The Greatest Story Never Told
I'm sorry, but we can't |
"The problem with being a secret agent," he thought as he soaked among the soap bubbles, "is that your mission is so secret that nobody knows how jolly brave you were." |
So the character has finally rescued his friends, saved the world and done whatever deeds prove he is a true hero. But nobody will ever know. Maybe he's a mere buffoon or a comedy sidekick, or the outcast of the society. Sometimes the media just hates him and ended up turning his story upside-down. Sometimes the Fake Ultimate Hero takes all the spotlights. Sometimes nobody believes his story. Sometimes his memory gets erased. Sometimes a weird time travel mechanism makes it so whatever happened didn't actually happen in time. Maybe it ends with Kill'Em All. Maybe the whole incident needs to be hushed up to protect important secrets. Or sometimes, for reasons of his own, he chooses not to tell anyone.
And occasionally - usually only in works that can comfortably invoke Rule of Funny - all the spectators are utter dimwits and can't even grasp what they've just seen. (A Confused Bystander Interview sometimes follows.)
At any rate, none of the other characters (or at larger scale, history itself) have to change their opinions about him. This can overlap with the Wild Wilderness trope often as no one outside the setting would know who the heroes were or what they did. In worst cases, by dealing with The Greatest Story Never Told, The Hero had miss the less-urgent but more well-known events. And thus the public think of him as Fallen Hero.
May be a A Day in the Limelight when done well. Poorly executed, is likely to be reviled as Filler. Often features What You Are in the Dark.
Contrast Famed in Story. Compare Victory-Guided Amnesia, in which not even the hero gets to remember, and Hero of Another Story, in which a someone other than the main character(s) is having their own adventures, and may or may not be recongized for it in-universe but will only be given token attention story-wise.See also Treachery Cover-Up.
Anime and Manga
- In the aftermath of the Captain Kuro arc of One Piece, Usopp swears the "Usopp Pirates" and Kaya to secrecy about them defeating the Black Cat Pirates, despite the fact that it would clear his reputation as a liar. He does this so that the villagers would not worry about pirate attacks.
- The Alabasta Arc, as well, features the world at large never knowing the full events about the Civil War and Crocodile's defeat.
- This continues to happen as the story progresses - the World Government usually goes to great lenghts to cover up their failures and mistakes to make sure its enemies does not gain support.
- The Alabasta Arc, as well, features the world at large never knowing the full events about the Civil War and Crocodile's defeat.
- The Zero Requiem plan of Code Geass involves creating world peace with no one ever knowing the real details behind how it came to be. Well, a chosen few know, but the truth certainly isn't going to make it into the history books.
- Pokémon - Ash Ketchum is occasionally recognized by random people who saw him lose in regional tournaments. Nobody seems to know he saves the world a few times every year on the side.
- Ash himself can't remember the first time he did so.
- Even more bizarre, no one even mentioned him bringing down two legendaries on live television.
- Being the ONLY person in the whole of Sinnoh to have managed to take down even one of said legendaries, you'd think that'd earn him some street cred.
- After Gohan in Dragonball Z destroys Cell, Hercule steps in and takes all the credit instead. Not that the heroes mind—they like their privacy.
- This becomes a plot point in the next arc, as Hercule, being the Fake Ultimate Hero, is responsible for most of the energy granted from the Earth's population into Goku's Spirit Bomb, destroying Buu. Even then, the Dragon grants a wish for everyone to forget the devastation Buu causes (the people still somehow remember Hercule as the savior, though).
- The ending of Revolutionary Girl Utena shows everyone slowly forgetting about Utena and everything she did. Well, almost everyone. While Akio muses on how, despite what she managed to do, she failed to achieve revolution because of this trope, Anthy proves him wrong by voluntarily walking out of the fairy tale-like world of Ohtori Academy to find Utena, signifying the end of Akio's machinations.
- Puella Magi Madoka Magica: The entire series ends up being a GSNT due to Madoka's wish—only Homura remembers what happened, and even Kyuubei only acknowledges that she might be telling the truth.
- Mobile Suit Gundam 00 has this as the entire premise: everyone thinks Celestial Being is just a terrorist group that just happens to be capable of curbstomping everyone into the ground all by themselves. It does change a little at the end of the second season when they get some recognition for exposing A-LAWS but they're still regarded as terrorists.
- The Distant Finale at the end of The Movie may have seen them eventually recognized as heroes, if humanity's first two interstellar spaceships (the Sumeragi and the Tieria) being named after members of Celestial Being is any indication.
- In the G Gundam prequel manga Fight 7th, Shuji Kurosu and his friends AKA the future Master Asia and Shuffle Alliance go to South Pole to keep a crazed terrorist from destroying the space colonies. They succeed, but fail to make it to Gundam Fight's Finals in time and are eliminated. Not only is their story is untold, their home nations also consider them cowards and traitors.
- A Certain Magical Index: Touma Kamijou saves the day all the time, yet no one in Academy City (besides his True Companions, enemies, and Unwanted Harem) have a clue who he is. How Touma is not treated like a celebrity after defeating Accelerator is beyond me, as people do mock Accelerator all the time for the loss. Touma doesn't mind much, as fame doesn't interest him. Touma's adventures are well known in the world of magic, where he is regarded as The Dreaded.
- The short film Kigeki is about a young girl who seeks out the Black Swordsman to save her village from an approaching army, in return for a special book. The Swordsman agrees and decimates all 200 soldiers in one night, then being a vampire, he devours the corpses. The girl sees it all, and before he goes the Swordsman tells her that if she ever breathes a word of it he'll return and kill her too. Many years later she has continued to keep the secret.
- Itachi assasinating the entire Uchiha clan to protect Konoha from a civilwar and another Ninja World War that would inevitably follow it.
- The duel between Yugi and Joey in the final episode of the Battle City Arc in Yu-Gi-Oh!. The episode ends before either of them makes any move, and conjecture aside, we can only guess how it turned out.
Comic Books
- In the DC Universe, Booster Gold is going through his entire superhero career as The Greatest Story Never Told, as he deals with Time Travel, so he has to be an idiot in the history books in order to prevent anyone messing with the timeline from having 'Eliminate Booster Gold' as step one.
- Batman knows, because Booster's failed attempt to prevent Batgirl's handicapping as per The Killing Joke results in Joker's camera having pictures of a beaten Booster. When he revealed this to Booster, he offered himself as a Secret Keeper.
- The UK Sonic the Comic did this in spades for Miles "Tails" Prower's early appearances. He had several comic where he would return to the Nameless Zone or join the Zonerunners in Chemical Plant Zone where he would perform great feats (usually by fluke), save the day, but on return not be able to say anything to Sonic either because it's hard for him to explain what happened or because Sonic is just too damn eager to move onto the next thing. A Summer Special issue continued this tradition by having a comic where Tails took out a whole swarm of badniks, only to have the last one catch him off guard and have Sonic to save him from it. Sonic admonishes Tails for not being able to defeat "one measly badnik" and doesn't believe Tails' protests that there were many more of them.
- In another story, Dr. Robotnik becomes all-powerful after stealing the power of the Chaos emeralds. Sonic and Knuckles defeat him and revert the changes he made to reality, then Sonic complains that it was the toughest challenge he'd ever won and nobody would ever know it happened.
