to make it an X.
Domon Kasshu from G Gundam has such a scar, the origins of which are mostly unexplained. It's a quick indicator of his ten-year Training from Hell.
Full Metal Panic!'s Sousuke Sagara has had one of these since he was at most twelve-years old (and likely younger). It's origins have yet to pop up, but Fanon suspects that they were inflicted during torture.
- Humorously, his Bonta-Kun costume has the same scar.
Yamcha from Dragon Ball.
- Goku's father, Bardock, also had one of these. While he can't exactly be called a good guy, he was the closest thing there was to an actually heroic Saiyan at the time.
Subverted in Naruto where Danzo has one of these on his chin.
- Maybe.
Mikage from 07-Ghost in both incarnations.
Glenn (the one from Chrono Cross, not his Chrono Trigger namesake) has a modest X-scar on his lower left cheek. He's capable of dual wielding time-duped legendary swords, but it's unclear if the scar is the source of his badassery, or simply an indicator of it.
Thatz in Dragon Knights has a small cross-shaped scar on one cheek and a larger slash mark across his face.
An antagonistic (and possibly Anti-Villain) example from One Piece is vice-admiral Doberman, who has no less than six X-shaped scars scattered across his face and neck.
- Coby also got one above his right eye when he Took a Level in Badass.
- Anti-hero X Drake has one on his chin.
- Laboon, a whale, is covered in x-shaped scars from his attempts to destroy Reverse Mountain by bashing it with his head.
- After the Time Skip, Luffy also has a huge X shaped scar on his chest. He got it from Admiral Akainu during the war at Marineford. If you check him out while Jimbei is carrying him, you can see it's still fresh.
Double subverted in Fullmetal Alchemist. Scar, who has one of these across his forehead, starts out as a He Who Fights Monsters-style Anti-Villain, but the ensuing Character Development slowly turns him into an Anti-Hero instead.
Juumonji from Eyeshield 21 sports one. He is a Delinquent Jerk with a Heart of Gold.
- His father has the same scar, though in a different place. Hero marks are apparently genetic in the Eyeshield 21 universe, though given everything else that is perfectly acceptable.
Tetsugyu from Giant Robo
While not the main character (just his boss), Saki Vashtal of Area 88 has an X scar on his forehead. In the manga, it's revealed to be self-inflicted after a disastrous attempt to make peace.
Ferio from Magic Knight Rayearth has one, but he's hardly the main hero.
Wolf's Rain's Tsume also has one on his chest that Toboe asks about, though Tsume ain't exactly eager to talk about it...
Kittan in Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann is a hero, not the hero, and has an X-shaped scar on his arm.
- And let's not forget Viral, who has one across his chest.
Sora from Shitsurakuen has one of these.
In DOGS Bullets and Carnage, Naoto has one on her chest.
Tsukune Aono from Rosario + Vampire has a huge one on his chest, among several smaller scars. Got it from a random Mook, but it also marks the first time he released his ghoul powers without Moka's aide.
Captain Miria from Claymore recently came Back from the Dead, sporting an X-shaped scar across her face and looking more badass than ever.
Katanagatari's main character has this by the end of the series, though it is explicitly shown how he got it. From intentionally taking two bullets to the face and body.}
Apollo from Genesis of Aquarion has one on his cheek. It's never mentioned how he got it.
Manji of Blade of the Immortal sports several on the right side of his face, caused by two horizontal scars and one vertical scar running through his right eye, causing him to be blind on that side.
Bean Bandit from Riding Bean - and its successor, Gunsmith Cats - sports one centered right between his eyes.
Takuto Tsunashi in Star Driver has an X-shaped Mark on his chest.

Comic Books

John Hartigan of Sin City: That Yellow Bastard has an X-scar on his forehead.
One Marvel comics character, Agent X, was distinguishable early on for these scars across his face. After being healed of these during a quasi-mystic ritual, he disappeared for a while. When he came back later on, the scars were back; he apparently carved them back on himself!
Cable has one over his eye, although sometimes it's drawn with 3 lines instead of just 2.

Film

Captain Jack Sparrow gets one on his cheekbone in time for the fourth Pirates of the Caribbean movie, though we never get an explanation as to how he got it.

Literature

In the latter books of The Dark Tower, Callahan has a cross-shaped scar. It was a memento from two would-be killers, who had tried to carve a swastika into his forehead, but were interrupted.
Redeemed Ulic Qel-Droma, from the Tales of the Jedi series, has this scar on his forehead.
Ripred from Gregor the Overlander gets this type of scar near the end of the fifth book from himself, so he could fill the role of the a person from one of Sandwich's prophecies.

Video Games

Tibarn from Fire Emblem has a large one where the horizontal cut extends across his nose and onto his other cheek.
- Og(u)ma from the same series also has one.
- It seems to be popular with the mercenaries. Dieck from Sword of Seals has one on his shoulder.
This is an option for your custom characters in Soul Calibur 3
Mass Effect allows the player to give Shepard this particular scar. Mordin Solus also has one.
Bang Shishigami of BlazBlue has one of these within his massive collection of uber-manly characteristics.
Mega Man X's Axl has one of these. Why, as a robot, he hasn't had them fixed up is never even brought up.
- Being who he is, he probably keeps it for the same reason the trope exists. However, it does heal when you use his White Armor in X8.
- A common joke among the fandom is that it's self-inflicted, and is essentially the equivalent of tattooing the name of your favorite Badass on your body.
- X's name is X, and his partner Zero has an emblem on his next shoulder that consists of an X over a Z.
Doumeki Kai of Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan! has this. One wonders where he got it, since he is, after all, head of a cheerleading squad.
Similarly, Elite Beat Agents has Commander Khan. Slightly more understandable, since he was a former CIA agent, but not by much.
Zack Fair of Final Fantasy VII fame has one of these on his cheek. Crisis Core shows how he got it... but strangely it only shows him getting one cut on his cheek.
Inverted in Kingdom Hearts, as Saix has a big ol' X right across the bridge of his nose, and he's not a heroic sorta guy.
Sue from Cave Story has one of these across the bridge of her nose.
Raven from Tekken has the two scars in the middle of his face, meeting above the nose.
Oscar, a sniper from Valkyria Chronicles, sports one of these on the left side of his forehead. He acquired it when he protected his brother in an unexplained incident from when they were children. Musaad, a scout, also sports a similar one in the same place. His scar likely came from his involvement in the previous war in the backstory of the game, him being a famous war veteran and all.
Glenn in Chrono Cross. Due to Sprite Mirroring, it's hard to say whether he has these on both cheeks or just one. And this is only the kid brother of the really heroic knight.

Web Comics

Sir Muir, in the webcomic Harkovast has scars crossing over his right eye.
Hanna Is Not a Boy's Name: Hanna has an X-shaped scar, but it's not on his face, it's on the sole of his foot. (He might have one on each foot, it's hard to tell.) X shapes are a motif of the comic in general and Hanna in particular; it's anyone's guess how much of it is related to Hanna's Mysterious Past and how much is just because Tessa likes to draw cross shapes.