Spiritual Licensee: Difference between revisions

Everything About Fiction You Never Wanted to Know.
Content added Content deleted
No edit summary
(update links)
Line 31: Line 31:
* ''[[Golgo 13]]'' has been described as a Japanese retelling of [[James Bond]], which isn't helped at all by the fact that the original mangaka also made official Bond manga back in the day.
* ''[[Golgo 13]]'' has been described as a Japanese retelling of [[James Bond]], which isn't helped at all by the fact that the original mangaka also made official Bond manga back in the day.
* ''[[Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn]]'' is practically ''[[The Da Vinci Code]]'' [[Recycled in Space|in the Universal Century]], with the Vist Foundation, Unicorn Gundam and Laplace's Box standing in for the Priory of Sion, codex and Holy Grail respectively. And as of the last episode, it can also pass for a Gundam version of ''[[2001: A Space Odyssey]]'' {{spoiler|given that Laplace's Box resembles a monolith and that Banagher and Full Frontal's Newtype vision begins very similarly to the infamous Star-Gate sequence}}.
* ''[[Mobile Suit Gundam Unicorn]]'' is practically ''[[The Da Vinci Code]]'' [[Recycled in Space|in the Universal Century]], with the Vist Foundation, Unicorn Gundam and Laplace's Box standing in for the Priory of Sion, codex and Holy Grail respectively. And as of the last episode, it can also pass for a Gundam version of ''[[2001: A Space Odyssey]]'' {{spoiler|given that Laplace's Box resembles a monolith and that Banagher and Full Frontal's Newtype vision begins very similarly to the infamous Star-Gate sequence}}.
* ''[[Shimoneta|Shimoneta: A Boring World Where the Concept of Dirty Jokes Doesn't Exist]]'' can be described as a more risque adaptation of ''[[Demolition Man]]'', if it took place in future Japan rather than [[Crap Saccharine World|future California]]. All that's missing are the Taco Bells and three seashells. It also helps that the series also satirizes and deconstructs [[Political Correctness Gone Mad]].
* ''[[Shimoneta|Shimoneta: A Boring World Where the Concept of Dirty Jokes Doesn't Exist]]'' can be described as a more risque adaptation of ''[[Demolition Man]]'', if it took place in future Japan rather than [[Crap Saccharine World|future California]]. All that's missing are the Taco Bells and three seashells. It also helps that the series also satirizes and deconstructs [[Political Correctness Gone Mad]].