- In Don Rosa's Donald Duck stories, Donald saves the feathers of his uncle and his nephews numerous times on each of Scrooge's treasure ventures. Most of the time no-one seems to notice his involuntary self-sacrifices, though the trope might feel a bit ignored, as Scrooge often observes the hapless heroics while commenting calmly on the situation. The answer might be that Donald has saved them so many times the bravado has lost all effect.
- Finally, finally subverted in Rosa's final Donald story, The Magnificent Seven (Minus Four) Caballeros, in which Pancho Pistoles and Jose Carioca are flabbergasted by Donald's off-hand comments about his adventures with his rich uncle, particularly when he backs it up by saving their bacon repeatedly. Actually being noticed, much less praised, did wonders for Don's self-esteem (as opposed to his ego).
- One of the many, many spinoffs to The Sandman was a miniseries called, Merv Pumpkinhead, Agent of D.R.E.A.M. in which the eponymous character—who mostly exists in the main series as comic relief—saves the Earth from a madman who wants to use Morpheus' dream-sand to conquer it. Predictably, nobody in the Dreamworld believes a word of it.
- Depending on your views on Adrian, the main plot of Watchmen may or may not play it straight. He claims to be saving the world- by killing millions of people and creating enough fear to prevent a nuclear holocaust that would kill billions instead. For obvious reasons, he doesn't admit to it, but he also loses likely trillions of dollars and his own peace of mind as well in the process and doesn't benefit from it at all.
- Technically, assuming that his predictions of the nuclear war and its preventation are right on the money (questionable but possible), he does save his own life and business by saving the world. Hard to sell anything after the civilization is gone, even if you personally survive the holocaust in some remote location.
- It's also left deliberately ambiguous as to whether the story never gets told or not.
- The League of Losers from the Marvel Universe. After a time-travelling supervillain called Chronok wipes out pretty much every superbeing on the planet thanks to future knowledge and technology, a group of little-known heroes (and one villain) are the only survivors. They manage to stop Chronok before he can kill everyone, saving the entire timeline...and are stuck in the alternate future. Not only will nobody in the 'core' reality ever know who saved the world, they won't even know it needed saving.
- In Saga of the Swamp Thing, even the other DC superheroes are surprised and stymied by Woodrue's attempts to unleash Gaia's Vengeance, as none of them had ever seen fit to include backwoods Louisiana as part of their protected territory. After Swamp Thing get the Green to settle down and quit listening to the Floronic Man's ravings, the Justice League (and presumably the world at large) has no clue what it was that stopped the plants from attacking, they're just relieved that somebody is looking out for all those little unregarded dots on the map.
- A six-issue limited series from Marvel Comics told the story of a normal human who was down on his luck and borderline suicidal who gets killed right as an extra-dimensional big bad is opening a rift with a magic artifact intending to unleash the embodiment of Death upon the multiverse. His resulting passage through the gate closes it and bonds him to the weapon making him immortal and causing him to be reborn into another universe anytime he dies as only the weapon can end his life. He eventually foolishly returns the weapon to the Big Bad after getting a promise to leave Earth alone and return him there but upon seeing all the deaths occurring sacrifices his life and dies a noble hero to end the Big Bad's scheme once and for all. Meanwhile back on earth you see the heartbreaking disposal of his worldly possessions such as family photos in a trash can while being called a worthless loser.
- X-Men member Forget-Me-Not's entire career as a hero is this. Well, most of it. A member of the core team since M-Day at least, his accomplishments include fighting the Brood, acting as a soldier during the Age of X, and saving the other members of the team from death, enslavement, and many other horrid fates dozens of times, but his heroic acts all remain unseen, uncredited, and ignored due to the odd nature of his mutant powers: you only know he exists when you can see him, and the instant he is out of your sight, you forget he existed at all. Only Xavier himself is immune to this, having put an "alarm clock" in his mind telepathically to remind him of his existence.[1]
- Also, whatever past the unnamed antagonist of Fantastic Four #50 had with Reed. He didn't seem like a megalomanical madman, so clearly, there had to be some reason he spent decades plotting revenge (and only against Reed - he clearly had nothing against the other members of the team) but he never said why, and seeing as he sacrificed himself to save Reed after Becoming the Mask, fandom likely will never know.
- Many of Squirrel Girl's exploits occur offscreen - where she has triumphed over the most powerful titans of the Marvel Universe - so as to avoid explaining exactly how. Despite this, a few of those battles were indeed fleshed-out in her own title.
- The entire plot of Too Much Coffee Man is this. The whole story focuses on what the super-hero protagonist does when he is not being a hero. All his heroics occur offscreen.
Fan Works
- This comic/animatic based on The Owl House. Hunter babysits Spikey (a baby Man-Eating Plant) for Willow, and it seems what happens while she is gone is epic. Though we only see small parts of it.
Film
- Evil Ambitions (on DVD as Satanic Yuppies) has a reporter uncover a Satanic plot to hand the world over to a group of wine-cooler-drinking yuppies. He stops the forces of Hell but Satan simply lets him go, knowing that he'll never be able to write the biggest story of his career.
- General Custer's speech at the end of the second Night at the Museum. "The greatest battle the world will never know?" (stupid in that it featured, what, 40 people? Not counting miniatures?)
- "The world will never know" because only one of the people there was an actual person. Everyone else was a mannequin or a prop.
- The emphasis there was probably on 'greatest battle', which implies no battle involving more than 40 people and lasting longer than one night has ever been lost in history.
- "The world will never know" because only one of the people there was an actual person. Everyone else was a mannequin or a prop.
- Men in Black mentions this as one of the downsides of being a MIB: "You ever hear of a guy named James Edwards? He saved 80 people on a subway car tonight, and nobody knows he even exists."
- Salt featured this in the ending, where the main character (Salt) saves America, Russia, the Middle East, and probably the rest of the world from nuclear holocaust by defeating the real villain, a Russian double agent in the CIA. The rest of the CIA arrives to see Salt and the Russian fighting, and because of the circumstances leading up to the ending, the CIA assumes Salt is one trying to kill the President and the world. In reality, she is stopping an Evil Plan by killing the Russian double agents, and no one will ever know except for one CIA agent that can never tell anyone.
- Mel Brooks' adaptation of To Be or Not to Be. An actor impersonates several Nazi officers, including Hitler, and when the whole deception is over, he remarks to himself, "My greatest performance ever...and no one saw it."
- In Wag the Dog, Hollywood producer Stanley Motss is initially enthusiastic about the fictional war he'll be "producing" just because of the challenge, but as time goes on the fact that he can't tell anyone about it eats at him more and more. Eventually his refusal to keep quiet gets him killed.
- In Source Code, the main character is sent to find out who destroyed a train, a few minutes before it happens. After many failed attempts (after each, he is sent back to the time a few minutes before it happens), this trope is invoked when he succeeds so well that nobody knew what he did--apparently he created an alternate world
Literature
- Several times in The Lord of the Rings it is implied that the majority of the peoples populating Middle-earth have forgotten almost everything about the First and Second Ages, including the existence of The One Ring of Power. Even Gandalf is unsure on the details until he spends almost a year in research. This, of course, changes.
- Gunner Ferik Jurgen, aide to Ciaphas Cain and often directly responsible for many of his greatest feats, is nevertheless omitted from pretty much all media that deals with the Commissar's life, a fact that irritates Cain to no end.
- In the new Rynn's World 40K novel, several of these are mentioned in passing, most notably the last actions of a particular artillery crew who died in sending their co-ordinates to other crews, in order to wipe out at least some of the massive Ork horde at their location. The sergeant's last words? "For the glory of Rynn's World, shining gem of the Imperium, second only to Terra itself."
- Timothy Zahn wrote a pair of Star Wars Expanded Universe novels called "Survivor's Quest" and "Outbound Flight"; "Survivor's Quest" has Luke and Mara looking at the ruin of Outbound Flight and finding survivors, "Outbound Flight" deals with Outbound Flight and the circumstances that led to its crash. They're set several decades apart and were written in that order.
- From Survivor's Quest we know that the survivor civilization hates the Jedi for having a hand in their situation, and Luke and Mara find a lightsaber and a distinct Chiss weapon. Chiss forces shot down Outbound Flight; thus, the two Jedi assume that this was the site where a Jedi fought invading Chiss and both died. Reading Outbound Flight, we find that this Jedi and that Chiss were working together to save those survivors, knowing that in doing so they were going to die. And no one ever knew. It's a little heartbreaking. Even Luke and Mara, Jedi themselves, never knew.
- G. K. Chesterton 's Father Brown story The Sign of the Broken Sword has Father Brown piece together what really happened in a battle where, according to the official version, "one of the wisest men in the world acted like an idiot for no reason. One of the best men in the world acted like a fiend for no reason." According to Fr. Brown, "First there is what everybody knows; and then there is what I know. Now, what everybody knows is short and plain enough. It is also entirely wrong." Fr. Brown chooses to keep his (public) silence about what really happened because in none of the memorials of the event does he see anyone wrongly condemned...only wrongly praised.
- In A Song of Ice and Fire, Jaime Lannister is villainized as the Kingslayer for murdering the king he had sworn to protect, even though everyone knew the king was insane. What they didn't know was that King Aerys was so insane that he had rigged his entire capital to explode if his army was defeated, and Jaime killed him to save the lives of countless thousands of people. Obviously, Jaime couldn't tell anyone this because, um... yeah. No real reason, he just wants people to hate him?.
- I don't remember the explanation in the book, if there is one, but maybe Jaime didn't tell anyone because people wouldn't have believed such a fantastic, self-serving story. This series is way, far down the Sliding Scale of Idealism Versus Cynicism. Which is more likely: a king that's not merely corrupt but actually Load Bearing, or an assassin willing to make up a fairy tale to avoid being reviled?
- Surely the explosives planted around King's Landing would have backed up his story...
- Jaime is a member of the Kingsguard, sworn to keep the King's secrets. He might have betrayed his oath to defend the King, but he still makes an effort to keep his other oaths. Plus, he seems to find a certain dark humour in everyone hating him for killing such a monster.
- This, and Westeros is a kingdom where, though honor is frequently paid lip-service, might very much makes right. And Jaime, as brother to the Queen and favorite son of the most powerful Lord in the land, doesn't have much reason to curry favor with anyone. Moreover, a need to be liked isn't part of his character.
- Surely the explosives planted around King's Landing would have backed up his story...
- I don't remember the explanation in the book, if there is one, but maybe Jaime didn't tell anyone because people wouldn't have believed such a fantastic, self-serving story. This series is way, far down the Sliding Scale of Idealism Versus Cynicism. Which is more likely: a king that's not merely corrupt but actually Load Bearing, or an assassin willing to make up a fairy tale to avoid being reviled?
- In Sheri S. Tepper 's The Fresco, when a miracle is faked to allow the eponymous fresco to be repainted.
- In Cthulhu Mythos. None other than The Call of Cthulhu, Gustav Johansen manages to avert Cthulhu's awakening by ramming his head with a steamship, so he's stuck in R'yleh once more as he begins to regenerate - saving mankind from global madness. Johansen never tells anyone and only the narrator knows this from his diary.
- In Lois McMaster Bujold's Vorkosigan universe Miles Vorkosigan undergoes this, somewhat on purpose. He is basically a highly decorated covert ops agent, while in his public persona he projects a spoiled noble who got a cushy job because of his father's influence. "Trying so hard, no wonder he'd succeeded in convincing everyone, even himself, that Lord Vorkosigan didn't... count." So what does he do in Memory when the new security chief has him physically thrown out of the HQ and threatens to do much worse if he ever comes back? He goes home, puts on his uniform and ALL his medals, including multiple of the highest medal his empire could give, the highest given by their mortal enemies, a row and a half of purple hearts and assorted high honors from the many planets he'd saved. Then he goes to see one of the few people who knew he earned all of those. Also a fun scene when the new chief sees him like that. "I didn't clean out my father's desk drawer, if that's what you're asking. Everything here is accounted for, in my classified files. You may be one of the few men on the planet who doesn't have to take my word for it.".
- The capper is Haroche's line: "Is that really a Cetagandan Order of Merit?"
- This is in fact typical of the exploits of ImpSec covert operatives. Very few people outside of ImpSec ever hear about them. Miles just has a lot more of these stories than anyone else in the business.
- And Gregor's reaction: ". . .Good God. . .I don't think I've ever seen you come the Vor lord with intent."
- This is in fact typical of the exploits of ImpSec covert operatives. Very few people outside of ImpSec ever hear about them. Miles just has a lot more of these stories than anyone else in the business.
- The capper is Haroche's line: "Is that really a Cetagandan Order of Merit?"
- Harry Potter goes through this several times, and unfortunately for him it means that, when it comes to the important thing (i.e. telling everyone that Voldemort has been resurrected) he isn't believed.
- At the age of 1, Lord Voldemort tried to kill him but the Killing Curse rebounded on him. He was alone when this happened, but word got out and everyone knew what Harry did.
- At the age of 11, he managed to defeat Voldemort when he was possessing Quirrell. He was alone, but he told Dumbledore about what happened.
- At the age of 12, he managed to kill a 60-feet-long Basilisk just with a sword (he got help from Fawkes, Dumbledore's phoenix, though) as well as destroying one of Voldemort's Horcruxes. He was alone again, but he told his friends, the Weasleys and a couple of Professors what had happened.
- At the age of 13, he manages to beat back several hundreds of Dementors with only one Patronus spell. This time, his friend Hermione is there to witness it.
- At the age of 14, he witnesses Voldemort's resurrection, duels him and manages to more-or-less defeat him. He even manages to bring Cedric Diggory's body back (after he had been killed by Peter Pettigrew). Unfortunately, although the professors manage to catch the culprit of sending Harry to the cemetery where Voldemort was resurrected, the Minister has him essentially killed. And this puts the stones for Fudge to portray Harry as a liar.
- Patrick McLanahan from Dale Brown books experiences both this and Famed in Story. While he is recognised as a hero for such events as the counterattack against the American Holocaust, there are also many of his world-saving missions that the public will never know about until he's dead if not years after due to being black ops.
- The very nature of the Oblivion War in The Dresden Files makes all battles the Venatori fight to protect humanity this trope by default. In fact, if any of said battles became known to an outsider, it would automatically become a sound defeat.
- Star Wars: This is how it is for all of the clone troopers. Non-clones can't tell them apart, many have no idea that they even are individuals (unless they work with them on a regular basis)--for all intents and purposes, they are the same. Which means that any heroism that an individual clone performs will be forgotten in the grand scheme of the entire army. In one novel, The Cestus Deception, a clone named Nate berates a woman who rants at him for his apparent lack of empathy.