== Film ==
== Film ==
Line 51: Line 51:
* ''[[Snow Day]]'' was originally written as a film adaptation of ''[[The Adventures of Pete and Pete]]'', and it shows.
* ''[[Snow Day]]'' was originally written as a film adaptation of ''[[The Adventures of Pete and Pete]]'', and it shows.
* ''[[Aliens]]'' is often referred to as a stealth adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein's ''[[Starship Troopers]]''—and a far superior adaptation to the later officially-licensed film. And even though it was just one suit, ''Aliens'' even had more [[Powered Armor]] than the actual ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' film franchise (at least until the third, straight-to-DVD film).
* ''[[Aliens]]'' is often referred to as a stealth adaptation of Robert A. Heinlein's ''[[Starship Troopers]]''—and a far superior adaptation to the later officially-licensed film. And even though it was just one suit, ''Aliens'' even had more [[Powered Armor]] than the actual ''[[Starship Troopers (film)|Starship Troopers]]'' film franchise (at least until the third, straight-to-DVD film).
* The [[Jean Claude Van Damme]] movie ''[[Double Impact]]'' is a better ''[[Double Dragon]]'' movie than the actual ''[[Double Dragon (film)|Double Dragon]]'' movie that miscasts Scott Wolf as one of the Lee Bros. It even had Bolo Yeung (the actor that Abobo was based on in the first place) playing an Abobo-like henchman who throws oil drums at his enemies.
* The [[Jean-Claude Van Damme]] movie ''[[Double Impact]]'' is a better ''[[Double Dragon]]'' movie than the actual ''[[Double Dragon (film)|Double Dragon]]'' movie that miscasts Scott Wolf as one of the Lee Bros. It even had Bolo Yeung (the actor that Abobo was based on in the first place) playing an Abobo-like henchman who throws oil drums at his enemies.
* Many ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' fans like to consider ''[[Event Horizon]]'' canonical.
* Many ''[[Warhammer 40,000]]'' fans like to consider ''[[Event Horizon]]'' canonical.
** Likewise, a few ''[[Doom]]'' fans consider it to be a better ''Doom'' movie than the one the game actually got.
** Likewise, a few ''[[Doom]]'' fans consider it to be a better ''Doom'' movie than the one the game actually got.
** Some combine all three.
** Some combine all three.
Line 95: Line 95:
* ''[[Dredd]]'', in addition to being much more faithful to the source material than [[Judge Dredd (film)|the 90s film]], also makes for a good ''[[Die Hard]]'' film.
* ''[[Dredd]]'', in addition to being much more faithful to the source material than [[Judge Dredd (film)|the 90s film]], also makes for a good ''[[Die Hard]]'' film.
* Clint Eastwood's ''[[Sudden Impact]]'' is the closest one gets to a ''[[Dirty Harry]]'' and ''[[Death Wish]]'' crossover, especially given how the vigilante in the movie is essentially a gender-flipped version of Charles Bronson's character.
* Clint Eastwood's ''[[Sudden Impact]]'' is the closest one gets to a ''[[Dirty Harry]]'' and ''[[Death Wish]]'' crossover, especially given how the vigilante in the movie is essentially a gender-flipped version of Charles Bronson's character.
* ''[[Captain America: The Winter Soldier]]'' has been described as the closest one can get to a live action adaptation of ''[[Metal Gear Solid]]'', with Captain America himself in the place of both Solid Snake and Raiden. {{spoiler|Especially given [[The Reveal]] about HYDRA and SHIELD.}}
* ''[[Captain America: The Winter Soldier (film)| The Winter Soldier]]'' has been described as the closest one can get to a live action adaptation of ''[[Metal Gear Solid]]'', with Captain America himself in the place of both Solid Snake and Raiden. {{spoiler|Especially given [[The Reveal]] about HYDRA and SHIELD.}}
* Both ''Pacific Rim'' and ''[[Independence Day]]: Resurgence'' are arguably the closest one could get to having a [[X-COM]] adaptation. As both films feature a military response force tasked with dealing with extraterrestrial threats.
* Both ''Pacific Rim'' and ''[[Independence Day]]: Resurgence'' are arguably the closest one could get to having a [[X-COM]] adaptation. As both films feature a military response force tasked with dealing with extraterrestrial threats.


== Literature ==
== Literature ==
* Simon R. Green's ''[[Deathstalker]]'' series will be immediately familiar and fun territory to any ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' player.
* Simon R. Green's ''[[Deathstalker]]'' series will be immediately familiar and fun territory to any ''[[Warhammer 40,000]]'' player.
* The ''Nina Wilde'' series by Andy McDermott, about a semi-reluctant [[Adventurer Archaeologist]], obviously takes more than a few cues from (and frequently references) Indiana Jones and Lara Croft. However, the number of pitched gun battles in exotic locations and rare vehicles which inevitably explode makes it far more akin to the written form of ''[[Uncharted]]''.
* The ''Nina Wilde'' series by Andy McDermott, about a semi-reluctant [[Adventurer Archaeologist]], obviously takes more than a few cues from (and frequently references) Indiana Jones and Lara Croft. However, the number of pitched gun battles in exotic locations and rare vehicles which inevitably explode makes it far more akin to the written form of ''[[Uncharted]]''.
* ''[[The Hunger Games]]'' is probably the closest that we'll get to an American remake of ''[[Battle Royale]]''. '''[[Fan Dumb|And that is]] [[They Copied It, So It Sucks|all that needs]] [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|to be said]].'''
* ''[[The Hunger Games]]'' is probably the closest that we'll get to an American remake of ''[[Battle Royale]]''. '''[[Fan Dumb|And that is]] [[They Copied It, So It Sucks|all that needs]] [[Rule of Cautious Editing Judgment|to be said]].'''
Line 131: Line 131:
== Tabletop Games ==
== Tabletop Games ==
* If there was ever a tabletop game version of [[Watership Down]], it would be called [[Bunnies and Burrows]].
* If there was ever a tabletop game version of [[Watership Down]], it would be called [[Bunnies and Burrows]].
* The [[Space Marine]]s in ''[[Warhammer 40000]]'' come almost prepackaged from [[Robert A. Heinlein]].
* The [[Space Marine]]s in ''[[Warhammer 40,000]]'' come almost prepackaged from [[Robert A. Heinlein]].