Nate: Men like me protect you. |
- In Memory, Sorrow, and Thorn, this is the fate of King Eahlstan Fiskerne and his battle with the great red dragon, Shurakai. Beloved as he was, it is only known publicly that the dragon killed him, and that decades later, Prester John came and finally slew the dragon, ascending to the kingship as a result. The League of the Scroll (and the Sithi), however, preserve the true secret of the Fiskerne line: he killed the dragon, taking his death-wound in the process. John took his sword Minneyar, renamed it Bright-Nail, and claimed to be the dragon's killer. This lie festers beneath the plot like an untreated wound and is largely responsible for the Sithi's failure to come to the aid of humanity in its struggle against the Storm King until it's almost too late.
- The Star Trek: Vanguard series plays with this (focusing on a highly classified Starfleet operation), but given how determined journalist Tim Pennington is to get the facts made public, it’ll probably avert the trope in the end. It helps when Commodore Reyes illegally releases a lot of the relevant information. One of the books in Star Trek: The Lost Era also demonstrates that several basic aspects of the Vanguard project are common knowledge in the Federation, at least on a basic level, as of the 2350s. The Star Trek: Typhon Pact novel Paths of Disharmony features classified records of Project Vanguard as an essential part of its plot, confirming that although the basics are widely known, much of the true picture is deeply buried beyond the reach of anyone but the highest members of the Federation government and Starfleet Command.
- A secondary character in Area 7 is a brilliant computer analyst and mathematician, at one point cracking a supposedly uncrackable encryption for the CIA. However, since you can't let your opponent know you've broken his encryption, his highest honor was a medal and a pat on the back.
- This is the life story of Alex Rider. He saves the world, or at least the country, over and over and over again, and all he gets is everyone thinking that he's a "druggie" because he misses school all the time in order to save their lives.
- In Stalky & Co. by Rudyard Kipling the "constructive deviltry" of study Number Five usually ends this way.
McTurk: ...and, besides, this is much too good to tell all the other brutes in the Coll. They'd never understand. They play cricket, and say: 'Yes sir,' and 'O, sir,' and 'No, sir.' |
Live-Action TV
- Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Xander chooses not to tell anyone about his role in saving the day in "The Zeppo." Namely, while the rest of the cast is in a battle to save the universe with each character getting a high drama moment, Xander escapes from a gang of reanimated corpses,
rootsgets rooted by Faith, then works out the gang had built a bomb and plan to blow up the school. For the Evulz. As the rest of the cast was fighting in the school to stop the Hellmouth from opening, the bomb would have killed them, and allowed the Hellmouth to stay open. Near the end of the same episode, the other characters (unwittingly) lampshade the fact that they never got to see Xander kill most of the gang and make the leader stop the bomb with the line "The world will never know how close it came to ending last night".- "I'm oddly full for some reason." Oz was going out of control as a werewolf and was placed in the school basement, where he eats the gang leader after Xander makes him switch off the bomb.
- Perfect capper to this episode; all throughout the episode, Cordelia has been making snide comments to Xander about how useless and redundant he is, which has affected his confidence. At the end, she sneers another one at him... only this time, he just smirks back and walks away. Cordelia, flustered, is reduced to yelling "What? What?!" at his back. He doesn't answer, realizing that he is, in fact, Made of Win and doesn't need anyone's validation to be sure of it.
- Fame: The TV Series had an episode entitled "The Crimson Blade" where the main character of a swashbuckling play inspires the students to fight back against an oppressive substitute principal. Everyone assumes the Blade is Jesse, the popular student playing the role in the play. It's actually the unlikable Miltie, and in the end only Jesse and Miltie know the truth.
- A touching version of this trope appears in the Doctor Who episode "Father's Day". Pete Tyler sacrifices his life to save the world - but nobody will ever know except for the one person who matters most; his daughter.
- The entirety of Doctor Who is arguably a Greatest Story Never Told. With the exception of Jon Pertwee's tenure as the Doctor (most of which was spent with him stranded on Earth) the Doctor rarely, if ever, sticks around after saving the world/galaxy/universe, with only a handful of survivors to know that he even exists, let alone about his involvement.
- On the other hand, he has justified this as far as "The Power of the Daleks" - he just doesn't want to get stuck with the bill.
- A more specific example is the Series 3 finale episodes: During the Year That Never Was, Martha Jones became known world-wide as she traveled the Earth as part of her plan to defeat the Master. But because the plan involved the year, well, never being, the only people who know what happened were those on the Valiant.
- Inverted in the Series 4 finale "Journey's End". Donna Noble saves the damn universe and isn't allowed to remember it or ANY of her travels with the Doctor else she'll die - although everyone else knows, including a few alien civilizations. Some viewers still haven't finished spewing vulgarities at Russell T. Davies for it.
- As a matter of fact, a track on the Series 4 OST is named "The Greatest Story Never Told", which is used so extensively throughout Series 3 and 4 (from at least "Gridlock", through "The Fires of Pompeii" to at least River Song's magnificent death) that it is hard to resist the conclusion that RTD knew exactly which trope's chain he was yanking.
- Actually pointed out and then averted at the end of "The Next Doctor," where the Doctor saves the day from the Cybermen, and Jackson calls out to the entire crowd on the streets about what the Doctor does, how he never gets any credit for saving the world time and time again, and then gets the crowd to clap and cheer for him. The Doctor can't help but show a small grin.
- This trope found frustrating new heights in Series 5, as the Doctor gradually discovers that the cracks in time have erased Donna's sacrifice and the Cybermen attack on Victorian London from history, making these instead The Greatest Stories That Never Actually Happened, leaving the Doctor alone with the painful memories. And then he presses the Reset Button, and that's a problem no longer.
- The entirety of Doctor Who is arguably a Greatest Story Never Told. With the exception of Jon Pertwee's tenure as the Doctor (most of which was spent with him stranded on Earth) the Doctor rarely, if ever, sticks around after saving the world/galaxy/universe, with only a handful of survivors to know that he even exists, let alone about his involvement.
- In the Scrubs episode "Their Story", Ted secretly gives the nurses the means to get the pay increase they deserve from Kelso. He doesn't care that they don't know it was him.
Kelso: Ted! Did you have something to do with this? |
- In an early episode of Bones, Booth threatens a gangster with his gun, warning him to stay away from Brennan (who had provoked him to the point of putting a price on her head). Booth is subsequently late to a funeral, which she berates him for...but he never tells her what made him late.
- On The West Wing, Vice-President Hoynes, while not a bad guy, occupies a significantly different spot on the Sliding Scale of Cynicism Versus Idealism than most of the characters, rarely doing anything that's not at least partly for his own political gain, and is constantly resentful of having to live in the president's shadow (among other things, he was originally the favorite for the party's nomination). In one episode, though ("Stirred"), he stops sponsoring an Internet education bill that's been his pet project for years, because the Republican-controlled Congress doesn't want to pass such a popular bill with the Democratic VP's name attached to it while he and the president are running for reelection.
- also notable because most of the White House senior staff spend the episode considering whether or not they want to replace Hoynes on the ticket, and it's revealed near the end of the episode that Hoynes was able to guess what they were doing.
- Another example has Toby realizing a Republican senator would be interested in sponsoring a bill to reform Social Security so it won't go bankrupt. He does all the legwork to get a Democrat who's willing to also co-sponsor, and (after having to write up a letter of resignation because one of his earlier attempts embarrassed the White House) the staff discover that both senators won't do it unless they can say they approached each other. Toby, President Bartlet, and the White House get no credit at all.
- In Babylon 5, this happens to the victors of the Shadow War when Earth restricts news about that conflict.
Marcus Cole: "Typical. First time in my life I'm a war hero, and nobody knows about it." |
- Star Trek: Deep Space Nine has an episode where Benjamin Sisko explains how he tricked Romulans to join the Federation in their war against Dominion: by giving a dangerous substance to a criminal in exchange of Cardassian secret writing material, writing a fake info framing the Dominion there and then killing the Romulan contact so that Romulans assume it was genuine (as Dominion must have killed him for it). The Episode ends with "Computer, erase recording".
- Season 6 Episode 19 "In the Pale Moonlight"
- Star Trek: Voyager has "Course:Oblivion" which depicts the adventures of a "fake" (copied) Voyager. They all are destroyed moments before being found by real Voyager, which never finds out what happened. Tear Jerker and Shoot the Shaggy Dog in the same Package.
- Early episodes of NCIS played with this, as they would be referred to at best as 'a federal agency' when their actions made the news, if their contributions were mentioned at all. Other times, other law enforcement members or agencies would take all the credit entirely, even if the team did all the actual work. This has fallen by the wayside as the show's gone on, though there are still a couple of occasions where civilians don't recognize the name.
- Gibbs does this to a serial killer in one episode. The killer killed multiple people in bizarre ways so when caught the trial would become a media sensation. Gibbs has enough of the case classified secret for (flimsy) national security reasons that the killer is barely mentioned on TV.
- Beautifully used in Lost for scrappies Nikki and Paulo. It was revealed in Exposé that they were in fact the first to find an important Dharma Initiative station and find that the Others are real after overhearing Ben and Juliet. But by the end of the episode they were killed off.
- Cousin Skeeter accidentally warps his friends on a space-faring adventure, thwarts a stereotypical bug queen overlord, and even plants a mole so that her 50,000,000 year old plot for world domination will be thwarted in the long run. Then his friends get deneuralized by Kay. IN GOLF PANTS. He rolled a natural 20 on dodge, the others call him stupid.
- Bulk and Skull have their Crowning Moment Of Awesome in "When is a Ranger Not a Ranger?". Unfortunately the Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Monster of the Week erases memories, so no one knows what happened.
- They get another in Power Rangers Zeo when the two are warped to an alien planet controlled by the Big Bad and help start a successful rebellion. On the planet they're deemed heroes. But as usual once they get back to Earth, no one believes them.
- In the Criminal Minds episode "Painless", a social pariah stares down a Mad Bomber and survives. Technically, his story is told—but by the guy who steals it for his own, passing himself off as the hero while the pariah is hospitalized. The real events of that day are left untold until the Unsub finally snaps.
- Bates from Downton Abbey tries constantly to be this, but is increasingly thwarted by Lord Grantham and the rest of the household staff's affection and concern for him. Anna in particular is very good at weaseling the (always very noble) truth about his past out of him, especially once they become a couple. It takes nearly the entire first season of the show for the characters and the audience to find out where Bates lived before coming to Downton, and still longer for them to find out why such an evidently kind and honorable man would have spent time in prison for theft. Turns out he was covering for his evil wife, who had actually stolen the silver.
- One episode of The Outer Limits revolved around a trio of astronauts traveling back to Earth from Mars. Earlier, two of the astronauts had been replaced by aliens, leaving just the one human who eventually learns about the impostor. Forced to choose between making it back to Earth and the fame and glory he would receive and preventing the alien species from spreading to Earth, the final astronaut finally decides to be a hero and sabotages the re-entry procedure causing the ship to burn up, with Ground Control believing it to be a disasterous malfunction.
- The ending narration: The true measure of a hero is when a man lays down his life with the knowledge that those he saves... will never know.
Tabletop Games
- Dungeons & Dragons adventure I5 Lost Tomb of Martek. At the end of the adventure the title wizard tells the PCs that:
Those people that cast you into this desert land will no longer remember you. You are once again free to travel the face of this world as you want. All to whom you tell this tale will believe it to be but a fable. Only you shall know the truth of what you have seen. |
- Exalted: The Lunars' sacrifice during the Balorian Crusade. Creation knows that the Scarlet Empress Fantastic Nuke'd The Fair Folk, but they don't know who bought time for her to do that. Even worse, the Lunars remain anathema in the Scarlet Empress' reign.
- Though this should be taken with a grain of salt. While there is no question that the Scarlet Empress saved Creation, there are several books that "reveal" that the only reason she succeeded was because some other group helped her. So far the Lunars, Sidereals and Fair Folk themselves have all taken credit for her victory, which really brings into question whether any of them actually are responsible for what happened, or whether they just tell themselves that they are.
- This is inevitable for the Sidereals. It's not that no one know their deed, it's that there's a strong magic that remove them from the public memory. It's a necessity, really.
Video Games
- Getting the bad ending in Giga Wing with Shinnosuke yields an ending in which he is forgotten from history.
- Final Fantasy I ends with no one remembering the Light Warriors because they repaired the time loop.
- In fact, the text-only ending breaks the fourth wall to say that the only one who will remember the events of the game is the player, and that it's incumbent on the player to do so, or it was all meaningless.
- The whole plot of Final Fantasy Tactics. The Church erases Ramza from history to hide its corruption. It then subverts this trope through the game's narrator, who is a historian who reveals the truth of the events, and is a descendant of one of Ramza's (very few) allies.
- Betrayal at Krondor ends up being this in the context of the series on which the game was based, because it ties into the secret of the Lifestone beneath Sethanon, which is where the final struggle takes place. As a result, Gorath may have died a hero and the best proof that the moredhel and enemies of the Kingdom are not Exclusively Evil, but aside from his travelling companions, no one will ever know.
- Castlevania:
- The plot of Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia in the game universe's timeline. Shanoa defeats Dracula and wins back her emotions and memories, but she and the story of her adventure vanish from history.
- Kind of justified in context, given where Ecclesia derives from. Ecclesiastes 9:5: For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing; they have no further reward, and even the memory of them is forgotten.
- The battle between Dracula and Julius Belmont in 1999 (the Demon Castle War) has never been portrayed in a game; seeing as this is the battle where Dracula is truly and irrevocably killed, it is likely the developers simply could not find a way to do portray such an epic event properly.
- Downplayed with the event where Dracula was challenged by Jonathan Harker and Abraham van Helsing in the year 1897. This is, of course, the events of Bram Stoker's original novel Dracula; very little of this event is detailed in the franchise, and is assumed to at least be similar to the plot of the novel. The biggest known difference is that the one who brought Dracula down - at the cost of his own life - was Quincy Morris, one of the Morris family of vampire hunters that replaced the Belmonts.
- The plot of Castlevania: Order of Ecclesia in the game universe's timeline. Shanoa defeats Dracula and wins back her emotions and memories, but she and the story of her adventure vanish from history.
- The epilogue of Einhander mentions that both the Earth Force and Selene have deleted every record of the protagonist's existence and endeavours.
- Happens in the Prologue of the first Mother game: George returns home and tells nobody what happened to him and his wife who by the way never returned.
- The story of Halo 3: ODST, being a mere aside to the fantastic adventures of the Master Chief. Halo: Reach shares this to some extent with Noble Six's role.
- Prince of Persia: Sands of Time. After falling in love with the Princess, and watching her plummet to her death, the Prince returns to the Hourglass of Time (which contained the Sands of Time whose released turned everyone in the kingdom into baddies), and used the Dagger of Time to re-seal the Sands into the Hourglass, and undoing the events of the night. The Prince wakes up in his camp with the Dagger in his hand, and steals his way in to the Princess's chambers to tell her the story. She doesn't remember a bit of it.