Line 138: Line 138:
** The ''[[The Hidden: Source]]'' [[Game Mod|mod]] for ''[[Half-Life 2]] '' also feels like a ''Predator'' game.
** The ''[[The Hidden: Source]]'' [[Game Mod|mod]] for ''[[Half-Life 2]] '' also feels like a ''Predator'' game.
* [[Shigeru Miyamoto]] had originally wanted to make a [[Popeye]] arcade game in the early 1980's, but Nintendo's right to the character were revoked midway through production. Miyamoto then took the idea of [[Super Mario Bros.|a scrappy hero]] rescuing [[Save the Princess|a helpless damsel]] from [[Donkey Kong|a hulking brute]] and made video game history.
* [[Shigeru Miyamoto]] had originally wanted to make a [[Popeye]] arcade game in the early 1980's, but Nintendo's right to the character were revoked midway through production. Miyamoto then took the idea of [[Super Mario Bros.|a scrappy hero]] rescuing [[Save the Princess|a helpless damsel]] from [[Donkey Kong|a hulking brute]] and made video game history.
* The [[Kunio Kun]] soccer league games, including Nintendo World Cup may as well be called [[Captain Tsubasa]]: The Game.
* The [[Kunio-Kun]] soccer league games, including Nintendo World Cup may as well be called [[Captain Tsubasa]]: The Game.
* Several games have been cited as evoking the feeling of the ''[[Alien]]'' films. Although ''Aliens'' is notable for averting [[The Problem with Licensed Games]] on various occasions, ''[[Dead Space (series)|Dead Space]]'' is probably the most recent example.
* Several games have been cited as evoking the feeling of the ''[[Alien]]'' films. Although ''Aliens'' is notable for averting [[The Problem with Licensed Games]] on various occasions, ''[[Dead Space (series)|Dead Space]]'' is probably the most recent example.
** Speaking of ''Dead Space'', owing to its somewhat derivative nature, and quality despite that, it has been mentioned as evocative of pretty much every notable sci-fi horror film ever.
** Speaking of ''Dead Space'', owing to its somewhat derivative nature, and quality despite that, it has been mentioned as evocative of pretty much every notable sci-fi horror film ever.
Line 148: Line 148:
** Before it underwent major decay, the same was said of ''[[Tomb Raider]]''.
** Before it underwent major decay, the same was said of ''[[Tomb Raider]]''.
** ''Pitfall: The Mayan Adventure'' also seems remarkably influenced by the ''[[Indiana Jones]]'' films.
** ''Pitfall: The Mayan Adventure'' also seems remarkably influenced by the ''[[Indiana Jones]]'' films.
* ''[[Starcraft]]'' reminds many people of, alternatively, ''[[Starship Troopers]]'', ''[[Alien (franchise)|Aliens]]'', ''[[Warhammer 40000]]''<ref>Debatably. Basically, they both have [[Space Marine]]s, a [[Horde of Alien Locusts]] and [[Scary Dogmatic Aliens]], but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.</ref> and, as of ''[[Starcraft II]]'', ''[[Firefly]]''.
* ''[[StarCraft]]'' reminds many people of, alternatively, ''[[Starship Troopers]]'', ''[[Alien (franchise)|Aliens]]'', ''[[Warhammer 40,000]]''<ref>Debatably. Basically, they both have [[Space Marine]]s, a [[Horde of Alien Locusts]] and [[Scary Dogmatic Aliens]], but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.</ref> and, as of ''[[StarCraft II]]'', ''[[Firefly]]''.
* Similarly, [[Blizzard Entertainment]]'s other big RTS franchise, ''[[Warcraft]]'', is practically ''[[Warhammer Fantasy Battle]]'' in disguise.
* Similarly, [[Blizzard Entertainment]]'s other big RTS franchise, ''[[Warcraft]]'', is practically ''[[Warhammer Fantasy Battle]]'' in disguise.
* It can also happen between games. ''[[Ōkami|Okami]]'' and ''[[Beyond Good & Evil (video game)|Beyond Good and Evil]]'' have been called "the best ''[[The Legend of Zelda]]'' games of the year" at times.
* It can also happen between games. ''[[Ōkami|Okami]]'' and ''[[Beyond Good & Evil (video game)|Beyond Good and Evil]]'' have been called "the best ''[[The Legend of Zelda]]'' games of the year" at times.
Line 183: Line 183:
** If one were to see the trailer for the original ''[[Pirates of the Caribbean]]'' while being unaware of the franchise, it wouldn't be a huge leap to expect it to be a straight-up Monkey Island movie, even though the influence actually went the other way.
** If one were to see the trailer for the original ''[[Pirates of the Caribbean]]'' while being unaware of the franchise, it wouldn't be a huge leap to expect it to be a straight-up Monkey Island movie, even though the influence actually went the other way.
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto Vice City]]'' was already a perfectly good ''[[Scarface]]'' game before ''[[Scarface the World Is Yours]]'' was made. In the leap from screen to game, ''[[Scarface]]'' was basically forced to ''rip off itself''.
* ''[[Grand Theft Auto Vice City]]'' was already a perfectly good ''[[Scarface]]'' game before ''[[Scarface the World Is Yours]]'' was made. In the leap from screen to game, ''[[Scarface]]'' was basically forced to ''rip off itself''.
** Similarly, the Los Santos chapters ''[[Grand Theft Auto]]: [[Grand Theft Auto San Andreas|San Andreas]]'' play out like ''[[Boyz N the Hood]]'' and ''[[Menace II Society]]'', while the Las Venturas section is basically ''[[Casino]]'' (for the main story strand) and ''[[Ocean's Eleven]]'' (for the optional casino heist plot).
** Similarly, the Los Santos chapters ''[[Grand Theft Auto]]: [[Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas|San Andreas]]'' play out like ''[[Boyz N the Hood]]'' and ''[[Menace II Society]]'', while the Las Venturas section is basically ''[[Casino]]'' (for the main story strand) and ''[[Ocean's Eleven]]'' (for the optional casino heist plot).
** And to go further back, ''[[Grand Theft Auto III]]'' looks and plays a lot like the ''[[Driver]]'' games that started on the [[PlayStation]]. Essentially, it's ''Driver'' with a criminal [[Villain Protagonist]] and on-foot controls that actually work—something that it took Reflections, the makes of ''Driver'', four games to get right (something that is [[Lampshade Hanging|lampshaded]] more than once in the ''GTA'' series), by which point it was ''them'' who came off looking like Johnny-come-latelies.