- In Mercenaries: Playground of Destruction, you have to save Seoul from destruction in one mission. When you finish it, Fiona would joke about how they would never know you saved them. The mercenary responds that fortune would be preferable to fame.
- While it is not emphasized, in the Thief series, most of the cataclysmic events that Garret is again and again embroiled in never reach the general public's attention. In fact, the only people who know about most of his exploits are the Keepers, whose very existence itself is unknown to Normal People. Also, Garret himself is referred to as "The Greatest Thief the World Has Never Seen".
- The Ending of Metal Max Returns after you choose to return home after defeating Noah
- By the end of Arm A 2, you- having gotten a promotion to leading an ultra-secret USMC detachment to the unstable allied nation of Chernarus- have cut through at least a hundred Mooks and have been in dozens of battles. And that won't get you much alone. But, if you get the best ending, the death toll is more in likely in the couple hundred range, while you have also fought your way through extremely inhospitable terrain often cut off from allied forces, have almost singlehandedly destroyed the Communist insurgency, have engineered an alliance between the Chernarusian government and the underground Nationalist party, have hunted down several very nasty terrorists, and have helped stave off Russian intervention if not all out war. The ending you get? "The war that never was."
- Single Player Minecraft is essentially this, until a new update anyway, when there are actually mobs that recognize your deeds.
- The entire plot of Mass Effect 2 features this. It's made fairly clear from the get-go that neither the Council or the Alliance know or care what you're doing against the collectors. All you've got is yourself, the Illusive Man and your crew of unstable maniacs and if you all die in the ensuing suicide mission, no-one will probably know until it's too late.
- It's subverted in the last DLC for the game though, where Shepard ends up doing something to stop The Reapers that everyone takes notice and blames him for.
- Invoked by Jacob when he tells Shepard about his background and what he did to get noticed and recruited by Cerberus- stopping an assassination plot on the Citadel that was covered up for political reasons. As he puts it:
Jacob: "Good deeds are like pissing yourself in dark pants - warm feeling but nobody notices" |
- Narrowly averted in the original Mass Effect. If not for discovering Vigil on Ilos, no subsequent race would have ever known about the Protheans sacrificing themselves on the Citadel in order to derail the Reaper fleet.
- In the Touhou Project game Imperishable Night, the real incident is not the eponymous unending night; that's actually a spell that the protagonists are casting to buy time so that they can resolve the problem of the corrupted full moon. However, it appears that only the protagonists you choose, the villains causing the corrupted moon, and possibly Keine, know about this. Everyone else assumes that the imperishable night is the true incident; indeed, the stage four boss is either Reimu or Marisa, who confront your characters to end the imperishable night in their usual way, thinking you to be the "final boss".
- This happens often in Gensokyou, actually. Many of the incidents are found and solved outside the public's knowledge, which makes it a bit hard for Reimu when no one comes to donate to her...
- This happens every time you do one of the story missions in In Famous, both the voice of survival and the USTV network provide different stories as to what happened, a particular example is the first train mission to save a bunch of civilians from the abandoned trains, the voice claims it was a "group of concerned citizens" and also trashes cole and USTV says something about a bunch of paratroopers that didn't exist
- It is a Justified Trope, as in Truth's last message It's made clear that it was Kessler who was keeping him quiet.
- It's heavily implied that while the rest of the country doesn't know about Cole's existence, the citizens of Empire City know who their hero is. This is enforced by times in the sequel where side missions will involve people who know he helped specific people in the first game and thank him for it, and of course by the end of the game, everyone in the city knows about what Cole did for them.
- Or to them, as the case may be.
- At the end of the first Resistance game, Nathan is taken by Black Ops and put into the top secret "Sentinel Program" while the Army is left to believe that He died in the destruction of the conversion center. After the end of the second game only a few people truth about what happened. What's left of SRPA, Capelli, and Malikov.
- Despite what Rance has done to the whole world, no one really knows about him. Of course, there are a ton of reasons behind it from a queen who's a Clingy Jealous Girl to the fact that the entire country had a civil war. Sengoku Rance may probably be the first time that he'll be mentioned as the savior of JAPAN.
- Muv Luv Alternative: Second Lieutenant Takeru Shirogane's achievements and central role in completing Alternative IV, and even his existence, will never be revealed to the rest of the world, due to him ceasing to exist and consequently getting wiped from the memories of everyone except Kasumi and Yuuko, who had vowed to take the secret of his existence, and therefore that of parallel worlds, to the grave. With all of his comrades dead, no one else will ever know that a certain bratty hero saved the world. No one.
- Dead Rising turns out to be this, one way or another. In three out of five endings, Frank manages to get most-to-all of the details of the story he's chasing but never leaves the mall - he finally does in the ending to Overtime mode, but exactly what happens after that is hard to say aside from heavy implication that eventually became a zombie. In the other endings in which he makes it out safely with whatever survivors he's rounded up, the epilogue states that he was able to write several articles on the events at Willamette themselves, but then again, never learned the truth behind the Zombie Apocalypse.
- As per it's setting, Call of Duty Black Ops is all about this trope, as it turns out the main character was responsible for saving the United States from a catastrophic mass attack with nerve gas in 1968.
- And firing a rifle in Dallas, Texas in 1963. But the less said about that the better.
- If the player chooses the good ending in Singularity, he goes back in time and shoots himself to prevent his past self from unintentionally saving the Big Bad. Doing so causes him to fall down, then wake up at the beginning of the game with all of his memories intact. He saved the world, and nobody knows it—hell, there isn't even a shred of evidence that it happened.
- The neutral ending of Shin Megami Tensei Nocturne ends with the main character undoing The End of the World as We Know It and restoring it to its previous state. Because everyone else was either destroyed by said ending of the world or killed during your quest to restore the world, only one person aside from the main character will ever know he did it. It's subverted by the fact that all the demons remember it. And, apparently, YHVH. And according to Lucifer, He will not be happy about it...
- In Tales of Vesperia, the guild Brave Vesperia saves the world from multiple threats including the designs of a madman and the horrific doom he inadvertantly unleashes upon the world. They also save many people along the way such as the victims of an incredibly corrupt nobleman. The only people who know of all their deeds and are not actually members of Brave Vesperia can be counted on one hand. Granted some of them are very important people but it is implied that the protagonist at least never gets the recognition he is due because of the circumstances. Namely Yuri allows Flynn to take the credit for most of his accomplishments, and by extension Brave Vesperia's, because this allows Flynn to affect change from within the system in a position of strength. Due to taking all their credit, Flynn gets promoted to Commandant in the end, head of the Empire's armed forces and now has the authority to affect lasting change. Helps that the members of Brave Vesperia are large and by content to let the greater good win rather than claim the glory.
- In Metal Gear Solid 3 the truth behind The Boss's actions can never be known because she deliberately adopted the persona of a traitor. In reality, she was one of the greatest patriots of all time.
- In MGS 4 it's revealed that through Big Boss' actions and saving the world, again, that her record as a traitor was eventually cleansed and she was recognized as the hero those who were close to her knew her to be, with Big Boss himself subject to similar acclaim. Solid Snake, the protagonist of the first and fourth MGS games is another example though, since he manages to free the world from the grip of his megalomaniac brother, and The Patriots (by accident no less) and yet not only will no one ever find out, but he was still technically labeled as a terrorist.
- In Professor Layton and the Curious Village, at the end, Layton tells Luke that the world must never know about the village populated entirely by robots (and their caretaker). The village was created to care for and protect the orphaned Flora, the Baron's daughter, whom Layton hereafter adopts as his own; he wants the story kept quiet because he doesn't want the media to make a spectacle of her.
- The instructions to Ultima II mention that, should you succeed, your victory will be this.
- A variant in Dragon Age 2: nobody but Hawke and his/her compatriots (and now Cassandra) know the real story of the events of the game. Everyone else idolizes Hawke as the greatest of heroes or curses his/her name as the darkest of villains despite the fact that Hawke was just a refugee who got thrown in way over his/her head.
- Shadow of the Colossus focuses on a boy named Wander single-handedly fighting more than a dozen giants, all to revive his dead girlfriend. At the end of the game, Wander gets transformed into a baby just before the girl is revived. She finds him crying, comepletely unaware of who he is or what he's done for her.
- One very important plot point in World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King is that Bolvar Fordragon became the new Lich King, and nobody knows it. There has to be a Lich King to control the Scourge, otherwise it would run amok, so when Arthas was killed, someone had to take his place; but for Azeroth to be free of fear of the Scourge, the people must not know there is another man sitting on the Frozen Throne wearing the Helm of Domination.
- Sam Fisher from the Splinter Cell Series can never receive any recognition for saving the world on multiple occasions due to belonging to the Third Echelon, a branch within the NSA that is even more secretive than the CIA. The Big Bad in the third game even comments on Sam getting no recognition or glory for his actions.
- The entirety of Valkyria Chronicles III. Ordinary Gallians will never know of Squad 422's deeds, the unholy alliance between Cardinal Borgia and Carl Isler, and how the world is spared from the devastation by an ancient Valkyric superweapon. To make it worse, Kurt and co are still considered bad people by the society. Hm, I wonder why that sounds familiar...
- In the last act of Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare, you save at least 15 million people, kill a major international figure, and watch your friends die. It's written off as missile tests and skirmishes. Only you and a handful of others, either in the highest echelons of NATO or on-site, know the truth.
- In BlazBlue, during the ten-year long Dark War when the Black Beast attacked the world killing off over half the population of the entire world, it mysteriously disappeared for a year, during that time humanity was able to recuperate and had made and gathered many weapons for when the Beast would appear again and even develop a type of magic called Ars Magus. The reason for its disappearance was because a man called Bloodedge Amnesiac Ragna from a different timeline sent into the past fought it for a year and sacrificed himself, and his sword and red jacket eventually get passed down to Ragna. And you would think that this would at least be told as a legend. Only Jubei knows about this until he tells Ragna, who probably told no one.
- Inverted in Kingdom Hearts: Chain of Memories, at the end of the game Sora and company's memories are erased of their adventures during the game, but everyone else (Namine, Riku, Ansem the Wise) still remember everything that happened.
- The 1998 RTS/FPS game, Battlezone 1998, has the entire campaign taking place in a covered-up war between the Soviet Union and the United States on the planets of the Solar System to gain control of the Bio-Metal. The protagonist, Grizzly One, ultimately saves humanity from the Furies, the man-biometal abominations that the Russians were building. His story is completely forgotten and/or covered up by the events of BattleZone II, set 40 years later, in the high tech future of 2004, where the Bio-Metal Wars are (mostly) public knowledge.
- Certain installments of The Legend of Zelda series employ this trope. Most notably on display in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, where Link is sent back in time following the events of the game in order to regain the seven years of life that he lost. This decision led to two primary timelines - the "adult" timeline where the trope is averted and the Hero of Time is loved and revered for generations to follow even after Hyrule itself is long destroyed, and then the "child" timeline where it's played almost completely straight and Link is able to avoid the catastrophic events of the game by warning of Ganondorf's treachery in advance. This Hero of Time later goes on to rescue Termina from imminent destruction in the sequel game Majora's Mask, and it's left ambiguous as to whether anyone other than a few individuals are even aware of the reality of what happened or Link's hand in stopping it.
- In Ending 1 of the first Way of the Samurai it is revealed that history does not record the name of the player character.
- Soul Calibur II's Weapon Master mode ends by revealing the player character is not recorded in history, while the main antagonist is a footnote, remembered only known as one of Soul Edge's many wielders.
Web Comics
- In the "A Girl And Her Blob" arc of The Wotch, Mingmei and Myrrh have A Day in the Limelight as a massive battle goes on elsewhere... we get bits and pieces of what's going on there as Ming and Myrrh pass through and the plots intersect.
- At the end, the writer actually credits Justice League's "The Greatest Story Never Told" for inspiration. The next arc has Jason reading a Booster Gold comic book, if you look closely.
- This strip of Questionable Content is a prime example. It seems to be satire until Tortura shows up again and Steve starts getting noticeably more badass.
- It is implied in Tales of the Questor that Quentyn's victory in "Hunter of Shadows" is victim of a governmental coverup.
- In the backstory of Order of the Stick one of the points of tension that leads to the break up of the older adventuring party "Order of the Scribble" is the fact that their struggle to contain the Snarl and the heroic sacrifice of their friend, Kraagor must be kept secret.
- Eight Bit Theater: When White Mage kills Chaos, no one will give her the credit. Since White Mage refuses to let the Light Warriors be recognized as heroes, she lets the Dark Warriors take it, as they're the next best option.
- This xkcd strip shows the predictable outcome of "Summon Everyman Hero" plot.
- The Perry Bible Fellowship got Mr. Ortego.
Web Original
- For all their goofiness, stupidity, and raging insanity, at the very end of Red vs. Blue: The Blood Gulch Chronicles the Blood Gulch soldiers actually do manage to finally defeat their Omnicidal Maniac nemesis, Omega, and prevent him from gaining control of an entire army of Aliens (heavy implied in the sequel series to be The Covenant) with which he could have brought great destruction to the galaxy. And no one will ever know or care about it. Hell, more than half of the Blood Gulch soldiers themselves don't even realize the implications of their final act.
- Played with by College Humor. Poor, poor Gary...
Western Animation
- Named for an episode of Justice League Unlimited, where glory-grabbing newbie hero Booster Gold saves the world while everyone else is off saving the world from something else (specifically, a powerful, magic-based supervillain). Afterwards, Batman lectures him for not following orders.
- Between this and Booster's main series, he REALLY likes this trope. It's no accident he's called, "The Greatest Hero History Will Never Know."
- At least he got the girl in the end, who was the one person who actually knew what he had done.
- "Squeaky wheel, buddy."
- He also got out of the subversion of Hero Insurance by the other Leaguers.
- The movie The Brave Little Toaster Goes to Mars features a song called Home Again, which lampshades this trope by describing that all they need is to be home safe; they consider it their "prize" and accept that not many people will ever know about what they did.
- Kim Possible: Ron's heroism in "Exchange" has to be kept secret to protect the secrecy of the ninja school he saved. Unlike most other instances, this is actually followed up on: In "Gorilla Fist", Kim is all, "Hey, who's that girl, why does she think Ron is a hero, and why the heck won't Ron say anything about her?" when she meets the girl from that episode.
- Also from The First Movie where Ron saves Kim by getting his new Mystical Monkey Kung Fu, throwing Drakken across the room just by grabbing his ankle - the same Drakken that defeated Kim and Monique with ease. The catch is that the McGuffin was destroyed, leading everything that happened to be written out of existence.