** And to go further back, ''[[Grand Theft Auto III]]'' looks and plays a lot like the ''[[Driver]]'' games that started on the [[PlayStation]]. Essentially, it's ''Driver'' with a criminal [[Villain Protagonist]] and on-foot controls that actually work—something that it took Reflections, the makes of ''Driver'', four games to get right (something that is [[Lampshade Hanging|lampshaded]] more than once in the ''GTA'' series), by which point it was ''them'' who came off looking like Johnny-come-latelies.
** Going in the other direction, some people consider ''[[Saints Row]]'' to be the true successor to ''San Andreas'' and the ''III''-era ''GTA'' games, especially after ''[[Grand Theft Auto IV]]'' went in a more realistic, [[Darker and Edgier]] direction.
** Going in the other direction, some people consider ''[[Saints Row]]'' to be the true successor to ''San Andreas'' and the ''III''-era ''GTA'' games, especially after ''[[Grand Theft Auto IV]]'' went in a more realistic, [[Darker and Edgier]] direction.
Line 196: Line 196:
** Some have suggested that the sequel, ''Manhunt 2'', is a spiritual licensee of ''[[Fight Club]]''.
** Some have suggested that the sequel, ''Manhunt 2'', is a spiritual licensee of ''[[Fight Club]]''.
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
* While it's pretty unlikely that anyone would ever make a ''[[Perry Mason]]'' video game, the world will always have ''[[Ace Attorney]]''.
* Many people have bemoaned the fact that ''[[Act Raiser]]'' never got a real sequel which featured the combination of town-building sim and real-time action (''[[Act Raiser]] II'' was a sequel [[In Name Only]]). But it did. It was called ''[[Dark Cloud]].''
* Many people have bemoaned the fact that ''[[ActRaiser]]'' never got a real sequel which featured the combination of town-building sim and real-time action (''[[ActRaiser]] II'' was a sequel [[In Name Only]]). But it did. It was called ''[[Dark Cloud]].''
* Despite the creator's efforts to give it a more unique art style, ''[[Deadly Premonition]]''—while [[So Bad It's Good]]—remains a closest thing we have that can be considered a ''[[Twin Peaks]]'' game.
* Despite the creator's efforts to give it a more unique art style, ''[[Deadly Premonition]]''—while [[So Bad It's Good]]—remains a closest thing we have that can be considered a ''[[Twin Peaks]]'' game.
** Even moreso than ''[[Alan Wake]]'', which in turn owes a bit for [[Stephen King]]'s work.
** Even moreso than ''[[Alan Wake]]'', which in turn owes a bit for [[Stephen King]]'s work.
Line 244: Line 244:
** In addition, [[Demon's Souls]] and [[Dark Souls]] are probably the best 3D ''[[Castlevania]]'' games made so far.
** In addition, [[Demon's Souls]] and [[Dark Souls]] are probably the best 3D ''[[Castlevania]]'' games made so far.
* ''[[Viewtiful Joe]]'' makes a excellent game adaption of [[Last Action Hero]], but with [[Toku]] themes instead. See [[X Meets Y]] for more.
* ''[[Viewtiful Joe]]'' makes a excellent game adaption of [[Last Action Hero]], but with [[Toku]] themes instead. See [[X Meets Y]] for more.
* Even though all the monsters are taken from the [[Public Domain Character|public domain]], and Simon Belmont looks like something by [[Frank Frazetta]], the first [[Castlevania 1986]] is obviously a take on the [[Universal Horror|Universal Monsters]], especially with the fake credits at the end of the game.
* Even though all the monsters are taken from the [[Public Domain Character|public domain]], and Simon Belmont looks like something by [[Frank Frazetta]], the first [[Castlevania (1986 video game)|Castlevania]] is obviously a take on the [[Universal Horror|Universal Monsters]], especially with the fake credits at the end of the game.
* Sacred was the best sequel for Diablo II in its day.
* Sacred was the best sequel for Diablo II in its day.
* ''[[Painkiller]]'' was thought to be more a sequel to [[Doom|Doom II]] than Doom 3 turned out to be.
* ''[[Painkiller]]'' was thought to be more a sequel to [[Doom|Doom II]] than Doom 3 turned out to be.
Line 258: Line 258:
* ''[[Crystalis]]'' is very close to being a [[Studio Ghibli]] video game, using much of the [[After the End|setting]] and [[Green Aesop|themes]], and conspicuously inserting familiar-looking objects (such as the [[Laputa: Castle in the Sky|floating castle]]). Most notably, the insect-infested jungle [[Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind|seems very familiar]], and the boss ''is'' an Ohmu.
* ''[[Crystalis]]'' is very close to being a [[Studio Ghibli]] video game, using much of the [[After the End|setting]] and [[Green Aesop|themes]], and conspicuously inserting familiar-looking objects (such as the [[Laputa: Castle in the Sky|floating castle]]). Most notably, the insect-infested jungle [[Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind|seems very familiar]], and the boss ''is'' an Ohmu.
* [[Mass Effect]] is essentially a licensed ''[[Lensman]]'' series. Or rather, Babylon5 with dialogue options.
* [[Mass Effect]] is essentially a licensed ''[[Lensman]]'' series. Or rather, Babylon5 with dialogue options.
* ''[[Kung Fu Master]]'' is more of an adaptation of ''[[Game of Death]]'' than the [[Jackie Chan]] movie which shares its title in Japan.
* ''[[Kung-Fu Master]]'' is more of an adaptation of ''[[Game of Death]]'' than the [[Jackie Chan]] movie which shares its title in Japan.
* On a review of it in this very wiki, [[Kid Icarus: Uprising]] was called the best [[Serious Sam]] game ever put onto a nintendo system.
* On a review of it in this very wiki, [[Kid Icarus: Uprising]] was called the best [[Serious Sam]] game ever put onto a nintendo system.
** Likewise, it's an awesome entry in the [[Sin and Punishment]] franchise.
** Likewise, it's an awesome entry in the [[Sin and Punishment]] franchise.