- Codename: Kids Next Door, "Training": Cadets Tommy, Sonia and Lee are left behind at the KND Arctic base by regular agents as they fly off to the moonbase. Turns out to be a decoy by the Big Bad to steal the "Codemodule" stored at the Arctic base. After they wash out the Big Bad and his minions, Sonia says when the regular agents return, "Oh, it was just a simulation" (they were supposed to be doing simulation training).
- Futurama did this thrice. In "The Day the Earth Stood Stupid" Fry, the only person on Earth not affected by the flying brains, is the only one who remembers them after he defeats them. When he saves the universe a second time in "The Why Of Fry," the Nibblonians erase his memory of both incidents, although they do give him a flower for Leela. A smaller-scale example occurs in "Time Keeps on Slippin'": due to temporal shifts Fry finds himself married to Leela, when neither of them have any memory of the really nifty thing he did to win her love. He finds out just before the evidence of his act is destroyed.
- The movies eventually bring to light most of what happened, except for the part about Fry's message to Leela.
- Pick a Fairly Oddparents episode. Any Fairly Oddparents episode.
- Or Phineas and Ferb, while we're at it.
- Not quite. Their adventures and ideas are quite well known; they're famous all around the world. The only one never, ever allowed to know of it is their Mom.
- Phineas and Ferb themselves may be a bit iffy, but Perry definitely pulls this off on a regular basis.
- The Simpsons did it when Maggie saved Homer from gangsters with a rifle.
- In the premiere episode of Gummi Bears, Cavin stops Duke Igthorn with the help of the Gummis. However, since he can't tell anyone about the Gummis' existence, he has to claim Igthorn's plan fell apart on its own.
- On Spider-Man: The Animated Series, attorney Matt Murdock was hired to defend Peter Parker when the latter was framed by Richard Fisk. The source of Murdock's hiring was not revealed to Parker nor the viewer until the end of the two-parter, when the viewer discovers that it was Parker's often antagonistic boss J. Jonah Jameson who had hired Murdock to defend one of his better photographers.
- In Scooby Doo and the Goblin King, for once Shaggy and Scooby save the day without any help from the others and are pretty much heroes - only to have the Goblin King erase everyone's memories.
- The only people in Wakfu to ever know Nox as anything other than a power-motivated Evil Overlord are Alibert, Grougaloragran, and Yugo. Only the last one cares.
- One episode of The Life and Times of Juniper Lee had June's littler brother, Ray Ray, suddenly become the Te Xuan Ze due to time wraiths rewriting history so that June never existed. Ray Ray manages to find the cause of the problem and save June. But in doing so erases all knowledge of the events save for his own. June doesn't believe him when he tries to tell, writing it off as a dream he was having. Ray Ray starts to doubt too...least till he see the photograph his older brother, Dennis, took of him in the alternate timeline much to his joy.
Real Life
- How many feats of extraordinary talent by obscure people have gone unnoticed and possibly destined to be Lost Forever to the world?
- In recounting the history of the Battle of the Bulge (during World War II), one historian says with regret that it proved to be impossible to track down all the stories of heroism during the early phases of the battle, as most of the records were lost in the confusion. He describes one such action, in particular, with the following words:
A platoon of engineers appears in one terse sentence of a German commander's report. They have fought bravely, says the foe, and forced him to waste a couple of hours in deployment and maneuver. In this brief emergence from the fog of war the engineer platoon makes its bid for recognition in history. That is all. |
- Five Real-Life Soldiers Who Make Rambo Look Like A Pussy. While the stories of these men haven't exactly never been told, most people wouldn't recognize their names. Simo Häyhä and Yogendra Singh Yadav are particularly impressive, but the whole list is full of complete Badasses. The last one apparently qualifies for Crouching Moron, Hidden Badass too.
- The 1925 serum run to Nome, Alaska was run by some 150 dogs and 20 mushers, and the run saved the city of Nome from an epidemic. Now, the only one at all known was the lead dog of the last leg, Balto; this is regardless of the fact that Togo led the run on the longest leg, almost twice as the next longest, and also the most dangerous.
- Averted now, but for years and years after World War II, Alan Turing and the rest of Bletchley Park weren't allowed to tell anyone about what they had done - namely working on deciphering intercepted messages which had been encrypted using Enigma. This meant they were despised as cowards for not fighting rather than recognised as just as vital to the war effort as the soldiers. Nowadays, fortunately, the site in Buckinghamshire has been turned into a museum so that visitors can learn about what went on there.
- This was reasonable, as the techniques developed at Bletchley remained useful for a long time after the war. In fact the Allies allowed Enigma-based encryption technology to be sold in the developing world just because they knew how to crack the codes.
- What makes this worse is Alan Turing's conviction for buggery, sentencing to chemical castration and eventual suicide. One wonders if, had his work been known, he might have been given some amnesty and survived.
- For about 10 years, the story of Russian Lieutenant Colonel Stanislav Yevgrafovich Petrov was this. In 1983, (during an extremely tense period in the Cold War) Petrov's new system for detecting a nuclear weapons launch at Russia incorrectly showed a missile being fired by the US and heading toward Russia. Petrov correctly believed that it was a system glitch, but the story remained buried and untold to the Russian public until the 90s, and didn't become widely known in the US until 2006. Link to that other wiki.
- Intelligence agencies such as the DOD, DOJ, DHS, CIA, G2, KGB, MI-5, SIS, CSIS, DCRI, ASIS, etc. are built on this trope. They can't tell anyone about what they do, but the truth is that sometimes they save the world without our knowledge... and, well, sometimes they make things worse, without our knowledge either.
- Similarly there are military special operations which usually can't tell what they do, due to security or political reasons. In fact, the very existence of some special operations units are almost certainly classified.
- Terence S. Kirk was a Japanese POW in WWII. Now this is a very undesirable position on its own, but what he did, with the help of a handful of collaborators is secretly made an improvised camera and documented what happened, so that it could be used in court about war crimes. Once he got out he showed it to the authorities, who then gave him a gag order not to discuss what happened, which he reluctantly signed. He then complied with the gag order for many years, but later defied it and published the pictures and his memoir. You can read about it in the book The Secret Camera.
- Nondisclosure agreements and the sealing of court records exist to invoke this trope, usually to cover up The Greatest Scandals Never Told.
- Just think of all the books that have been burnt over the course of centuries, whether deliberately or by accident (the Ancient Library of Alexandria comes to mind).
- Many of the finest poets, philosophers and scientists of the ancient world are virtually unremembered because no extant copies of their work exists.
- Roland McGrath, of the GNU Project. Donald Knuth also semi-qualifies, although he is known by some people.
- The life of Cora Strayer (1868-1932) is all but this trope. She was a female detective in Chicago who had several younger boyfriends who never managed to live very long. She led an all-female cavalry regiment in the Border War. Her ordinary life included car chases, gun fights, and evil plots out of a Dashiell Hammett novel. For the most part, the only people who've ever heard of her have been to the website of Paul Reda. He ran across an newspaper advertisement of hers with some great copy, and decided to learn more about her. Public records are amazing things. More information here.
- ↑ To be frank, Forget-Me-Not is a tongue-in-cheek Author's Saving Throw used to explain Negative Continuity issues that cause the X-Men to escape certain defeat; for example, if there is no logical way to explain why the bad guy's super-destructive Doomsday Device failed to work, they can simply say Forget-Me-Not sabotaged it.