Revision as of 20:42, 9 April 2017

A counterpart of Better by a Different Name in a way, and also a sort of subtrope of Spiritual Successor and Follow the Leader (but not always), in effect a Captain Ersatz of a story rather than a character. It's particularly evident with video games; most people have certain movie characters with tons of potential they dream of playing as in an amazing game, yet as most movie licensed games are terrible, there's almost no chance of that happening...

Technically no chance, anyway. This is when something has nothing to do with a certain series, but evokes almost the same feeling you'd imagine a decent license invoking with a certain franchise, making it (intentionally or not) a Spiritual Licensee.

This can also occur after a developer decides to create a Spiritual Successor to a game from a previously established franchise, but put an original spin on the game to differentiate it from its predecessor(s).

Please do not add personal examples; the main page should be for comparisons that you have seen numerous times (or ones that are really, really obvious).

Contrast Dolled-Up Installment.

Examples of Spiritual Licensee include:


Anime & Manga

Film

Literature


Live Action TV


Stand-Up Comedy


Tabletop Games


Video Games

Western Animation


Other

  • The MagiQuest simulated-adventure franchise, although much lower-tech and modest in scale, is currently the closest that fans of Niven & Barnes Dream Park can come to savoring the fictional mega-theme park's attractions.
  1. Debatably. Basically, they both have Space Marines, a Horde of Alien Locusts and Scary Dogmatic Aliens, but that's also true of several other science fiction franchises.